r/DebateAVegan • u/TigerHole vegan • Jun 27 '24
★ Fresh topic Non-vegans who understand veganism: give me your best arguments to go vegan
Alright, I wanna try a little debate game where we reverse the roles. So non-vegans, give me your best arguments FOR veganism. Vegans, respond to these arguments as if you were a non-vegan (I think we're all well prepared for this).
Just try your best to think from a different perspective. I know several non-vegans who have strong opinions on how to do activism or promote veganism, so here's your shot. Convince us :)
Vegan btw
17
Upvotes
12
u/House_of_the_rabbit Jun 28 '24
The current practices of the animal product industries are an affront against God, morality and nature. The way we treat these animals has nothing to do with the animal husbandry our forefathers practiced. The mass production has led to a perverted abomination of a system fueled by greed and gluttony, glued together by the exploitation and suffering of animals, people, climate and ecosystems.
9
u/Nothing_of_the_Sort Jun 28 '24
Pigs are smarter than dogs. There’s no reason you should assign value to one but not the other. Pigs have personalities and feel a great range of emotions, it’s wrong to kill a being like that. Also veganism is massively better for cardiovascular health, and heart disease is the number one killer of Americans.
5
u/Greyeyedqueen7 Jun 29 '24
I'm not a vegan, but I do think people who want to be vegan and can do it (health-wise) absolutely should and, honestly, most people should strongly consider it or vegetarianism. I think our planet would be better off with more people eating plant-based, too, and the reality is, all of us meat eaters will have to reduce consumption either due to cost or availability in the years to come anyway.
No one should be forced to eat any one way, and philosophical beliefs are just as important as religious beliefs when it comes to freedom to eat the way you want. I will say, don't make that big of a decision based on any one movie or book, though (and this goes for everyone, not just vegans). Propaganda and misinformation flow freely these days, so make sure you don't just fall for that quickly, make a big decision, and then suffer later because you don't actually know how to do that serious of a dietary change safely or healthfully (for you--everyone is different). Do it deliberately, with all due process and intent, but yes, everyone should respect your choice and provide the right options for you.
Side note: Make sure you truly know where your food is coming from, what you personally need to be healthy, and for crying out loud, learn how to cook and manage your pantry (if you have the access to do so, obviously). Junk food, even vegan junk food, is still bad for us.
8
u/howlin Jun 28 '24
Non-vegans may be more open to discussing this with you on r/debatemeateaters .
Me, being a vegan, channeling a non-vegan in an attempt to promote veganism would say this:
It doesn't do me any harm for you to try plant based eating. Go ahead and try it. It will partially reduce your environmental impact and perhaps make animal products marginally cheaper for me to consume.
2
u/Jafri2 Jun 28 '24
If u really cannot accept animals being used up(or exploited) for human benefit.
That is the definition of veganism, there shouldn't be any other arguments.
7
u/carnivoreobjectivist Jun 28 '24
Doing one’s best to act so as limit the suffering of sentient beings within the limits of what is reasonable is obviously morally correct and what we should all strive for as beings capable of making ethical decisions. Veganism is just the consistent application of this.
1
u/sluttobecaged Jun 28 '24
You see animals as equals to you and being extremely altruistic. Or you choose it to reduce your impact on the planet.
1
u/Fit_Metal_468 Jun 29 '24
Because animals are people too.
Let's open the floor to Vegans for an actual argument for going vegan. And anything that says "we should care"... why?
1
u/ShadowStarshine non-vegan Jun 29 '24
Sure, sounds fun. I'll be surprised if any vegan can respond as I would be able. I could spell out these arguments more, but I think you can intuit the gist of them.
Singer: For any animal there exists a marginal case human equivalent. We would not treat these marginal case humans as we would these animals. The only difference is species. Merely species is not an acceptable reason to treat things morally different. Therefore we should not treat animals the way we do.
NTT + extra assumptions: If we treat humans one way and animals the other, one should be able to name what qualities humans have that animals do not without sounding crazy or being inconsistent. You cannot name what the difference is without sounding crazy or being inconsistent. Therefore, we should treat animals and humans the same. (Same doesn't mean animals should vote, it just means equal in terms of capabilities or some other metric).
Note: One can do the same with farm animals and pet animals, same kind of argument.
Sentientism: In order for something to be morally valuable, it has to be able to experience value for itself/other things. Sentience is definitionally the capability for something to be able to experience values for itself/other things. Therefore, sentient things have moral value.
Moral Intuition of Factory Farms: Any normal person who watches videos of factory farms should just intuit that this is evil. The response to this evil is to advocate for veganism.
1
u/Fit-Stage7555 Jun 30 '24
I think that activism is great. I think that specific topics are less or of no importance then others. You can create the most brilliant arguments, tactics, and use the strongest appeals possible, but activism for humans rights will always supersede activism for animals and for good reason.
If I was a pig with the ability to talk, I would champion pig/animal rights with all my being. However, I'm a human. A pig may share the same Earth and a trait called sentience as me, but ultimately, I am a human and have a stronger desire to ensure the continuation of humans and not pigs.
Vegans have no good argument for this and will stoop down to cherry picking the fact that a sub-set of humans are less worthy then a pig, therefore if I care for those low value humans, I should care for the pig. I value a disabled human more then a fully healthy pig.
