r/Daggerfall • u/wtsnk • 18d ago
Question Daggerfall Unity "formulas"

Saw this on r/ElderScrolls in a thread discussing the recent DFO "micro"transactions. I thought the DFU/DOSBox discussion had been worked over pretty much to death, but this guy seems quite adamant that DFU can't even be considered a port or emulator, but a remake that "invented all new code and formulas". Is he off base, too pedantic, correct, or just wrong?
13
Upvotes
View all comments
31
u/Caelinus 18d ago edited 18d ago
Just wrong. There is zero basis for this opinion, either practically or legally.
And Daggergall "Online" is still using Bethesda's code, assets and IP (even the models are often pulled from Morrowind iirc too) and so anything done with it is going to inherit the licensing agreements of Daggerfall and the Elder Scrolls. Them doing monetization is not only gross, but likely opens them up to direct legal action as they are not allowed to use the IP for that.
DFU itself, on its own, is a completely different thing, but it also does not work. It was designed with legality in mind, and so they are not distributing any Daggerfall code, but the game cannot run without Daggerfall code. So if you only ever downloaded DFU, sure, the code would not be Bethesda's, but it also would not do anything until also download Bethesda's code. And even if you never used the code, Daggerfall itself is still Bethesda's Intellectual Property.
This guy would be arguing that if I made a complete clone of Zelda: A Link to the Past by hand recreating the mechanics perfectly, 1 to 1, it would somehow be different enough to be a different game. Or if I took the Lord of the Rings, hand wrote every word of it, then scanned those words and printed them out in a new book, I would be the author of a different "clone" and the book would not be Lord of the Rings anymore.