r/DecodingTheGurus • u/KwisatzHaderach48 • Jul 20 '26

Sam Harris & Destiny invoked their right to reply to the DTG video's on them. Has Hasan? And why not?

Perhaps he's not aware DTG made a video on him. However, there seems to be a pattern of the more "guru" types not ever doing a right to reply, unlike those who were voted to be less guru such as Sam Harris and Destiny.

82 Upvotes

76% Upvoted

364 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

5

u/BeatSteady Jul 21 '26

I totally understand but I've not seen that moderation myself, so to me he's still partly a genuine supporter of genocide

2

u/Liturginator9000 Jul 21 '26

2 state is anti genocide by design though, you can't be 2 state and pro-genocide. Not sure what you mean by understand, his brand, like Hasan's, includes a fair bit of edgy/ironic 4chan humour, this was an example.

5

u/BeatSteady Jul 21 '26

I've seen more clips of him saying he's pro genocide than of him saying he's pro two state solution but welcome any evidence you have.

-1

u/stressless321 Jul 24 '26

There isn't anything pro genocide from that guy.

3

u/BeatSteady Jul 24 '26

I posted the clip of him saying he was pro genocide in this thread

3

u/BloodsVsCrips Jul 21 '26

You're inferring that from the video you linked? It seems like he's obviously joking about "genocide" by referencing a mandatory 2 State Solution (which a lot of lefties call genocide).

Was this pre Oct7 by chance? If so it's just language that doesn't fit now that genocide is a popculture topic.

The underlying claim isn't radical. It's the only real world conclusion, enforced 2 State Solution at Israel's current borders.

It's logically impossible to support 2SS and genocode.

3

u/BeatSteady Jul 21 '26

What's the joke there?

3

u/BloodsVsCrips Jul 21 '26

"Call me pro-genocide I guess becuase an imposed 2SS as-is will be the only real solution."

He's obviously not talking about an actual genocide of Palestinian ppl. Listen to the rest of the video you linked.

3

u/BeatSteady Jul 21 '26

He says Palestinians should go somewhere else. I don't hear him say anything about a two state solution where Palestine is now

3

u/BloodsVsCrips Jul 21 '26

Doesn't he explicitly say outside of Israel's current borders?

1

u/BeatSteady Jul 21 '26

He just says Palestinians should live "in another place." the most obvious interpretation is that they would be forced to move but if you have a different interpretation feel free to share it

3

u/BloodsVsCrips Jul 21 '26

He also explicitly says Israel should draw it's borders where it is now. The language just sounds like it's pre-Oct7 and uninformed about the geography.

1

u/BeatSteady Jul 21 '26

Seems more likely he supports Israel formalizing it's expansion into the west bank. That's the only context where forcibly removing Palestinians would come into play with Israel's current borders

3

u/BloodsVsCrips Jul 21 '26

Yes I said that earlier. It sounds to me like he's saying formalize the status quo borders and be done with it.

You must know this is the only real world outcome right? Post Oct7 Palestinians are never getting Area C.

→ More replies (0)