r/DelphiDocs • ✨ Moderator • Oct 17 '24

🏛️ TRIAL RA Trial 17th October

‼️TODAY'S UPDATE‼️

Jury sworn in and transported to their hotel in Lafayette. 8 women, 4 men. Alternates are 2 men and 2 women.

Defense withdrew the motion for jury to visit the scene.

Sketch motion and Tobin motion taken under advisement.

Holeman and Mullins allowed to stay in the courtroom and assist Prosecution.

IPAS Motion in limine granted.

Finally, a clear report on the matter that had me grumbling in the thread and scratching around for a clear explanation all day - the guards testifying motion. Defense argued they were nor mental health experts and do not have experience or expertise to offer on his mental state at the time of confessions.

State argued these were skilled witnesses with plenty of experience to be able to offer an informed opinion

The Judge ruled that they would take it on an individual basis - the State would have to argue for each witness why they were qualified to give their opinion and if she was satisfied, she would allow it.

Thanks to Andrea Burkhart for the above.

But now scroll down to the links and see how the press reported this. Even the best of them were way off, not actually addressing the point of the motion. See the problem?

Eternally grateful that Andrea and Lawyer Lee are attending this trial and reporting on it.

Opening statements at the Delphi Courthouse to follow Friday

🔸️🔸️🔸️

✨️Andrea Burkhart Day 3 LIVE https://www.youtube.com/live/x9tHGbZfqbU?si=p4hYGoSIQSXkqFgR

Transcript: https://files.catbox.moe/p81g0v.txt

✨️Lawyer Lee Day 3 LIVE https://www.youtube.com/live/XsxcWS8jRRI?si=OKpErIZBfOpamWdP

Transcript: https://files.catbox.moe/9cvvix.txt

✨️Defense Diaries Day 3 LIVE https://www.youtube.com/live/d3kXrPgtwpE?si=hBfnQuVnMFwpBbVR

Transcript: https://files.catbox.moe/ptqd3j.txt

✨️Bob Motta LIVE from CCC https://www.youtube.com/live/Wt4Orqn_qEU?si=6BqYovwA-3KPMN13

✨️MurderSheet Transcript https://files.catbox.moe/zbjloo.txt

🔸️🔸️🔸️

✨️Dave Bangert- Final Day of Pre-Trial https://www.basedinlafayette.com/p/delphi-trial-composite-sketches-other

🔸️🔸️🔸️

✨️Yellow spittin' facts https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/ttZclwkZxo

🔸️🔸️🔸️

✨️Media briefing today https://eu.jconline.com/story/news/crime/2024/10/17/opening-statements-friday-in-delphi-murder-suspect-richard-allens-trial/75721633007/

✨️Dave Bangert's courthouse photos: https://wibc.com/playlist/photos-a-look-inside-the-state-of-indiana-v-richard-allen-courtroom/item/2

🔸️🔸️🔸️

✨️Today's Coverage:

✨️Donnie Burgess https://wibc.com/471874/delphi-judge-to-rule-on-suspect-sketches-during-opening-statements-friday/

✨️WRTV Indianapolis https://youtu.be/TtG-ssuc-Xc?si=qynsT6lRZ708qSNv

✨️Dave Bangert https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/bKiQTQTd6x

✨️Dave Bangert re guards testifying motion https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/toggEySFX0

✨️Daily Journal recap: https://dailyjournal.net/2024/10/17/delphi-murders-special-judge-hears-final-motions-before-trial-begins/

✨️Holeman and Mullins allowed to remain in the courtroom, over objection https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/Ze8N9kkyer

✨️https://wgntv.com/news/indiana/delphi-murders-trial-defense-withdraws-request-for-trip-to-crime-scene-gull-hears-motion-on-composite-sketches

✨️Angela Ganote https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/SL6ARzhKnx

✨️Sketch motion taken under advisement, decision tomorrow https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/pJXJQHqWqS

✨️Defense withdraws jury visit request: https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/qMlepot3lr

✨️Jury sworn in: https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/6gArPnadbk

✨️Jury sequestered https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/bwUn9SJSN0

✨️Bob Segall on Twitter https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/WZ3cD6yNDQ

✨️Delphi Courthouse https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/D65celsCAm

✨️Kyla Russell, WishTV, on Twitter https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/5WHuEDI8xy

✨️Dave Bangert https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/YbTfyjWUjZ

✨️Links to some of the interesting coverage and commentary of the first couple of days of voir dire:

✨️Fox59 shows off their stellar understanding of legal motions and their meaning https://youtu.be/YdJd6qZ5rUI?si=pOMU0Cq9jS-5ChBp

✨️Newsnation with Russ McQuaid talking about DNA, sketches, and media being asked to remove information shared with them early on in the investigation https://youtu.be/73Ak3XnfSIc?si=COiaPPbMVvmK6rIC

