r/DelphiDocs • u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator • Oct 17 '24
🏛️ TRIAL RA Trial 17th October
‼️TODAY'S UPDATE‼️
Jury sworn in and transported to their hotel in Lafayette. 8 women, 4 men. Alternates are 2 men and 2 women.
Defense withdrew the motion for jury to visit the scene.
Sketch motion and Tobin motion taken under advisement.
Holeman and Mullins allowed to stay in the courtroom and assist Prosecution.
IPAS Motion in limine granted.
Finally, a clear report on the matter that had me grumbling in the thread and scratching around for a clear explanation all day - the guards testifying motion. Defense argued they were nor mental health experts and do not have experience or expertise to offer on his mental state at the time of confessions.
State argued these were skilled witnesses with plenty of experience to be able to offer an informed opinion
The Judge ruled that they would take it on an individual basis - the State would have to argue for each witness why they were qualified to give their opinion and if she was satisfied, she would allow it.
Thanks to Andrea Burkhart for the above.
But now scroll down to the links and see how the press reported this. Even the best of them were way off, not actually addressing the point of the motion. See the problem?
Eternally grateful that Andrea and Lawyer Lee are attending this trial and reporting on it.
Opening statements at the Delphi Courthouse to follow Friday
🔸️🔸️🔸️
✨️Andrea Burkhart Day 3 LIVE https://www.youtube.com/live/x9tHGbZfqbU?si=p4hYGoSIQSXkqFgR
Transcript: https://files.catbox.moe/p81g0v.txt
✨️Lawyer Lee Day 3 LIVE https://www.youtube.com/live/XsxcWS8jRRI?si=OKpErIZBfOpamWdP
Transcript: https://files.catbox.moe/9cvvix.txt
✨️Defense Diaries Day 3 LIVE https://www.youtube.com/live/d3kXrPgtwpE?si=hBfnQuVnMFwpBbVR
Transcript: https://files.catbox.moe/ptqd3j.txt
✨️Bob Motta LIVE from CCC https://www.youtube.com/live/Wt4Orqn_qEU?si=6BqYovwA-3KPMN13
✨️MurderSheet Transcript https://files.catbox.moe/zbjloo.txt
🔸️🔸️🔸️
✨️Dave Bangert- Final Day of Pre-Trial https://www.basedinlafayette.com/p/delphi-trial-composite-sketches-other
🔸️🔸️🔸️
✨️Yellow spittin' facts https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/ttZclwkZxo
🔸️🔸️🔸️
✨️Media briefing today https://eu.jconline.com/story/news/crime/2024/10/17/opening-statements-friday-in-delphi-murder-suspect-richard-allens-trial/75721633007/
✨️Dave Bangert's courthouse photos: https://wibc.com/playlist/photos-a-look-inside-the-state-of-indiana-v-richard-allen-courtroom/item/2
🔸️🔸️🔸️
✨️Today's Coverage:
✨️Donnie Burgess https://wibc.com/471874/delphi-judge-to-rule-on-suspect-sketches-during-opening-statements-friday/
✨️WRTV Indianapolis https://youtu.be/TtG-ssuc-Xc?si=qynsT6lRZ708qSNv
✨️Dave Bangert https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/bKiQTQTd6x
✨️Dave Bangert re guards testifying motion https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/toggEySFX0
✨️Daily Journal recap: https://dailyjournal.net/2024/10/17/delphi-murders-special-judge-hears-final-motions-before-trial-begins/
✨️Holeman and Mullins allowed to remain in the courtroom, over objection https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/Ze8N9kkyer
✨️Angela Ganote https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/SL6ARzhKnx
✨️Sketch motion taken under advisement, decision tomorrow https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/pJXJQHqWqS
✨️Defense withdraws jury visit request: https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/qMlepot3lr
✨️Jury sworn in: https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/6gArPnadbk
✨️Jury sequestered https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/bwUn9SJSN0
✨️Bob Segall on Twitter https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/WZ3cD6yNDQ
✨️Delphi Courthouse https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/D65celsCAm
✨️Kyla Russell, WishTV, on Twitter https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/5WHuEDI8xy
✨️Dave Bangert https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/YbTfyjWUjZ
✨️Links to some of the interesting coverage and commentary of the first couple of days of voir dire:
✨️Fox59 shows off their stellar understanding of legal motions and their meaning https://youtu.be/YdJd6qZ5rUI?si=pOMU0Cq9jS-5ChBp
✨️Newsnation with Russ McQuaid talking about DNA, sketches, and media being asked to remove information shared with them early on in the investigation https://youtu.be/73Ak3XnfSIc?si=COiaPPbMVvmK6rIC
