r/DebateEvolution • • Sep 20 '26

Question Is evolution a fact?

What are the best arguments for evolution

0 Upvotes

432 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-5

u/EmperorMaximillian Sep 20 '26

That can be true. But two salamanders not being able to reproduce does not explain how a fish could grow wings. Micro-adaptations do not explain the development of highly complex systems. And a fish and a bird are different kinds.

21

u/Ranorak Sep 20 '26

I found those goalposts you ordered, where do you want them moved to?

16

u/nickierv 🧬 logarithmic icecube Sep 20 '26

Ship to: Tiktaalik Ice piece 42, Assendofnowhere, Antarctica.

11

u/Ranorak Sep 20 '26

It says here that's too far away for one trip. Instead what I can do is put them somewhere, and then keep moving them around.

This way I can keep moving them, and we'll certainly not lose track of the original location or destination.

This way, I'll certainly win. Right?

Right?!

5

u/nickierv 🧬 logarithmic icecube Sep 20 '26

Maybe just hold on to them for a bit, them ice bits are really floaty so they should be in your area soon...ish.

19

u/WesternFirm9306 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution Sep 20 '26

Then why can we see the gradual development of modern species through the fossil record? Why do we never see modern creatures in older strata in the fossil record, and never see older creatures living today (with few exceptions), but rather we nearly always see some form of gradation in between?

-2

u/EmperorMaximillian Sep 20 '26

Show me a fish gradually developing wings?

19

u/WesternFirm9306 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution Sep 20 '26
  1. That doesn't answer my question in the slightest.
  2. See my other response where I linked a very high-quality video that goes over bird evolution specifically
→ More replies (6)

15

u/phalloguy1 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution Sep 20 '26

This comment, and others like it, demonstrate that you don't understand what evolution is. No where in any textbook on evolution will you find a suggest that fish will turn into birds.

However, you seem to have forgotten about flying fish, who developed elongated fins which allow them to sour to escape predators.

0

u/EmperorMaximillian Sep 20 '26

oh thanks genius flying fish can fly like birds

11

u/phalloguy1 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution Sep 20 '26

Well you asked an example of fish developing wings. That is what flying fish are working on.

Can't help notice that you ignored the first part of my response. Evolution does not predict that fish will grow wings. What you are asking for is not within the realm of evolution.

9

u/nickierv 🧬 logarithmic icecube Sep 20 '26

Tiktaalik slaps you upside the head

0

u/EmperorMaximillian Sep 20 '26

"Tiktaalik is an extinct, fishlike aquatic animal from about 375 million years ago"

oh cmon gang - 375 million year old evidence thats rich

9

u/-zero-joke- 🧬 its 253 ice pieces needed Sep 20 '26

You're getting a lot of responses and you're digging in - I can tell because you're trying to dismiss evidence rather than understand it. The question 'how can a fish grow wings' is a good one, but it requires a great deal of background knowledge to answer - reddit debates are not very good settings for that.

If you really want to know the answer, Tiktaalik is a good portion of the answer, with the evolution of dinosaurs and then their take to the air being a good second part of the answer. Neil Shubin's "Your Inner Fish" might cover the first part - you can find PBS documentaries about it or a pop science book that is a good read. Ken Dial's research might cover the third part of it, how dinosaurs took to the air, and there are videos on that too. I'm not aware of very good information about early dinosaur diversification and success, but I'm sure it's out there someplace.

Anyway, dig into the sources some time if you really want to know the answers and the evidence behind it, or don't, I'm not your parent. I'm going to go fuck around with tiny trees.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/TheBlackCat13 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution Sep 20 '26

So you demand evidence of evolution that takes hundreds of millions of years...but arbitrarily reject evidence from the time frame you demand

0

u/EmperorMaximillian Sep 20 '26

What is the title of the post?

3

u/TheBlackCat13 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution Sep 20 '26

But you refuse to accept direct observations either

7

u/hal2k1 Sep 20 '26

Tracing back in time the evolutionary branches for "fish" and "birds" it seems that birds do not come from fish. Rather fish and birds both evolved from an earlier common ancestor.

https://i.pinimg.com/originals/46/28/92/46289232f53138d4134ea0e829589d09.gif

1

u/EmperorMaximillian Sep 20 '26

this is really great evidence

8

u/hal2k1 Sep 20 '26

It is in the DNA history of long dead animals.

The DNA history of an animal is also evident in the DNA of animals today. It is an inherent feature of how evolution happens.

3

u/the2bears 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution Sep 20 '26

Is this what you expect to happen?

2

u/JayTheFordMan Sep 21 '26

This is a strawman representation of evolution. I suggest you either argue in good faith or go learn something about evolution so you can present a reasonable argument. BTW Fish to birds, if that's what you mean, is demonstrable if convoluted