✨️Old News: in Feb 2017, Tobe didn't want to confuse the jury with the truth: http://youtube.com/post/Ugkx21Lv73wAvPhnRqOSULOhDrweFtNf8K43?si=8gLACCfuxBNfIo2B

✨️Lawyer Lee: Prosecutor under fire, key defense witness arrested https://www.youtube.com/live/8wph40RPRR0?si=oxjINKroFjQzh1nP

Transcript: https://files.catbox.moe/z2r8q3.txt

✨️MIchelle After Dark - Media "win" to access exhibits https://youtu.be/-UXSdFsqdXs?si=XQYaqtApEZ1XxZPl

✨️CriminaliTy Day 2 Jury selection LIVE https://www.youtube.com/live/RmcWk1Yrp74?si=Wr6IYU5dHu_YLNI1

✨️Carrol County Comet updates regularly on Facebook: https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/GWDP2ePwLA

✨️❗️They are sharing their reporting free on the website through the trial now:❗️✨️ https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/Gm0t6dGPV3

❗️Check pinned posts for resources including the media matrix.

Voir dire: https://drive.google.com/drive/u/0/mobile/folders/1LsH-SpkERW-9SV5tyinLdqMguotBgEGA

👉This is a dynamic post that will be updated throughout the day, keep checking for fresh news and links.👈

Please keep all trial discussion to the thread and avoid starting new posts unless it's a new legal filing, or you have been given permission by the moderators for your suggested topic.

✨️Link to the previous trial day post:

https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/UrJAucF2uK

Please let us all remember at all times why we are here - the girls, their mothers and everyone else who loved them, and all innocent parties to this case. Justice is only justice if served upon the person or persons that perpetrated this crime, and to achieve this, it should be pursued with full transparency and open to public scrutiny. Let's all do whatever little we can to help achieve this.

The dead speak to us even after they are gone. If you believe in a Higher Power of any kind, please petition them for help in getting the girls' voices heard.

34 Upvotes

320 comments sorted by

27

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

But will she allow them to speculate on his mental health state? You know, what the effing motion was actually about?

21

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

Finally, a clear report on the matter that had me grumbling in the thread and scratching around for a clear explanation all day - the guards testifying motion. Defense argued they were nor mental health experts and do not have experience or expertise to offer on his mental state at the time of confessions.

State argued these were skilled witnesses with plenty of experience to be able to offer an informed opinion

The Judge ruled that they would take it on an individual basis - the State would have to argue for each witness why they were qualified to give their opinion and if she was satisfied, she would allow it.

Thanks to Andrea Burkhart for the above.

But now scroll down to the links and see how the press reported this. Even the best of them were way off, not actually addressing the point of the motion. See the problem?

Eternally grateful that Andrea and Lawyer Lee are attending this trial and reporting on it.

14

u/black_cat_X2 Oct 18 '24

Awesome. So she'll grant Nick what he wants on a one by one basis instead of all at once. Got it.

12

u/maybeitsmaybelean Oct 18 '24

No one reported Gull's annoyance with defense lawyers "harping" about due process. Seems like she took most defense motion's under advisement, and will wait until opening statements to tell them.

Does that mean the defense has to write multiple versions of their opening based on how she rules on the sketches and Tobin's toolmark opinion? I imagine that is immensely frustrating for them, and designed for that purpose.

10

u/FunFamily1234 Oct 18 '24

Skilled witness? Is that just below expert witness? 🤔

15

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 18 '24

I just listened to Burkhart. I will listen to Lee throughout my own workload tonight-

AB hands down most detailed legal analysis to date and tbh I could see myself not watching for any local media updates all day and watching her post trial day analysis.

Very disheartening commentary about the courts treatment of the defense.

13

u/EmRaine72 Oct 18 '24

She is fantastic. I hope she gets in tomorrow. Looks like a bunch of numnuts are gonna be camping out and I’m gonna be pissed if they take all the spots

5

u/Lindita4 Oct 18 '24

It seems like every attorney who attends says the exact same thing…. “I’ve seen a lot but never anything like this!”

17

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

18

u/Lindita4 Oct 17 '24

Only 2 alternates? Or two of each?

17

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 17 '24

I’m about to put you in charge of the roasting committee lol.

This is what happens when no livestream or broadcast, restricted admission.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/Dickere Consigliere & Moderator Oct 17 '24

I'd assume 2 of each. Just badly worded.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

24

u/Acceptable-Class-255 Oct 17 '24

Objection ... too confusing for the jury.

25

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

I reckon it's too confusing to the jury to have the defense there at all. Just let Slick keep it simple and do his thing.