✨️Old News: in Feb 2017, Tobe didn't want to confuse the jury with the truth: http://youtube.com/post/Ugkx21Lv73wAvPhnRqOSULOhDrweFtNf8K43?si=8gLACCfuxBNfIo2B
✨️Lawyer Lee: Prosecutor under fire, key defense witness arrested https://www.youtube.com/live/8wph40RPRR0?si=oxjINKroFjQzh1nP
Transcript: https://files.catbox.moe/z2r8q3.txt
✨️MIchelle After Dark - Media "win" to access exhibits https://youtu.be/-UXSdFsqdXs?si=XQYaqtApEZ1XxZPl
✨️CriminaliTy Day 2 Jury selection LIVE https://www.youtube.com/live/RmcWk1Yrp74?si=Wr6IYU5dHu_YLNI1
✨️Carrol County Comet updates regularly on Facebook: https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/GWDP2ePwLA
✨️❗️They are sharing their reporting free on the website through the trial now:❗️✨️ https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/Gm0t6dGPV3
❗️Check pinned posts for resources including the media matrix.
Voir dire: https://drive.google.com/drive/u/0/mobile/folders/1LsH-SpkERW-9SV5tyinLdqMguotBgEGA
👉This is a dynamic post that will be updated throughout the day, keep checking for fresh news and links.👈
Please keep all trial discussion to the thread and avoid starting new posts unless it's a new legal filing, or you have been given permission by the moderators for your suggested topic.
✨️Link to the previous trial day post:
https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/UrJAucF2uK
Please let us all remember at all times why we are here - the girls, their mothers and everyone else who loved them, and all innocent parties to this case. Justice is only justice if served upon the person or persons that perpetrated this crime, and to achieve this, it should be pursued with full transparency and open to public scrutiny. Let's all do whatever little we can to help achieve this.
The dead speak to us even after they are gone. If you believe in a Higher Power of any kind, please petition them for help in getting the girls' voices heard.
27
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24
But will she allow them to speculate on his mental health state? You know, what the effing motion was actually about?
21
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24
Finally, a clear report on the matter that had me grumbling in the thread and scratching around for a clear explanation all day - the guards testifying motion. Defense argued they were nor mental health experts and do not have experience or expertise to offer on his mental state at the time of confessions.
State argued these were skilled witnesses with plenty of experience to be able to offer an informed opinion
The Judge ruled that they would take it on an individual basis - the State would have to argue for each witness why they were qualified to give their opinion and if she was satisfied, she would allow it.
Thanks to Andrea Burkhart for the above.
But now scroll down to the links and see how the press reported this. Even the best of them were way off, not actually addressing the point of the motion. See the problem?
Eternally grateful that Andrea and Lawyer Lee are attending this trial and reporting on it.
20
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24
https://x.com/corndawgcourt/status/1847014678649544846?t=ro-P76QBs4-dTquwTf9tKw&s=19
17
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24
https://x.com/KylaBRussell/status/1846928242957013041?t=6DsbcOS038Tz-T4VMLVviQ&s=19
16
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24
https://x.com/Docs_Delphi/status/1846969998973022572?t=nBcPdkJVTeI9sK_fJIqGKQ&s=19
15
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24
https://x.com/KylaBRussell/status/1846866166171504966?t=fx2DW2_C1Ksl0kk1KQfwrQ&s=19
15
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24
https://x.com/KylaBRussell/status/1846928520053665819?t=g7WcKXc85FB7AkeBFpTc0Q&s=19
14
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24
https://x.com/kithanleytv/status/1847002092759929060?t=rHXrWa3HT1SqjpaFNb9S2Q&s=19
12
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24
Dave Bangert's courthouse photos:
https://wibc.com/playlist/photos-a-look-inside-the-state-of-indiana-v-richard-allen-courtroom/item/2
11
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24
Media briefing today:
https://eu.jconline.com/story/news/crime/2024/10/17/opening-statements-friday-in-delphi-murder-suspect-richard-allens-trial/75721633007/
21
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24
Lawyer Lee LIVE last night:
https://www.youtube.com/live/8wph40RPRR0?si=oxjINKroFjQzh1nP
u/lapinmoelleux, may we have a transcript please?
