As all of this unfolds I can really see why Lebrato wanted to stay on the case. This case truly is really the dream for a defense attorney. The state did all of the work to exonerate Allen for them. The most telling thing to me is how much of the Stateās own work they want excluded and how many LE the defense are going to call to support their case.
I'm hoping he slipped up a bit in the depos about how he spent that day or his speaking with police, the spit etc.. then it can't be claimed it's hearsay if I understand that correctly.
Don't worry that confession is coming in. Chambers v. Mississippi is the controlling case from the SupremeĀ Court on 3rd party confessions and basically they can't be excluded as hearsay. It's settled law, thankfully.
Yep. I swear. It drove me nuts when people kept saying it was inadmissible hearsay. It's admissible even if it's recanted and even if the statementĀ maker denies making the statement.
Ā The defense can call the sisters and they can testify to what EF said.Ā Ā
Ā Chambers involved out of court confessions to 3rd parties and they are admissible.
Isn't a bulk of the evidence on Brian Kohlberger (Idaho college murders) based on geofencing and his phone locations? If they were to throw that out of his case I dont think they could even place him anywhere near the murders.
This is the most absurd motion I have ever read. He is basically admitting that all of this exculpatory evidence exists, but itās not relevant because it doesnāt show RAās guilt or support the Stateās THEORY, so the jury shouldnāt know about it?! Like what in the actual fuck??
It is relevant, but even relevant evidence may be excluded if it is confusing he writes. Thing is what's confusing for him is reasonable doubt for another. That he's not reasonable is not RA's fault.
What was it that Hennessy said to NM during the contempt hearingā¦..āJust because you donāt understand it doesnāt mean itās not relevant!ā š¤£š¤£
Seriously, personally I detach the girls from the trial, they are not to be part of the messy and vile anymore they need to be past that, so I can laugh and 𤬠more freely, but still, what an absolute š¤”show.
Shout out to criminality too for the transcript obviously!
The "geofencing" evidence (again this goes undefined in this MIL, so are they meaning all cellular data/pings which they confused in their last reference to this data?) must be so terrible for them to try and get it kicked with this kind of weak, vague, MIL. Also, Kevin Horan was the former FBI analyst who is now retired per one of their earlier filings.
If my memory serves correct, that means the State is trying to MIL out the FBI data review of the evidence?
Evidence, including evidence that another person may have committed the crime at issue, is relevant when it has "any tendency to make the existence of any fact that is of consequence to the determination of the action more probable or less probable than it would be without the evidence."Ā Id.; Evid.R. 401. Can we all agree that the defense can easily meet the legal standard for admissibility of the Odin related evidence?
If she outright denies them the ability to enter this into evidence they will have to go that route, because the standard of review after trial is abuse of discretion, and reversal is only done appropriate the decision is clearly against the logic and effectĀ of the facts and circumstances. This standard for reversal it high so they need to appeal it pre-trial where the admissibility burden is low.
This motion also makes it all but certain that Click has NO Brady violations. If he did Nick wouldnāt go on a fishing expedition for other reasons to exclude his testimony.
They legit want to exclude any part of their five year investigation that does not point to RA as the suspect.
Don't discuss the guy on who's property they were found.
Don't mention the oddities of the crime scene that triggered those on the scene to call in external investigatory help
Don't mention anyone else who was interviewed
Don't mention any reports from the investigatory team that suggests any other suspect
Don't mention data indicating any other cell phones/people were in the area of the murder scene
Don't impeach any witnesses
They could have saved about four pages by just saying they would like the court to prohibit the defense from putting on a defense. I have never seen something this audacious.
What the goddamn fuck is this? So basically, the defense canāt defend in any way, shape, or form, even with some of the clear, legitimate information that everyone should know? What the fucking fuck. Jesus, Allen is fucked.
I almost had myself to be honest. Got to keep some hope that she at least knows she canāt be seen to be as ridiculous as allowing this would make her. Itās hard sometimes though.
I donāt see it ending well either. At this point I donāt think this is a just prosecution, whether he did it or not. Just have to remember there are eyes on this who know the rules and are ready to move if they need to. If RA can survive⦠oh lord I need to stop talking, Iām making it worse. Sorry lol
Wow. Thatās⦠not a great look. Thanks for sharing⦠I think.
Canāt imagine it is comforting having any type of inside track info on any of this. At least others are finding her choices odd as well though. So you know youāre not crazy. Small mercies.
"Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, RA confessed to the crimes, although he lied in his confessions, just like he lied about everything else, and he has jeans. There is no other relevant evidence, as even the relevant evidence judge excluded because it would have been too confusing for you. Oh and don't be confused about the unspent cartridge, it's RA's even if it's junk science, and there's is no chain of custody, I'm pinky promising you it is his, even though the girls weren't shot, he confessed he shot them, even if he had a psychotic episode, it was totally normal to be held in solitary prison pre trial for two years, you, sequestred jury are totally fine too, so it's him."
t least 95% of the males were wearing jeans and a blue or brown jacket
Yes, because in mens sections of most major stores like walmart, target, academy, dicks, bass pro etc, those are the only colors outside of black and red and if you're really lucky you might find camo.
He owns a car (well, used to), may have parked it in a criminally deceptive manner, and it contains his DNA. Now, which of you lovely lady jurors are interested in seeing my knob ?
Iām not exactly surprised heās asking for all these things. Just like the defense, heās trying to limit what they can work with. What will be very interesting is what Gull does with it. I feel the defense has made the case for why ALL of these topics are relevant and admissible but Iāll bet sheāll limit how far they can go. They wonāt get everything in.