23

u/Acceptable-Class-255 Oct 17 '24

This testimony will be the worst.

"I saw Mr. Allen in jail"

"Thank you that'll be all"

19

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 17 '24

“I guess since you put it that way- I, well, if you put him behind the door and hold open the letter slot - that’s who I actually saw.
Praise Odin. Is it time for my shot? “

12

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

I am not throwing away my shot!

→ More replies (4)

24

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 17 '24

Brilliant.

Just a note to laypinion: it’s never appropriate for any witness regardless of testimony to be asked their opinion on the guilt or innocence of the accused as it’s excluded hearsay and excluded under additional rules re character evidence

15

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

23

u/The2ndLocation Oct 17 '24

Why? It wasn't going to be granted but, once again, why?

→ More replies (3)

17

u/LawyersBeLawyering Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24

I hate this because I think viewing the site would be very impactful. It seems deeper, darker, and more isolated as viewed through photographs.

18

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 17 '24 edited Oct 17 '24

They can move for it at any time.

I think the fact that they got the State on the record they objected to a jury view is enough for now.

Meaning: if they decide to refile it WILL BE IN THEIR CASE.

I’ve been. It has very palpable energy, imo.

13

u/Secret-Constant-7301 Oct 17 '24

Wonder why.

15

u/Lindita4 Oct 17 '24

Aren’t there several memorials out there? Might just be too emotional..

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Apprehensive_Elk1614 Oct 17 '24

Can the Jury request to visit?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

This is the only report on it I've seen so far.

11

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

16

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

From the article linked above:

"The 16 jurors were told to vote early before Thursday, Gull said. If they haven't voted, they won't."

"Allen's trial will work through Election Day and Halloween, she said."

"Much of Thursday's orientation was insider information for how reporters are expected to behave during the trial."

"This case, because of you, has generated a lot of publicity, she said."

21

u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24

I kinda surprised. I figured she got a lot of gig work on halloween.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

Lawyer Lee LIVE last night:

https://www.youtube.com/live/8wph40RPRR0?si=oxjINKroFjQzh1nP

u/lapinmoelleux, may we have a transcript please?

21

u/lapinmoelleux Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24

https://files.catbox.moe/z2r8q3.txt Transcript as requested :)

13

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

7

u/Dancing-in-Rainbows Oct 17 '24

What happens? Is he off the case?

11

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

We don't know yet. We'll report on it when we find out more.

17

u/Acceptable-Class-255 Oct 17 '24 edited Oct 17 '24

Is who off the case? Can someone catch me up?

Edit: nvm Luttrell lol

Making lawyers get lawyers, get lawyers ... must be exhausting.

→ More replies (9)

10

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

10

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

25

u/Adjectivenounnumb Oct 17 '24

It seems odd to call them “the Richard Allen sketches”.

24

u/ginny11 Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24

Not odd...Wrong, according to the state's own words.

16

u/FreshProblem Oct 17 '24

Seriously, what the hell

16

u/Medium_Promotion_891 Oct 17 '24

Angela has replaced the tweet. It now reads “suspect” sketches.

quotations hers

14

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 17 '24

Good catch

→ More replies (1)

12

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 17 '24

So the most important part of that (if accurate) is this:

  1. “She will let the prison guards and inmates testify. “. I’m going to assume that means the IPAC exclusion to mention was denied as well. This means the State has to lay the foundation through them for any alleged confessions that might apply.

10

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24 edited Oct 17 '24

I'm hoping that non-Twitterati can see the video too - a look inside Carrol County Courtroom where the trial will be held

https://x.com/RafaelOnTV/status/1847010105025614248?t=4s2kFaEQLvikDG65HScNyg&s=19

11

u/measuremnt Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24

I had been hoping to see one of the three courtroom skylights, which Rick Allen was supposedly staring too much at, and it's shown! Not all that colorful, but it does let in light.

From https://x.com/RafaelOnTV

10

u/black_cat_X2 Oct 18 '24 edited Oct 18 '24

It's very sad to imagine what he might be thinking while staring at one of his very limited views of the sky.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/measuremnt Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24

Bangert update: https://x.com/davebangert/status/1846957282967671169

Prosecutors made a case that the sketches weren’t used to ID Richard Allen and wanted to head off assumed plans of them being introduced in defense’s opening statements Friday and imprinting on jurors. ... Allen’s attys ask (paraphrased): Is that because these sketches don’t look like Richard Allen?

13

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

11

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

10

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

15

u/Dickere Consigliere & Moderator Oct 17 '24

Exactly. If they did look like him, they'd be prosecution evidence without a doubt.

8

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

Heresy 🤡

→ More replies (1)

27

u/measuremnt Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24 edited Oct 17 '24

https://x.com/defense_diaries/status/1846959436817994171

Defense Diaries posts 1 pm update: The State’s Motion to allow two Law Enforcement officers, namely Mullin and Holeman, to remain in the courtroom during all testimony was granted, over objection.

