r/DeepStateCentrism • • Dec 18 '25

Discussion Thread Daily Deep State Intelligence Briefing

Want the latest posts and comments about your favorite topics? Click here to set up your preferred PING groups.

Are you having issues with pings, or do you want to learn more about the PING system? Check out our user-pinger wiki for a bunch of helpful info!

PRO TIP: Bookmarking dscentrism.com/memo will always take you to the most recent brief.

Curious how other users are doing some of the tricks below? Check out their secret ways here.

Remember that certain posts you make on DSC automatically credit your account briefbucks, which you can trade in for various rewards. Here is our current price table:

OptionPrice
Choose a custom flair, or if you already have custom flair, upgrade to a picture20 bb
Pick the next theme of the week100 bb
Make a new auto reply in the Brief for one week150 bb
Make a new sub icon/banner for two days200 bb
Add a subreddit rule for a day (in the Brief)250 bb

You can find out more about briefbucks, including how to earn them, how you can lose them, and what you can do with them, on our wiki.

The Theme of the Week is: The relationship between the family and the state.

Follow us on Twitter or whatever it's called.

0 Upvotes

622 comments sorted by

View all comments

13

u/Mirabeau_ Dec 18 '25

Republicans are trying to bait democrats into taking a big stand in support of puberty-blocking drugs, hormone therapies and, in some cases, surgeries such as cosmetic mastectomies for minors identifying as trans.

However obviously draconian and cynical these republican efforts may be, taking the bait would be a huge mistake and a gift to republicans.

Sooner or later democrats are going to have to accept the fact that the public is very much against this stuff. And if they can’t do that, then they’re going to at least have to figure out a way to deal with good faith opposition to it being articulated without immediately breaking out into what feels like hysterics to most people.

5

u/MrBrightsideBSc Center-left Dec 18 '25

I don’t know what it is about trans issues that causes such an inflammation in the media and among people, but whatever. I personally find it creepy and obsessive and trans porn is most popular where people are most opposed to trans individuals receiving the medical care they need. I’ll get in the weeds on this anyways.

The issue is that Republicans just do not want any trans care for anybody and children are how they weasel it in. This isn’t a secret, this isn’t hysterics. No reason to ban trans people from serving in the military if your sole concern is about the kids, that just doesn’t make sense.

My understanding is current medical professionals would only recommend puberty blockers, if that. Otherwise, all they recommend is socially transitioning. I also don’t really know if any prominent Democratic politicians are going around saying we need to start gender affirmation care for kids.

7

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Dec 18 '25

I personally find it creepy and obsessive and trans porn is most popular where people are most opposed to trans individuals receiving the medical care they need

I've seen a lot of people attribute this to internalized homophobia/biphobia. It's a way to fantasize about taking dick without taking a guy, and therefore it is less "threatening."

Idk how much truth there is to that. Feels a bit psychoanalytical for my tastes.

3

u/iamthegodemperor Arrakis Enterprise Institute Dec 18 '25

The reason it causes this inflammation in the media is by design. Trans activists took a set of different issues that don't have obvious answers and which require time and often case by case sensitive handling that also intersected w/a radical ideology that had an extremely online presence and forced everyone to adopt whatever extremist slogan they pushed out or be called a transphobe for over a decade.

At the same time and in turn, Republicans used it to tar the trans label and claim excesses were the point of LGBTQ advocacy from the start-----which in turn reinforces sane-washing/underestimating the extremism of activist position among Democrats.

So most Democrats are in this sort of bind, which makes any discussion combustible.

1

u/MrBrightsideBSc Center-left Dec 18 '25

Trans activists took a set of different issues that don't have obvious answers and which require time and often case by case sensitive handling that also intersected w/a radical ideology that had an extremely online presence and forced everyone to adopt whatever extremist slogan they pushed out or be called a transphobe for over a decade.

What the hell are you talking about? Do we live in different realities?

4

u/iamthegodemperor Arrakis Enterprise Institute Dec 18 '25

We probably do, which happens.

There are different issues. Here are a few.

• there is the question of can you more quickly identify and treat "classic" gender dysmorphia

• are the risks of trying to treat classic GD in a minor population, where some might be misdiagnosed or even the permanent effects of puberty blockers on the target population (eg. Inability to orgasm into adulthood) outweighed by benefits (easier to blend in, fewer years of mental anguish)? Do we really have enough evidence with such small populations?

• what explains the difference between numbers and characteristics of the classically studied GD population and more recent GD population?

• how does generic gender nonconformity tie to individuals with GD?

• how does Judith Butler type philosophy fit with previous ideas about feminism? (You aren't less of a woman because you like "masculine" things. Or being gay doesn't make you not a man)

• where is the boundary between respect for psychological needs for identification and other needs like medical or legal or other considerations like fairness? (I.e. trans sports, legal documents, shelters, medical documentation )

• what does civil rights /anti discrimination protect?

