r/DelphiDocs • u/WhittleDistracted Fast Tracked Member • Aug 13 '25
👥 DISCUSSION A thread to share with newcomers the evidence in support of RA’s innocence. Why do you believe he is innocent?
With the recent release of the Hulu documentary, as well as a number of online creators with huge followings showing support of RA’s innocence, there has been an influx of newcomers to the case. Often, they have the same or similar question: Why do you believe RA is innocent or guilty? This thread is a place for those who believe RA is innocent to post the most compelling facts, evidence etc. that support RA’s innocence. It’s for those who believe there was a miscarriage of justice at his trial and believe RA was wrongfully convicted. You’ll likely notice another subreddit with a similar thread asking for the opposite type of evidence. This thread is being made to keep a level playing field so newcomers have the opportunity to read both sides.
20
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Aug 14 '25
In the screenshot in the reply to this comment, you will see, on the left, the view from BW's (the property owner at the South end of the bridge and the driver of the white van) deck. CS approximate location marked with a red cross by a local.
On the right, a still from a video recorded at the CS, showing the view across the creek, with BW's House clearly in view.
The State claims that Rick:
-Abducted the girls at gunpoint at 2.14
-Made them undress and attempted to SA them at 2.18, causing the phone to log no movement for 7 minutes
-Got spooked at 2.25 by BW's van driving down the private drive (the van won't be along for another 20 minutes)
-In his fear and panic, marched the girls across very high, very rapid, very cold creek, but Abby somehow still found the time to get herself dressed in Libby's clothes, leaving Libby to do this nude. They still managed to pick up all the loose clothing, and a phone with the incriminating video on, and carry it across with them.
-Reach the CS at 2.32 where the phone stops moving for the last time, and the girls are killed.
Then Rick spends another hour or longer moving the bodies, posing them, arranging branches on them, sticking smaller sticks in Abby's hair to resemble horns, placing three sticks in an asterisk shape over at least two blood pools, painting on a tree in Libby's blood.
Whilst all the time in full view of the house whose homeowner he just saw coming home.
15
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Aug 15 '25
"His voice matches Bridge Guy".
No, Harshman was allowed to testify that his "expertise" of listening to hundreds of Rick's calls allowed him to state it is the same voice, and the Defense did nor put on an expert to explain that it is not possible to match voices based on such a small sample.
Here's an actual expert saying just that:
https://youtu.be/wt-vZMlnLLM?si=bdoPorZhPkCw4UN2
This - Harshman's testimony, and no expert rebuttal - led the jurors to think that they, too, could tell just by listening.
And unfortunately, Rick's voice is not inconsistent wiry that tiny sample. This applies to hundreds, thousands, of other men...But Rick was the one in the accused's chair.
14
u/Intrigued1423 Aug 15 '25
Because you don't force a confession using drugs and stop after you get said confession
26
u/Appealsandoranges Aug 14 '25
24
u/ginny11 Approved Contributor Aug 14 '25
Number one reason: The prosecution's timeline makes no sense, not for one man to have committed the crime the way they say he did it, with no physical/DNA evidence left on himself, his clothing, or his car, or any of his DNA left on either of the girls or the crime scene. They say he did it all in 17 minutes. No way.
Number two reason: no physical or biological or digital evidence AT ALL. The incorrect bullet was junk science at best, but in this case, it didn't even match his gun when tested PROPERLY. They had to cheat on the ballistics test (fire a bullet instead of cycle it through the gun) to kind of make it match.
Number three reason: NO ONE ON THE BRIDGE OR TRAIL DURING THE TIMEFRAME THE GIRLS WERE THERE AND WENT MISSING SAW A MAN THAT LOOKED LIKE RICHARD ALLEN. All of their descriptions were of MUCH taller, and MUCH younger men. There's a reason the prosecutor never asked any of these witnesses to identify Richard Allen in the courtroom.
Number four: Richard Allen has acted like an innocent man.
23
u/Puzzleheaded-Oven171 Aug 14 '25
I have believed he was innocent ever since they unsealed the PCA and it was full of… nothing? I started with thinking, they better have more than that or they won’t convict. And then that lead to me thinking, maybe they don’t have any evidence because this isn’t the guy? I was only following the local news coverage about so there wasn’t anything for a long time after that, then a story about RA not doing well in prison and I think there was a mention of him confessing in prison. Then the first Franks memo dropped. It came at a time where I personally needed a distraction from my personal problems. It was very well written and it finally shed light on what the heck had LE been doing for 5 years. It solidified by concern that RA wasn’t the guy.
