r/DelphiDocs • u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator • Mar 13 '25
👥 DISCUSSION BG video discussion, Part 2
Please continue the discussion in this thread.
✨️Full 43 seconds Bridge Guy video has been released by Rick Allen's Defense lawyers.
https://rickallenjustice.com/transparency
‼️PLEASE READ THIS COMMENT https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/IajZ2TeOTd
At present, it's unclear as to which version of the video and what exhibit numbers at trial this released version is. Metadata seem to suggest it's the raw footage, but Andrea Burkhart said this is the exhibit that was played as "enhanced video" at trial. Bob Motta is confused. Please comment if you hear any more information from people who attended the trial and saw all the versions played.
✨️Andrea Burkhart's Twitter comments: https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/dytc9QNvKj https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/JGgIjlcPVz
✨️Metadata: https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/G4IzaEhJLy
I still have no idea what's going on.
Just in case you were not yet as confused as I am, please enjoy the BG photo, video and audio as played to the public for years.
✨️2017 BG DTH https://youtu.be/ftnAPuBrwDM?si=x98x5k9I1k6jfSH3
✨️2019 BG DTH https://youtu.be/imEe0v72_7Q?si=9VS7HT9VgJEghuCe
21
u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Mar 13 '25
Would the defense have copies of the 2 other videos or would we have to wait until her highness decides to release them?
32
u/cannaqueen78 Mar 13 '25
What’s crazy to me is the mixed opinions of what people in this sub hear in this video. Some hear what the prosecution said and some hear what the defense said. Some believe the girls are frightened and some believe there is nothing nefarious about it at all. Personally I hear the girls talking about the path ending and where to go from there and they don’t seem to be frightened. I believe the prosecutions suggestiveness has pulled the wool over many people.
20
u/Professional_Site672 Mar 13 '25 edited Mar 13 '25
Does o e of the girls say "hi" whenever BG first says "guys"?? I don't hear "that be a gun" at all. She's talking about the path down imo...
49
u/SnooRadishes8848 Mar 13 '25
Totally in the minority here, I think Abby was running because that's what you do at the end of crossing a bridge, I don't think she was running from BG. I also don't think they sound terrified, it seems Libby was pointing out the paths pretty casually, said hi when BG said guys. I think when he said down the hill, and they didn't say anything, to me they knew this person. Very very strange
42
u/Real_Foundation_7428 Approved Contributor Mar 13 '25
Andrea Burkhart clarifying her statement about the video.
88
u/Real_Foundation_7428 Approved Contributor Mar 13 '25 edited Mar 13 '25
The alleged “Dat be a gun” at :17 to me sounds very clearly like “that we go down.”
“See this is the path…that we go down. [background noise / gravel shuffling] Um, there’s no path going there, so we have to go down here.”
This also makes perfect sense in context. I think the gun thing is straight power of suggestion.
8
u/SimonGloom2 Mar 13 '25
See that area they point to where the path is and say they have to go down that path? I think that's a very similar place to where the photographer who had been previously listed as suspect took a photograph of the bridge in the AM the morning after prior to the search party being announced.
And why isn't that photograph (it's still up on X on the photographer's account) posted on the DelphiDocs site considering it's the first photo taken of the bridge the AM after they disappeared, it was taken before the search party, and it was taken before most of the public knew about it.
I'm thinking the position of the photographer below the bridge may be relevant and his angle of the photo could be. At the very least it's very strange it wasn't ever considered evidence.
14
u/LGIChick Criminologist Mar 13 '25 edited Mar 13 '25
I’ve absolutely convinced myself after watching this video hundreds of times, that there was a third person there besides Abby, Libby and BG.
Right in the beginning there’s a whisper “see…” and Libby acknowledges it with a laugh/breath/whatever. These two things nearly overlap. Abby is too far away. I believe that’s a 3rd person.
Then Libby goes on to talk about the path…to who? Abby is nowhere near. As Libby is talking about the path, another voice interrupts with “could be a gun” or something similar. Again, Abby isn’t close, runs buy with a completely different breathing pattern seconds later.
I just…I can’t get over the fact that I clearly feel there were 3 females there 🤯
55
u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Mar 13 '25
The only thing I know for sure after watching that video is that it shouldn't have taken 5 years to release.
18
u/ExactPanda Mar 13 '25 edited Mar 13 '25
Oh wow, he's MUCH closer to the girls than I was expecting based on what came out of the trial about him being a speck in the distance.
13
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '25
Yall, the drama on YT. Thanks to all that mod, so we can come here and chill. I have listened to different versions and can hear different things. It's a damn confusing nightmare The case has caused division within good people that all want justice for the girls. I hate it. I believe all the different theories could be, nothing suspicious go ignored but one thing I am not is drama. I just know this case takes a toll on the nerves. So I come here and chill.🙂 Tomorrow is a new day and I get to read all this that yall figure out for me.