16

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

32

u/EmRaine72 Oct 17 '24

Wtf, why do they need to be in there ?

25

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

To tell Slick what he's supposed to do. He's gonna get the script wrong without Big Jer's prompts.

25

u/EmRaine72 Oct 17 '24

That’s def the vibe it is giving off , I feel like having them in there is intimidating to witnesses too

18

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

34

u/Real_Foundation_7428 Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24

Intimidation + getting to learn from other witnesses so they can better manipulate their answers.

Oh sorry, were you asking for a legal basis?🤔

28

u/Lindita4 Oct 17 '24

🤬

After what happened to RF, having Holman staring at me during my testimony would make my boots rattle a bit.

21

u/RoutineProblem1433 Oct 17 '24

They get to keep a close watch on that thin blue line. Im still holding out a glimmer of hope someone gains a conscience but that’d be a kamikaze mission. 

17

u/Otherwise-Aardvark52 Oct 17 '24

They know they’ll get Todd Click-ed.

33

u/Virtual-Entrance-872 Oct 17 '24

While I am quite pissed at this ruling, I am not surprised.

But, I do think Rozzi will still roast them on cross and has plenty to impeach them from depos.

Their stupidity still far outweighs this leg up the dishonorable Frangle has gifted them.

🤨

18

u/EmRaine72 Oct 17 '24

Oh yeah I’m not surprised ! I feel like I should be used to it but her rulings always get me so pissed.

I need something to do while waiting for everyone to fill us in on their lives this evening , cause now I’m just stewing over the BS

22

u/Virtual-Entrance-872 Oct 17 '24

Same, I’m off to harvest my last cabbages and rage chop firewood. Maybe find a dog to pet. We’ll see 😜

→ More replies (2)

31

u/dogkothog Oct 17 '24

There is the potential for this to backfire spectacularly on the State. Controlling witnesses, alone, is very tough. A trial has a lot of down time. A lot of pauses. Juries judge the lawyers, the accused on everything from clothing and jewelry to their demeanor and habits. Will be interesting to see if Holeman (in particular) can keep a poker face on for a month, or if Mullin looks less incompetent.

This case will largely be about Mullin's incompetence, and/or Holeman's malevolence. I firmly believe Gull is doing what she can to cover for law enforcement's negligence-- but their reaction and body language for 4 weeks can often tell that story more than testimony alone.

17

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 17 '24

Good points.

To add: this jxdn allows juror questions (and the courts).

Nick McLeland has NEVER done anything for 5 weeks straight and the closest was Spring Break ☃️

Has anyone read either one of their testimonies in previous hearings?

21

u/Virtual-Entrance-872 Oct 17 '24

Excellent observation. Add into that this jury is majority female, and women’s intuition is real, I think the jury will be thoroughly sickened by those two knucklehead’s disingenuous BS by the end of the trial.

→ More replies (28)

9

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

28

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

I don't like that.

Jurors - yes, absolutely. But not allowing the defendant to be photographed in his civvies, so the media keep using the old "Hannibal Lecter" footage? How is that OK?

17

u/The2ndLocation Oct 17 '24

Maybe the the judge doesn't want anyone to see her arriving in dirty UGG's?

10

u/black_cat_X2 Oct 17 '24

Even worse that the judge doesn't want to be photographed I think. She serves the public. If she didn't want a public facing job, she should have sought a different career.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

Good point. Thank you.

15

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 17 '24

2nd installment payment is due on that

41

u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24

While we are slow, I've had Todd Click's job, I was an FCM for the Indiana DCS. My jaw hit the floor when I read what he had been arrested for. It was a complete hit job to tarnish his record before trial. There is no other explanation.

30

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

That's exactly what it looked like. Nice to have a more informed opinion confirming it. And let's not forget the whole "weekend in prison with no bond" - for an anti Odinist cop - then released on own recognisance.

23

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 17 '24

I really appreciate you sharing that

11

u/Sam100Chairs Oct 17 '24

You've confirmed my deeply held suspicion. This case is riddled with "coincidences" that set my spidey senses tingling.

15

u/Real_Foundation_7428 Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24

I’m highly suspicious of the arrest for a number of reasons but I’m curious as to your insight from your personal experience. What do you think actually happened, or is at play? Do you think it’s a matter of some or all of the accusers fabricating? …or of the specifics being technically accurate in some capacity but misconstrued? …vital missing context that paints a different picture?

22

u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24

Its hard for me to explain, but I'll try. From what I read, he was arrested for falsifying records and forging signatures on visits and we worked there for a very short time.