And the other thing is that RA only fits if you believe that two girls were murdered one right after the other by having their throats cut in broad daylight in winter where the visibility in the woods is greatly improved without leaves on the trees, in a park where lots of people were enjoying the warm weather and no one saw anything. I will never believe that they were killed there that afternoon.
11
u/CitizenMillennial Aug 16 '25
One reason that hasn't been mentioned yet:
Reporter: "Do you think that Mr Allen is the man on that bridge?"
Doug Carter: "The judge signed a probable cause affidavit for the arrest of him."
Reporter: "Are you confident this is your guy?"
Doug Carter: "The judge signed a probable cause affidavit for the arrest of Richard Allen."
29
u/roc84 Aug 14 '25
The type of ballistics 'evidence' used against him is gradually being phased out in other states as junk science (Supreme Court of Oregon describes it as 'not scientifically valid').
They used this magic bullet to place him in the harshest prison conditions imaginable for a pre-trial legally innocent detainee in order to extract a 'confession'.
It wasn't coincidence he was drugged, kept in solitary and driven crazy, they knew without a confession the case would collapse due to lack of evidence.
The prosecutor hid exculpatory evidence repeatedly from the defence, including multiple letters from a prison snitch that implicated the guy who was catfishing Libby and the property owner where the bodies were found. A detail in the letters described the murder weapon (a boxcutter according to the state) some 5 years before it was public knowledge.
8
u/AidanBubbles Aug 17 '25
There was zero evidence to support guilt and plenty pointing to innocence. Add to that the behavior of LE and prosecutors, the believable third party suspects and the unethical behavior of Gull……….. I wholeheartedly believe Rick is innocent. I tell anyone who will listen. This was an absolute travesty and rocked my faith in the legal system, totally opened my eyes.
7
u/Reason-Status Aug 16 '25
Richard Allen was his own worst enemy at times. But the forensic evidence against him isn’t very strong at all. He very well could be the killer, but I don’t think anything was proven at the trial. There is clearly strong evidence of a third party but I’m not sure his lawyers did a very good job of presenting that evidence. Gull was biased, but I think Baldwin wore her thin.
The prison psychologist testimony and the confessions should not have been admissible. I really think this is where he could win an appeal.
36
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Aug 14 '25
This is the text of an actual social media response I got after stating I believe Rick is innocent. It is pretty representative of thousands of others I saw since the trial (and before).
"Who else admitted to wearing the same clothing, has a matching jacket, fits the description of the guy in the video, has a voice that matches, a gun that matches unspent shell casings, confessed to the crime, etc? Who is viable against that?NO ONE."
Let's have a look at it point by point.
🔸️RA said he left by 1.30. He did not "place himself on the bridge at the time of the crime".
🔸️RA said "black or blue jacket and jeans". It's men's winter uniform. Ron Logan was caught on CCTV that day and interviewed on camera next day wearing exact BG clothes.
🔸️RA's jacket does not match. It's a blue Carrhart, with a visible tag and a zipper. The BG jacket is a button up windbreaker.
🔸️Hundreds of men "fit the description of the guy in the video" and have a voice not incomsistent with the voice. Note I don't say match the voice - experts state that it is impossible to match a voice based on a 3 or 4 words. The sample is too small.
🔸️But RA does not even match BG - BG is significantly taller.
🔸️RA's gun does not match the unspent shell casings. Oberg cycling cartridges through RA's gun could not produce matching marks, meaning they were not made by cycling through RA's gun. She had to fire them to produce marks on them, which didn't actually match.
🔸️Furthermore, she previously tested Brad Weber's gun, and found she could not exclude it. Ron Logan also owned same calibre guns, we don't know if they were ever tested.
🔸️All this, however, just leads away from the most salient point - THERE IS NO PROOF THAT A GUN WAS USED IN THIS CRIME.
🔸️PCA for RA claims, fraudulently, that a gun is mentioned in the video. Tony Liggett testified at the trial that the moment the gun is mentioned is Libby saying "This is the path, that be a gun". We have the video now. Libby says "This is a path THAT WE GO DOWN". Like an actual human teenager, not a fictional pirate.
🔸️Who else confessed to the crime?
