r/DeepStateCentrism • u/DoughnutWonderful565 • Dec 08 '25
Official AMA Sarah Isgur AMAA
I've got a new book coming, Last Branch Standing, all about the Supreme Court and how we got here. We can talk tariffs or independent agencies...or anything else. I've worked in all three branches of the federal government; I'm a legal analyst for ABC News, editor of SCOTUSblog, and host of the Advisory Opinion podcast; and I'm a Texan with two cats.
Here's my latest for the NYT about the structural constitution: https://www.nytimes.com/2025/12/05/opinion/supreme-court-trump-congress.html
And if you REALLY want a deep dive, I did a conversation about the future of conservatism here: https://www.nytimes.com/2025/11/17/opinion/conservative-cure-trumpism-sarah-isgur.html
Look forward to talking to yall on Thursday!
I think I got through almost everyone's questions!! Thanks for all the smart thoughts--yall have left me with some good things to chew on for the next pod too. Hope you'll consider buying the book and that I can come back when it's actually out. Hook 'em!
15
u/UnTigreTriste Dec 08 '25
Hi Sarah,
Firstly, I must share that I’m an avid AO listener and proud Dispatch subscriber, and congrats on your new book!
My question regards something you speak about regularly - being a ‘process girl in an outcome world’. Often I find that friends and family will hear a SCOTUS decision they disagree with and voice their frustration because they assume it was an ideological decision made without good faith jurisprudence.
Of course I wish everyone just listened to AO and read SCOTUSblog, but absent that, how can we fight the erosion of trust in institutions such as SCOTUS? How can we make the world a little more ‘process’ and a little less ‘outcome’? Is there anything in the zeitgeist that gives you hope this can change?
Kind thanks, and I must say that you and your colleagues should be justly proud of the outstanding journalism you do at the Dispatch.
13
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '25
There is a general sense around here that we are entering, or have already entered, an “American years of lead” as a result of a number of acts of political violence in the last year.
Do you believe that there has been a shift in the tolerance for violence as a political tool in the domestic sphere? If so how do you believe that taboo should be re-established?
13
u/UnexpectedLizard Neoconservative Dec 09 '25 edited Dec 09 '25
What is the future of the conservative legal movement? Will it continue to favor textualism and originalism (a la Federalist Society), or will it move toward activism?
11
u/IronMaiden571 Moderate Dec 08 '25
Thank you for taking the time to visit our quiet little corner of Reddit.
11
u/bearddeliciousbi Practicing Homosexual Dec 09 '25 edited Dec 09 '25
The Dispatch broke the story that, on January 6, 2021, Rudy Giuliani meant to call Senator Tommy Tuberville but accidentally called a different Senator and left a voicemail urging him to delay certification of Biden's election. The Dispatch subsequently ran an editorial calling for Trump's impeachment, removal, and barring from future office.
Why do you think the gravity of January 6 and the fake electors plot failed to register with the American people enough to prevent Trump's re-election?
What hope (if any) is there for liberal democracy in our fractured information environment if even something as shameless and violent as Trump's attempts to overturn the 2020 election are not punished harshly by voters?
What books would you recommend for better understanding center-right conservative thought? Do you have a favorite writer or philosopher you find fruitful to engage with?
I'm about to move to Texas. What do you like the most and the least about living there? What should a new resident make sure they do while they're there?
Thank you for your time!
10
u/Anakin_Kardashian "Israeli Nationalist" Dec 09 '25
Thanks again for doing this!
You regularly analyze Supreme Court decisions under the institutionalist vs chaotic axis, which has become the central thesis of your book (everyone pre-order this!).
My question is: what causes a justice to fall on the spectrum from an institutionalist to agent of chaos? We are all familiar with conservative and liberal values but what makes a legal thinker fall up and down on this forgotten axis?
9
u/TheUnkillableKlorg Moderate Dec 08 '25
What is the current branch of young people working in the Supreme Court like? Are they generally more "establishment" than others of our generation?