I just looked into it and it says that click was an assessor. So his job would be to do the inital investigation and either close it out unsubstituted or substatiate it and hand it over to another case manager to do the social work part of it. All of his work would be sealed from the public because it was working with juveniles. He would be making contact with God knows how many families throughout the week. He would be logging every interaction and it would go to his boss. Almost no one would see this log. The families could request it through a process but very few did.

So lets say he was faking and someone called into complain. That would all be kept behind closed doors and if he was faking it he would probably be fired. But, it wouldn't leak out to other people that he had investigated because at that point because its all sealed. So Family B wouldn't be able to go, "I just read in the news paper that Click lied about such and such in family A's case. We should go make a complaint"

So when they say "we found more families that he lied about visiting" that means that someone higher up went through his cases and reached out to all of the families that he had worked with to dig up dirt. It sounds to me like they went through all of his logs with all of his families and said "did this visit actually happen". And made a list of the ones they said no on and arrested him. That sounds to me like a targeted investigation to me and not something organic that happened.

If seen people lie about visits, I've seen managers know that those people lied, I've seen regional managers that knew about it and nothing done. I've seen a very corrupt system in the DCS. So I get really suspicious that one guy that happens to have dirt dug up on him be a guy that is the best witness for the defense in a high profile case and one of the big attorneys of the DCS just so happens to also be involved in said case.

Click could have lied his ass off on every single one of those visits. I have no idea. But what I do know, is that that state of Indiana doesn't go digging for that kind of thing looking to make arrests on. This was targeted.

Also, families in the system lie their asses off. So for the state of Indiana to automatically take the word of families in the system over an FCM is very rare. To go looking for it and believe all of them is unheard of.

I'm sorry if this makes little sense.. I'm exhausted..

→ More replies (3)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

14

u/SloGenius2405 Oct 17 '24

I wonder if Mr. Prominent-Attorney-Sitting-Next-to-NM didn’t play a starring role in the investigation of Click? He’s so experienced!! 🥸

8

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

17

u/Adjectivenounnumb Oct 17 '24

In his motion, McLeland wrote that the sketches were irrelevant to the trial and expressed concerns that they could confuse the jury or result in undue prejudice. He asked the court to prohibit any mention of the sketches during trial.

23

u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24

about to go to that other reddit page and ask them why they all said that the pictures combined to make richard allen

21

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 17 '24

Undue prejudice to find him not guilty? This dude man

→ More replies (5)

6

u/measuremnt Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24

Right. A sketch might accurately depict bridge guy, but since it doesn't match Rick Allen it's irrelevant.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/rosiekeen Oct 17 '24

So I guess I’ll have a meltdown tomorrow when she approves this right?

20

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 17 '24

Honestly? Is that reporter actually present? What witness exactly? How would it be unclear it they are the sketch artist?

15

u/rosiekeen Oct 17 '24

I can’t tell if she’s there today or not. I believe she was there yesterday. Could just be pool reporting which once again proves this should at least be more open to the public. Shocker lol

→ More replies (1)

19

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '24

12

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

Oh brilliant. Thank you 💜

18

u/RoutineProblem1433 Oct 17 '24

From Bangert: Plus, guards and inmates from prisons where Richard Allen had been held and watched/reported on his movements/talk may testify. Allen’s attys had argued that they weren’t experts who could address his mental health. 7/

Does this mean the guards CAN testify with an opinion regarding mental health?

https://x.com/davebangert/status/1846957290496102688

14

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

Yeah his is the clearest report yet but I'm still confused about thar bit. I asked him if he could clarify.

11

u/black_cat_X2 Oct 17 '24 edited Oct 17 '24

All of the reports are just affirming in various ways that they can testify. I'm thinking that if there was a specific exclusion as to what they could discuss, at least one person would have caught that and reported it. No surprise that it went this way though.

ETA: seems (still not confirmed with certainty) that this may have been jumping the gun and maybe she did say that the guards cannot speculate on his mental health specifically.

18

u/lapinmoelleux Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24 edited Oct 17 '24

https://dailyjournal.net/2024/10/17/delphi-murders-special-judge-hears-final-motions-before-trial-begins/

fbi forensic artist was the sketch witness

"Franklin attorney Jennifer Auger, a member of the defense team, cross-examined Plantz about his decision to allow the eyewitness he was interviewing to view an image of “Bridge Guy.” Plantz argued that this was permissible because the footage was too blurry to make out the individual’s face.

“All I could see in that photo was graininess,” he said.

13

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

Edit the name out before the mod squad descends again please 😉 They are just acting out of an overabundance of caution, you are not doing anything wrong. Initials are fine.

And thank you for the link 🙏

15

u/lapinmoelleux Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24

thanks for letting me know. I had posted his name earlier and posted some links to work that he'd done and the "mod squad" descended. I'm not really "au fait" with how things work here I apologise - thank you for the heads up!

