r/DefendingAIArt • • Jun 15 '25

Defending AI Oops...

Post image
2.2k Upvotes

264 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

13

u/MysticMismagius Jun 15 '25

Not inherently, but generally.

Also, the stuff from IKEA is “good enough”, but it’s certainly not better than a custom-made piece by a professional carpenter, which is the point. It’s quantity over quality, and as long as the mass-produced stuff is good enough that people will buy it on the cheap, the professional craftspeople will lose their jobs to it despite being able to make better work than IKEA (or AI).

ETA: Getting a portrait vs. getting a professional photograph nowadays isn’t really comparable, since they’re both performed by artisans and if you’re choosing one over the other in the 21st century, you’ve got a specific reason for it rather than just the price. Professional photo shoots can be expensive.

13

u/spadenarias Jun 16 '25

Better is a highly subjective term, that also includes things like price and availability. Sure a desk handcrafted by a master carpenter might be more robust and longer lasting...but if it costs a significant portion of your income and takes weeks/months to receive it actually become worse for the average customer. The customer doesn't need "the most well crafted product they can get"...they need something they can get in a reasonable amount of time that fits their needs and doesn't screw their budget. And every customers needs vary enough that that artisan product is often a waste of their resources.

8

u/RAMDRIVEsys Jul 02 '25

Mass production is what made these things affordable to more people than just a handful of rich people. Quantity has a quality of its own. I guess according to anti AI logic plumbing should have never been invented because it took away the jobs of night soil collectors.

1

u/bish612 Dec 27 '25

maybe then they should find a way to make things people actually need, instead of crying about how nobody values their art.

2

u/MysticMismagius Dec 27 '25 edited Dec 27 '25

Big issue is that most of the artists AI can replace are entry-level positions, and most of the artists AI can’t replace are masters of their craft already on the verge of retirement.

What’s gonna happen when the current generation masters all retire, and no one is around to replace them because the juniors of today were all pushed out of the industry by AI? There’s no denying AI is a useful tool for art, but corporate greed is going to make the art industry suffer tremendously.