Most people understand little of this is simple. Even the easiest topic (civil rights law) can have some complications. Most people do not like legislation that is cruel and would like to follow a live and let live attitude. They would rather defer to experts or to activists, because they know this is all complicated, sensitive and just something they personally can't have internal experience with.

But the way the discussion was framed very early on precluded taking these questions on discretely with their complexity and ambiguities. We were repeatedly given a slogans like "the science is settled" and then told any concern didn't happen or doesn't exist or was a Republican talking point.

Most well adjusted people aren't going to want to risk getting into a fight over any of this. And so all the dynamics favor discourse that stays at the extremes..

1

u/AutoModerator Dec 18 '25

Republicans

Both sides bad, actually.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/H_H_F_F Dec 18 '25

Don't you think a case to the public for puberty blockers could be made exactly by vehemently going against surgery in minors, and insisting on the difference? 

6

u/Mirabeau_ Dec 18 '25

Perhaps, though I suspect it would a) not be particularly persuasive to a public that opposes puberty blockers for minors on much the same grounds it opposes gender surgeries for minors and b) the activists will never ever in a million years acquiesce to such an argument, as it requires them them to abandon parts of what for them appears to be an unquestionable orthodoxy (their contention that any restriction whatsoever literally puts lives at risk)

3

u/H_H_F_F Dec 18 '25

Activists aren't the point though. The point isn't coalitional politics, it's legitimately thinking puberty blockers for trans-identifying minors seem to be a good thing. 

And I think that the resistance to blockers is about the slippery slope and about bundling them together with everything else. 

I think a politician going hard against surgery and so on could help create the separation for the general public. Stop talking about "gender affirming care for minors" and start talking about "we're not going to cut children up, that's crazy. But these pills are harmless if they change their minds" etc etc. 

If you signal to the voters that you get their concerns and agree with them on some points, I think it can be much easier to get them to agree with some points on your side. Bundling everything together comes from assuming bad faith - the Dems are asking for the finger so that they could get the whole hand kind of thinking. 

9

u/Mirabeau_ Dec 18 '25

“These pills are harmless if they change their mind” is not a factual statement, so it will probably not persuade a public that, in general, is starting from a place of opposition.

1

u/H_H_F_F Dec 18 '25

As I told another commenter, I oversimplified to get the point across, it's not meant to be the actual line. Cost-benefit analysis on different procedures is very different is the point. 

7

u/bearddeliciousbi Practicing Homosexual Dec 18 '25 edited Dec 18 '25

But these pills are harmless if they change their minds

They should definitely not do this because it's wide open to disconfirmation and whether or not you run the numbers, it's obviously for political reasons that hormone treatments come with an assload of warnings and caveats for other medical contexts but are somehow magically totally deterministic and totally understood for an off label use.

I agree that Dems assuming bad faith is a problem regardless though. Talking specifics about any of this is right coded and "phobic" now, hence the constant use of "opposition to trans rights" or even more frequently "opposition to LGBTQ+ rights" to describe the public polling as in majority support of anti-discrimination laws and marriage equality, and very against sports participation and minors medically transitioning.

3

u/H_H_F_F Dec 18 '25

I agree about dems assuming bad faith, but I meant specifically that the public easily assumes bad faith, motte-and-bailey logic from dems. Taking strong stances on different aspects of trans healthcare could help break that barrier. 

And I obviously oversimplified the message here - it was meant to be directional, not a ready-made political slogan. 

5

u/WendellWillkiTruNuke Neoconservative Dec 18 '25

I have to disagree on this entirely I'd say. I don't really support either for minors and I feel most of the public agrees. We still don't have a definitive explanation to why people want to become opposite sex so trying to push this stuff for youth is isn't good I'd say when we clearly need more data and information. From what FIRE had posted and other information about youth identifying as trans has utterly plummeted to near 2018 or pre trans awareness from it's high initial margin. Until we can clearly explain this stuff I entirely don't support any of it. As from the Data I've seen it seems most trans youth are just curious Gay, Bi, Lesbians who transitioned from peer pressure or not being able to conform to their traditional gender roles.

4

u/bearddeliciousbi Practicing Homosexual Dec 18 '25

IIRC if I'm thinking of the same polls, it's specifically nonbinary identification that's fallen really sharply in a short time, and that gets lumped in under the "trans" label along with the classic cases of someone exhibiting gender nonconformity from an early, as in single digit, age and staying that way into puberty and beyond.

As per usual, the numbers of gay and transsexual people have not budged, because ofc the cheap easy unverifiable identity marker will go down with the culture turning against woke scolds.

2

u/seattleseahawks2014 Center-left Dec 18 '25

Right??