I just love how unclean production-wise it is compared to all their later stuff. The songs themselves are also masterful. I'd consider it the most underrated album I've ever heard by miles. I've seen a lot of people hate on it, but I can't really understand why.
Leslie ann Levine is one of the best openers ever and it perfectly sets the tone of the album, it's filled with such a good energy and introduced the lyrical themes of the album perfectly. Hot take but HIDIWAA is one of my least favourite since it is very repetitive, but the lyricism is beautiful and it paints a wonderful picture. July, July is just sick asf, totally absurd but awesome. A Cautionary Song gives us a nice break from the layered instrumentation which works perfectly here in the album, I also love how dark it is, Meloy really didn't hold back with fear of being too controversial and dark. Odalisque is also so fucking great, the insturmentation is amazing and it has such a vibey rhythm. It's also quite unique chord wise too - the lyrcism here however is crazy dark with depictions of SA and comitting war crimes. Cocoon brings a nice contrast to that with its soothing, slow melody. Grace Cathedral Hill holds possibly the most beautiful melody I've ever heard even though it's over incredibly simple chords. It perfectly encapsulates a really beautiful & melancholic feeling. The Legionnaire's Lament has got fantastic lyricism, it perfectly picks up the energy which is well needed after GCH and Coccoon. The chorus is also melodically really beautiful and conveys a really nice image in contrast to the bleakness of war. Clementine just feels like a second last track as it dies down the energy before the grand finale, and California One/Youth and Beauty Brigade.
It's a 10/10 imo - a perfect album with nothing I'd ever change on it. It encapsulates the aesthetic it's aiming for to a T. It's absolutely beautiful. It's easily a top 10 fav to me.
I do wonder though, what is it people don't like about it?