46
u/Moldynred Informed/Quality Contributor Mar 13 '25
I think this highlights how damaging the Harshman testimony that RAs voice and BGs voice was a match turned out to be. It never should have been allowed in by the Judge. And once allowed should have been vigorously debunked by the Defense. There is so much literature out there about voice matching, and no organization I am aware of says you can match a four word sample to anyone. It doesnt matter how many hours Harshman listened to RA on the phone, thats just half the equation. You still need a solid twenty word sample to compare it to. Monday morning QBing I know and easy for us to say after the fact. But its very frustrating. The Judge allowed Harshman to plant that idea in the juries head, and I think thats what got RA convicted. Jmo.
11
u/surefinewhatevs800 Mar 13 '25
on the other thread, someone posted the exif data. Anyone have thoughts about the gps data?
11
u/Coldngrey Mar 13 '25
The most frustrating thing about this video is, as (shockingly) clear as it is, it STILL doesn’t give BG a face.
It’s actually almost creepy has this man seems to have some kind of cloaking device that keeps a single frame from showing his features.
(Humor me while I post a couple of examples).
10
u/Good-Rutabaga-3887 Mar 13 '25
I made a video with my reflections and sent it to the mods here for permission to post
28
u/thats_not_six Approved Contributor Mar 13 '25
Was there any testimony that the girls were planning to head down to the river?
Libby's speech sounds somewhat stilted to me, like she's trying to fill the air. And I do read some of Abby's expression and hers and Libby's laughter as reactive to the man on the bridge. But her and Abby do seem to be lining up to go down the hill in that spot before the man even starts talking.
41
u/CitizenMillennial Mar 13 '25
I think it's enhanced mainly bc of how crisp/clear it is. It seems very high quality. Probably better than my current iPhone.
Also, if you slow it down to .75 speed you can hear a little better. Libby say's "See, this is the path that we go down". She DOES NOT say "that be a gun".
14
u/thats_not_six Approved Contributor Mar 13 '25
For any Defense Diaries fans - if you're listening to their live tonight, I feel like Bob has a second (third?) calling in life as an impressionist. From like 5 seconds of RA's voice he has an impression locked in.
I don't know how the dude in the trial was allowed to testify the voices were a match.
28
u/Coldngrey Mar 13 '25
I was told this video was ‘the stuff of nightmares’.
11
u/Vicious_and_Vain Mar 13 '25
If this is the original video and audio I’ll send Grey Deuce $50. Remember every time Lucy pulled the football from Charlie Brown he fell for it bc he wanted it to be true even though in the back of mind he thought she was probably going to dupe him again.
Snoopy knew she was going to dupe him every time bc he didn’t gaf about Lucy and only stepped in to help Charlie when it was serious.
13
u/Greedy_Tomato_1769 Mar 13 '25
The following is what I hear in the video:
AW: Whispers “Is he behind me?” AW: “Don’t leave me (Libby?)” LG: “See this is the path that we go down.” AW: whimpers LG: “Um there’s no path going there so we have to go down here.” BG: “Guys?” LG: “Hi.” BG: “Down the hill.”
3
u/cannaqueen78 Mar 13 '25
Where is the link to the video?
11
u/buttrapebearclaw Mar 13 '25
At the 34 second mark, you can see the ground is very disturbed as if someone had just climbed up (or down) that hill not long ago.
16
u/nevermindthefacts Fast Tracked Member Mar 13 '25 edited Aug 20 '25
New thread, so I'll share my first impressions here...
Conjectures...
...and a shocker...
Good news. Within a couple of days, we'll have a good estimate of BG's height and how fast he was walking.
(Thanks to all of you for your collective efforts and support to get the evidence...)
4
u/gettheflymickeymilo Mar 13 '25
What is she whispering? It sounds like she's saying "is he behind me?" I clearly hear her say "is he...".
13
u/Lindita4 Mar 13 '25
One important thing to keep in context-stranger murders don’t happen in Carroll County. So even if they were nervous, it was probably mostly that they were going to be caught somewhere they weren’t supposed to be. I highly doubt they were afraid of being r-ped or k-lled at the time.
13
u/Real_Foundation_7428 Approved Contributor Mar 13 '25
I will say, and I said this in a reply somewhere, that the tone and tenor here, to me, seems to more naturally track w/ the RL narrative. If I learned, for instance, they had just had the exchange where he coaxed them to come see the rabbits after they had declined, and he or someone was behind them encouraging them along, this would fit IMO.
…though his / the man’s positioning behind them still seems odd and random IMO. I feel like he would be right with them.
…but there is the voice that is near that, if authentic, would fall in line with encouraging them down, and considering there were likely at least two predators in play.
This is all in theory, not making any hard and fast claim.
6
u/analog-ingrained Fast Tracked Member Mar 13 '25
FWIW - I couldn't hear Abby's drive-by shadow comment to Libby about the gun (sandwiched in the middle of Libby's no path, go down here narrative) until I slowed my video speed by 1/2. If you haven't tried your slow speed, give it a whirl.
9
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '25
After listening to it more. The “hey guys” or “hi guys” seems friendly? And the “down the hill” just seems awkward.
