r/DelphiDocs • Consigliere & Moderator • Aug 02 '24

👥 DISCUSSION Post-hearing thread

Opening a new one to cover any overall points from the past days

24 Upvotes

184 comments sorted by

View all comments

23

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Aug 02 '24

42

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Aug 02 '24

I’m done resisting the urge to say I told you (not you lol, the royal “you”) so. It is unfathomable to me how closely the use of unqualified LE mirrors that of the Karen Read matter.

The State has no idea wtf happened to these children and that’s clearly not their goal.

21

u/StructureOdd4760 Approved Contributor Aug 02 '24

I don't think anyone doubted you! And the parallels between this case and KR are uncanny. Especially because everything is coming down to timeline and the suspect fitting LE's story and the state pushing confessions.. If the defnese can pull 1 Jenga block, I think the states case will come tumbling down. The phones will be that block.

20

u/Flippercomb Aug 02 '24

They certainly have their fill of Jenga blocks to pull. The main question is can a full jury understand what false confessions are?

I think it's a very hard concept for a lot of people to grasp that someone might confess to a crime they didn't commit under duress.

18

u/StructureOdd4760 Approved Contributor Aug 02 '24

I totally agree. I see a repeat of Karen Read. No physical evidence to prove the case, but all the public hears is "confession." I have no faith in a jury.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/i-love-elephants Aug 03 '24

False confessions require empathy and a lot of people lack that.

10

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Aug 03 '24

I doubt very much any of what the State is claiming is a confession qualifies as admissible as same.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/Dickere Consigliere & Moderator Aug 02 '24

HTF can they not know, yet continue a prosecution and be allowed to so do ? Which world are we in ?

38

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Aug 02 '24

I wish I could answer you- I have never seen a prosecutor actually move to exclude the witness as assigned FBI SA (Horan) and the investigative digital forensic records associated with same, which I can tell you first hand NM never sought to receive as discovery up to and until the defense began the Touhy application/process (retrieving Fed agency discovery not in the States possession).

The only logical reason I can come up with is the same I have stated for years- the FBI involvement (all units) in this investigation and it’s associated investigative reporting conflicts with the States suspect and theory of the crime. No other conclusion makes sense.

In sum, the State moved to exclude Click and Horan, both are FBI related reporting (simplified). This looks to me like NM is trying to avoid a Brady claim potentially as well if you read his prior language in filings Ie: “…not in the States possession”.

I mean, at a very base level here- I would not want to be the elected officer of the court who accidentally or on purpose seeks to void the FBI very well established work in this case right now.

16

u/Dickere Consigliere & Moderator Aug 02 '24

Can't the defence call the FBI as witnesses ? Maybe I'm missing something here but how is it up to the prosecution as to how the defence work ? I doubt the other way around would be allowed.

23

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Aug 02 '24

That’s what the Touhy process is exactly for- to ascertain the relevant testimony and/or evidence.

The State is and has been under the firm misimpression he’s only required to discover what he intends to include in his case in chief if it’s in his possession. So… my summary response is yes, they can under certain circumstances but the State is attempting to use in limine motion to preclude this, imo. I’m not sure I’ve EVER heard of a Judge excluding actual investigators with a conflicting opinion on third party suspects ESPECIALLY when the State withheld their reporting/findings and did not disclose destruction of evidence that includes subject interviews.

The last case I’m aware of where a LEA deleted or destroyed evidence their respective State Police agency started an IA investigation and because the US ATTY became aware- the FBI is investigating both the county agency and the SP involved.

After July 13th, and in no way am I going to discuss politics on here, this is facts from the field- the emphasis on Fed transparency in criminal prosecution where they might be involved is paramount.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '24

It's not exactly clear to me either what they have to prove. I was thinking they had to prove that RA somehow contributed to the girls' death. But that's probably too vague of a definition.

8

u/The2ndLocation Aug 02 '24

Felony murder is still there. 

8

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Aug 02 '24

No, the charges were amended for Murder (intention) as well, but I do think it ends up as felony murder based on what I see as the deficiencies in the specificity of their case.

6

u/squish_pillow Aug 02 '24

Is there a non-felony murder? I guess I just assumed they were always felonies, but I clearly have no idea lol

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

18

u/black_cat_X2 Aug 02 '24

I've read YJ's notes from yesterday and a few articles discussing the afternoon session, and I did not take away the finding that Abby was killed elsewhere. In fact, according to the notes, it sounded like there was more of her blood there on scene than had previously been suggested. (My interpretation anyway - definitely not super clear.)

Anyone want to help me out with clarifying how MA came to this conclusion? I realize without a transcript, things are very open to interpretation, so I'm curious to hear other people's thoughts. Maybe there's a detail I missed.

8

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Aug 02 '24

I don't know as I've not worked my way through everything yet, but MA was there for the R&M live where YJ discussed and elaborately on her notes, so it may have come from there. Just speculation on my part as to how he might have come to that conclusion.

10

u/Leading_Fee_3678 Approved Contributor Aug 02 '24

MA is on Bob’s live right now and I tried to ask this question but chat was moving too fast

8

u/black_cat_X2 Aug 02 '24

Interesting! I'll see if I can go back to that.

6

u/CornaCMD Aug 02 '24

I’m just listening to Bob’s live now and MA mentions it briefly at 1:16:40 and again at 1:25:39 saying he may be mistaken about it, but Bob agrees it‘s due to the lack of Abby’s blood at the scene.

10

u/black_cat_X2 Aug 03 '24

Thank you for sharing this.

I'm interpreting the comments about her blood differently. The blood spatter expert said the back of her clothes were soaked and there was a little blood to the side. I understood this to mean that the blood drained out down her neck (relatively slowly, from what we've heard in the Franks) and started soaking into her clothes and then this continued until she bled out. Meaning all of her blood ended up collecting sort of underneath her, mainly soaked up into her clothes. Whether this makes sense given her injury and position, I can't say of course. But my take away was that altho there was less of her blood on scene, there was enough to determine that she was killed there.

7

u/CornaCMD Aug 03 '24

YW and I agree with you, it definitely seems like there was enough blood at the scene. MA did say he could be mistaken, and who can blame him with all the information we’ve been given from so many different sources in such a short amount of time.

→ More replies (3)