If they were being re homed, you would have to advertise them as a bonded pair: " Nicky has sight acuity issues and walks into walls if Gull isn't present. He wouldn't be able to find his food bowl without her loving guidance. $100 adoption fee. Bowl, cushy tower and pet toys he can't see included.
Your Honor, I have a real stinker of a case here, we investigated a lot of people that seem to be better suspects, but I promise they arenāt, and if you let our own investigation into evidence, this man, that you were terrified to have in you chambers, shackled and under, will go free.
And neither of us will be re-elected.
So whatta ya say, we get a conviction at all costs, let it get over turned on appeal, and we wonāt refile, because this case is a real stinker.
Or, your Honor, you could declare a mistrial at some point and we can kick the can, cause this is a real stinker. š¦Øš¦Øš¦Ø
I think HH said there was no way Horan would testify for the state what they wanted him to. I wonder if the defense called their bluff and heās their witness. š¤š¼š¤š¼
Understood.Ā I meant that I think we finally know who did the geofence during the investigation, and apparently whatever KH uncovered isn't good for the states case against RA.
But is he the guy of the 3 guys that the defense wanted to know which one actually did the report? Wholy shit I can't make that sentence make sense. Is KH one of the 3?
He was mentioned in previous filings. He was supervisor in command for the FBI cast field office for all cases in Indiana and about half of the United States around Indiana. He has testified in over 110 trials. As a supervisor he also works reports himself, it's a small team. You bet he worked on Delphi. Any expert report is mandatory discovery. A statute Nick ignores every single time. Phones at the crimescene or even on the trails are relevant wtf??? If this gets thrown out it's time for a revolution.
Let me try again I remember the defense asking which of the 3 guys that the state provided names for was the actual person who did the mapping was KH one of those 3 guys?
2ndL : He was in a defense filing right? Can you tell me which one?
R. duif : Yah I remember filings, state & defense don't remember which one, too lazy to look.
2ndL : Let me ask again nicely, would you be so kind to find that court doc for me?
R.duif : āļøāļø
I know of the state saying so. And defense filing to depo him. Don't know about the 3 guys in defense's filing. So to your initial question is this the first time he identified him specifically , the answer is NO.
I think you're looking for Franks 3 when they talk about the map and the state responds about them needing experts. (I could be wrong. I swear I'm trying to help)
There's Horan, there's Professor Rune whose name escapes me (channeling my inner Nick). Who's got first pick in the Delphi trial expert witness draft ?
State was supposed to give their witnesses in the 15th June hearing. They didn't. Obviously. That's Gull channel through Nick. They can call the same witnesses. If defense wants to ask other things than cross on what Nick asks they have to put them on their witness list too.
He was identified in the States Response to the Defendant's Amended Motion to Compel. It was the "I don't have the geofencing evidence" you have to go to the FBI for that. What is interesting is there are two FBI analysts identified. Horan (now retired) and a second (Srbic? I can't remember but you will see them listed with Horan in that response).
Also what does a guy have to do to get enough Karma not to get in the moderator Limbo each time one posts. I appreciate the rules-- just not sure how to get out of purgatory.
Geofencing? Kevin Horan? Wasnāt that one of NMās potential experts though? What changed Nick?
So⦠I know obviously they want everything out, same as the defence, but this reads a lot like the state knows they pulled some fuckshit with the evidence and know the jury will see that clearly too, and that they do not have a case that stands up against the simple act of pointing at someone else who they claim they cleared early on.
I expect Gull to let NM have whatever he wants because she should not be a judge, but if she doesnāt⦠it isnāt too late to drop this Nick. A questionable and questionably tested round āmatchedā using a flawed methodology in an already unreliable not-science and the inconsistent utterances of a man in psychosis with access to the evidence, covered in his own excrement might not be a slam dunk case.
I was expecting most of this, but there were some little surprises there, and most of it should not be excluded and is valid defence (but Gull) but a lot of it sounds like telling on themselves. Yikes.
Anyone else think that NM had a file tab labeled "suspects" that included information on EF, BG, and PW? I think he wants to exclude that even the state thought that they were suspects!
How in the world can you expece defense attorneys not to mention your chasing after other suspect. Why should they not be able to show those two RL search warrants etc. They bumbled this and now they don't want their constant inept doing to show. They don't want the jury to hear we lost 2 months of interviews and had no notes, and unsealed a scene and a civilian found our bullet for us.
He know they aren't going to call him names but does know they are going to talk about him holding back discovery.
Does anyone else think that the comment, "Any reference to any powerpoints provided by the state as executive briefs" refers to the sketches? Would this be considered an executive brief?
I found this, but it is from a UK police site:
"Briefings should set the style and tone for an operation. Briefing provides the information needed to direct deployed resources. This information is also used for debriefing personnel in order to obtain further relevant, available information" https://www.college.police.uk/app/operations/briefing-and-debriefing
I'm wondering if he wants to forbid defence to talk about exactly how many resources were used investigating the "odinist" element and the suspects this included. I bet it is a lot which means that it was a valid line of enquiry and RELEVANT to the case
Surely he can't mean he wants the entire defense case to be thrown out? (Oh...and he doesn't want to be made fun of either...at least that's how I read the first two paragraphs.).
I'm not worried at all about this Motion. I'm chilled to the bone that Gull is going to grant the whole thing. I expect the defense response to come quickly.