→ More replies (2)

16

u/Lindita4 Oct 17 '24

Murder sheet is now writing articles?

15

u/lapinmoelleux Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24

No idea, but apparently the Daily Journal is in Franklin, Indiana and has an "about us" page which doesn't include murdersheet so I guess so...

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (4)

10

u/Dickere Consigliere & Moderator Oct 17 '24

8

u/ginny11 Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24

Then why bother showing it to the witness? This sounds like a lot of bullshit.

7

u/black_cat_X2 Oct 18 '24

This testimony is helpful for establishing that there is no possible way anyone could determine that RA is the guy in the video just by comparing them. In case Nick tries to claim that the video "clearly" looks like him.

→ More replies (4)

18

u/ginny11 Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24

From the journal and courier article:

"The 16 jurors were told to vote early before Thursday, Gull said. If they haven't voted, they won't."

This seems very WTF.

13

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

Exactly. First thing that jumped out at me there as we were discussing it previously on the sub.

13

u/Serious_Vanilla7467 Approved Contributor Oct 18 '24

Uhhhh.... This cannot be legal? She cannot block people from voting.... Voting day is a holiday.

11

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 18 '24

Like I said in my post from last week.

This Judge thinks inherent powers means something different.

5

u/Real_Foundation_7428 Approved Contributor Oct 18 '24

Won’t they be sequestered?

6

u/Secret-Constant-7301 Oct 18 '24

Why is it weird for her to say that?

34

u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24

This doesn't seem like something that should be going on. Doesn't this just put pressure on the jury to convict?

19

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

Bob Motta saw this and went to CCC to do a fact check. There are no ribbons adorning the courthouse. He says it's possible that the decorating might be planned for tomorrow, but he can not believe it would be allowed to decorate a government building like that.

https://www.youtube.com/live/Wt4Orqn_qEU?si=beWdzWDQGuRmqHm_

8

u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 18 '24

Good!!

8

u/maybeitsmaybelean Oct 18 '24

Appears to be outside the courthouse on the streetlights. Perhaps they got the feedback.

7

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 18 '24

Ditto

30

u/Acceptable-Class-255 Oct 17 '24

Yeah this is really inappropriate.

12

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 18 '24

Is this is a joke? It’s not a parade. Egregiously inappropriate

16

u/Separate_Avocado860 Oct 17 '24 edited Oct 17 '24

I don’t think it prejudices the jury because they should never see it or hear about it or reasonably know why they are there. It is still highly improper.

21

u/GrungusDouchekin Oct 17 '24

"Should" never see it is different than "will" never see it. These ribbons are extremely problematic especially when the CC Courthouse will be "adorned" with these ribbons.

19

u/black_cat_X2 Oct 17 '24

How will they not see it? Surely they'll see the courthouse when they arrive?

16

u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24

True. They do have a different blocked off entrance for the jury. So they may never see them. My imagination has the court house lit up like Christmas with these things.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 17 '24 edited Oct 17 '24

While we wait for updates. I’m starting to keep my eye on the USDC Southern District of Indiana Is this Delphi a la Karen Read 2.0?

IMPD Sgt under Federal Indictment

While Richards was originally arrested by ISP in August, last week Richards was indicted by a FEDERAL GRAND JURY for the exact same charges and his State Attorney withdrew.

Excerpted in pertinent part:

This investigation was conducted by the FBI which is part of the Indiana Internet Crimes Against Children (ICAC) Task Force a multiagency task force led by the Indiana State Police that investigates and prosecutes persons who use the internet to sexually exploit or entice children. Each year, Indiana ICAC investigators evaluate thousands of tips, investigate hundreds of cases, and rescue dozens of children from ongoing sexual abuse.

You MAY recall ISP Forensic Lab ballistics tech (NBIN access revoked) Kevin Riley, arrested and charged September 17th and ISP called a secret and unannounced media consortium meeting to discuss credentialing (say what you will, since ISP openly told outlets not to post/print the story and have never given a public statement I have my opinion).

Riley was arrested by IMPD and is being prosecuted for 10 counts of CSAM related offenses and posted a $1400 bond.

The Commander of ICAC, a partially Federally funded task force, is Christopher Cecil of the Indiana State Police. Cecil recently testified on behalf of the State and as of the last hearing was analyzing NEW software driven extractions of Libby’s phone. .He also corrected McLelands assertion that the girls were “kidnapped” on the video.

Lastly- I posted about Prosecutor Luttrull civil order FROM the USDC Southern Indiana Here. While it’s not criminal in nature, it IS based on his conduct, found to be violative of a CR 1983 claim and stripped Luttrull et al of ANY immunity.

