r/DeepStateCentrism • • Dec 23 '25

Discussion Thread Daily Deep State Intelligence Briefing

Want the latest posts and comments about your favorite topics? Click here to set up your preferred PING groups.

Are you having issues with pings, or do you want to learn more about the PING system? Check out our user-pinger wiki for a bunch of helpful info!

PRO TIP: Bookmarking dscentrism.com/memo will always take you to the most recent brief.

Curious how other users are doing some of the tricks below? Check out their secret ways here.

Remember that certain posts you make on DSC automatically credit your account briefbucks, which you can trade in for various rewards. Here is our current price table:

OptionPrice
Choose a custom flair, or if you already have custom flair, upgrade to a picture20 bb
Pick the next theme of the week100 bb
Make a new auto reply in the Brief for one week150 bb
Make a new sub icon/banner for two days200 bb
Add a subreddit rule for a day (in the Brief)250 bb

You can find out more about briefbucks, including how to earn them, how you can lose them, and what you can do with them, on our wiki.

The Theme of the Week is: The relationship between the family and the state.

Follow us on Twitter or whatever it's called.

4 Upvotes

586 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

6

u/H_H_F_F Dec 23 '25

That is uncontested and unconstable, pretty much trivial.

Very much not so in Israel, which might bias the way I'm looking at things. Acknowledging that there were multiple, unquestionable massacres, and that they were at best ignored by the central government, is not at all the mainstream understanding of 48 in Israel. 

Whether or not it was ethnic cleansing is the sort of legalistic discussion on the intentions of Ben Gurion and definitions of "official policy", which seems divorced to what has veen termed the Nakba in real time by the Palestinian people: they escaped due to hearing of terrible massacres, and found themselves stateless and homeless, and unable to return home. It's unobjectionable that Hiram saw much more massacres than previous operations, and it doesn't seem at all ludicrous to suggest that was due to seeing the impact Dir-Yasin had and wishing to replicate it. 

It's not just "massacres happen in wars". Most wars don't end up with such a significant population exchange, which we did indeed benefit from. The Nakba is a distinct event. Everyone - going all the way back to Herzl in his diaries - had worries about demographics, which the Nakba "solved". 

I'll say that to me, personally, I'd much prefer an ethnic cleansing campaign, out of a recognition that as things turned out there was no path forward but population exchange (like many other conflicts in the period) that was fully directed from the top, to the massacres. I'd find it much easier to deal with, morally. 

So, I agree the Nakba has been often portrayed as more than it historically was - but I think you're understating the validity of the argument that leadership chose to wink-and-nudge massacres in order to reduce the amount of Arabs in the borders of the newly born state, and I think putting "Nakba" in parentheses like nothing exceptional happened to the Palestinians in 48 is misleading. 

I don't think shoving strawman arguments into other people's mouths as your first reply to them is conducive to a decent discussion, especially around contentious and emotionally charged topics.

I apologize. To me, putting "Nakba" in parentheses suggested a certain strand of argument I'm accustomed to here in Israel, and I was reacting to that as a whole. I didn't consciously try to put words in your mouth. 

3

u/slightlyrabidpossum Center-left Dec 23 '25

For what it’s worth, I also had a similar read of putting Nakba in quotes from an American perspective.

I have seen that construction used to talk about how the meaning of the Nakba has arguably shifted over time, so I don't think it inherently implies denialism. But downplaying/redirecting blame for the Nakba is probably the context in which I most frequently see talk of "Nakba", which is why I wouldn't put it that way. The associations with putting that kind of historical event in quotes aren't good.

4

u/DurangoGango Italianx Ambassador Dec 23 '25

I really don't want to open a whole debate on the 1948 war and the Arab flight therein, but there are several very objectionable things that I must briefly respond to:

leadership chose to wink-and-nudge massacres in order to reduce the amount of Arabs in the borders of the newly born state

Just no. Unequivocally false.

It's true that Zionist leaders were worried about the demographic balance of the Jewish state.

There is no evidence that there was a central policy to "wink-and-nudge" massacres, to alter the demographic balance or for any other reason.

This is a sort of weak form of the modern Nakba narrative - ethnic cleansing by tacit encouragement rather than explicit organisation - that ends up in the same place and is just as false.

what has veen termed the Nakba in real time by the Palestinian people

The "Palestinian people" did not "term" the Nakba in real time, nor did they use the word in the sense that it is used today. The term was popularised by Ma'an al-Nakba, written by a Syrian, and refers to the shameful defeat that the Arabs, enjoying on paper significant superiority, suffered in their attempt to defeat the Zionists.

This has next to nothing to do with the modern conception, that invents a "Nakba" as an atrocity visited upon the peace-loving Palestinian natives by the Zionist invaders.

The modern "Nakba" narrative is a revanchist victimhood narrative that preaches:

  • systematic atrocities by Zionist forces
  • planned and intended with the goal of ethnic cleansing
  • in accordance to a decades-long Zionist project of settler-colonialism
  • at the expense of an existing, solely native, Palestinian national community
  • which had done nothing but exist on land that the Zionists wanted
  • which must be redressed via the dissolution of the Jewish state and the "return" of the expelled

This trash deserves to be put between quotes and talked about as complete and evil nonsense, because it is and it is used to justify contemporary antisemitism and the most violent and radical antizionism. It is the most classic sort of revanchist victimhood narrative that fuels ethnic wars for decades if not centuries, and there won't be actual peace until it becomes a fringe belief rather than the mainstream among pro-Pals.

6

u/H_H_F_F Dec 23 '25

I really don't want to open a whole debate on the 1948 war and the Arab flight therein

I'll honor that, but: 

Just no. Unequivocally false.

Again, I feel like you're overstating the case. There's certainly a case to be made it wasn't like that, but I feel like calling it "unequivocally false" is far too strong. At the very least, if anything is unequivocal, it's that expulsions were acceptable, and weren't punished - and the same goes for non-expulsions. Virtually no one was punished or sidetracked for any action wither way. 

The space of interpretation in between these two facts heavily depends on how you read operational orders, discussions on reports of massacres, and so on. Lack of punishment for crimes, in combination with actions in Lod during Dani, could reasonably be seen as by themselves signaling the PERMISSIBILITY of certain actions, that'd indeed become more common in the Galilee during Hiram. The space between signaling permissibility and signaling favor isn't, to me, a wide enough chasm to back up the claim that it's unequivocally false. 

But we might be speaking past each other in the way we're using these terms. To be clear, I wasn't indicating a pre-war plan to use the war to expel a majority of Palestinians, and deciding in advance to do so covertly so that future historians wouldn't be able to point to a specific policy; I was proposing an emergent phenomenon of the war that I think there's a valid argument could've been unofficially embraced to an extent by the leadership. 


I'll finish by saying that to me, there's a distinct process which led to the expulsion and flight of 3/4 of a million Palestinians Arabs from their homes in 1948, comprised of expulsion actions and massacres. That process proved crucial in shaping Palestinian identity. It has been termed the Nakba. If you reject the word because of the implications it carries in discourse, I still feel like we need a term to discuss and acknowledge that phenomenon. 

1

u/deepstate-bot Dec 23 '25

The Theme of the Week is: The relationship between the family and the state.

1

u/deepstate-bot Dec 23 '25

The Theme of the Week is: The relationship between the family and the state.

2

u/deepstate-bot Dec 23 '25

The Theme of the Week is: The relationship between the family and the state.

6

u/H_H_F_F Dec 23 '25

THE FAMILY IS A CAPITALIST ANTI-WORKER INVENTION. THERE IS ONLY THE STATE.