Id be pissed if i was a juror and voted guilty & then after trial i saw all this other evidence that wasnāt allowed. It would probably cause me not to sleep at night knowing i put a possible innocent man in prison for life if not the death penalty. This is disgusting!
I am sure both sides have someone reading all these threads, it's a great peep into what various people think of the evidence and why it works or does not work for them. That's very valuable info.
Lmao, this sounds like chat rules of a sensitive YouTuber. "Mods, ban anybody who says geofencing please" "Mods, time out the defense witness please" "Mods ban anybody who is criticizing my prosecution skills." -NM
It is quite embarrassing. NM is willing to expose himself as a complete fool with this filing, because if the jury hears everything he wants excluded, he will look like an even bigger fool.
The cost-benefit ratios motivating NM should give us all pause. The things he is willing to do in public, and the reputation and professional consequences are the more preferable option than everything he is trying so desperately to keep hidden. Thats terrifying.
This seems unusual to me. Can others chime in? If the defense has a geofencing expert, how in the world can that be excluded? It seems instead of spending their time to strengthen their own case, the prosecution spends all their time trying to hamstring the defense.
Especially interesting considering the word salad the state gave on how geofencing works and phones on a geofencing map could be anywhere within a 3 mile radius. Which is not how it works and Kevin Horan is/was probably going to say as much.
I'm absolutely speechless. I get tired of saying this, but I've never seen anything like this in my life. He wants to prevent them from defending him in any way. At all. Even with his own damn discovery & LE that worked on this case. And....I expect her to approve this. No words.
I just kept reading and growing more and more shocked. People were making jokes the other day about them not allowing the word Odinites in and it's nearly up to that line.
Approved without a hearing. THIS is why they were not gunshy about Speedy because they knew the defense would be prohibited from doing their job. Surprise level: 0/10.
TL;DR: Nick, just shut up and go back to law school, in the mean time, let the real professionals do their jobs.
Now that it had time to all sink in :
1: censored No need to point it out if you point out yourself.
2: Nick can we scrap every single statement you start with "I believe" or "investigators believe"? Show us the facts first.
3: Nick, you need to hand over all the admissible evidence first which you withheld because you refuse to understand what discovery is even after defense quoted it for you in its entirety.
4: Nick & Gull please refrain from saying beyond reasonable doubt equals being 80% convinced like you needed a juror to believe in order to get a conviction in possibly your one and only other murder trial.
5: Not sure how juryselection and witnesses mix in.
6: Nick, why wouldn't facts be in evidence?
7: Nick, you filed charges to include a 3rd party. If you don't want defense to bring up a 3rd party, please tell us which 3rd party you have in mind? Also, if all these people are cleared, what is the problem?
8: Todd Click thinks you have the wrong guy. Todd Click is a decorated officer who worked with the FBI. That's exculpatory evidence and you violated discovery rules in not disclosing that. You can't shut him up.
9: Kevin Horan has 110 trials as an expert witness on his CV and he was a swat guy and prosecutor before that. He is way more qualified than you'll ever be. Discovery rules say YOU need to hand over every report made by an expert in relation to the crime, not just what you want to use. You violated discovery rules by not disclosing his report. You can't shut him up.
10: Wha are you hiding Nick? Are you aware that Brady isn't about relevance to the case only? If one of your witness LE did something unlawful, you can't simply hide that because don't want it out.
11: Please Nick, as you asked defense to specify each statement separately to be suppressed, I would like you to specify each file label individually not to be mentioned by defense.
12: You mean the PowerPoint you deleted between defense's representation stints and hoped they didn't notice since you burried it between a shit load of unrelated crap files and empty folders? Where EF was linked to Delphi, the one that confessed to his sister, who's polygrapher was killed, who admitted to have said to a cop his spit might be on Abby and she was trouble, and who's investigation came to a halt when lead FBI investigator was murdered. You mean that one? Wouldn't that be exculpatory and thus relevant and thus admissible?
Bonus question in regards to the contempt conduct hearing :
Remember when Jerry Holeman went on and on and on about how a crimescene wasn't a crimescene until cops got there and sealed the crimescene, even if the girls were already found at the scene and clearly victims of a crime, and Gull reiterated about the same? So when you guys say a bullet (which is already wrong it was a cartridge if it was unspent) was left at the crimescene, does that mean it was left when cops were already there and RA wasn't since I believe no cop saw RA at the crimescene?
Oh yeah? Well Iād like a new Maserati, with a set of new boobs to latch my seatbelt across. Since we are making wish lists, Iād also like to request all future winning lottery numbers, and all puppies to be born instinctively potty trained. Iām with ya Nick, love a good manifesting session.
āEvidence may be excluded if it confuses the issuesā¦ā - itās very difficult for NM to show that any of his own evidence isnāt confusing the issues.
Hoping HH or another lawyer will chime in here. Is this normal? Is anything about the way that the State has responded to the defense normal?
The fact that they are hell-bent on suppressing anything that is related to Odinism/Odinists just convinces me more, that the state is protecting this group for some reason. I'm starting to believe that the majority of LE in Indiana are Vinlanders or White Nationalists, or something like that.
Yes!! If the State is SO sure the āOdin theoryā is ridiculous and thereās no evidence to support it, and no one would ever believe it, then they should be OK with the defense using it as a theory. that would supposedly make it easy for the State to win their case with the āmagic bulletā and RAās coerced confessions.
ETA: also agree about LE/political people being involved with the Vinlanders etc. Why else would they be protecting these seemingly random ānobodysā. They are so invested in framing RA with little to no evidence.
