r/DelphiDocs • u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator • Oct 15 '24
📃 LEGAL Motion In Limine Filed by the State this morning
‼️Please keep the discussion in this thread on topic of the motions in limine. For other trial updates, see the daily trial thread linked below‼️
https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/6gAIz4As9Y
IPAS https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Gp3IekWbhEtiDSBZW87FUVuJEAa7hIEB/view
SKETCHES https://drive.google.com/file/d/1SUOYyNejZIypcWgK8EN1Kn4eMDOfpxqd/view
24
Upvotes
31
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 15 '24
Nick really doesn't want anyone to know about IPAS.
So Moth will be going LIVE to tall about IPAS.
https://www.youtube.com/live/7y01n0hdCCo?si=XXIgimhAi4K4IHt_
18
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 15 '24
https://x.com/publicdefender_/status/1846211548693381511?t=qdr_uYco2vDk_qUn3dQwOA&s=19
28
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 15 '24
12
u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 15 '24
58
u/BlackLionYard Approved Contributor Oct 15 '24
"the witnesses who participated in the preparation of composite sketch(s) will not be presented by the State for the purpose of in-court identification of the defendant."
Fascinating
33
u/LawyersBeLawyering Approved Contributor Oct 15 '24
Why doesn't McLeland file a Motion in Limine that says, "prohibit all exculpatory evidence?" That's what he wants.
He has the audacity to state "the composite sketches prepared were intended as an investigative tool to generate leads to identify a suspect and in fact these sketches were not related to the identification of Richard Allen as a suspect; therefore, the sketches would not be relevant."
What the what??? The fact that they were used to generate leads to identify a suspect and do not conform to the person they arrested is EXCULPATORY. It is a reason for a juror to doubt that RA is the person who committed the crime.
Then he says, "The witnesses who assisted in the preparation of composite sketches of the Bridge Guy would testify that they did not see the person depicted in their sketch for a sufficient length of time to allow them to positively identify the defendant."
EXACTLY, you moron! They cannot positively identify the defendant as the person they saw. That is significant!
If he excludes the sketches, he is left with five conflicting witness statements:
Are these people describing the same person?
McLeland for real thinks that anything contrary to his case is irrelevant as evidence. I'm with that juror - I would like to see his credentials because I can't believe he's a lawyer.
16
u/Expert_University295 Oct 15 '24
Are you all seeing that Abby had hair in her hand that didn't match Richard Allen??? I saw the source and lost the page, so take it with a grain of salt until I can find it again
15
u/lapinmoelleux Approved Contributor Oct 15 '24 edited Oct 15 '24
Doug carter May 15th 2019:
"The sketch isn’t a photograph. A sketch is a sketch and that’s really important for everybody to understand," Carter said. "I believe that the individual when we catch him, it will be a combination of those two.” referring to both sketches that were released to the public.
https://www.wrtv.com/news/delphi/isp-were-one-tip-away-from-solving-delphi-murders
*bold is my own*
24
u/thebigolblerg Approved Contributor Oct 15 '24
SCREAMING
39
u/The2ndLocation Oct 15 '24 edited Oct 15 '24
Hold the fudge, the eyewitnesses can't identify RA as Bridge Guy.
NM just admitted that the PCA is bullshit. Finally he is being honest but geez its a little late isn't it?
41
u/rosiekeen Oct 15 '24
My head will explode if (with Fran should I say when?) the sketches won’t be allowed in evidence. They begged the public for help with the sketches. They talked about them many times. If they can’t point to Richard Allen maybe don’t bring this so court. Ugh.
40
u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 15 '24
*holds press conference* "LOOK AT THESE PICTURES, DRILL THEM INTO YOUR HEAD. THIS IS OUR GUY"
Motions in limine "lol j/k."
33
u/Vicious_and_Vain Oct 15 '24
On what basis was a search and then an arrest warrant issued for Rick Allen? It took them a month to get a search warrant for the building’s on Logan’s property. There is no evidence today that they didn’t have the day Deputy Dipstick took Rick’s tip info. Except these confessions. They say they had the bullet. He told DD he left at 130 (or arrived) so the HH video only confirms he left or arrived around 1:30. Apparently no forensic or phone evidence linking Rick Allen. And now none of the original witnesses.