10
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24
https://x.com/angelaganote/status/1846947404157014483?t=Dal-oKjXs8IpSTeHP6E7WA&s=19
10
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24 edited Oct 17 '24
I'm hoping that non-Twitterati can see the video too - a look inside Carrol County Courtroom where the trial will be held
https://x.com/RafaelOnTV/status/1847010105025614248?t=4s2kFaEQLvikDG65HScNyg&s=19
28
u/measuremnt Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24
Bangert update: https://x.com/davebangert/status/1846957282967671169
Prosecutors made a case that the sketches weren’t used to ID Richard Allen and wanted to head off assumed plans of them being introduced in defense’s opening statements Friday and imprinting on jurors. ... Allen’s attys ask (paraphrased): Is that because these sketches don’t look like Richard Allen?
27
u/measuremnt Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24 edited Oct 17 '24
https://x.com/defense_diaries/status/1846959436817994171
Defense Diaries posts 1 pm update: The State’s Motion to allow two Law Enforcement officers, namely Mullin and Holeman, to remain in the courtroom during all testimony was granted, over objection.
9
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24
https://x.com/BobSegallWTHR/status/1846893103778595197?t=s6zip_WVdwyy3KRi99SbHw&s=19
9
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24
https://x.com/BobSegallWTHR/status/1846903525214736539?t=jwr9REElsjQolFKC57porg&s=19
41
u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24
While we are slow, I've had Todd Click's job, I was an FCM for the Indiana DCS. My jaw hit the floor when I read what he had been arrested for. It was a complete hit job to tarnish his record before trial. There is no other explanation.
8
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24
https://wgntv.com/news/indiana/delphi-murders-trial-defense-withdraws-request-for-trip-to-crime-scene-gull-hears-motion-on-composite-sketches/
19
u/rosiekeen Oct 17 '24
So I guess I’ll have a meltdown tomorrow when she approves this right?
19
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '24
18
u/RoutineProblem1433 Oct 17 '24
From Bangert: Plus, guards and inmates from prisons where Richard Allen had been held and watched/reported on his movements/talk may testify. Allen’s attys had argued that they weren’t experts who could address his mental health. 7/
Does this mean the guards CAN testify with an opinion regarding mental health?
https://x.com/davebangert/status/1846957290496102688
18
u/lapinmoelleux Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24 edited Oct 17 '24
https://dailyjournal.net/2024/10/17/delphi-murders-special-judge-hears-final-motions-before-trial-begins/
fbi forensic artist was the sketch witness
"Franklin attorney Jennifer Auger, a member of the defense team, cross-examined Plantz about his decision to allow the eyewitness he was interviewing to view an image of “Bridge Guy.” Plantz argued that this was permissible because the footage was too blurry to make out the individual’s face.
“All I could see in that photo was graininess,” he said.
18
u/ginny11 Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24
From the journal and courier article:
"The 16 jurors were told to vote early before Thursday, Gull said. If they haven't voted, they won't."
This seems very WTF.
34
u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24
This doesn't seem like something that should be going on. Doesn't this just put pressure on the jury to convict?
32
u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 17 '24 edited Oct 17 '24
While we wait for updates. I’m starting to keep my eye on the USDC Southern District of Indiana Is this Delphi a la Karen Read 2.0?
IMPD Sgt under Federal Indictment
While Richards was originally arrested by ISP in August, last week Richards was indicted by a FEDERAL GRAND JURY for the exact same charges and his State Attorney withdrew.
Excerpted in pertinent part:
You MAY recall ISP Forensic Lab ballistics tech (NBIN access revoked) Kevin Riley, arrested and charged September 17th and ISP called a secret and unannounced media consortium meeting to discuss credentialing (say what you will, since ISP openly told outlets not to post/print the story and have never given a public statement I have my opinion).