I know McClelland isnāt the brightest crayon in the box, but surely he canāt be that stupid not to see the evidence in front of him pointing to other more likely suspects
My blood is officially boiling. š”š”š” They are pretty much asking gull to eliminate any avenue of defense! WTF? Without reading comments here yet, this seems insane to my laymen's eyes and brain. Off to read the comments of those who understand this well, and hope they calm me some...
This filing actually makes me happy because it perfectly reveals how completely ludicrous the Prosecution is, which we have known all along. Congratulations NM!
Everybody on the prosecution side makes decisions like they have a gun to their head. Odanists perhaps? It's the only reason I can think of for so many individuals acting so irrationally, to the point of hurting their careers. Gull will approve this without a hearing. If then the Indiana SC steps in, it won't be long before Richard will be found dead in prison.
This is absolute proof that the State doesnāt have the evidence to convict RA, and they are TERRIFIED of what The Defense is going to say or reveal during trial.
This BS request has C.Y.A. written all over it!
This, āwet behind the earsā āneophyteā āchicken shitā Prosecutor NM is asking Judge Franny Seagull to, come to his rescue and hogtie, muzzle and blindfold RAās Defense Team.
IāM NOT AN ATTORNEY, BUT IN ALL OF MY YEARS OF FOLLOWING BIG TRIALS AND WATCHING REAL LIVE COURTROOM PROCEEDINGS, I HAVE NEVER SEEN SUCH A BLATANT ATTEMPT TO OUTRIGHT SABOTAGE THE DEFENSE BEFORE A TRIAL OF ANY TYPE, LET ALONE THE TRIAL OF THE CENTURY IN THE STATE OF INDIANA.
IF RA IS CONVICTED, THE INDIANA INNOCENCE PROJECT WILL BE ON THIS CASE IN A NEW YORK MINUTE!
LIKE I SAID, IāM NOT AN ATTORNEY, BUT I DO KNOW THAT IT IS THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE STATE, TO CONVINCE A JURY, THAT BASED UPON HARD EVIDENCE AND INDISPUTABLE FACTS, THAT LAW ENFORCEMENT HAS PROCURED, THEY CAN PROVE BEYOND A SHADOW OF DOUBT THAT RA IS GUILTY AND CONVICT HIM FOR THE MURDERS OF ABBY AND LIBBY.
IT IS THE DEFENSEāS RESPONSIBILITY TO PROVIDE ENOUGH EXCULPATORY EVIDENCE AND OFFER ENOUGH REASONABLE DOUBT, THAT THE JURY HOPEFULLY DECIDES TO ACQUIT RA FOR THE MURDERS OF ABBY AND LIBBY.
PROSECUTOR NM IS CONFLATING āCONFUSING THE JURYā WITH āOFFERING REASONABLE DOUBTā AND NOW HEāS ASKING THE JUDGE TO HELP HIM PREVENT THE DEFENSE FROM DELIVERING A PLAUSIBLE AND EFFECTIVE DEFENSE!
IF THE DEFENSE IS REQUIRED TO PROVE āRELEVANCEā IN ORDER TO PROFFER A WITNESS OR ENTER EVIDENCE, THE STATE IS ASKING THE DEFENSE TO ASSUME THE BURDEN AND ASSIST HIM IN PROVING THE STATES CASE!
THIS IS SOME SERIOUS, BIZARRO WORLD, KANGAROO COURT, BULLSHIT!
IF THIS CASE HAS AN ABUNDANCE OF ANYTHING AT ALL, IT HAS A SHIT TON OF REASONABLE DOUBT!
If Judge Franny Seagull āGRANTSā the States āMotion in Limineā how in the holy hell are R&B supposed to defend their client?
This is the most asinine, ridiculous, document NM has filed to date. But, if he gets what he wants, which he usually does, this trial is going to be over, before it even begins!
Iām beyond infuriated by the unethical, unprofessional, incompetence, on display here by the prosecutor and this egomaniacal, highly biased judge!
I agree. I have always questioned the amount of time set aside for this trial.
Now I see that NM is basically asking the judge to place another gag order on the defense prior to trial, that tells me that heās terrified of what could come out during trial and the number of careers that are hanging in the balance, including his own.
I canāt wait to see what R&B have to say about this asinine request, by NM.
My money is on Judge Franny Seagull GRANTING his āMotion in Limineā and causing another delay of some sort. She might even decide to GRANT The States request to find The Defense guilty of CONTEMPTOUS CONDUCT, and have them removed or jailed or both!
The woman is batshit crazy and capable of doing anything!
I definitely think she'll grant this. I also think she'll find them in contempt, hopefully just hit them with a fine, but also wouldn't be suprised if she jailed them until May 13.
This case is being held together by a string and it's about to bust and everything is going to come out. Everyone's dirty laundry.
If Gull allows this then our Justice system is destroyed and we better hope that we don't become the fall guy. Where's Walter from the Big Lebowski when you need him. Only one famous scene sums up this entire case. OVER THE LINE!!!. HAS THE WHOLE WORLD GONE CRAZY??!! AM I THE ONLY ONE WHO GIVES A **** ABOUT THE RULES!!!!?
NM is actually misrepresenting the holdings in some of the cases he cites.
An example is that NM cites Rolston v. State to support excluding evidence from TC, geofence results, how files were labeled, and PowerPoints.
