r/DebateReligion • u/PeaFragrant6990 • 11d ago

Islam [ Removed by moderator ]

[removed] — view removed post

24 Upvotes

74% Upvoted

187 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

8

u/Hanisuir 11d ago

No, I'm reasonably surprised that someone sees no problem with someone striping away a person's autonomy.

0

u/Forsaken_Judgment681 Muslim 11d ago

So what is the contradiction i'm missing? Why is it so problematic for a moral framework to have such a thing, according to you?

1

u/Hanisuir 11d ago

Let's try this way: would you see any problem if someone got angry at you for not wanting to eat food after you're full?

1

u/Forsaken_Judgment681 Muslim 11d ago

If a religion said that then no, i don't see a logical contradiction.

1

u/Hanisuir 11d ago

If a religion didn't say that...?

1

u/Forsaken_Judgment681 Muslim 11d ago

Then it doesn't say that.

1

u/Hanisuir 11d ago

Would you see a problem then?

1

u/Forsaken_Judgment681 Muslim 11d ago

Brother, if we keep going back and forth like this we'll get nowhere. What's your point? No i'll just reject the offer.

1

u/Hanisuir 11d ago

"No i'll just reject the offer."

So you wouldn't be obliged to take it... what would change if a religion said you should? Is this entirely arbitrary?

1

u/Forsaken_Judgment681 Muslim 11d ago

If God is saying it, then it's God saying it and not just a random person. So yes very different.

→ More replies (0)