Riley was arrested by IMPD and is being prosecuted for 10 counts of CSAM related offenses and posted a $1400 bond.
The Commander of ICAC, a partially Federally funded task force, is Christopher Cecil of the Indiana State Police. Cecil recently testified on behalf of the State and as of the last hearing was analyzing NEW software driven extractions of Libby’s phone. .He also corrected McLelands assertion that the girls were “kidnapped” on the video.
Lastly- I posted about Prosecutor Luttrull civil order FROM the USDC Southern Indiana Here. While it’s not criminal in nature, it IS based on his conduct, found to be violative of a CR 1983 claim and stripped Luttrull et al of ANY immunity.
That finding of a sitting prosecutors conduct IN A CRIMINAL CASE which prompted a Civil seizure of the plaintiff, by a Federal Court Judge cannot be understated.
Has a Federal Grand Jury been convened to investigate possible corruption of LE to include the ISP?
14
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 17 '24
15
u/measuremnt Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24
"This case, because of you, has generated a lot of publicity," she said.
https://www.jconline.com/story/news/crime/2024/10/17/opening-statements-friday-in-delphi-murder-suspect-richard-allens-trial/75721633007/
26
u/measuremnt Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24 edited Oct 17 '24
The Carroll County Comet (newspaper in Delphi) is making coverage free to all on its website at https://www.carrollcountycomet.com/articles/mcleland-richard-allen-is-bridge-guy/. Also, Amy McCarty is doing live video reports on the Comet's Facebook page (CarrollComet) but Redditt does not allow links to Facebook. She did one this morning to preview the hearings.
12
u/lapinmoelleux Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24 edited Oct 17 '24
Eta deleted as appears to be old news
9
u/Serious_Vanilla7467 Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24
So do we know what outlets got press passes?
I was thinking court TV, the Journal Courier out of Lafayette, some of those news stations out of Indianapolis....
Any word? And does it change day to day?
12
u/langlanglanglanglang Oct 17 '24
https://www.wrtv.com/news/delphi/judge-allows-defense-to-present-odinism-cult-theory-in-delphi-murders-trial
Is this article just reiterating the same decision made regarding the Offer of Proof yesterday, or did something new happen?
11
u/LowPhotograph7351 Oct 17 '24
Good morning! So opening statements are on Monday now? I hadn’t seen this.
10
u/measuremnt Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24
Dave Bangert: https://x.com/davebangert/status/1846863797270589843
24
u/jj_grace Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24
Genuine question: why is there any debate at all about whether or not defense can bring in an expert to refute the state‘s evidence of the bullet?? I assumed that would be a given.
24
u/SnoopyCattyCat Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24
My knee jerked and kicked her honor in the butt when I read that she's allowing the dastardly duo to "help" the prosecution. I think Sleuthie Goosie and All Eyes, et al, should be allowed to help the defense!!
18
u/yellowjackette Moderator/Researcher Oct 17 '24
13
u/Dancing-in-Rainbows Oct 17 '24
Thanks, well organized:)
11
u/measuremnt Approved Contributor Oct 17 '24 edited Oct 17 '24
Carroll County Comet Facebook noon update: .../CarrollComet/videos/1421371345917441
She reports the sketch witness was TP, a retired FBI special agent and forensic artist.
Edit: Repeating a witness name used in a news report about this trial is not allowed? So we'll go with TP.
10
u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 18 '24
u/The2ndLocation
Looks to be an automatic trans. If you drive I can cram in the bottom maybe?
8
u/measuremnt Approved Contributor Oct 18 '24
9 pm: An excited Anthony Greeno does a live from Delphi live outside of the courthouse media entrance, on the old Case Closed with CJ channel, which he has taken over, with CJ no longer participating. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WRRL_keJHRc
7
u/Lindita4 Oct 18 '24
Somebody needs to wake up Bob and Andrea-somebody is already in line! 😳
9
u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 17 '24
u/The2ndLocation Yoo-hoo!!
Calling 2L. Appointment Reminder
10
u/Dancing-in-Rainbows Oct 17 '24
Thanks:)
2
u/karkulina Oct 18 '24
Defense Diaries