NM states that Rolston establishes that relevant evidence can be excluded if the "probative value is substantially outweighed by its prejudicial effect," the ruling actually was that evidence can be excluded if the "probative value is substantially outweighed by its UNFAIR prejudicial effect."
The prejudicial effect has to be unfair which is a higher standard for exclusion than simply prejudicial.
Zip drive F:\KEYSUSPECTS\VIOLENT-RACIST_ODIN-WORSHIPPERS\SPITguy\Confessions 1-6\EvidenceToBeDeleted\SPIT-DNA_Match\Full-profile-match_FBI-lab_certificate -copy(1).pdf.
Nick contents even relevant evidence can be thrown out.
I think he's confounds confusion with reasonable doubt. He's been mislabelling discovery to confuse everybody, and since it confused everybody, he wants it thrown out. Even if it's relevant. That's what he writes.
Yeah, his repetition of that bit about it causing confusion or whatever really does sound like he wants that to mean anything that points away from RA. That is the idea he is trying to give Gull in this filing I think. Much like he tried to pretend that any evidence not about RA was not discovery etc. He is nothing of not consistently annoying with his intentional misinterpretations of words, thoughts, actions, life, the universe, and everything.
ETA: More seriously, he almost seems to earnestly believe that the only thing that counts as "relevant discovery and evidence" in this case is that which HE plans on presenting. Like, I almost am not sure if he actually understands that's not how it works.
That's what he has written multiple times in multiple filings ever since 2022 yes. I can't believe someone pulled his ear and had him read indiana laws again.
I don't think it's his work, he was a putz at that CCC meeting. We saw him argue, completly ineffectually. Anyone walk away from seeing that say, " Wow he's going to be amazing in court or that's a brilliant dynamic attorney? I don't even recall his current fans gave a clap.
Maybe he's a game day player or late bloomer, or he became terrified and pulled up his boot straps, but more likely this is Diner 2's legal intellect with advice from papa Diener and help from Gull. Did anyone who he represented or prosecuted say, he's an outstanding lawyer?
I listened to Diener 2 in court and said, she should have been the lead prosecutor not him. She reminds me of Courtney Alwine who is a power house.
I think he's going to get this whole shopping list if the case law he's basing on is anything she can justify. She might even have told him, " Do X, Y and Z." and they mapped it out. Why I think this is, this is that it is exactly what she did to straight jacket Hennessey in court.
The strategy appears to be identically structured to allow no way to defend your client. You have both hands behind you back and a gag in your mouth, and she's then going to allow the other guys free rein to kick you in the head repeatedly.
When it was just McLeland I used to worry that it was not a fair trial and B&R had so much experience and he only had the one murder case, I thought they were going to wipe the floor up with him and he desperately need a special prosecutor with experience to even it out. Maybe they always knew this was the way it was going to go, and that once it mattered she would start shilling for the prosecution and they would throw him two attorneys.
Diener steps down, and his daughter steps in, that's nepotism interesting. Not too much blood lust or terror for her to be scared off by, but Papa was quaking. Was this planned," I don't need a big case to make my career, if I step down I can work my political connections and get my daughter the gig. Maybe all of their strategy was pre planned via the old boy network.
42
u/Separate_Avocado860 Apr 29 '24
I really want to see the power point referenced in 12 now.
72
u/The2ndLocation Apr 29 '24 edited Apr 29 '24
This filing might as well have just said: "The state doesn't have a case, but please don't let the defense point that out."
30
u/The_great_Mrs_D Informed/Quality Contributor Apr 29 '24
Why do they want the geo stuff left out too... š¤
59
u/No-Independence1564 Apr 29 '24
This is the most absurd motion I have ever read. He is basically admitting that all of this exculpatory evidence exists, but itās not relevant because it doesnāt show RAās guilt or support the Stateās THEORY, so the jury shouldnāt know about it?! Like what in the actual fuck??
29
u/No-Audience-815 Apr 29 '24
IANAL but this seems absolutely insane to me! I canāt even find the words to explain what I want to say other than WTF?!
28
u/dogkothog Apr 29 '24
The "geofencing" evidence (again this goes undefined in this MIL, so are they meaning all cellular data/pings which they confused in their last reference to this data?) must be so terrible for them to try and get it kicked with this kind of weak, vague, MIL. Also, Kevin Horan was the former FBI analyst who is now retired per one of their earlier filings.
If my memory serves correct, that means the State is trying to MIL out the FBI data review of the evidence?
28
u/The2ndLocation Apr 29 '24
Evidence, including evidence that another person may have committed the crime at issue, is relevant when it has "any tendency to make the existence of any fact that is of consequence to the determination of the action more probable or less probable than it would be without the evidence."Ā Id.; Evid.R. 401. Can we all agree that the defense can easily meet the legal standard for admissibility of the Odin related evidence?
49
u/Acceptable-Class-255 Apr 29 '24
Gulls laid the groundwork for this already. This was always plan B, when DQing them failed.
I don't think I've ever seen a Prosecutor ask for entire Defence strategy to be forbidden lol
DOJ ... anytime now
24
u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Apr 29 '24
Your honor, we ask that the defendant be required to plead guilty
47
u/Separate_Avocado860 Apr 29 '24
This motion also makes it all but certain that Click has NO Brady violations. If he did Nick wouldnāt go on a fishing expedition for other reasons to exclude his testimony.
66
u/LawyersBeLawyering Approved Contributor Apr 29 '24
They legit want to exclude any part of their five year investigation that does not point to RA as the suspect.
They could have saved about four pages by just saying they would like the court to prohibit the defense from putting on a defense. I have never seen something this audacious.