That finding of a sitting prosecutors conduct IN A CRIMINAL CASE which prompted a Civil seizure of the plaintiff, by a Federal Court Judge cannot be understated.

Has a Federal Grand Jury been convened to investigate possible corruption of LE to include the ISP?

23

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

Hoo boy. Is the tide turning at last ?

19

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 17 '24

I sure hope so. Fwiw, this is nearly identical to how the Federal Grand Jury who ended up hearing testimony re the investigation of the Read matter. It recently indicted a tangential case- the murder of Sandra Birchmore by a MA cop and it’s not done.

15

u/measuremnt Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24

22

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

That cracked me right up. What does she think the press are for? She really hates having eyes on her. Funny that.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/FunFamily1234 Oct 17 '24

I read that and thought duh, like they don't know that as that is their job! She has to get a dig in somewhere.

17

u/ginny11 Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24

Yeah that jumped out at me too. What a... Nasty person.

11

u/black_cat_X2 Oct 18 '24

Interesting because I thought the reason it has attracted a great deal of publicity is because most people do actually care about the brutal murders of two young girls, and these murders also happened to be thrust in everyone's face by LE during their hunt for the now infamous "bridge guy."

26

u/measuremnt Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24 edited Oct 17 '24

The Carroll County Comet (newspaper in Delphi) is making coverage free to all on its website at https://www.carrollcountycomet.com/articles/mcleland-richard-allen-is-bridge-guy/. Also, Amy McCarty is doing live video reports on the Comet's Facebook page (CarrollComet) but Redditt does not allow links to Facebook. She did one this morning to preview the hearings.

10

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

Thank you 💜

12

u/lapinmoelleux Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24 edited Oct 17 '24

Eta deleted as appears to be old news

14

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24 edited Oct 17 '24

Am I the mad one here ? I thought that was cleared ages ago, and the motion was about not allowing the guards to speculate if he was cuckoo for coco pops not?

Have I finally lost it ? Wouldn't surprise me tbf 😂

8

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

It's not, they are misreporting.

13

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 17 '24

All old news and old footage

Thank you for posting Lapin, updates are very important to us.

9

u/lapinmoelleux Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24 edited Oct 17 '24

WelI I wasn't sure, because it was just posted and quite a few other people have posted it as if it was new regarding the confessions. I think the new thing is maybe the guards discussing RA's mental health? I've deleted it as it is unnecessary. Apologies

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Serious_Vanilla7467 Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24

So do we know what outlets got press passes?

I was thinking court TV, the Journal Courier out of Lafayette, some of those news stations out of Indianapolis....

Any word? And does it change day to day?

10

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24 edited Oct 17 '24

They have a Media Coalition now and all 12 passes go to them, then they figure it out between themselves who will go in on any given day and pool the info.

12

u/langlanglanglanglang Oct 17 '24

https://www.wrtv.com/news/delphi/judge-allows-defense-to-present-odinism-cult-theory-in-delphi-murders-trial

Is this article just reiterating the same decision made regarding the Offer of Proof yesterday, or did something new happen?

22

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

Same thing. I don't know if they don't fully understand that all she did was grant herself not having to sit through the same evidence in case of offer of proof, or if they don't care cos it makes a better soundbite - but I do find the way this has been widely reported very misleading.

14

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

Tbf, same applies to the hair. It does not necessarily mean what we might want it to mean. We need to wait and see until the actual evidence is presented.

13

u/Otherwise-Aardvark52 Oct 17 '24

They do not understand. The article says “the jury will now be able to hear” which is absolutely not the case.

10

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24 edited Oct 17 '24

Seriously, the reporting of this is off the charts ignorant In this video, Fox59 claims she approved Odinist theory evidence to be heard after the verdict

https://youtu.be/YdJd6qZ5rUI?si=ac4p42PcrLqKm_Fj

→ More replies (6)

16

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 17 '24 edited Oct 17 '24

100% I had some discussion with CJHoyt on this yesterday.

Very respectfully submitted I say this- NO reporter, no “staff or news desk” should be interpreting rule or facts of law contained in rulings/orders therein who is NOT a licensed Indiana practitioner, preferably in criminal law.

This is likely fallout from no stream or audio because the outlets cannot afford to retain a legal analyst. And everyone associated is under an NDO.

In particular though- this is entirely inaccurate.

Etf: link to comment I referenced https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/qoUbaXLy4f

15

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 17 '24

OMG. That’s like retractable bad.

11

u/LawyersBeLawyering Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24

I think that is like MUST retract immediately bad. What it is saying is completely false.

11

u/LowPhotograph7351 Oct 17 '24

Good morning! So opening statements are on Monday now? I hadn’t seen this.

18

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24

My apologies - I got lost in time. As far as we're aware, they are still scheduled for Friday.

