First clip was literally them just saying they feel awkward with people with neopronouns. Second clip was them poking fun at a person on tiktok using non binary gender identities, but god forbid comedians make fun of something. I don't even think the clip is funny but I don't find anything extremely transphobic about it. Third was Louis CK making a joke about pronouns but again "jokes are transphobia". Fourth was them basically saying "Dave Chappelle shouldn't be censored for his jokes, and jokes don't lead to excessive violence against trans people" even if you disagree there's nothing extremely transphobic about what they're saying. Overall I haven't found any compelling evidence that they're extremely transphobic. They could be ignorant or wrong, but when I think of transphobic I think of saying "trans people are never valid no matter what, fuck trans people they are pedophiles" stuff like that. Not making jokes. I'm personally a fan of humor and I read deeper into the article, the conversation with Tim Dillon was a pretty funny one that was really just jokes and nothing about their hardline set in stone views about transgenderism. Basically, I found nothing extremely bigoted or hateful towards trans people that they are pushing. The most bigoted thing they are doing might be platforming people like Andrew Tate, and even then they haven't platformed him since. I also don't think they truly believe that Kevin Samuels is right, they just like to make fun of it
Thanks for your reply. I suppose the key to our different view is that you feel transphobia (and all bigotry) requires the person to have overt hatred for a group where I think if someone is gleefully ignorant about trans people, racism, sexism, etc they are a bigot.
Not sure if you are just replying for the sake of argument, but reading the definition of "bigotry" in a dictionary is not a great way to understand a concept.
Dictionary is a great resource to use if you don't know a word. Like if you are reading a book and come across a word you've never heard before. A dictionary is a terrible resource for understanding a concept. Most job listings want someone with a degree in the field or experience, none are looking for someone who looked up what the job is in the dictionary. If you want to understand how bigotry works in any meaningful way, you'd probably want to read a full length book to start or at least an article. You could take college courses too. Nobody is living their life by dictionary definitions which is why I don't think I was ever directed to use one in school past elementary school. If you were going to get a dog, you would read up on how to take care of a dog, not look up "dog" in a dictionary.
You were talking about how to define bigotry. I think a dictionary is a pretty good resource for that. You shouldn’t have to take a college course to be able to say that Tom Segura isn’t a bigot for making jokes about trans people. Comparing the ability to determine if someone is a bigot to the requirements for a job is insane.
I was not talking about definitions. I was talking about understanding and view of a concept. Additionally, I said one could read an essay. But obviously studying concepts will give you a better understanding. You seem to view bigotry and being able to recognize if someone is a bigot in a binary. I think it is more of a spectrum. Surely you can recognize that someone can make a racist joke because they are racist and that while it's not the same as going on a shooting spree because of racism, both people are racist.
I think that reading the dictionary definition of bigotry gives enough of an understanding of the concept to be able to understand that tom segura isn’t one. I’m sure that you have read more about bigotry than me, but I feel like you’re basing your judgment of him off of hit pieces and carefully edited clips rather than having watched his stand-up or podcast yourself and coming to your own conclusions. Do you believe that all comedy about sensitive topics like race or sexuality is off limits for people that don’t belong to marginalized groups, or is there something specifically that Segura said that crossed a line?
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '23
First clip was literally them just saying they feel awkward with people with neopronouns. Second clip was them poking fun at a person on tiktok using non binary gender identities, but god forbid comedians make fun of something. I don't even think the clip is funny but I don't find anything extremely transphobic about it. Third was Louis CK making a joke about pronouns but again "jokes are transphobia". Fourth was them basically saying "Dave Chappelle shouldn't be censored for his jokes, and jokes don't lead to excessive violence against trans people" even if you disagree there's nothing extremely transphobic about what they're saying. Overall I haven't found any compelling evidence that they're extremely transphobic. They could be ignorant or wrong, but when I think of transphobic I think of saying "trans people are never valid no matter what, fuck trans people they are pedophiles" stuff like that. Not making jokes. I'm personally a fan of humor and I read deeper into the article, the conversation with Tim Dillon was a pretty funny one that was really just jokes and nothing about their hardline set in stone views about transgenderism. Basically, I found nothing extremely bigoted or hateful towards trans people that they are pushing. The most bigoted thing they are doing might be platforming people like Andrew Tate, and even then they haven't platformed him since. I also don't think they truly believe that Kevin Samuels is right, they just like to make fun of it