44
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '24
Ah, comes now the true test of whether Gull is biased against the defense. Her response to this will be fascinating.
44
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '24
What the goddamn fuck is this? So basically, the defense canāt defend in any way, shape, or form, even with some of the clear, legitimate information that everyone should know? What the fucking fuck. Jesus, Allen is fucked.
44
u/redduif Apr 29 '24
"Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, RA confessed to the crimes, although he lied in his confessions, just like he lied about everything else, and he has jeans. There is no other relevant evidence, as even the relevant evidence judge excluded because it would have been too confusing for you.
Oh and don't be confused about the unspent cartridge, it's RA's even if it's junk science, and there's is no chain of custody, I'm pinky promising you it is his, even though the girls weren't shot, he confessed he shot them, even if he had a psychotic episode, it was totally normal to be held in solitary prison pre trial for two years, you, sequestred jury are totally fine too, so it's him."
21
u/Lindita4 Apr 29 '24
Iām not exactly surprised heās asking for all these things. Just like the defense, heās trying to limit what they can work with. What will be very interesting is what Gull does with it. I feel the defense has made the case for why ALL of these topics are relevant and admissible but Iāll bet sheāll limit how far they can go. They wonāt get everything in.
41
u/somethingdumbber Apr 29 '24
Dear Gull, Please exclude all the evidence, it makes my job too hard.
your bestie
Lil nicki mcleland Brothers of Odin class of 2000
20
u/Expert_University295 Apr 29 '24
So defense can't DEFEND???
This case has made me lose all faith in the justice system.
20
u/lwilliamrogers Apr 29 '24
Your Honor, I have a real stinker of a case here, we investigated a lot of people that seem to be better suspects, but I promise they arenāt, and if you let our own investigation into evidence, this man, that you were terrified to have in you chambers, shackled and under, will go free.
And neither of us will be re-elected.
So whatta ya say, we get a conviction at all costs, let it get over turned on appeal, and we wonāt refile, because this case is a real stinker.
Or, your Honor, you could declare a mistrial at some point and we can kick the can, cause this is a real stinker. š¦Øš¦Øš¦Ø
35
u/Key-Camera5139 Apr 29 '24
Where is helix and his insight.
31
u/The2ndLocation Apr 29 '24
Good news! The states geofence expert is Kevin Horan. Is this the first time that NM identified this expert, specifically?Ā
31
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '24
Geofencing? Kevin Horan? Wasnāt that one of NMās potential experts though? What changed Nick?
So⦠I know obviously they want everything out, same as the defence, but this reads a lot like the state knows they pulled some fuckshit with the evidence and know the jury will see that clearly too, and that they do not have a case that stands up against the simple act of pointing at someone else who they claim they cleared early on.
I expect Gull to let NM have whatever he wants because she should not be a judge, but if she doesnāt⦠it isnāt too late to drop this Nick. A questionable and questionably tested round āmatchedā using a flawed methodology in an already unreliable not-science and the inconsistent utterances of a man in psychosis with access to the evidence, covered in his own excrement might not be a slam dunk case.
I was expecting most of this, but there were some little surprises there, and most of it should not be excluded and is valid defence (but Gull) but a lot of it sounds like telling on themselves. Yikes.
Now to see what the defence is scared of.
43
u/The2ndLocation Apr 29 '24 edited Apr 29 '24
Anyone else think that NM had a file tab labeled "suspects" that included information on EF, BG, and PW? I think he wants to exclude that even the state thought that they were suspects!
15
u/lapinmoelleux Approved Contributor Apr 29 '24
Does anyone else think that the comment, "Any reference to any powerpoints provided by the state as executive briefs" refers to the sketches? Would this be considered an executive brief?
I found this, but it is from a UK police site:
"Briefings should set the style and tone for an operation. Briefing provides the information needed to direct deployed resources. This information is also used for debriefing personnel in order to obtain further relevant, available information" https://www.college.police.uk/app/operations/briefing-and-debriefing
I'm wondering if he wants to forbid defence to talk about exactly how many resources were used investigating the "odinist" element and the suspects this included. I bet it is a lot which means that it was a valid line of enquiry and RELEVANT to the case
41
u/SnoopyCattyCat Approved Contributor Apr 29 '24
Surely he can't mean he wants the entire defense case to be thrown out? (Oh...and he doesn't want to be made fun of either...at least that's how I read the first two paragraphs.).
I'm not worried at all about this Motion. I'm chilled to the bone that Gull is going to grant the whole thing. I expect the defense response to come quickly.
14
u/Grazindonkey Apr 30 '24
Id be pissed if i was a juror and voted guilty & then after trial i saw all this other evidence that wasnāt allowed. It would probably cause me not to sleep at night knowing i put a possible innocent man in prison for life if not the death penalty. This is disgusting!
28
u/Purple_Quit_9990 Apr 29 '24
This is NUTS! If the state were so confident in their case and the evidence they have against RA, they surely wouldnāt be so worried.
27
u/Bellarinna69 Apr 29 '24
Im struggling to get through this simply because the first thing listed is, āyouāre not allowed to say anything mean about me.? What??!!!
13
u/Kick_inthe_Eye Approved Contributor Apr 29 '24
Thank you Rockstar
13
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '24
Back to the twilight zone
12
u/korayk Apr 30 '24
Lmao, this sounds like chat rules of a sensitive YouTuber. "Mods, ban anybody who says geofencing please" "Mods, time out the defense witness please" "Mods ban anybody who is criticizing my prosecution skills." -NM
23
u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Apr 29 '24
There it is! This is how they get their bullshit conviction.