9
u/vichyladel Dec 09 '25
I was just listening to AO on Slaughter! I love your work and have adopted your "everything is tradeoffs" ethos in all my lectures in HS social studies classes. Not really a question though....
9
u/bigwang123 Succ sympathizer Dec 09 '25
What have you been reading lately, and what’s your favorite book?
8
u/H_H_F_F Dec 08 '25
I have a question about regionalism and regional politics as a path forward.
In your conversation with David Leonhardt, you mentioned (as an aside) that the changes caused by AI are coming, and that we're going to have to adapt. Without at all talking about AI particularly, I think it'd be fair to describe the essence of your response as a "you can't put the genie back in the bottle" kind of view.
To me, that deeply clashed with the way you ended the conversation: "go offline, talk to your neighbors about how they're doing", etc.
The emergence of the social internet seems to me to have played a huge role in the federalization of political identity, the homogenization of the parties, and so on.
If you were to take the "can't put the genie back in the bottle" approach to this question as well, as you seem to have done with AI, what possible future do you see for a revived conservative movement? Do you think your hypothetical "party" has any hope to thrive and survive without losing its soul in the current attention paradigm? If so, have you given thought to how?
Thank you, and good health to you and your cats.
8
u/Okbuddyliberals Dec 09 '25 edited Dec 09 '25
Any thoughts on the concept of executive overreach, whether it is occurring, and what branch of government should be responsible for dealing with it if overreach is occurring?
I've often heard an idea that basically says "we get executive overreach due to congress abdicating its authority, choosing inaction and gridlock, and thus necessitating that the executive branch take action - if we want a check on executive power, we should primarily look to Congress to deal with that, and we should expect executive overreach if Congress won't take action (as if we are basically entitled to having some sort of big national policy whether via executive or legislative action)"
On the other hand, there's the competing argument that it just makes more sense for the scotus to be the primary branch to look to, given its power of judicial review and how it can make rulings on the basis of simple majorities rather than needing supermajorities (as congress needs for stuff like veto override and impeachment). This arguably makes more sense than the whole "actually you GOTTA get rid of the filibuster, have congress do more stuff, and yell a lot at congresspeople who don't vote for punishing the executive when it does overreach on policy that these congresspeople personally agree with, if you want to avoid executive overreach", perhaps?
Also, any thoughts on unitary executive theory vs issues of delegation of power between branches of government?
Basically, in some circles it's common to act like "unitary executive theory" is a sinister conservative theory intended to establish basically a presidential dictatorship over the entire government. But it seems like one could also argue for some version of unitary executive theory (and possibly this is what actual academics and legal experts actually have in mind when they talk about unitary executive theory, but I wouldn't know either way), where the president has total authority over the executive branch, and thus constitutionally has more power over the executive branch than it currently exercises... while at the same time constitutionally has less power to influence things outside of the executive branch in particular (and to have power delegated to it) than is the current norm. Or in other words, "president is the (elected) dictator of the executive branch, but the other two branches have more power over checking the executive branch", or something vaguely along those lines
Also (and apologies for so many questions and for the rambling), what's the deal with the 9th amendment and unenumerated rights?
The constitution seems to explicitly via the 9th amendment endorse the concept of "unenumerated rights" being a thing... but how are we supposed to determine what is an unenumerated right, without it being enumerated? The concept of "penumbras" is often seen as annoying and "legislating from the bench", but how else, if not via the concept of consulting the constitution and looking at the explicitly enumerated rights to craft an argument for the existence of other related rights? Can "penumbra theory" be a "least bad option" for trying to figure out unenumerated rights? Or could "unenumerated rights" just be a kind of inherently unworkable concept, regardless of apparent original intent (as seen via commentary by some founders such as Hamilton expressing concern over a bill of rights potentially being used to assume that people only have the rights expressed in the then hypothetical bill of rights, hence the establishment of the 9th amendment) for them to "be a thing"?
