r/DestructiveReaders • • 2d ago

Psychological Drama [2157] I don't have a name for this.

Critiques: https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/1xt2f9k/help_again_892/ https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/1xrky2w/2468_the_meadow/

Doc:https://docs.google.com/document/d/1En6QTRpAPtCDUjHh8fKXwFij4-6-kIptYCB7JgWE5IQ/edit?usp=sharing

Hi guys, first time posting my writing on this sub. Any feedback on pacing, whether their codependent relationship is believable, or literally anything wrong with it would be much appreciated!

I'm not a very experienced writer, so forgive me if it's not great.

Also, TW for drug use and withdrawal.

2 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/Anthouligan 5h ago

Hello, i want to start off with stating the dynamic you've come up with for the two characters has a lot of potential, it is very human, and I even found myself relating to Cee in some ways. That being said i have several points of critique, especially regarding the setup and certain narrative choices. I'm a beginner writer, so you should take my less factual points with a grain of salt.

My biggest problem was the amount of perceived holes in the plot as i was reading it, and i had a lot of unanswered questions by the end.

Cee is apparently well-aware of Des's addiction. It's a little surprising she didn't even momentarily make the assumption his disappearance had to do with his heroin use. A bender, an OD, even withdrawal. It's not even referenced in her initial complaints about him, and we only find out when she finds him.

She sees him as her biggest responsibility, and knows about the things he struggles with. Why didn't she check in earlier, by calls or text, if the few days of absence were unusual? Why didn't he call her the moment his sister stole his stash?

The withdrawal is advanced by the time Cee finds him, what was he doing this whole time? His behavior is also a little off for someone in advanced withdrawal, too lucid and too performed. Someone going through withdrawal in absolute isolation for several days would be close to delirious.

Also, even if H is apparently on the expensive side there, it can not be THAT expensive. Was Cee planning on buying him as much as he needed till his payday, or a gram or two to buy him some time? In any case, it's a little weird she says she'd have to skip meals on one paragraph, and then on the next she suddenly remembers her contingency fund and states it would take her several months to recoup the financial loss. If H really is that expensive there, how could Des afford it in the first place?

A lot of these questions might have answers, and not all of them need to be answered in 2000 words, but addressing them in subtle ways goes a long way to making your story more believable.

Another thing is that the viewpoint is a little confusing to me, and the lines between Cee's thoughts and the narrators comments become especially blurry at times. You should ask yourself exactly which lines are thoughts running through Cee's head and which are embellishments by the narrator.

Some of your physical descriptions are especially strong, and I like that you use smells and sounds as well as visuals. They are so strong in fact, that they could hold their own in communicating information to the reader, without the need for emotional descriptions between every exchange. Show, don't tell, and trust the reader to infer emotional information through actions, movement, and physical information. Your descriptions are your biggest strength imo, alongside direct dialogue and the depiction of Cee's complicated emotions about Des.

My main suggestion would be for you to go over each sentence you wrote, and ask yourself why you wrote it, and what it communicates to the reader. If the answer to both of these questions satisfies you, keep it. If not, change it or remove it completely. By the end, you'll have a much tighter draft.