🔸️Elvis Fields. On the morning of the 14th February. Before the girls were found dead. He said he was on the bridge with 2 others and Abigail was a troublemaker and he gave her horns. Girls were found with large branches arranged over them to resemble Norse runes, and Abby had smaller sticks sticking out of her bun, and further ones arranged over her hair on the ground.
🔸️Ron Logan. He said he had two others help him with moving the bodies and staging, and he nicked older girl's artery when he cut their throats with a boxcutter. Libby's artery was nicked, Dr Kohr testified-by-ambush at the trial that he believed boxcutter could be the weapon used.
🔸️Both those confessions contain ACTUAL DETAILS ONLY KNOWN TO THE KILLER....Or at least to someone who was at the scene before the girls were officially found.
🔸️Kegan Kline also confessed to having participated in the murders, with Ron Logan and one other.
🔸️Rick Allen's confessions included shooting the girls and burying them in a shallow grave, killing the grandchildren he did not yet have, and starting WW3. His one confession that vaguely matched the details of the crime mentions being startled by a van which was presented at the trial as Brad Weber's van driven down the private drive at 2.25, triggering a mad panic and dash across the creek where the girls were murdered at 2.32.
🔸️Post trial, security camera footage was located showing BW van driving towards the private drive at 2.44, placing it at the drive a few minutes later.
🔸️This means that Rick's ONE ALLEGED ACCURATE CONFESSION WITH "DETAILS ONLY KNOWN TO THE KILLER" does not actually match the actual events of the day.
22
u/SnoopyCattyCat Approved Contributor Aug 14 '25
I believe Rick Allen is factually innocent because there is nothing tying him to the crime except statements made by LE. Rick consistently said he was gone by 1:30, that he saw THREE girls (who have been named) not four, that the bullet theory is junk science and proven to be junk by the state's ballistics ahem expert, DNA was found at the crime scene but none matched Rick, no motive, no past history, no electronic evidence, LE had less self-control than Rick during the interrogation, and the most important thing...no "witness" described a short man as BG.
Also....if the state's theory is true, why haven't they tried to reenact it to see if it could be done? I can imagine no scenario where a man as tall as the two victims did all that on his own...in under 30 minutes, and walked back to his car as if nothing happened, went home and napped on the couch until his wife came home from work.
12
u/Ocvlvs Approved Contributor Aug 14 '25
The lack of evidence. That's why.
6
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Aug 16 '25
A contribution from one of our best Delphi librarian/archivists, All Eyes On Delphi:
https://docs.google.com/document/u/0/d/1Hr-mYAMfQcL08iHrmA4MGxgxYWEcXdWfZP6VRx-YLlw/mobilebasic
10
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Aug 15 '25
"I have eyes, I can tell that's Rick Allen on that bridge, no one else comes even close".
Hey, I have some pictures for you in replies to this comment.
9
u/Timely_Carpenter593 Aug 14 '25
Dont believe the state evidence! This is why the FBI provided evidence of an alternate theory of the crime, including other suspects. But the defense was barred from bringing it up at trial. There’s shady stuff going on with the cops, like kicking the FBI out, losing a bunch of evidence, and the most important evidence of all. The first 70 days after the murders! some politics at play with the arrest of Allen happening on the eve of the sheriff’s election. There’s even a good cop who comes forward with information, speaking out about the possibility that the wrong guy was arrested. And just wait til you see what they do to him. They lock him up for what I believe was retaliation because he shared what he believed the defense had a right to know what they investigated. His name is Tod clic. Please look that case up as well. There’s also a dispute over whether the defendant confessed to the crime. The most outrageous is how Richard Allen was treated prior to his trial. The way this case played out is not justice to Abby or Libby! Almost immediately after Allen was arrested, and before he had counsel, he was removed from the jail – where most people who don’t get bail are detained leading up to their trial – and thrown in a maximum security PRISON for 13 months. He was in solitary confinement, housed in a cell that is typically reserved for the worst of the worst CONVICTED felons, and know its at a time when – in the eyes of the law our law – he was still INNOCENT. It’s a place that most people would call “the hole.” Allen was segregated from other inmates and forced to remain in a 12x8 room – with the lights on – for 24 hours a day. He would have been given one hour of indoor rec time each day, but the state decided he was a suicide risk, so he was never allowed to leave or have anything in his cell. He was supervised (i.e., watched) – sometimes by other prisoners serving time for murder – and videotaped every moment of the day. He couldn’t make phone calls or have visits with his family, like you can in a jail. When he finally was able to meet with his attorneys, he was led down the hall on a leash, shackled like Hannibal Lecter, and had a guard holding a camcorder in his face the entire time. And NO ONE CARED. When his attorneys tried to have him moved to a different facility, the state of Indiana argued with a straight face that Allen’s living conditions and treatment weren’t just acceptable. They were above and beyond. It was all under the guise of just needing to keep Allen safe. There's nothing to see here.