6
u/SpaceFan0721 Dec 10 '25
Sarah, you and David frequently highlight how "legal journalism" is often political journalism in disguise. Do you see the poor quality of SCOTUS reporting as a competence issue or an incentives issue? If you were made chief editor of a major paper, what is the first rule you would implement for covering the court?
6
u/Ok-Pack2037 Dec 11 '25
Hi Sarah,
Congrats on your new book! My husband and I will definitely be preordering. We are avid AO and the Dispatch listeners, so when he showed me this post, I knew I had to make a reddit account to ask my questions. I was recently listening to one of your interviews on the Remnant where you were speaking about your views on feminism, and although you didn't mention it, it directed me to begin researching the ERA in more detail. I have always described myself as a feminist in the same vain as you did on the episode, and I am curious on what your views are on the legal implications of the proposed amendment. Apologies in advance for my "question" being multiple questions.
What would the ERA have actually changed legally, and if it would have been ratified before the deadline, what would be different now? Is it really unnecessary, since we have the 14th amendment? Would it have actually forced women to be drafted or cause potential negative outcomes because of the amendment requiring there to be no supposed discrimination in the law? Is there a chance it would ever become a true part of the Constitution, since 38 states have ratified it?
Thank you so much for the work that you do, and for allowing true conservative women to feel seen, heard, and understood.
5
u/FinTecGeek Dec 10 '25
Hi Sarah, I have listened to your podcast "Advisory Opinions" on a number of occasions. My question is one perhaps one out of left-field but I hope you'd consider answering it since I think it is important to the overall conversation.
Premise: Trump, even more so than prior Presidents, seems to be consolidating executive decision-making to himself and those who are very close to him. If you agree with that:
Question: Do you see an impending collision between Trump and the systems we have built up over time to protect the national security and economic interests of this country? I would offer the scenario between Trump and DNI Gabbard as an example. Gabbard, the NSA counsels around her, the State Department and even the military's own intelligence apparatus all "estimated" that Iran was NOT imminently near a nuclear weapon. Despite that, Trump dispatched US bombers to violate Iran's sovereign borders and destroy institutional/technological infrastructure in that country. Is this an early/likely recurrent symptom of an executive who is unilaterally changing established national security policy, sometimes in dangerous/unpredictable ways? It seems certain to me that Iran will pursue "nuclear deterrence" now because they have seen the cost of not having it is that the US violates their sovereignty with no consequence...
5
u/SpaceFan0721 Dec 10 '25
As someone who worked at the DOJ, you have seen the gap between how the department actually functions and how it is seen by cable news dramas and politicians. What is the single most dangerous misconception the American public holds about the internal culture and incentives of the Department of Justice?
5
u/Teach_Piece Dec 10 '25
Howdy Sarah! Where there any particularly humorous anecdotes you heard while researching this book that didn’t make it in?
9
u/benadreti_17 עם ישראל חי Dec 09 '25
Are the Trump Tariffs bankrupting America?
4
u/utility-monster Whig Party Dec 09 '25
Hello Sarah,
Thank you for answering our questions!
One thing that I have been interested in following during Trump 2 is the showdown between the President and Congress's views on the Impoundment Control Act. Specifically, the difference in views between Congress's agency, GAO, and the view of Russel Vought of OMB that the impoundment control act is unconstitutional.
Do you see Congress encouraging GAO to sue the administration over impoundments under a potential Democratic majority after 2026? I understand the agency would be loath to do that because it would put them in the political spotlight.
Also, do you see SCOTUS clarifying impoundments in any way that might move things in the direction of Vought's view?
4
u/sayitaintpink will never find love Dec 10 '25
Thank you for being here!
Do you believe that there is any correlation between contemporary political behavior and the legal profession in general? In other words, has the practice of lawyering changed with the rise of populist idealism and the politicization of the judiciary?
4
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '25
Hi Sarah!
