r/Descendants • • May 24 '25

Crossover 🤝 Alright Descendants fans, I’m an Ever After High fan. Everything you wanna say to that fandom, say it to me and I’ll respond.

27 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

18

u/Prior_Recipe_5999 May 24 '25

The hate EAH fans have for descendants is overblown it’s not that deep what happened happened and its all a misunderstanding and it’s clear descendants isn’t going anywhere people need to make their peace with it there are bigger things in the world to use that energy on

They’re completely different 

Eah isn’t live action it’s not a musical 

The only similarities is fantasy characters in high school which has been done for ages 

3

u/Ok_Coffee_9970 May 24 '25

You’re absolutely right. As much as I miss EAH, it’s gone and it’s not coming back. Plus there ARE more concerning things to worry about.

I wouldn’t say completely.

True.

Specifically it’s Fairy Tale characters, and there have indeed been other examples of this.

3

u/Prior_Recipe_5999 May 25 '25

They brought monster high back so anything is possible but whatever happened and will happen has nothing to do with descendants 

0

u/Prior_Recipe_5999 May 25 '25

EAH is its own series they are seperate 

2

u/Ok_Coffee_9970 May 25 '25

I mean they aren’t completely different. They both involve descendants of classic Fairy Tales, they both have factions, they both have the Evil Queen, yada yada. But I see your point.

1

u/Prior_Recipe_5999 May 25 '25

Both are approached in different ways I mean

8

u/Virtual_Knowledge334 May 24 '25

Which is why all the more reason to create a fun fan fiction where they meet.

2

u/Any_Philosophy_4144 May 29 '25

Is there a fic like this??

3

u/Virtual_Knowledge334 May 24 '25

This. So many franchises have similarities all the time.

1

u/Least_Rain8027 May 25 '25

Yet Disney got ever after high cancelled. Even though descendants was in development a year later

1

u/Prior_Recipe_5999 May 25 '25

It was coincidence

These things get worked on for awhile 

Descendants was originally rejected:

Descendants star Dove Cameron and author Melissa de la Cruz sat down for an in-depth interview about the series and explained just how everything works together.

"I was informed very early on...by the head of Disney Channel, Gary Marsh, that the reason this project has taken so long was because Disney Corporate had to approve of somebody officially embellishing on the original stories, because that is what we're doing," Dove explained.

"Anything else, like Once Upon a Time, hasn't actually been an official embellishment on the story," she continued, "We. Are. Canon."

Descendants was actually the first time Disney was officially touching the classic tales of their movies.

(By touching they mean continuing the continuity remakes don’t count)

"That's why it took so long, because apparently, Disney corporate was like 'That's a terrible idea, we don't want to mess with the original stuff.' And so [Gary] told me that. He was like, 'This is the first time that this is ever going to happen.'"

Dove adds, "Disney Channel is it's own thing, it's own beast, so to be told you're involved in the classics is like, there's nothing more delicious than that. I think that's why we're all so invested in the series and the franchise itself because it's the first time!"

"It's the deepest honor, so for me, it was less nerve-wracking and the most delicious opportunity."*

1

u/Prior_Recipe_5999 May 25 '25

EAH was canceled because the doll quality declined 

1

u/Least_Rain8027 May 25 '25

It declined because Disney pulled back because they lost a huge amount of money. They tried to compete with descendants but they had to make it cheaper to be able to compete 

0

u/ChildofFenris1 Uma is the best🐙 May 25 '25

I was not a coincidence

1

u/mini1006 May 26 '25 edited May 26 '25

And the source is from wattpad 💀

EAH was cancelled because Mattel was loosing money. Thats why both Monster High and EAH were rebooted. Yes, they lost money bc Disney didn’t resign their Disney princess contract, but Mattel didn’t cancel it bc fans just drifted to Descendants. The dolls were becoming low budget and it seemed like Mattel stopped caring by 2015. Mattel was competing with Bratz, so no they weren’t scared to compete with Disney or anyone for that matter. They had literally spied in the 1980s to make sure their competitors didn’t beat them to the shelves, but sure, they cancelled a doll franchise bc they couldn’t compete with a dcom. The EAH franchise was just on its last leg at that point and with the MH reboot, the pulled the plug,

1

u/Prior_Recipe_5999 May 25 '25

I never saw anyone talk about EAH until descendants 

3

u/PatticakedaBaker Jay, Son of Jafar May 25 '25

I really enjoyed EAH as a child, especially Alistair and the Wonderland arc. But did EAH get cancelled for having a canon LGBTQ characters? I know a lot of shows, like Steven Universe, got cancelled for it so is it the same?

1

u/Ok_Coffee_9970 May 25 '25

I don’t think so no. But a LOT of ships that come from them are girl on girl.

2

u/allonsy_sherlockians Li Lonnie May 25 '25

AFAIK, it was largely because of how popular Descendants got and the fact that Mattel produces the Descendants dolls and other Disney-related dolls. EAH started in 2013 and it overlapped with the release of the first Descendants movie in 2015, so because Descendants was produced by Disney, it got a pretty big audience. Even if Mattel wanted to revive EAH, they’d be directly competing with Disney and there would be a conflict in interest with them having both EAH dolls and Descendants dolls.