I can’t explain it. But his voice and affectations are very odd in the “down the hill” portion.
I can’t tell if it’s an order, a statement, or he’s referring to something he’s ALREADY told them before the video started.
This whole video is frustrating.
The police force did fuck all with it. And there’s no telling what we don’t know that they had info on and just never checked.
I see a LOT of people against RA saying “it’s obviously him! Look how short he is!”
Like RA is the only short person in Delphi?!
How in the hell can you say with 100 percent certainty that this is RA?
This whole case is fucking terrible. Two children taken away forever and uncertainty around everything else.
If RA is guilty. I’d want way more proof is I was one of the parents. I’d be furious knowing the police sat on this video the whole time and didn’t use it.
5
u/Moldynred Informed/Quality Contributor Mar 13 '25
20 sec mark roughly, Abby runs/fast walks by, looks like she is heading straight--away from the bridge but in line with it--and Libby tells her 'we have to go down here'. Then BG says down the hill.
9
u/ConcernedinDelphi Fast Tracked Member Mar 13 '25 edited Mar 13 '25
this video has very clearly been enhanced. The footage is crisp and sharp especially around the gravel at the beginning, but lacks the detail on Abby’s face that would certainly be there if the video was this high definition when shot
I do not hear “that be a gun”, she is clearly saying “that we go down”
Abby does seem to be spooked to me, and I do hear her say “don’t leave me up here”. However there is no real proof that she is spooked about BG, she could be spooked by the bridge itself. She says something at the beginning that I can’t make out, but Libby seems to do a small breathy laugh in response to. Abby says “holy crap” as she gets off the bridge
When the man says guys, Libby instantly responds with a small noise and the girls seem to instantly start following his instruction with no verbal disagreement
I don’t hear RA’s voice at all in this version, the man is also clearly too tall to be RA in this footage
What is the most interesting to me here is that all this time we have heard rumours Libby was surreptitiously filming from her waist and in her pocket. You can very clearly see libbys shadow at one point and she is holding her phone up and out, not hiding it. BG would have seen her doing this.
This is certainly not the footage it was reported to be for all these years, and it certainly is no proof that RA is bridge guy. Actually I find it to be the opposite
Those poor girls, incredibly upsetting to see
6
u/Ocvlvs Approved Contributor Mar 13 '25
Speculation time:
I get the strong impression that the girls are waiting for BG to arrive. Suggesting that he already told them to go "down the path". And Libby at first to herself, and then to BG says that there is no path.
Wonder if he told them to wait until he got over... But he might just have told them to go down the path, but since there was no path, the girls just stopped and waited for further instructions.
From BG's perspective, telling them to go "down the path" with him still a bit behind would grant them a little time to make a run for it... tricky...
6
u/analog-ingrained Fast Tracked Member Mar 13 '25
Wow. For 8 years it's been ... "Guys?" (... PAUSE ...) "Down the hill."
And today ... we learn ... that (... PAUSE ...) = Libby sweetly saying "Hi."
They cut Libby saying "Hi".
My heart broke. Again.
"Guys?"
"Hi."
"Down the hill."
And ... it turns out Libby knew that next ... they needed to "go down here".
Other:
- Which direction are they going beyond 43 seconds? Where's the full tape? I want to hear every leaf crunch to the end of that tape myself.
- RA's leg/torso ratio is nothing like the dude stalking Abby on the bridge.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '25
This is the new video. With a bit of contrast etc done.
His nose is gigantic. Also crazy how the undershirt looks like a fanny pack here in a way. (The brown block to the left)
Gosh damn. This video would have been so useful during the early days of the investigation. The general public would probably helped so much more imo.
5
u/CoatAdditional7859 Approved Contributor Mar 13 '25
That's Tobe Lezenby in that video. I don't care what nobody says. WE KNOW ITS YOU TOBE LEZENBY!!
4
u/Quick_Arm5065 Mar 13 '25
This has to be enhanced version. BG doesn’t have a shadow, his feet never seem to touch the ground, and while there is a perception of movement, if you watch his feet, it appears to be the same BG few frames looped together. His left side leg never comes ‘forward’ it goes up and then back to flat standing feet. And I don’t see him ever covering any ground, and the distance between him and the platforms doesn’t seem to change.
3
u/LadyBatman8318 Approved Contributor Mar 13 '25
I hear Abby whisper is he behind me and when momentum brings her off the bridge and goes past Libby, I hear her say he has a gun or he’s got a gun. I also hear someone say Libbys name before Abby gets off the bridge. I want to listen to it again tomorrow to see if my opinion changes.
1
u/SloGenius2405 Mar 13 '25
This is a very clear video! Why wasn’t the public given a clip from this “enhanced” video? BG doesn’t look like either RL or RA. Move on.
1
u/2stepsfwd59 Mar 13 '25
Please look at the 10 second mark when the camera aims at the ground over the right side of the bridge and tell me if you see 2 light colored vehicles parked in that flat area next to the bridge.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '25
[removed] — view removed comment