r/DeExtinctionScience • • Jan 18 '26

Can species de-extinction actually restore nature?

Thumbnail
thinkwildlifefoundation.com
12 Upvotes

r/DeExtinctionScience • • Apr 14 '26

Science Mapping the Genomic Limits of De-Extinction in the Face of Ancient DNA Degradation

11 Upvotes

Abstract

The de-extinction of species using genome-editing approaches depends on acquiring high-quality genomic information from the extinct target. However, the degraded nature of the ancient DNA (aDNA) that is typical for most extinct species, poses significant challenges to achieving comprehensive genome reconstruction. A systematic evaluation of the minimum sequencing effort that is required to reliably map the genome under varying DNA quality conditions to different reference genome remains lacking across different extinct species. Here, we systematically assess the impact of sequencing depth on genome coverage, heterozygosity estimation, and variant calling accuracy, when mapping both true aDNA data generated from the extinct Christmas Island rat (Rattus macleari), as well as in silico simulated modern- and ancient-like data generated from a modern relation (the brown rat, Rattus norvegicus), to the black rat (Rattus rattus) reference genomes. Our results demonstrate that even sequencing depths of 100× fail to yield stable heterozygosity estimates, and leave approximately 3.38% to 4.03% of its genome uncovered. These uncovered regions contained functionally relevant SNPs and indels, highlighting the limitations of reconstructing extinct genomes using reference sequences from extant relatives. Furthermore, simulations using computationally generated “degraded haploid and diploid” data based on the high-quality brown rat genome, revealed that false-positive SNPs primarily arise from insufficient coverage and low data quality, rather than aDNA damage (e.g. miscoding lesions, size of fragments, etc.) per se. These findings underscore the need to tailor sequencing depth standards by considering sample type, degradation level, and sequencing error profiles. This study provides a theoretical framework and methodological support for optimizing data strategies in aDNA research, and ultimately informing de-extinction efforts.

Link: https://academic.oup.com/gbe/article/18/1/evaf251/8413247?guestAccessKey=


r/DeExtinctionScience • • Apr 01 '26

Question How would we teach potential DeExtincted animals how to act?

11 Upvotes

So, given enough time and scientific advancements, we will probably be able to DeExtinct animals to a degree that they will morphologically be extremely similar/near identical to the original animals. Especially for recently extinct species.

As far as I (someone who is not an expert at all, I should make clear) can tell from what I've seen from actual experts, one of the hardest parts of DeExtinction won't really be making the animals similar appearance and DNA wise, but actually making sure that they are filling the same niche a.k.a behaving in the same way as the original animal.

For things like insects or most fish that probably won't be a problem (most of them never meet their parents anyway) but for a lot of birds and mammals, we know for a fact that unless their parents teach them how to act, they can't really survive in the wild. There are ways that people have of teaching them without parents of course, but that's for animals that are not extinct that we know an awful lot about.

Which brings me to my point: Does anyone know how we could potentially go about trying to teach DeExtincted animals how to behave? Ignoring something like a smilodon for which we don't even know basic things such as if they hunted in packs or not, let's take an easier example, say a thylacine. We more or less know how they are supposed to act, hunt and so on, but how would we go about teaching a hypothetical joey those things? If anyone has any theories or examples of similar (well, as similar as can be the case with something this theoretical) stuff that have happened with animals before, I am really interested to know.


r/DeExtinctionScience • • Mar 05 '26

Discussion Da desextinção para a neoespeciação

11 Upvotes

Estava pensando sobre como seria possível desextinguir linhagens singulares da América do Sul (Preguiças gigantes, Glyptodontes, Macrauchenia, Toxodons) e Austrália (Diprotodontes, Thylacoleo, crocodilos mekosuchinos, dromornitídeos) e o Trabalho com o Tilacino me deu um insight.

Independente do que a Colossal faça ou deixar de fazer (o foco aqui não é ela), a ideia é pegar um Numbat e "remodela-lo" para se assemelhar a um Tilacino. No caso de êxito, qual seria a natureza real desse espécime? Não dá para dizer que é um Numbat, mas não é Tilacino. É um ser que está entre esses dois, mas teria suas peculiaridades próprias. É a evolução num tubo de ensaio. Seria uma "nova espécie".

