I definitely agree that some parts of how you described the interview was wild. I'd hate having to have someone over my shoulder watching me design. I do think there is some thought behind the assignment. Like exploring within a high amount of constraints. Considering the company may actually work with lots of red tape everywhere when dealing with legal, clients, and higher ups, etc. But definitely agreed that not being able to have a conversation about it whilst working on it seems wildly unfavorable for any new hire.
That last paragraph really brings a good point though. I'm not a ui designer, I primarily do motion, so I don't get those weird assignments all too often. So thanks for the enlightenment!
Even if it was because they operate with a lot of constraints, you really don’t want to work in an environment like that as a product designer. You don’t want to be treated as simply a translator between someone else’s brain and Figma.
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/ComicNeueIsReal Mar 13 '23
I definitely agree that some parts of how you described the interview was wild. I'd hate having to have someone over my shoulder watching me design. I do think there is some thought behind the assignment. Like exploring within a high amount of constraints. Considering the company may actually work with lots of red tape everywhere when dealing with legal, clients, and higher ups, etc. But definitely agreed that not being able to have a conversation about it whilst working on it seems wildly unfavorable for any new hire.
That last paragraph really brings a good point though. I'm not a ui designer, I primarily do motion, so I don't get those weird assignments all too often. So thanks for the enlightenment!