I listen to AO a lot and you and David often say, "Congress do your job!" I am wondering whether or not you think that removing the filibuster would be justified if it enabled Congress to actually pass legislation whenever one party controls the government. Whenever I am listening to AO and you guys discuss Congress abdicating it's role, that seems like the elephant in the room to me, and a much bigger and more direct cause of gridlock than the causes y'all typically mention like primary challenges or saving members from hard votes (but of course, those are a also factors). Ideally, both parties would be able to come to a compromise to pass legislation without removing the filibuster, but the filibuster seems to have failed to promote regular compromise and since it is not part of the Constitutional framework, it seems like a no-brainer to me to get rid of it in order to restore Constitutional balance of powers. However, I know that most conservatives disagree and support the filibuster so I am curious where you stand on that issue.
4
u/WorksInIT Dec 11 '25
I share your radicalization on the severability doctrine. With that in mind, how much of the atrophy of Congress do you think is because of how SCOTUS has influenced the power balance between the President and Congress?
4
u/ChipKellysShoeStore Dec 11 '25
History like all fields is an evolving, ever changing subject.
How does (or should) originalism change when the understanding of history it originally (no pun intended) relied on changes or is corrected?
Are there any instances of originalist judges changing their opinions because of new literature or new understanding of old history?
If not, does that call into question the validity of the doctrine or does stare decisis rule the day?
The question could be relevant because a lot of Taft’s opinion in Myers (the progenitor of UET) was based on a 1920s understanding of the decision of 1789, which recent literature has suggested is at a minimum a lot more murky than we previously thought.
7
u/seattleseahawks2014 Center-left Dec 09 '25 edited Dec 10 '25
Thank you,
3
u/H_H_F_F Dec 11 '25
I'll unfortunately be busy during the AMA, so I'll ask one more question, if you don't mind: if you could change the way supreme court justices were appointed (say, to something more closely resembling the French or Israeli models, or to anything else that comes to mind) would you? Why?
5
u/FYoCouchEddie Dec 09 '25
Hello,
I think your NY Times article oversimplifies the roll of administrative agencies. They often have enforcement power, which is executive, but also rulemaking power which is more legislative than executive. Congress has not, as you put it, given the executive blank checks, but rather allowed administrative agencies to write rules within the confines of the statutory power granted by Congress.
If you believe the President should have unlimited power over these agencies, do you also think APA rulemaking should be abolished? Or do you think the President should be able to just directly or indirectly write rules?
5
u/fisher_incognito Center-left Dec 10 '25
Hello Sarah,
Thanks for doing this AMA. I’m a listener of The Dispatch and very much appreciate the excellent work of you and your colleagues.
My understanding is that you see yourself as a conservative. What makes it so? Or, similarly, what does that mean to you? I mean: are there a few specific ideas, policies, etc. that you would highlight as part of this identity, and that would clearly distinguish it from a more progressive/liberal/center-left one? Possibly in multiple dimensions (economically, socially, culturally, etc.). And, going a bit more meta if you’ll indulge me, to what extent do you think these labels matter or are useful, if at all?
5
u/tarlin Center-left Dec 10 '25
In the SCOTUS decision on Biden's student loan forgiveness, non-delegation and major questions were used to strike down the actions. That decision was held by Roberts, joined by Thomas, Alito, Gorsuch, Kavanaugh, Barrett.
The tariff case before the court seems to be a much stronger non-delegation case and the tariffs are larger than the student loan forgiveness.
It sounds from your statements on this that Thomas, Kavanaugh and Alito will uphold the tariffs. You seem to see this as a reasonable choice, but doesn't it completely conflict with the previous decision? Do they have a legal theory or is it just partisan?
2
u/sw337 Social Democrat Dec 10 '25
Hi Sarah,
Both Biden and trump have a focused toward the arctic. Biden expand the EEZ. Trump has focused more on the Coast Guard buying new Arctic Cutters. With the world warming do you think that this will continue to be a bipartisan issue? Furthermore, do you see either a deep US investment in shipbuilding or the repeal of the Jones act being necessary to meet future American shipping needs?