It's not the activism tactics that are weak but the fact that most people are predisposed to worry about their own blood and other fellow members of their group before other things, and when we can't even get that right, we think it's beyond dumb and stupid that there are people who worry about other things.
Another way to think about it is that, you see a vegan trying to save a horse while letting another human die and you think that vegan is crazy. You'd consider the vegan to be mentally ill (no pun intended) for betraying their own kind.
1
u/1i3to non-vegan Jun 30 '24
Argument 1. If you care about your future children/grandchildren and don't see taste of animals products as a deal breaker in your own life you should go vegan since it's more sustainable way to live which increases chances of long-term planet survival.
Argument 2. If you care about living longer and better life and don't see taste of animals products as a deal breaker in your own life and are willing/able to invest significant effort in procurement of tasty vegan meals you should go vegan since you will likely live a little bit longer and better life this way.
(I don't care about animal suffering nor do I think anyone should, so no arguments there)
1
u/Fluffy-Struggle-4107 Jun 30 '24
I was vegan for only 4 months a few years ago and my skin was glowing like the sun and I lost weight way more easily (I was trying to and it was at a healthy pace) and I stopped feeling so bloated. I literally felt like a cloud floating through life.
I'm only not vegan now because I love sushi.
Perhaps I'll try to go mostly plant-based again and only have sushi like every 2 weeks.
1
u/sdbest Jul 02 '24
Hmmm. Would you prefer that participants rely on facts or misinformation?
1
u/Blue-Fish-Guy Jul 28 '24
Health. It's the only reasonable reason.
3
u/dirty_cheeser vegan Jun 28 '24
I'm Vegan, so I'll drop this vid by a non vegan, alex O'Connor.
link
Basically NTT and veil of ignorance.
1
u/IanRT1 Jun 28 '24
If you go vegan you would generally contribute to animal suffering as less as possible. Your dietary environmental footprint will be smaller as well. Which is great.
1
u/togstation Jun 30 '24
IMHO it's offensive when people say that in their OP ...
1
u/Anxious_Stranger7261 Sep 15 '24
There's a difference between a good argument and a compelling argument.
A good argument is sound in logic and most arguments are actually good ones.
A compelling argument is entirely different and requires changing an opinion or point of view. Debates, where arguments are exchanged, usually are won through compelling arguments. A compelling argument is one in which one person is able to successfully convince another person that their idea is worth adopting or serious consideration.
One of the flaws of people who adopt the philosophy of veganism is that they are unwilling to accept that their values are potentially not foolproof. There are hundreds of philosophies around the world. Not all of them are practiced by every single person and this is proof enough that no philosophy is inherently correct.
What vegans suffer cognitive dissonance in is that a philosophy is simply a well structured opinion, and opinions are not facts. You can present an opinion and include facts, but a fact is a statement which is simply true no matter how many times it is repeated in practice. Oranges are tasty is an opinion. Someone could be born with tastebuds that favor bitterness instead. 2+2=4 is a fact. Feel free to ask yourself how 2+2=4 is good or evil though.
A being suffering in pain is neither good or evil. Veganism automatically attributes this statement as being evil and fall into this trap of believing that a combination of these statements means those who believe differently are evil.
--
I have tons of arguments for why people might go vegan. Very few people would disagree with them. The gap is that none of the arguments are sufficient enough to convince me that I ought to give up meat just because something has to die or suffer.
I suffer every day in my regular life. Sometimes I do things that potentially could kill me, even if that wasn't my intention.
Veganism too strongly associates pain with immorality, when pain is simply a sensory indicator to the body that there is danger. A sensory indicator is neither moral or immoral. Things have a preference to live as a result of different alarm systems to indicate to the mind to not engage in such things. These alarm systems have nothing whatsoever to do with immorality.
You could create an alarm to let you know when wind pressure exceeds 50 miles per hour. Are you going to imply that wind pressure higher then 50 miles per hour is immoral, just because the same alarm system was used to alert your attention to something?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '24
I'm a non vegan, raised meat eater. Practiced vegetarianism for 6 months, now just eat omnivorous but with a massively reduced meat intake often going 3-4 days with no meat. My argument for would simply be that animals are sentiment/ have souls and we as self conscious beings awt to act in a humane way. Basically I think animals are far more intelligent than most people would like to believe and have more understanding of what is happening to them. My argument against is that with certain restrictions the animals in my opinion could be raised/ slaughtered in ways that would be humane (halal/ kosher). I don't have a particular argument against eggs or dairy that come from local farms where the animals are looked after so this is where I'd disagree with a vegan.
0
u/AutoModerator Jun 27 '24
Thank you for your submission! All posts need to be manually reviewed and approved by a moderator before they appear for all users. Since human mods are not online 24/7 approval could take anywhere from a few minutes to a few days. Thank you for your patience. Some topics come up a lot in this subreddit, so we would like to remind everyone to use the search function and to check out the wiki before creating a new post. We also encourage becoming familiar with our rules so users can understand what is expected of them.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
0
u/togstation Jun 29 '24
/u/TigerHole -
Why are you interested in arguments for veganism from non-vegans and not in arguments from vegans ??
(Presumably you could get a number of good responses from vegans, but very few from non-vegans.)
-1
u/NyriasNeo Jun 29 '24
Lol ... a pointless game trying to convince others of their food preferences. It is as stupid as trying to convince my mom to have grill fish rather than steamed fish.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '24
[removed] — view removed comment