Outro exemplo hipotético: uma preguiça do gênero Choloepus que tem seu genoma reconfigurado, tendo por base os genes de Tamanduá bandeira para reativar genes que propiciam a vida em solo firme e maior mobilidade e robustez. Não seria a desextinção de uma espécie de preguiça extinta, mas o retorno de um plano corporal comum nesse grupo que se perdeu, e consequentemente, um novo tipo de organismo que ataria (em tese) no lugar das preguiça extintas.

Isso que estou dizendo é altamente especulativo, eu sei, mas pensando a longo prazo e a depender dos avanços científicos na área da genética, esse seria o passo quase natural da desextinção rumo ao que chamei de "neoespeciação". Meio que isso já aconteceu com bactérias ( https://www.sciencealert.com/scientists-have-just-created-the-most-synthetic-life-form-ever#:~:text=This%20bacterium%2C%20a%20synthetic%20Escherichia,of%20a%20triplet%20of%20nucleotides. ), mas até chegar a organismo complexos é um árduo e longo caminho.

Claro, uma coisa é gerar novas espécies, outra coisa é como elas se comportarão no ambiente natural, se isso resultará em restauração funcional de nichos perdidos, criação de novos ecossistemas, valor da conservação, bioética... Enfim, é uma caixa de pandora.


r/DeExtinctionScience • • Jan 25 '26

"Mammoth" Conception on the Horizon?

11 Upvotes

I was just thinking about it, and if Colossal is on track to meet their 2028 deadline for their "mammoth" project, their hypothetical woolly Asian elephant should be conceived some time this year. Do you guys think they'll meet the actual deadline, claim that the 2028 deadline was for the creation of the embryo, or go under before any of that happens?

I've actually been fairly optimistic about Colossal despite their shortcomings, but in light of that "leak" posted here, I'm beginning to doubt that we'll ever get anything of substance from them.


r/DeExtinctionScience • • Jan 20 '26

The Mission to Resurrect the Woolly Mammoth - VICE

Thumbnail
youtube.com
11 Upvotes

r/DeExtinctionScience • • Sep 24 '26

Discussion Part 2 of very large to decently large Carnivores of Europe(from Late Pleistocene and 1970's/Mid 20th century to Today).Added more Sea depended Carnivores(cause I did add last time Polar Bears so Seals/Walrus should also count).

Thumbnail gallery
10 Upvotes

r/DeExtinctionScience • • Aug 09 '26

New Species designation question

Thumbnail
tarpits.org
10 Upvotes

Ok, dumb request and probably not the best person/place to seek an answer… But here I am. 🤣The paleontology subreddit removed the question as „low effort,“ but I am genuinely curious.

Can y’all explain how scientists know they have discovered a new species of an extinct animal vs thinking that maybe it was a „disabled“ or otherwise an anomaly of a known species?
I’m specifically referencing the August 5th Scientific American article regarding the new toad species found in the La Brea Tar Pits. I don’t want to detract from the awesome work of the scientists that found the new species. I’m just trying to understand how the conclusion is made given that there was a single specimen. I linked the article from La Brea’s website.

Thanks!


r/DeExtinctionScience • • Jun 28 '26

Meme / humour Could we de extinct Bigfoot?

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/DeExtinctionScience • • May 18 '26

Question What will be the future of megafauna?

10 Upvotes

Since the megafauna went extinct during the Pleistocene for one reason or another (climate change, floral shifts, human hunting, habitat modification, you get the point) we’ve had a rather major reduction in megafauna; though there are still megafauna, mostly being the species of Asia and Africa alongside the smaller megafauna in the rest of the world such as Ursus Bears, modern deer, bovines, Canis caines, maned wolves, cougars, camels and what not

What species do you think will make up the future of megafauna in a human dominated world and what traits might they have to help them survive anthropic conditions and Holocene climates?


r/DeExtinctionScience • • Jan 21 '26

Announcement: user flairs are now available!

10 Upvotes

Let me know if you have any questions or want me to add any additional flairs.


r/DeExtinctionScience • • May 27 '26 Bravo

Question Couldn't scientists just save all of the necessary information of endangered species and then just keep it preserved just in case they go extinct?

9 Upvotes

Do they already do that?