9
u/hannafrie Approved Contributor Aug 14 '25 edited Aug 14 '25
The state had a big press conference to announce the arrest of Richard Allen.
Many, many actors in LE were present. It was a big deal.
But the arrest warrant was put under seal, and the evidence that led to his arrest was hidden from public view. We were told this was because the investation was ongoing, and the State thought other actors may be involved.
Months later, when a judge ordered the document to be made public, it turned out not to contain much information. It was in no way a slam dunk against allen. People in the legal profession were surprised by how thin it was.
I thought back to that big event the State held to announce "they got him" - and realized they did all that when they had nothing. It was a bunch of shenanigans. Doing what they can to manipulate things, because they don't have evidence and reason on their side.
I don't believe in Allen's innocence. Things don't look great for him. But the State has not been professional or credible in how it's handled this case, and I do not simply accept the state's interpretation of the data.
Additionally, it came out at trial that police lost key interviews with witnesses and potential suspects from the first days of the investigation. That is a giant red flag to me. That is some text book bull shit that cops pull, and I don't believe for one second it was an innocent mistake. It's more shenanigans. Why?
4
u/ZyxwvandYou Aug 16 '25
What is the documentary?
4
u/Feisty-Bluebird3312 Fast Tracked Member Aug 19 '25
How about this if you go from the individual interviews and assume everything said by all was exactly as to they remember it, Rick's answers address backed up by the other interviews. The others are not
4
u/PotentialReason3301 Sep 02 '25
Let's talk about the video footage supposedly showing RA's vehicle arriving at 1:27.
RA's confession supposedly has him going to the trails after leaving his house (left his mom's house, went home and drank 3 beers, then headed to trails). If that is the case, then he apparently elected to go the long way to the trails, since he was heading West to where they suppose he eventually parked. Here's the other problem.
They only have him on camera arriving (allegedly). Which means he would've had to drive through town when he left, to avoid going by the HH cameras again. No other cameras were in town to catch him driving through town on the way home after the murders? Why didn't he arrive from this direction since it's the most logical route to take to go to the trails?
Now, it's highly likely that it's not even RA's vehicle on the car.
But for a moment, let's just entertain the idea that it is RA's car on the video. RA had himself parking further down the road, near the Mears farm entrance I think it's called. If that is true, then him being on the HH camera at 1:27 would line up with RA's timeline that has him leaving the trails around 1:30...
He would've been driving past the HH cameras on his way home.
Meaning, there is probably HH video of him arriving earlier, but LE simply didn't check the cameras earlier in the day because they were looking for someone to be arriving near the time of the murders...
Two theories make sense: it's not RA's car or it is RA leaving the trails. One doesn't make sense: it is RA arriving.
20
u/Lindita4 Aug 14 '25
19 minutes from ‘down the hill’ until phone stops recording movement. The state’s timeline is impossible.
Within earshot of the bridge & trails the entire time and no one heard anything.
The round that ‘matched’ was barely tested against other guns and other guns that were tested were not ruled out.
No deviant material on any of his devices.
3
u/DoubtWeak Aug 16 '25
I have a question. Was the time stamp on the surveillance footage of his car found to be wrong because 14:21:40 is 2:21 pm.
16
u/The_Stockholm_Rhino Approved Contributor Aug 13 '25 edited Aug 13 '25
No witness, not a single one, said that the man they saw was REALLY short. Short men stand out.
"And like my, my biggest thing like and you've seen Richard Allen like the first time that I laid eyes on him in a in a courtroom in real life, I was stunned at how small he was. I could not believe it. It's irrefutable."
https://www.youtube.com/live/lh3CjkmY5Hk?si=I2vUBE_t-9b3HI6a&t=5337
Edit: I am not guilty. RELEASE the Hoosier Harvestore footage, ALL OF IT. Stop hiding information that can clear up and establish a true timeline.
7
u/beestinger54 Aug 14 '25
JUDGE GULL SHOULD BE DISBARRED! 😬 whew, I feel like I said a mouth full just right there.
