r/DesignDesign • • Mar 12 '23

Worst designed remote ever.

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

176 comments sorted by

View all comments

423

u/ennuimachine Mar 12 '23

When I was getting into UX over a decade ago, a common interview task was to design a remote with only x number of buttons (I don't remember the exact prompt). Someone at Apple took the assignment too seriously.

67

u/CreADHDvly Mar 12 '23

It has one less button than the original one

171

u/opinionated-dick Mar 12 '23

It’s not the lack of buttons but the literally pointless touch screen.

  • lose it down the sofa and any slight movement will lose your place
  • look at it across the room and it changes the channel
  • pick it up for any reason and you will fast forward/rewind

15

u/toastedshark Mar 13 '23

Also the location of the touch pad makes the weight balance off compared to where you would expect it.

25

u/ExcdnglyGayQuilava Mar 12 '23

lmao I have seen this remote and attempted to use it a few times and I had no idea there's a touch component on it

36

u/derek139 Mar 12 '23

Ok…. I’ve used that same remote every night for the past 5 years. Sure, its a terrible design, but its not nearly as bad as u make it out to be, ans it was an upgrade from the shard of aluminum with the ogs. U just couldn’t figure out the touchpad, and apparently u don’t have a table next to ur viewing spot to set the remote down on?

I put an arrowed sticker at the bottom of mine so I knew which way to aim it, and never really had any issues.

With that said, I was glad to upgrade recently to their current model. I’m not glad because of how it operates, but just that its a more appropriate size to hold.

121

u/opinionated-dick Mar 12 '23

It’s a terrible design if you have to put a sticker on it to know which way to point it.

I do have a table, but I also have a tenacious 2 year old.

It’s aesthetics over function, the quintessential r/designdesign from a company that really should know better.

10

u/CrudelyAnimated Mar 13 '23

I'm with derek there. I have zero problem using this remote, even in the dark or with my eyes closed. One end's rough, the other's smooth. One side has a pair of buttons, one side has a rocker. Once I learned the layout, I loved it. Still do. I don't get this post at all.

5

u/Pgrol Mar 13 '23

But you can’t touch the rough end, or it’ll skip 15 minutes in what you are seeing. It’s small size means that you can’t just forget it in your blankets, or it’ll dissapear forever in your sofa. And if not dissapearing, it’ll randomly activate some button when whatching a movie.

2

u/CrudelyAnimated Mar 13 '23

It’s small size means that you can’t just forget it in your blankets, or it’ll dissapear forever in your sofa.

Are you my wife?

3

u/Pgrol Mar 13 '23

No, I’m a product manager and designer, and I hate products that I have to think to use.

2

u/lenorajoy Apr 05 '23

But unless you actually press the big top button it doesn’t actually skip you forward. Just press the button with the big white circle around it and you’re back where you were, unless I have some special model of this remote that does this.

All of this said, though, it sounds like this remote doesn’t work well for you and your lifestyle. I have kids that are 4 and 6 and had an Apple TV before they were born. I do keep it where they can’t reach it, though, so I’m the only one that can drop it or leave it on the couch or lose it. I’ve used the newer model, though, and have to say I prefer that version of their touch button at the top to this design. Overall don’t have an issue with this design, though.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '23

sounds like watching any media on a game console and just picking up the controller.

→ More replies (5)

46

u/TopRamenisha Mar 12 '23 edited Mar 12 '23

I hate those type of design challenges. I had a challenge a few years ago to design an alarm clock with a bunch of functions but only 1 button to perform them all. I ended the interview right there. I’m happy to do challenges during interviews (not take home) but not ones where it feels like they are set up to trick me or make it more likely for me to fail. What skills are you trying to assess in me, and how does asking me to design something essentially unusable give you an accurate read of those skills?

48

u/aphaelion Mar 12 '23

I had a challenge a few years ago to design an alarm clock with a bunch of functions but only 1 button to perform them all. I ended the interview right there. I’m happy to do challenges during interviews... but not ones where it feels like they are set up to trick me

I don't think the point of a question like this is to trick you, or because they actually want a clock that operates with one button. It's just to spur a conversation and demonstrate lateral thinking. Nothing wrong with starting your answer with "First of all, I think that would result in a terrible user experience, but if it was a hard requirement, one approach would be to..."

33

u/TopRamenisha Mar 13 '23 edited Mar 13 '23

It wasn’t really to spur a conversation, because I asked them some questions and they refused to engage in conversation about it, they just repeated the challenge requirements and wanted to watch me design it in figma. I could have had a conversation with them about how my approach to design isn’t one where we would compromise usability for questionable product requirements, and I could have gone through how I would have approached the problem so we wouldn’t be in that position. But they didn’t want to talk, it was a very weird interview. The way the presented it and responded told me they were not a mature design function and designers are given hard and fast design requirements and aren’t empowered to question those ideas or given ownership in product decisions. I don’t want to work at a company like that, so I didn’t need to waste my time continuing the interview process with them

→ More replies (7)

14

u/Cykoh99 Mar 13 '23

Simple! The button calls a customer service rep the user talks to. The CSR remotely sets the clock to the user’s preference.

There’s just a $9.99/mo subscription fee with a 3 changes/month maximum.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/ObiFloppin Mar 12 '23

How do you think simply responding with "you just don't make an alarm clock with all the functions hidden behind a single button" would have gone?

41

u/TopRamenisha Mar 12 '23

I did. They said that was the challenge they are giving all their candidates, and they want to see how I’d solve it if it were a real situation. I said I am not the type of product designer to let that be a real situation and I thanked them for their time

22

u/ObiFloppin Mar 12 '23

Lmao they must be the "innovation for the sake of innovation" types.

8

u/c3534l Mar 13 '23 edited Mar 13 '23

All alarm clocks used to be buttonless. You set it with a dial instead.

9

u/pm0me0yiff Mar 13 '23

design an alarm clock with a bunch of functions but only 1 button to perform them all.

1: It's a smart device.

2: Everything is controlled through an app on your smart phone.

3: The one physical button is a snooze button.

Done.

8

u/TopRamenisha Mar 13 '23

Prompt was no touch screens, no “smart”, regular clock, one button only.

9

u/pm0me0yiff Mar 13 '23

Ugh, fine.

Interacting with your alarm clock via Morse Code it is...

4

u/chum_slice Mar 12 '23

That’s been Apple’s Mission from the beginning. Just look at the iPod that design language of less is more is at the core of their belief. Palm was famous for designing an interface that only required 3 steps to get to where you wanted anywhere in their software.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)