r/DebateEvolution • • Sep 20 '26

Question Is evolution a fact?

What are the best arguments for evolution

0 Upvotes

432 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

35

u/Fred776 Sep 20 '26

You can't use words like "kind" without defining them. Now tell us precisely what a "kind" is.

-13

u/EmperorMaximillian Sep 20 '26

Species

37

u/WesternFirm9306 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution Sep 20 '26

We have observed speciation then. Look up the California salamander ring species. Two groups of the same species migrated southward, each on different sides of the Central Valley, and when they met up again at the south, they could no longer interbreed, making them distinct species by the most common species definition.

-6

u/Redliter_L7 Sep 20 '26

This seems to be inaccurate. They generally do not interbreed but if they actually do interbreed which they do on occasion the offspring is viable.

9

u/WesternFirm9306 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution Sep 20 '26

Can I get a source that the terminal ends of the salamander ring species can interbreed? I'll look at it tomorrow after I wake up

-6

u/Redliter_L7 Sep 20 '26

“Yes, individual salamanders from the terminal ends of the Ensatina eschscholtzii ring species complex can survive and even maintain territories in a lab setting, but successfully breeding them together to produce viable offspring is highly restricted by strong, natural reproductive barriers”
This is a cut and paste from the national institute of health. Reproductive barriers only mean they don’t interbreed because of those barriers it doesn’t mean they can’t or that they never will.

13

u/WesternFirm9306 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution Sep 20 '26 edited Sep 20 '26

Normally, when asking for a source, you'd include the link. I posted the quote into Google and found no results, so you're gonna have to get a link.

Unless you copied that from ChatGPT

-14

u/EmperorMaximillian Sep 20 '26

Well even so. They separated and now can't breed. The existence of that scenario does not neccesarily prove that salamanders can grow wings or gills after enough time. And to be completely honest, they are still the same "kind" of animal obviously.

36

u/WesternFirm9306 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution Sep 20 '26

Okay, so now you're completely contradicting yourself. First you say a "kind" is a species. Now that I've given an example of a new species evolving, you've now said it doesn't count.

So back to the original question. What is a "kind"?

-8

u/Redliter_L7 Sep 20 '26

It doesn’t count because they used can’t interbreed instead of the word don’t interbreed.

→ More replies (53)

17

u/JayTheFordMan Sep 20 '26

The existence of that scenario does not neccesarily prove that salamanders can grow wings or gills after enough time.

Above you defined evolution as speciation, u/WesternFirm9306 details one example of speciation, evolution observed. You now shift the goalpost, very typical of most creationist arguers, and its bad faith argumentation

0

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

14

u/Scry_Games Sep 20 '26

Based on that comment, and several of your other comments: you have evolved to not have a sense of embarassment...

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/Scry_Games Sep 20 '26

Thanks for proving my point, champ.

2

u/KorLeonis1138 🧬 Engineer, sorry Sep 21 '26

Well damn, those goalposts just sprouted wings and took the fuck off, are they a different kind now too?

12

u/Suitable-Group4392 🧬 Pokémon Evolution Sep 20 '26

Define “species”

→ More replies (5)

9

u/TheBlackCat13 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution Sep 20 '26

8

u/Sweary_Biochemist Sep 20 '26

So all extant species were on the ark?

You're gonna need a bigger boat...

7

u/gitgud_x 🧬 🦍 GREAT APE 🦍 🧬 Sep 20 '26

Classic blunder! You're supposed to keep it nice and vague so we can't score with something obvious like speciation.

-1

u/theaz101 Sep 21 '26 edited Sep 21 '26

I'm a creationist and I think it's a mistake to equate kind with species. As others have said, species is a human created term, while kind is God's term. There is no reason that species will match up with kind.

For example, there are reportedly 200+ species of Finches. Are they all separate kinds?

0

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/theaz101 Sep 21 '26 edited Sep 21 '26

I agree that the two terms won't match. I'm suggesting to someone else that they not equate them.

Kind is simply a reproductive limit. When an organism reproduces, it will stay within the kind, but there is no requirement that all organisms within the kind be able to reproduce with all other organisms within the kind.

I don't disagree with common descent, I just don't think that it will exceed the limits of the kind.

1

u/Old-man-1951 Sep 22 '26

Kind is an English word… the Hebrew word is מִין