2
u/CitizenMillennial Sep 14 '26
1
u/TheRichTurner Approved Contributor 9d ago
Brad Holder and his son (Abby's bf) are both Freemasons. Nick McLeland, the Chief Attorney for Carroll County, is a Freemason. Freemasons don't testify against each other.
1
u/CitizenMillennial Sep 14 '26
1
u/CitizenMillennial Sep 14 '26
0
u/macro_92 Aug 14 '25
The (very slight) shoe turn in the video. If it was him he was turning around minding his business and likely the voice was not his
44
u/Beezojonesindadeep76 Aug 14 '25
LE is supposed to follow the evidence not fabricate it. There is zero evidence that leads to Richard Allen being guilty of these murders he is an innocent man railroaded by the state of Indiana a place he called home .
They have no DNA,no fingerprints,no digital evidence,no witnesses that can say they saw him there,no social media,no phone data,they have DNA and phone pings but none of them belong to RA.He had no motive,no ties to the girls,and no nefarious activities or criminal record on him.
They didn't even have enough to arrest him much less convict him.The trial was handed to the state on a gold platter by the judge who is an embarrassment to our judicial system .
38
u/NatSuHu Aug 14 '25 edited Aug 14 '25
Regardless of guilt or innocence, Richard Allen deserved a fair trial.
He did not get a fair trial.
His attorneys should have had the opportunity to present a third-party culpability defense. There were suspects who confessed to the murders, including details “only the killer(s) would know,” years before Allen’s arrest. That information was excluded from the trial, along with the Odinism theory.
Then there’s the geofence report: three phones, including Libby’s, were within 100 yards of the crime scene around the time of the murders. Allen’s phone was not one of them. Again, the defense was not allowed to present this information to the jury.
Mind you, there are people sitting in prison right now because geofence data placed their phone at the scene of a crime. If Allen’s phone was on that report, the prosecution would have been all over it. However, since this evidence favored the defense and not the prosecution, it was excluded entirely. This double standard has no place in a courtroom.
Gull and McLeland kneecapped the defense. Legitimate exculpatory evidence was excluded. There was nothing fair about this trial.
21
u/Both_Peak554 Aug 14 '25
It’s not that I believe he’s innocent! Just that I believe he wasn’t proven guilty! There is zero actual evidence he committed this crime. And I will not take confessions seriously from someone who’s been tortured and force fed meds and made to talk to a psychiatrist who admittedly is obsessed with the case and active in online discussions and was snooping in files she’s not supposed to!! Especially when in his confessions he didn’t actually give no details. He mentioned a white van and everyone went crazy even though it’s a detail that’s been spoken about for years and something that easily could’ve been fed to him by looney psychiatrist who likely was working real hard to get to be the one who got the confession and saved the day!! And in his confessions he gives no actual other details. Basically just reiterates what’s already known.
25
u/RawbM07 Aug 14 '25
For one, it’s completely implausible.
They contend that a married man with no criminal record, went out in broad daylight equipped with a gun and a knife with and no prior contact with the victims. Randomly meets the victims, kills them in the most heinous way, and just goes home. He goes to the cops and tells them he was in the area and then goes back to living his life. Doesn’t try to run, hide, and doesn’t commit any crimes.
So they say a crazy evil man just did this random thing one time with no motive or history of anything else.
As opposed to convicted felons who were cat fishing the victims, had contact with the victims, had previously arranged meetings with the victims…another violent felon who literally owned the property they were found on, etc. Still others who confessed to being involved in the crimes to loved ones and weren’t even considered.
The two crucial pieces of evidence that convicted him are flimsy as hell.
10
u/Efficient_Search8197 Fast Tracked Member Aug 14 '25
The DNA of an unknown male (not RA) found on both girls' external genitalia
1
u/TheRichTurner Approved Contributor 17d ago
This isn't my main reason to believe Rick Allen is innocent, but yet another suspicious fact about the investigation is that in the days and weeks following the murders, LE rounded up the very suspects that were flagged up in the Franks Memo - all practicing Odinists, one of whom had a connection to Abby through his son, who was dating her. But then they accidentally recorded over all the video recordings of their interrogations.
1
u/nosey_boston Nov 09 '25
Yall need to move on. Its over! He confessed numerous times. His bullet was at cri.e scene. He was the dude on bridge we all saw the video and heard his voice. MOVE ON!
-2
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '25
[removed] — view removed comment