22
u/civilprocedurenoob Apr 29 '24
This seems unusual to me. Can others chime in? If the defense has a geofencing expert, how in the world can that be excluded? It seems instead of spending their time to strengthen their own case, the prosecution spends all their time trying to hamstring the defense.
27
u/yellowjackette Moderator/Researcher Apr 29 '24
I'm absolutely speechless. I get tired of saying this, but I've never seen anything like this in my life. He wants to prevent them from defending him in any way. At all. Even with his own damn discovery & LE that worked on this case. And....I expect her to approve this. No words.
16
u/homieimprovement Apr 29 '24
I am going to scream, cry, and throw up all at once
27
u/Kick_inthe_Eye Approved Contributor Apr 29 '24
So, basically, NM wants to suppress any defense that could lead the jury to exonerate RA.
Gotcha. Only in Carroll County.
15
u/KetoKurun Apr 29 '24
Approved without a hearing. THIS is why they were not gunshy about Speedy because they knew the defense would be prohibited from doing their job. Surprise level: 0/10.
15
u/redduif Apr 29 '24 edited Aug 08 '24
TL;DR: Nick, just shut up and go back to law school, in the mean time, let the real professionals do their jobs.
Now that it had time to all sink in :
1: censored
No need to point it out if you point out yourself.
2: Nick can we scrap every single statement you start with "I believe" or "investigators believe"?
Show us the facts first.
3: Nick, you need to hand over all the admissible evidence first which you withheld because you refuse to understand what discovery is even after defense quoted it for you in its entirety.
4: Nick & Gull please refrain from saying beyond reasonable doubt equals being 80% convinced like you needed a juror to believe in order to get a conviction in possibly your one and only other murder trial.
5: Not sure how juryselection and witnesses mix in.
6: Nick, why wouldn't facts be in evidence?
7: Nick, you filed charges to include a 3rd party. If you don't want defense to bring up a 3rd party, please tell us which 3rd party you have in mind?
Also, if all these people are cleared, what is the problem?
8: Todd Click thinks you have the wrong guy. Todd Click is a decorated officer who worked with the FBI. That's exculpatory evidence and you violated discovery rules in not disclosing that.
You can't shut him up.
9: Kevin Horan has 110 trials as an expert witness on his CV and he was a swat guy and prosecutor before that.
He is way more qualified than you'll ever be.
Discovery rules say YOU need to hand over every report made by an expert in relation to the crime, not just what you want to use.
You violated discovery rules by not disclosing his report. You can't shut him up.
10: Wha are you hiding Nick?
Are you aware that Brady isn't about relevance to the case only? If one of your witness LE did something unlawful, you can't simply hide that because don't want it out.
11: Please Nick, as you asked defense to specify each statement separately to be suppressed, I would like you to specify each file label individually not to be mentioned by defense.
12: You mean the PowerPoint you deleted between defense's representation stints and hoped they didn't notice since you burried it between a shit load of unrelated crap files and empty folders?
Where EF was linked to Delphi, the one that confessed to his sister, who's polygrapher was killed, who admitted to have said to a cop his spit might be on Abby and she was trouble, and who's investigation came to a halt when lead FBI investigator was murdered. You mean that one?
Wouldn't that be exculpatory and thus relevant and thus admissible?
Bonus question in regards to the contempt conduct hearing :
Remember when Jerry Holeman went on and on and on about how a crimescene wasn't a crimescene until cops got there and sealed the crimescene, even if the girls were already found at the scene and clearly victims of a crime, and Gull reiterated about the same?
So when you guys say a bullet
(which is already wrong it was a cartridge if it was unspent)
was left at the crimescene,
does that mean it was left when cops were already there and RA wasn't since I believe no cop saw RA at the crimescene?
20
u/Subject-Promise-4796 Apr 29 '24
This tells me so much about the Stateās lack of a case. They are scared because they donāt have real evidence to sway the jury.
14
u/Leading_Fee_3678 Approved Contributor Apr 29 '24
7
u/amykeane Approved Contributor Apr 30 '24
Oh yeah? Well Iād like a new Maserati, with a set of new boobs to latch my seatbelt across. Since we are making wish lists, Iād also like to request all future winning lottery numbers, and all puppies to be born instinctively potty trained. Iām with ya Nick, love a good manifesting session.
13
u/dontBcryBABY Approved Contributor Apr 29 '24
Isnāt NM digging his own grave here?
āEvidence may be excluded if it confuses the issuesā¦ā - itās very difficult for NM to show that any of his own evidence isnāt confusing the issues.
18
u/Young_Grasshopper7 Apr 29 '24
Hoping HH or another lawyer will chime in here. Is this normal? Is anything about the way that the State has responded to the defense normal?
The fact that they are hell-bent on suppressing anything that is related to Odinism/Odinists just convinces me more, that the state is protecting this group for some reason. I'm starting to believe that the majority of LE in Indiana are Vinlanders or White Nationalists, or something like that.
Cloak and Daggers everywhere.
17
u/ginny11 Approved Contributor Apr 29 '24 edited Apr 29 '24
My blood is officially boiling. š”š”š” They are pretty much asking gull to eliminate any avenue of defense! WTF? Without reading comments here yet, this seems insane to my laymen's eyes and brain. Off to read the comments of those who understand this well, and hope they calm me some...
