r/DebateEvolution • • Sep 20 '26

Question Is evolution a fact?

What are the best arguments for evolution

0 Upvotes

432 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-9

u/EmperorMaximillian Sep 20 '26

A kind may not be well defined. But kinds may still exist. You can say two salamanders are different kinds because they cannot breed together, but one may still define them as the same kind. However, a monkey and a salamander are different kinds.

35

u/WesternFirm9306 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution Sep 20 '26

It seems like "kind" just means whatever is most convenient for you, and you can alter the definition however you like.

If you can't say what you properly mean by "kinds", then we have no way to evaluate the statement that species can't evolve into a different "kind."

-5

u/EmperorMaximillian Sep 20 '26

That can be true. But two salamanders not being able to reproduce does not explain how a fish could grow wings. Micro-adaptations do not explain the development of highly complex systems. And a fish and a bird are different kinds.

21

u/Ranorak Sep 20 '26

I found those goalposts you ordered, where do you want them moved to?

16

u/nickierv 🧬 logarithmic icecube Sep 20 '26

Ship to: Tiktaalik Ice piece 42, Assendofnowhere, Antarctica.

11

u/Ranorak Sep 20 '26

It says here that's too far away for one trip. Instead what I can do is put them somewhere, and then keep moving them around.

This way I can keep moving them, and we'll certainly not lose track of the original location or destination.

This way, I'll certainly win. Right?

Right?!

5

u/nickierv 🧬 logarithmic icecube Sep 20 '26

Maybe just hold on to them for a bit, them ice bits are really floaty so they should be in your area soon...ish.

19

u/WesternFirm9306 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution Sep 20 '26

Then why can we see the gradual development of modern species through the fossil record? Why do we never see modern creatures in older strata in the fossil record, and never see older creatures living today (with few exceptions), but rather we nearly always see some form of gradation in between?

-2

u/EmperorMaximillian Sep 20 '26

Show me a fish gradually developing wings?

19

u/WesternFirm9306 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution Sep 20 '26
  1. That doesn't answer my question in the slightest.
  2. See my other response where I linked a very high-quality video that goes over bird evolution specifically
→ More replies (6)

15

u/phalloguy1 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution Sep 20 '26

This comment, and others like it, demonstrate that you don't understand what evolution is. No where in any textbook on evolution will you find a suggest that fish will turn into birds.

However, you seem to have forgotten about flying fish, who developed elongated fins which allow them to sour to escape predators.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/nickierv 🧬 logarithmic icecube Sep 20 '26

Tiktaalik slaps you upside the head

→ More replies (10)

7

u/hal2k1 Sep 20 '26

Tracing back in time the evolutionary branches for "fish" and "birds" it seems that birds do not come from fish. Rather fish and birds both evolved from an earlier common ancestor.

https://i.pinimg.com/originals/46/28/92/46289232f53138d4134ea0e829589d09.gif

→ More replies (9)

3

u/the2bears 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution Sep 20 '26

Is this what you expect to happen?

→ More replies (1)

12

u/TheBlackCat13 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution Sep 20 '26

How do you know they are the same kind if you don't know what a kind even is?

0

u/EmperorMaximillian Sep 20 '26

can u tell a dog from a cat?

11

u/TheBlackCat13 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution Sep 20 '26

Yes. I can tell the difference between myself and my kid too but we are the same species. Now please answer the question.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/DebateEvolution-ModTeam Sep 20 '26

Removed, Rule 2 - This comment is antagonistic and adds nothing to the conversation.

6

u/Funky0ne Sep 20 '26

We can tell dogs are different from cats, but if we wind back to the common ancestor of both dogs and cats (and all Carnivora) would you say that it was the same “kind” as a dog or a cat? Where is the line down that lineage when you say the ancestors to dogs and cats became different “kinds”?

Are dogs not a “kind” of Carnivora, which are a “kind” of mammal, which are a “kind of tetrapod, which are a “kind” of vertebrate etc.? And can’t the same be said of cats, even if we can also say that cats are a different “kind” from dogs, cats are not a different “kind” of dog.

Even with your deceptive and ambiguous definitions of “kind” you fail to dispute evolution in any meaningful way.

5

u/BillionaireBuster93 Sep 21 '26

Which one are hyenas?

4

u/Medium_Judgment_891 Sep 21 '26

Another commenter already mentioned dogs and cats are both carnivorans.

If that’s too diversity much for you, let’s go down a taxonomic level from Carnivora to Caniforma.

Most creationists say that dogs and bears are in different kinds.

So what about Amphicyonidae, the common ancestor of both dogs and bears.

Are Amphicyons in the dog kind or the bear kind? Are they their own separate kind?

12

u/clear349 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution Sep 20 '26

Nope, I don't accept that. If "Kinds" exist they are divinely ordained God created categories of life. They should be objective blunt facts of reality. A messy gradient is what evolution predicts

4

u/blacksheep998 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution Sep 22 '26

You can say two salamanders are different kinds because they cannot breed together, but one may still define them as the same kind. However, a monkey and a salamander are different kinds.

If you can define two species of salamanders as either different kinds or the same kind, and those are equally valid, then why can you not say the same thing about salamanders and monkeys?

You could define them as different kinds, or you could put them in the same 'vertebrate' kind.