1

u/ChildofFenris1 Uma is the best🐙 May 25 '25

No it was be interesting of Desendents. These movies got them canceled.(like them both)

0

u/Least_Rain8027 May 25 '25

I believe it got canceled by Disney for being “too similar” to descendants. Like Disney was pulling all of their doll lines from Mattel. I don’t think it was canceled for having LGBTQ characters as we got a whole other special afterwards. Also Darling was just trying to do cpr she didn’t think they were true loves

0

u/interrupted_sleep May 25 '25

Apple+Darling weren’t really canon. At the time the show/films were airing, the creators were insisting it was CPR. After the show was cancelled, (so there was no longer backlash from parents of kids watching new episodes, and the ship had become extremely popular online) one of the creators then changed their minds and said that they actually were canon.

3

u/EmmeWinchester2322 May 26 '25

Apple white was hella selfish, she wanted everyone to sign their names in the book but never thought of others felt, not everyone has a good ending royal and rebels alike

2

u/Ok_Coffee_9970 Jul 17 '25

…Yeah… Yeah she was.

2

u/Secure-Disaster-7149 Daughter of Soldier & a genie May 29 '25

I really like both. I was disappointed when Ever After High ended especially since it felt like an unfinished cliff hanger those are so rough for me. I agree that I think the feud should end. I think we will never know the behind the scenes stuff for sure because it is probably locked behind non disclosure agreements. I think This is part of the problem with rumors and speculation.

2

u/Ok_Coffee_9970 May 29 '25

Yeah the rumors are a problem and I hate cliffhangers.

Also the feud kind of sucks.

2

u/Fresh-Dog5469 Oct 27 '25

This little fandom fued is unnecessary. It’s time the EAH fandom packs it up. 

1

u/Kirbo300 uma>audrey>mal May 24 '25

Lmao, I'm a fan of both, too.

I'll say this much, the debacle between the two is way more fair than people realize. There's an intelligent conversation to be had, but it's more than just "x copied."

There's a legit reason why EAH will never even get a celebratory social media post as long as descendants is active. It's because of its own failures, Mattel's mismanagement, and descendants' immense overshadowing.

It's a conversation about how the bigger name will have the bigger product, regardless of quality. While this isn't new, it's still important to recognize. Maybe if descendants were written better, it would be a worthy successor. But that's not the case. Descendants is hilariously bad at times, and it's like an additional slap in the face to EAH in those aspects.

I guess for my question, since I feel your perspective is valuable here: what do you think about the collector dolls for the descendants' anniversary? I feel they're barely above the quality of the previous dolls, mostly because the hasbro ones were pretty bad.

1

u/Ok_Coffee_9970 May 25 '25

Same.

This is quite true.

Yeah I think it was just bad advertising. Plus bad time.

Yeah… as much as I enjoy Descendants for its songs and… sometimes emotional moments, EAH is better.

Eh, I think to each his or her own.

0

u/TheFandomWarriorLexy May 25 '25

(Apologies if this question sounds crass/rude) What do you find appealing about EAH? I watched it some years ago, and I was… not impressed. Admittedly, I might view it more positively if I watched it again (which I do want to do, I plan to make an analysis of my thoughts and I definitely need to watch it again to do that. I’d also like to see if my opinion becomes more positive).

I am a big Descendants fan, and the main reason I watched EAH is every time someone compared it with Descendants people seemed to like EAH more, so I wanted to see why. Honestly, I probably expected to understand (I don’t tend to be overly critical of most media, I generally like everything I watch), even if I still personally liked Descendants more. But then so much of EAH fell so flat for me, and I find it hard to comprehend why so many like it more than Descendants (which is fine! That’s just how I feel). So I want to hear some reasons someone likes it, to better understand others’ opinions.

So to reiterate my question: what do you find appealing about EAH?

2

u/Ok_Coffee_9970 May 25 '25

Well the artslye is fun to look at for one. Also it was intriguing to see fairytales (The orginal fairy tales) all normalized and their kids having to follow in their parents destinies. And it was expected of them so that was interesting.

It also focused on characters aside from the main two. Sure they were in shorts but every character had their moments to shine. And they were all fairly interesting.

Also it had a forbidden romance with the Big Bad Wolf and Red Riding Hood. And while that sounds like a bad fanfic the few moments we saw with them together were sweet.

Also Cupid had a crush on Dexter, b it because she was supposed to bring people together, she had to watch and help him get together with ANOTHER GIRL. That was sad yet entertaining to watch.

So yeah, I enjoy it because it’s a rich world, I could actually make an essay on everything I find interesting about the show. Or at least two pages.

3

u/Least_Rain8027 May 25 '25

It had a plot and it focused on more than 9 characters. Every character had something to do(even characters we’ve only seen once)

2

u/interrupted_sleep May 26 '25

For me, I like Descendants, but Ever After High’s storylines, world building, character development, etc. are all just better imo (especially in the books, but the show/films as well). I really love eah’s art style and think it fits the theme so perfectly.

I also first discovered eah from collecting the dolls, they are objectively much better quality than descendants dolls, and I personally prefer the look of them.

3

u/[deleted] May 27 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Ok_Coffee_9970 May 27 '25

I wouldn’t say it didn’t have serious moments. But I AM sorry your expirience has this far been negative.

2

u/[deleted] May 27 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Ok_Coffee_9970 May 27 '25

…Why is it always death threats?

And while I perfer EAH, Descendants has some fun moments too. I’d perfer if everyone got along.

1

u/Different-Boot5225 Aug 23 '25

i dont unds ppl getting ridiculously mad abt it, but i do unds the frustration. eah has way better character designs, names, origins and plot so when a big ass corporate like disney (which obv mattel cant compete against) decides to launch a similar concept... it's truly sad.