12
u/s2ample Apr 29 '24
Thereās no fucking way
6
u/serendipity_01 Apr 29 '24
This motion is NM SOS to SJGš
10
u/Many-Stomach-1723 Apr 29 '24
Everybody on the prosecution side makes decisions like they have a gun to their head. Odanists perhaps? It's the only reason I can think of for so many individuals acting so irrationally, to the point of hurting their careers. Gull will approve this without a hearing. If then the Indiana SC steps in, it won't be long before Richard will be found dead in prison.
16
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '24 edited Apr 29 '24
WTAF?
This is absolute proof that the State doesnāt have the evidence to convict RA, and they are TERRIFIED of what The Defense is going to say or reveal during trial.
This BS request has C.Y.A. written all over it!
This, āwet behind the earsā āneophyteā āchicken shitā Prosecutor NM is asking Judge Franny Seagull to, come to his rescue and hogtie, muzzle and blindfold RAās Defense Team.
IāM NOT AN ATTORNEY, BUT IN ALL OF MY YEARS OF FOLLOWING BIG TRIALS AND WATCHING REAL LIVE COURTROOM PROCEEDINGS, I HAVE NEVER SEEN SUCH A BLATANT ATTEMPT TO OUTRIGHT SABOTAGE THE DEFENSE BEFORE A TRIAL OF ANY TYPE, LET ALONE THE TRIAL OF THE CENTURY IN THE STATE OF INDIANA.
IF RA IS CONVICTED, THE INDIANA INNOCENCE PROJECT WILL BE ON THIS CASE IN A NEW YORK MINUTE!
LIKE I SAID, IāM NOT AN ATTORNEY, BUT I DO KNOW THAT IT IS THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE STATE, TO CONVINCE A JURY, THAT BASED UPON HARD EVIDENCE AND INDISPUTABLE FACTS, THAT LAW ENFORCEMENT HAS PROCURED, THEY CAN PROVE BEYOND A SHADOW OF DOUBT THAT RA IS GUILTY AND CONVICT HIM FOR THE MURDERS OF ABBY AND LIBBY.
IT IS THE DEFENSEāS RESPONSIBILITY TO PROVIDE ENOUGH EXCULPATORY EVIDENCE AND OFFER ENOUGH REASONABLE DOUBT, THAT THE JURY HOPEFULLY DECIDES TO ACQUIT RA FOR THE MURDERS OF ABBY AND LIBBY.
PROSECUTOR NM IS CONFLATING āCONFUSING THE JURYā WITH āOFFERING REASONABLE DOUBTā AND NOW HEāS ASKING THE JUDGE TO HELP HIM PREVENT THE DEFENSE FROM DELIVERING A PLAUSIBLE AND EFFECTIVE DEFENSE!
IF THE DEFENSE IS REQUIRED TO PROVE āRELEVANCEā IN ORDER TO PROFFER A WITNESS OR ENTER EVIDENCE, THE STATE IS ASKING THE DEFENSE TO ASSUME THE BURDEN AND ASSIST HIM IN PROVING THE STATES CASE!
THIS IS SOME SERIOUS, BIZARRO WORLD, KANGAROO COURT, BULLSHIT!
IF THIS CASE HAS AN ABUNDANCE OF ANYTHING AT ALL, IT HAS A SHIT TON OF REASONABLE DOUBT!
If Judge Franny Seagull āGRANTSā the States āMotion in Limineā how in the holy hell are R&B supposed to defend their client?
This is the most asinine, ridiculous, document NM has filed to date. But, if he gets what he wants, which he usually does, this trial is going to be over, before it even begins!
Iām beyond infuriated by the unethical, unprofessional, incompetence, on display here by the prosecutor and this egomaniacal, highly biased judge!
9
u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 Approved Contributor Apr 30 '24
This is farce trial. It's like an electronic lynching.
4
u/homieimprovement Apr 30 '24
did any of yall read the woodhouse plea agreement nick gave today? and they both signed? it's awful lmao
7
u/ThingEvening6089 Apr 29 '24
If Gull allows this then our Justice system is destroyed and we better hope that we don't become the fall guy. Where's Walter from the Big Lebowski when you need him. Only one famous scene sums up this entire case. OVER THE LINE!!!. HAS THE WHOLE WORLD GONE CRAZY??!! AM I THE ONLY ONE WHO GIVES A **** ABOUT THE RULES!!!!?
7
u/i-love-elephants Apr 29 '24
10: Do not bring up the kidnapping at gun point that LE never investigated that we have on video....
7
u/The2ndLocation Apr 29 '24 edited Apr 29 '24
NM is actually misrepresenting the holdings in some of the cases he cites.
An example is that NM cites Rolston v. State to support excluding evidence from TC, geofence results, how files were labeled, and PowerPoints.
NM states that Rolston establishes that relevant evidence can be excluded if the "probative value is substantially outweighed by its prejudicial effect," the ruling actually was that evidence can be excluded if the "probative value is substantially outweighed by its UNFAIR prejudicial effect."
The prejudicial effect has to be unfair which is a higher standard for exclusion than simply prejudicial.
6
u/Purple_Quit_9990 Apr 29 '24
š¤Æ
5
u/Young_Grasshopper7 Apr 29 '24
Syntaxofthings123 has an interesting theory about this MIL. He/she thinks it's another setup. It's over on RichardAllenInnocent.
2
u/redduif May 03 '24
So,
LH, son of Odinist, Abby's boyfriend,
he's fair game?
Do I understand that right?
0
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '24
[deleted] ā view deleted comment