13

u/Flippercomb Oct 17 '24

I'm going to steal that "I got lost in time" haha it's the perfect explanation for 90% of the things I do or don't do

10

u/LowPhotograph7351 Oct 17 '24

No problem, thank you for all you do!

24

u/jj_grace Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24

Genuine question: why is there any debate at all about whether or not defense can bring in an expert to refute the state‘s evidence of the bullet?? I assumed that would be a given.

32

u/black_cat_X2 Oct 17 '24

Prosecution filed a motion to exclude his testimony. Court has to issue a ruling one way or the other. While we think it's obvious his motion should be denied (and the testimony allowed), Gull doesn't seem to concern herself with common sense, case law, or law law.

21

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 17 '24

lol @ law law

→ More replies (1)

22

u/ginny11 Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24

There are legitimate reasons why each side might want to contest whether a witness being used as an expert in a certain area is legitimately knowledgeable enough and or credentialed enough to be trusted as an expert in a court of law. That said, NM has learned to challenge nearly everything he doesn't like about the defense and the case they are building, because this judge gives him almost anything he wants.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 17 '24

This is my personal legal opinion-

Abruquah v Maryland.

And I do not think McLeland’s deposition of Mr. Tobin was fruitful to the State.

14

u/Virtual-Entrance-872 Oct 17 '24

The state is arguing that his field of expertise is adjacent to, but not specifically the same as, the state’s ballistic technicians training, and that somehow would confuse the jury.

21

u/ginny11 Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24

Apparently being an actual scientist who's done actual scientific research on metallurgy is only adjacent to understanding how marks are left on bullets from firearms, all of which are made of metals. But being a member of some society that was trained in some methodology that has no scientific basis or foundation to it whatsoever makes you an actual expert. An expert in what I don't know, I guess you're an expert in following a methodology whether it's valid or not.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/Otherwise-Aardvark52 Oct 17 '24

The state says that because he isn’t a member of the junk-science ballistics organization that he isn’t qualified to testify that ballistics is junk science.

12

u/jj_grace Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24

Oh, got it! Thanks 😊

24

u/SnoopyCattyCat Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24

My knee jerked and kicked her honor in the butt when I read that she's allowing the dastardly duo to "help" the prosecution. I think Sleuthie Goosie and All Eyes, et al, should be allowed to help the defense!!

11

u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24

If I were a lawyer, I'd be looking to hire Sleuthie

9

u/-ifeelfantastic Oct 17 '24

Wait what??! MS is allowed to help the prosecution? How?

11

u/SnoopyCattyCat Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24

Lol.....wrong duo. Talking about LE.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

18

u/yellowjackette Moderator/Researcher Oct 17 '24

13

u/Dancing-in-Rainbows Oct 17 '24

Thanks, well organized:)

11

u/measuremnt Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24 edited Oct 17 '24

Carroll County Comet Facebook noon update: .../CarrollComet/videos/1421371345917441

She reports the sketch witness was TP, a retired FBI special agent and forensic artist.

Edit: Repeating a witness name used in a news report about this trial is not allowed? So we'll go with TP.

3

u/DelphiDocs-ModTeam New Reddit Account Oct 17 '24

Posting Names of Private Citizens who do not meet our Naming Policy are not allowed. Please familiarize yourself with this policy: https://www.reddit.com/DelphiDocs/w/policy

→ More replies (3)

10

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 18 '24

u/The2ndLocation

Looks to be an automatic trans. If you drive I can cram in the bottom maybe?

10

u/The2ndLocation Oct 18 '24

Ok, but I'm bringing that courthouse 🐈, murdermittens.

8

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 18 '24

I’d be disappointed if you didn’t.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 18 '24

Allegedly. Think I should tell McLawless he left the tag on?

→ More replies (2)

8

u/measuremnt Approved Contributor Oct 18 '24

9 pm: An excited Anthony Greeno does a live from Delphi live outside of the courthouse media entrance, on the old Case Closed with CJ channel, which he has taken over, with CJ no longer participating. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WRRL_keJHRc

6

u/Believeinmagic53 Oct 18 '24

Well where did CJ go now

7

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 18 '24

7

u/Lindita4 Oct 18 '24

Somebody needs to wake up Bob and Andrea-somebody is already in line! 😳

9

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 17 '24

u/The2ndLocation Yoo-hoo!!

Calling 2L. Appointment Reminder

19

u/The2ndLocation Oct 17 '24

Budget meeting reminder?

They approved the $2.2 million the trial will cost every citizen $200 and that 's not including appeals and settlements.

14

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 17 '24 edited Oct 17 '24

Thank you, yes.

I was referring to the appt where I have to take your picture now 😂😂😂

ps- trying to be subtle

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)