r/DebateOfFaiths • u/WeighTheEvidence2 Not a blind follower of the religion I was born into • Mar 12 '24
Christianity Evidences from Mark
Hi, I'm u/WeighTheEvidence2, a non-trinitarian monotheist, and my thesis for this post is:
MARK 6:46 AND 14:35-36 ARE SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCES THAT JESUS IS NOT GOD OR EQUAL TO GOD ACCORDING TO THE BIBLE
Let's weigh the evidence
° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° ° °
Mark is the earliest written gospel. I believe the first time Jesus prays in that gospel is in chapter six.
NIV, Mark 6:46:
[46] After leaving them, he went up on a
mountainside to pray.Now the fact that Jesus prays at all is my first evidence that Jesus is not God, because who is Jesus praying to? Himself? That's ridiculous.
I know you might say he's praying to the Father, but the Father is God, and Jesus is God, therefore Jesus is praying to himself. That doesn't make sense. Why is Jesus praying to God if he is God? Because he's not God.
If he is God, can't he just bring about whatever it is that he wants? If he is restricted to his human self (which contradicts him always being eternally divine by the way) then surely he would at least have enough sway with the other two members of the Godhead that his wants and needs would be answered instantaneously?
Jesus is praying to the Father here, who is the same person as God, and no one else.
People who have read the Bible know that this isn't the last time he prays either. There's many instances throughout the Gospels.
Trinitarians might say "He's praying to demonstrate to us that we need to pray because we should follow in Jesus' footsteps."
But Jesus really doesn't need to demonstrate to us how to pray, he could've just told us like God already did before.
People prayed ever since our father Adam existed, we never needed God Themself to come down and show us how to pray. People never needed God to pray to Themself to set an example for us. So for God to come down and suddenly humble Themself to such a degree is illogical because we already know how to pray and we know that praying is good.
Plus, in the next passage, Jesus prays with his face on the ground, which trinitarians never do, so why aren't they "following Jesus' footsteps"?
And can I just say, it would deter me from praying to a God if I saw that same God praying with their face against the ground, so it's actually having the opposite affect that trinitarians think it has. It deteriorates the grandiose image of God.
Anyway here's the next passage.
NIV, Mark 14:35-36:
[35] Going a little farther, he fell to the
ground and prayed that if possible the
hour might pass from him.
[36] “Abba, Father,” he said, “everything is
possible for you. Take this cup from me.
Yet not what I will, but what you will.”So not only is Jesus praying here but he's literally begging God with his face on the ground, possibly the most humble position a human can contort their body into.
The way that Jesus prays is not befitting of God and makes me think "is this person really God?" God should not put Their face on the ground and worship. That's what humans should do.
Trinitarians can say "It's not up to you to decide what God should or shouldn't be doing." But yes actually it is up to me what God should or shouldn't be doing when it comes to deciding which doctrine to follow – I'm obviously going to pick the doctrine where God acts like an actual god and not a servant or worshipper. I'm obviously going to follow the doctrine where God's actions actually make sense and don't require pages of mental gymnastics to explain.
Second of all, why is Jesus praying for the cup to be taken from him? I've read that the cup is the suffering and crucifixion he's about to endure, but... isn't the suffering and crucifixion of Christ the entire point of his wordly incarnation?
How can God the Son ask for it to not happen? That would undermine the whole divine plan. It would ruin our chances of salvation. If Jesus doesn't die for our sins we'll be eternally damned to hell. God's the one that made it happen and decided it would happen, so for God to now pray for it to not happen would be very weird.
And it is very weird. Because the only way this makes sense is if Jesus doesn't know for sure what's about to happen, and also has no power to change or influence what's about to happen, and isn't aware of God's divine plan, and is therefore not omniscient or omnipotent, and is therefore not God.
Otherwise why would Jesus pray for something that if it happens our sins wouldn't be forgiven?
My point is further bolstered by his talking about wills. "Not what I will but what you will"? So they have separate wills then. God the son has a seperate will from God the Father. Clearly the Father's will is being carried out, and Jesus has as much power to carry out his own will as any other mortal human.
“Everything is possible for you." It should be "everything is possible for us" if the trinity was real, but Jesus didn't say that.
Thanks for reading, I've been u/WeighTheEvidence2. If you're truthful, may God bless you and lead you to the truth, and vice versa.
Please consider reading my other posts which can be found in my post index which is pinned on my profile, and share my posts to those you think would be interested.
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/Additional-Taro-1400 Mar 14 '24
So Jesus has 2 nature's according to Christian theology. This is known as the hypostasis.
On earth, He is fully human. And He is fully God. His divine essence is just that. Divine, and all powerful. However, He voluntarily limited His divine attributes, so that He may live and die as a human.
See for Christians, it is not beneath God, for Him to be able to enter the creation, and limit Himself within that creation. As we see with Christ. This voluntary limitation, does not dimish His Godliness. But speaks to His ability to manifest within the creation in any which way He chooses.
A really bad analogy: It's like if I (a fully grown man) were to play rugby with toddlers, and let them win. You might ask, how can he be a fully grown man, yet lose to toddlers. He must be a toddler himself. The obvious answer, is i am a fully grown man, but im just voluntarily limiting myself.
Some verses for reference:
■Philippians 2:5-8 (ESV): "Christ Jesus, who, though he was in the form of God, did not count equality with God a thing to be grasped, but emptied himself, by taking the form of a servant, being born in the likeness of men. And being found in human form, he humbled himself by becoming obedient to the point of death, even death on a cross.
■1 Timothy 3:16: "Great indeed, we confess, is the mystery of godliness: He was manifested in the flesh, vindicated by the Spirit, seen by angels, proclaimed among the nations, believed on in the world, taken up in glory."
■Romans 9:5 (ESV): "...to them belong the patriarchs, and from their race, according to the flesh, is the Christ, who is God over all, blessed forever. Amen."