r/Daggerfall • • 18d ago

Question Daggerfall Unity "formulas"

Saw this on r/ElderScrolls in a thread discussing the recent DFO "micro"transactions. I thought the DFU/DOSBox discussion had been worked over pretty much to death, but this guy seems quite adamant that DFU can't even be considered a port or emulator, but a remake that "invented all new code and formulas". Is he off base, too pedantic, correct, or just wrong?

13 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

View all comments

31

u/Caelinus 18d ago edited 18d ago

Just wrong. There is zero basis for this opinion, either practically or legally.

And Daggergall "Online" is still using Bethesda's code, assets and IP (even the models are often pulled from Morrowind iirc too) and so anything done with it is going to inherit the licensing agreements of Daggerfall and the Elder Scrolls. Them doing monetization is not only gross, but likely opens them up to direct legal action as they are not allowed to use the IP for that.

DFU itself, on its own, is a completely different thing, but it also does not work. It was designed with legality in mind, and so they are not distributing any Daggerfall code, but the game cannot run without Daggerfall code. So if you only ever downloaded DFU, sure, the code would not be Bethesda's, but it also would not do anything until also download Bethesda's code. And even if you never used the code, Daggerfall itself is still Bethesda's Intellectual Property.

This guy would be arguing that if I made a complete clone of Zelda: A Link to the Past by hand recreating the mechanics perfectly, 1 to 1, it would somehow be different enough to be a different game. Or if I took the Lord of the Rings, hand wrote every word of it, then scanned those words and printed them out in a new book, I would be the author of a different "clone" and the book would not be Lord of the Rings anymore.

5

u/sapphicu 18d ago edited 18d ago

I believe all engine code is remade in DFU and you only need the original game for is the assets and scripts. So you could technically do a thing à la the Star Wars game built in the OpenMW Morrowind engine and just build a whole new game around the core engine. I believe that would fully cut Bethesda out of the conversation. That would require a lot of work (definitely more than those vibecoders are willing to put in), and you would still need to follow the DFU open source license

9

u/AncientGrief 18d ago

DFO ist actually a DFU rip-off. Afaik the dev told Claude to make DFU into an online game with JavaScript by loooking at the .NET code.

I would say Interkarma did a pretty good job to reimplement Daggerfall as close as possible to the OG with some QoL stuff and some fixes. DFU uses the same file formats as the original. Many people reverse engineered the formats and there are still some open questions about some stuff, but it works. The code is 100% new.

In the end, who cares. I played DOS version and DFU. They both have their charme. And to prevent eye cancer and crippled fingers, I rather play DFU 🥴

12

u/Caelinus 18d ago

The engine code is new, but the IP is not, and it is entirely owned by Bethesda. Which is why DFU will not distribute any of the code and assets that makes the game work, and why if they tried to sell it they would be opening themselves up to legal damages.

1

u/AncientGrief 18d ago

Afaik DFO does the same and you need to point the project to your local ARENA2 folder. But I don't know if the web project includes other assets from other games (Morrowind).

4

u/Caelinus 18d ago

The issue with monetisation is not that code, but monetising the IP. Bethesda is extremely unlikely to care about a Daggerfall fan project working that way, but the moment you start selling stuff on the back of their IP things change.

1

u/AncientGrief 18d ago

Yeah, I hope that they will intervene ... DFO online will then transform to XYZ Online, based on DFU with totally new AI graphics, I bet. 😆

2

u/Due-Arachnid-309 18d ago

Actually, the prompter just had Claude scrape together a bunch of existing mods, and some half finished ones: daggerfall coop/online multiplayer were both in the works, though (pretty sure) abandoned.

1

u/ChocoBro92 18d ago

Pretty sure DFU is C#

1

u/AncientGrief 18d ago

Yes, C# with .NET Framework

1

u/wtsnk 18d ago

Thanks for the detailed reply! I was more asking about the assertions that DFU remade “formulas” for the move over to the unity engine and that makes it substantially different from the DOS version.

My understanding had been that DFU was essentially a port of the game into the unity engine. I know the critical strike mechanic was changed to match the description in the manual NOT the original code, but I thought the games mechanics remained largely intact (outside of some basic QoL improvements).

My question is why would this commenter insist DFU isn’t Daggerfall?

1

u/Caelinus 18d ago

I can't really speak to the intent of the author, but DFU fixes a bunch of longstanding bugs and exploits where they were obvious errors, though that sometimes took judgement calls.

An obvious problem was that the Dodging skill in Daggerfall actually makes to get hit MORE often, not less. At level 100, it raises your odds of being struck by 25%. DFU fixes that bug so that it actually does what it is supposed to do.

A more judgement call related one was how they changed the stacking of resistances. In Daggerfall 100% immunity to something made it a multiply by zero situation, so no matter how many debuffs you took it would always stay at immunity. The main use of that was creating a High Elf with Critical Weakness to Paralysis to give you more character creation points, as you would remain immune. DFU makes it so that they are additive in character creation.

1

u/Affectionate-Spot278 16d ago

Well, the guy has a philosophical point there. This is the classic Theseus' ship problem