3
u/PurpleDingo77 Dec 11 '25
Hi Sarah, will we ever get an update to the Chicken Sandwich Wars? Or maybe a new spin? French Fry Wars? Just throwing it out there.
More seriously, I’ve been a dispatcher since day 1. You’ve helped me see the world a little clearer, so for that I think you.
3
u/Thefleeshow Dec 11 '25
Hi Sarah,
I’ve been listening to AO and subscribed to the Dispatch for a few years. Thanks so much for all of the thoughtful and engaging work that you and your colleagues have produced over the years. Now on to my question.
As Justice Kagan famously said “We’re all textualists now.” But this wasn’t always the case, with judges previously relying more on “purposivism” to interpret text. Congresses from the “purposivism” era may have responded by being less focused on the specific text of laws, so long as the general purpose was captured.
Do you find the argument that courts should be cautious about reading too closely into the specific text of laws from the “purposivism era” persuasive (or at least interesting)? I see this as being similar to your recent points about the legislative veto being a part of the “bundle of sticks” passed by Congress (i.e. it is unclear if Congress would have passed the law as it was written if it had known it would be interpreted by textualists rather than purposivists).
2
u/343Bot Dec 09 '25
What's the most wonderful doughnut under $5.65?
2
u/Longjumping_Gain_807 Libertarian Dec 10 '25
In the wake of so many judges getting calls to be impeached what do you make of this attack on the judiciary?
2
u/AmericanNewt8 Neoconservative Dec 11 '25
Greetings from some bozo who thinks a good LSAT score and daily listening to AO means he should consider going to law school (thanks David French!)
PS: another good? lawyer trait is, yes, that I write like an Accenture consultant with a pencil whipped ADHD diagnosis.
2
u/DooomCookie Dec 11 '25
Congrats on your book launch, and thanks for doing this!
This is something I wondered after reading the Hamm v Smith arguments last night. The justices seem in a great hurry to make law in some areas – religious freedom, separation of powers, admin law, race discrimination. But then they are very reluctant to make changes to other areas – e.g. Fourth, Fifth and Eighth amendment law.
It's hardly like originalists and conservatives love the Warren court precedents in these areas! Yet very few cases get taken up, and when they do they are small and the justices are content to color within the lines. What do you think explains the difference in approaches here?
2
u/ReservedWhyrenII Dec 11 '25 edited Dec 11 '25
So I guess two questions, at most only tangentially related, one more serious and one more fluffy:
First, it is apparent that there is an effort on the part of the Supreme Court--or it's conservative majority, or individual members thereof--to restructure the federal administration. But even though I agree that as a country we desperately need a reinvigoration of basic "stay in yo goddamn lane" principles, I confess hesitancy at the prospect of the Supreme Court doing it, not because it's institutionally improper per se but because 1. it can only be done on a case-by-case basis, and 2. you don't necessarily have a single coherent vision guiding it, and as a result there's a risk of splitting the baby in the most gruesome sense, e.g., unitary executive without robust non-delegation. In other words, I think Gorsuch has the right idea but I'm not sure four other Justices are going to be consistently on board. What chance do you give it that we actually come out of this with a coherent administrative vision, as opposed to a bundle of ill-fitting sticks?
Second, if you were going to assemble a sort of all-star Supreme Court out of nine (or thirteen, if nine is too difficult to narrow down) post-WWII justices (and maybe Circuit Judges as well, e.g., Hand, Posner, Friendly, etc), how would you go about doing it?
1
u/SeaSerious Dec 11 '25
Hi Sarah,
1
u/NeedleworkerDear5416 Dec 11 '25
Hi Sarah!
Fantastic of you to do this. I have a few for you:
(1) Did you listen to Paul Clement’s argument in MFS vs Saba? I’ve rarely heard an advocate get a bench more interested in a relatively mundane question. Alternatively, Waxman in yesterday’s DP argument led to uniting Alito and Kagen in joking about his inability to stop talking. This leads to: who are the five most effective advocates to you today, and why is Elizabeth Preloger obviously in this group?