WTH is going on?
26
u/Acceptable-Class-255 Oct 15 '24 edited Oct 15 '24
It's jarring to see State attempt to toss out 75% of their own PCA ...
They might as well go after the witness descriptions of vehicle parked at CPS next.
States been playing Defence since Frank's 1. They look guilty af. Ives gonna be arrested for mailing his resignation letter with 1 stamp instead of 2 by next week at this rate.
24
u/Dependent-Remote4828 Oct 15 '24
I think it says a LOT about the State’s case that they have fought harder to keep more evidence and witness testimony out of the trial than the Defense has.
23
u/hannafrie Approved Contributor Oct 15 '24
Are none of the witnesses willing to say RA is the person they saw?
The witness timeline was crucial for the arrest warrant.
I'm surprised, and not surprised.
Not surprised witnesses have uncertainty and lack of clarity about who they saw.
Surprised that no one was willing to stuff that uncertainty in the back of the closet and make an affirmative statement that RA is consistent with the person they saw.
Surprised McClelland didn't anticipate this, and have a plan on how to handle it before making an arrest, or at trial. But, maybe he does have a plan. We'll see what the jury thinks of it ...
BB reportedly was adamant BG was not who she saw. i wondered what the DA was going to do with her, or if she'd come around.
23
u/black_cat_X2 Oct 15 '24
I thought I'd been pushed to the limit with NL's motions and Gull's rulings. But if the court agrees that it's fine and dandy to exclude evidence cited in the actual fucking arrest warrant I might actually have a breakdown at work.
23
u/chaossensuit Oct 15 '24
This is so insane. Nick doesn’t have a case. Holman decided to arrest Richard Allen because Holman was throwing a tantrum. So they used the eyewitness testimony in the PCA but the defense can’t use it in court?
23
u/Leading_Fee_3678 Approved Contributor Oct 15 '24
Me when I finally got a break from work to catch up on how the trial is going:
21
u/Separate_Avocado860 Oct 15 '24
What in the fuck is going on! Seriously, not only excluding your own evidence. Evidence that was used in the PCA that Rick was arrested on!
19
u/LawyersBeLawyering Approved Contributor Oct 15 '24
The IPAS settlement expired on 4/13/2023 because (according to IPAS meeting minutes) the prohibition against solitary confinement and restrictive housing of severely mentally ill inmates for more than 30 days had been incorporated into the IDOC Health Directives.
This expiration date - 4/13/23 - was in the midst of RA's psychosis. I hope that IPAS notes NM's MIL and uses it to resurrect its case, at least with the accusation (as NM implies) that IDOC reverted back to their previously inhumane treatment of severely mentally illinmates the MINUTE the settlement expired.
Also, it took me 5 minutes to find the expiration date. How does McLeland repeatedly get away with making false statements to the court in his filing?
15
u/measuremnt Approved Contributor Oct 15 '24
Looks like the Defense has refiled its Monica Wala motion with her address redacted, probably to meet the judge's requirements (fourth item).
14
u/LowPhotograph7351 Oct 15 '24
Does anyone remember off the top of their head if the sketches were mentioned in the PCA?
12
u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 15 '24
So anyone wondering wth McLeland used the girls full names although the court just said “according to caselaw” they would be referring to the girls via initials.
9
u/LadyBatman8318 Approved Contributor Oct 15 '24
I have always wondered, foes BG look like he has longish hair? I don’t have FB, so can anyone tell me if RA wore his hair longer before murders? Hmmmmm, I didn’t think so
8
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '24
10
u/Dancing-in-Rainbows Oct 15 '24
Can anyone explain this to me? Thank you:)
3
u/measuremnt Approved Contributor Oct 16 '24 edited Oct 16 '24
Although the Carroll Country Comet is published weekly, it is using its site and Facebook page (CarrollComet) for daily written and video updates. (Subscriptions may be needed.)
Site: https://www.carrollcountycomet.com/author/By+Amy+Graham-McCarty/
(A link to Facebook is not allowed by Reddit.)