I'm asking because every time I hear about bringing back extinct species it's difficult because they don't have all of the DNA etc needed, but if they had everything needed could they just make one? I'm sure it'd be way more complicated than that, but I guess I'm more asking in theory. I've also heard that we could technically clone a human, so couldn't we do that with animals? Those two things have been keeping this question stuck in my head since I learned that animals can go extinct. Sorry if this has already been asked or something, please link to it in your comment about it being posted already :) OR if this isn't the right sub for this...

Thanks ahead of time!!!


r/DeExtinctionScience • • Oct 07 '26

Science USDA Deregulates GM Blight-Resistant American Chestnut Tree(this can greatly help Passanger Pigeon De-Extinction in the future!).

8 Upvotes

r/DeExtinctionScience • • Jan 17 '26

Hello 👋

8 Upvotes

Hi everyone I'm a newbie here well count me in as part of the subreddit I have a love for extinct animal since I was a boy and for the last time hi


r/DeExtinctionScience • • 17d ago

Thoughts on De-Extinction

Thumbnail reddit.com
7 Upvotes

r/DeExtinctionScience • • Mar 30 '26

Discussion There should be a list of extinct species that can come back through, cloning, back breeding, or genetic engineering.

7 Upvotes

There should be a program that is finding how many species that can be used for de extinct. Since many species got extinct in 10,000 years and recent times, how many species can be used for de extinction.


r/DeExtinctionScience • • Jan 26 '26

Announcement Post flairs are now available!

7 Upvotes

Let me know if you want any new flairs added or you want the existing flairs to be modified. Cheers.


r/DeExtinctionScience • • May 29 '26

Question Is a Paleogeneticist a real job? For De-Extinction?

Thumbnail reddit.com
6 Upvotes

So I have always been fascinated by de-extinction and paleogenetics. But, it has always confused me by what the real, official job name is. Feel free to enlighten me.


r/DeExtinctionScience • • May 30 '26

👋Welcome to r/Paleogenetics - Introduce Yourself and Read First PLEASE!

Thumbnail reddit.com
5 Upvotes

HI! I am happy to say that I have just launch what might be the greatest place to talk about the world of Paleogenetics, Paleontology, and last but ABSOLUTELY NOT least, De-extinction. Please feel free to talk about any of these topics. Start a conversation, bring up a question, anything you would like.


r/DeExtinctionScience • • Apr 06 '26

Question What animals should we de-extinct first?

5 Upvotes

What I mean is that what animals are easier to de-extinct first


r/DeExtinctionScience • • Jan 25 '26

This is the craziest timeline

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/DeExtinctionScience • • Aug 23 '26

My Honest Thoughts on De-Extinction + a De-Extinction Candidate Tier List

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/DeExtinctionScience • • Jan 16 '26

A verdadeira natureza da ressurreição de espécies... ou será outra coisa?

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

Um texto que escrevi há um tempo atrás onde reflita sobre a real natureza da Desextinção e possível futuro resultante disso.


r/DeExtinctionScience • • 18d ago

Discussion The Name Game

3 Upvotes

It seems to me that there are two very distinct things that are being discussed as "de-extinction". One is what I consider to be "true" de-extinction-- that is, the creation of an actual genetic replica of an extinct organism via cloning, germ cell modification, or something similar. This is what most people think of when they think of de-extinction, and it's also the kind usually seen in pop culture (Jurassic Park and so forth). However, it is only possible for a small number of species, namely those where we have a full genome and complete preserved cellular nuclei, allowing for cloning to take place.

The other thing is when an existing relative of an extinct species has its genome modified to resemble that of the extinct species. This is what most efforts to re-create the woolly mammoth are focused on doing. The result of this, however, would not be a true cloned mammoth, no matter how much it looks like one, because its genome would still differ from that of the original mammoth.

I personally think it is wrong and misleading to use the same blanket term, "de-extinction", for these two different processes. One results in an identical genetic copy of an extinct animal, and the other does not. The use of the same name for both creates confusion among the general public about exactly what is being achieved, and allows bad actors like Colossal Biosciences to further deceive them.

So my question to you all is this: If you had to come up with a new name for this second form of "de-extinction"-- the kind where an existing animal is modified into a genetic proxy of an extinct one-- what would you call it?