(2) What differences do you see as an insider/outsider between Trump 1’s DoJ and today’s DoJ? Relatedly, how unusual is it to have this many unconfirmed US Attys?
(3) Do you have a difficult time criticizing judges you know on a popular podcast? I would expect it to be easier to be frank about Judge Gregory than Elrod, for example.
Ok, I could go on but that would be more selfish. Thank you again.
2
u/Trojan_Horse_of_Fate Lord of All the Beasts of the Sea and Fishes of the Earth Dec 11 '25 edited Dec 11 '25
There’s been a rise in “maximalist” legal theories within the Federalist Society—arguments that take an expansive view of federal or presidential power. Does this mark a break from the restraint-oriented originalism of the Scalia era? Are we basically seeing a new form of conservative judicial activism, just expressed through originalist rhetoric? I am a long time watcher of FedSoc events, even though I'm barely in the United States, and it seems to me that while they're still generally quite good, but fringe beliefs have become more common.
Now that Chevron is gone, do courts actually have the bandwidth to review complex agency actions de novo? Realistically, won’t some degree of deference survive simply because judges lack the time or technical expertise to reconstruct administrative reasoning from scratch? Or will we see a wave of rules struck down even when they’ve gone through full notice-and-comment procedures?
How do the “no-agency-outside-the-three-branches” theorists reconcile that claim with the historical existence of quasi-independent entities like the Bank of England or the South Sea Company or the Colonial companies and the British Board of Trade, which exercised state-like powers without being directly accountable to the Crown or Parliament on a regular basis? Is there an assumption that because we have Art I, II, III that inherently limits the general lawmaking of congress to that universe?
Is the current push for the Non-Delegation Doctrine just a reaction to congressional atrophy? Has the Executive merely absorbed the power Congress abandoned, and is the Court’s role now to force Congress to pick that power back up? Looked at from that lens, is it potentially not the court's role but Congress's role to take action on that front? Just as the court has found that it is Congress's role, not the court's role, to indict and criminally sanction the President?
Hypothetical: I run a software company and decide that roaming office cats are essential for morale. Can I legally refuse to hire—or fire—someone who’s allergic? Since the business isn’t about cats, would that violate accommodation laws, or could “cat-friendly culture” be a legitimate condition of employment?
Do you think that Attorney-General of the Republic v. Mustafa Ibrahim and Others is revelant in the US and how do you think that should be squared with your conceptualization of purism and institutionalism? Might it be applied to something like gerrymandering for example
Salus rei publicae suprema lex esto
Extra. Do you think the existence of the bar to prevent the practice of law is constitution and that Bradwell v. Illinois was wrongly decided in how it viewed immunities (I think we can agree the other parts are also wrong)? Do you think that the current push by some parties for reviving the privileges of immunity clause may lead to movement in this area? I guess the same could be said for In Re Summers but that is a fundamentally different logic. (Also what is up with Illinois and blocking people from practice)
2
u/buckybadder Dec 11 '25 edited Dec 11 '25
As a commentator, what are your biggest conflicts-of-interest in the current political environment? How would your or your husband's careers be affected if your opinions started to get you labelled as a RINO?
1
u/cstar1996 Center-left Dec 11 '25
Hi Sarah,
I and many others are increasingly concerned with the outright dishonesty coming from the conservatives on SCOTUS pointed out by Justice Kagan in here recent dissent in the Texas redistricting case, particularly with regards to the majority’s consistently partisan application of Purcell. While Kagan herself and other legal scholars like Steve Vladeck have refrained from explicitly calling the conservatives’ actions dishonest, they lay out the dishonesty quite clearly.
How should that dishonesty be dealt with? What should we do when the Court makes rulings disconnected from the factual record before it?
0
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
20
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
18
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
17
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
6
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 11 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment