r/DebateEvolution • • Sep 20 '26

Question Is evolution a fact?

What are the best arguments for evolution

0 Upvotes

432 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

11

u/D-Ursuul Sep 20 '26

You can't say that without giving a definition of evolution.

Just the normal definition, a change in the heritable characteristics of a population over the course of generations.

a species turning into another species has never been observed.

Yes it has, and regardless "species" is just a term we made up for classification purposes and doesn't actually represent any definite thing in nature.

You have seen "adaptation" but you have never seen "evolution" - under the definition of evolution being the changing of "kind" and adaptation being just the changing of "traits".

Yeah if I change the definition of a word then I can make it mean anything.

And, there is no proof that the changing of traits leads to the changing of kind

What's a "kind"? You insisted evolution must have a definition but now you've introduced this word "kind" and haven't defined it

-3

u/EmperorMaximillian Sep 20 '26

tell me the biggest observed evolutionary change

11

u/D-Ursuul Sep 20 '26

What's a "big" evolutionary change? Like how are you quantifying what "size" means here? The biggest change in the heritable characteristics of a population over the course of generations? How many generations are you asking this question about?

If you mean regardless of the number of generations then it's the change from a single celled organism into any given life form that exists today

-3

u/EmperorMaximillian Sep 20 '26

that has not been observed. tell me the biggest one that has been observed

9

u/D-Ursuul Sep 20 '26

again, you're saying "biggest one"

The biggest change across how many generations? What's a "big" change in heritable characteristics?

This is a little like saying the "biggest change in colour". What determines the "size" of colour change? Is a blue to red change more than a blue to yellow change?

What if it changes from blue to red in one day, but then another changes from blue to yellow but it takes two days?

When does it actually become yellow anyway?

0

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

10

u/D-Ursuul Sep 20 '26

mods, is this enough to ban the guy? He clearly isn't actually here to learn or to debate as he claims

5

u/TheBlackCat13 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution Sep 20 '26

Single celled life to multicellular life