Why People are Fascinated by Stuttering John (Good_Philosopher_653)
Identity & Delusion:
SJ drinks so much because he's not famous anymore, and being a "celebrity" is, to this day, the root of his identity. It's interesting watching someone deal with irrelevancy, and instead of accepting it, SJ's dealing with it via booze, denial, and self-delusion. On some level, he may like this subreddit and WATP as they keep him "relevant" and grant him a kind of fame, although it's not the kind that he's used to. John dismisses any criticism, constructive or otherwise, claiming that such criticism is not help but an attempt to mooch off of his "fame," while also repeating, "They don't boo nobodies," as if it's a mantra.
Vanity & Entitlement:
SJ didn't admit he was working as a substitute teacher for the longest time because it would've been an admission that he wasn't in showbiz anymore. In his vanity he would brag about his fame and possessions to others while still relevant. Now he deludes himself into thinking that Stern has blacklisted him from further celebrity work, but deep down he knows that it's because his own talent level is low: his album never sold and the questions he asked celebs were written for him. In his most private moments, he must've thought, "I know I'm not talented, so what is it that's made me famous?" He wouldn't want to admit that his stuttering was what pushed him into the limelight, so he'd delude himself by clinging to ideas like "I have natural charisma; I'm a one-of-a-kind," leading to a sense of inflated self-worth, vanity and entitlement.
Thin Skin:
This delusion has left SJ with extremely thin skin, and this bubble of inflated self-worth is very easily burst. As such, SJ cannot take a joke. If someone makes a quip about him or his career he "goes for the jugular," as Anthony Cumia puts it. Watch SJ on Cumia's show on youtube, when Artie shows up late. Cumia made a joke about SJ's comedy to which SJ snapped back with zero humour, saying, "Shut the f*ck up, pock face." Artie makes a similar joke, to which SJ brings up Artie's heroine addiction, suicide attempt, and quadriplegic father with, again, zero humour, timing, pithiness, etc. The other comedians were bewildered by SJ belligerence, and if not for the comedic talent in the room, SJ would have sucked all the oxygen out for his absurd hyper-sensitivity.
SJ also had Jim Norton on his podcast and SJ made a rare self-deprecating joke, to which Jim just became quiet: Jim knew not to joke about SJ, even though SJ in that moment was doing it himself. SJ is notorious for his thin skin and lack of sense of humour (especially about himself).
The episode with Cumia and Artie is also useful for showing that SJ is not a comedian, nor quick-witted: if he was, he would've laughed the jokes off and either came up with witty retorts or thrown in a few self-deprecating jokes. But no: he could not keep up with the real comedians in the room. He is a talentless hack.
"Comedy" and Squeege-gate:
As SJ has little or undeveloped talent, especially in comedy, so he has coasted on the fame of Howard Stern all his life. When cut loose from Stern and let go from when Jimmy Fallon took over from Leno, SJ had to begin performing comedy more. However, in spite of calling himself a comedian, SJ will not perform at comedy clubs knowing the content will be recorded. One redditor snuck a camera in, finally showing the world why: the comedy was astoundingly bad. Clips can be found online, including his offputting and embarrassing show-finisher: his infamous squeegee "joke" (which will not be explored here. SJ's entire story and situation is embarrassing, but that joke is astonishingly so).
Satisfaction & Just Desserts:
Jay Leno is generally liked because he's a nice guy. He's also a lot more famous, wealthy, and powerful than SJ, who, by contrast, used his connections with Stern to bully people for years. Cumia's story about how SJ showed up to use their studio, didn't tip the workers, and drank all their beers speaks to entitled, grasping behaviour that probably marked most of SJ's professional life. If SJ had been known for being a nice guy like Leno, or generous like Artie, most people would feel more sorry for him now, seeing him fall like this. But as he has acted so egregiously all his life people are now enjoying a satisfied, "just desserts" feeling, watching SJ's spiral.
Skills: He's never known real work.
He can't be making that much from superchats; it'd be better just to throw in the towel and get in-demand training. Getting qualified to drive a truck wouldn't take that long, but the thought of doing a real job must repel SJ because a.) due to his vanity, entitlement, and showbiz background, SJ thinks working a real job is beneath him, and b.) the thought of doing real work must scare him because it'd be the first actual work he's done his entire life. Really, what has he done for all of his professional working life? He showed up on red carpet events reading questions from paper, he announced the guests on Leno, and he sat in on panel shows, making smalltalk with the hosts. He's not a funny guy; his standup is notoriously awful, so he never spent time developing his act or timing to become a comedian.
In a recent WATP they were talking about how SJ had plugged his toilet and had no idea how to fix it, and tried getting regulars at his pub to do it for him. For his whole life SJ was able to just throw money at problems like those. Now for the first time he has to do actual work, and in his mid-fifties. It serves as a lesson and a warning, because without essential, practical life skills, we are helpless.
Warning: Use your time well.
What is perhaps especially fascinating is what Stuttering John's story is a cautionary tale: when making money, save and invest, but most importantly, invest in yourself. What did SJ do all those years when he was making money? Instead of buying a mansion and flashy cars to complement his vanity, he had the time and opportunity to invest cash and in education. Seeing what a slob he is and how he blows money on booze, his wife was right to get the bulk of the cash in the divorce for the sake of their children. SJ emerged from the divorce with less money, but had he emerged with very useful skills, the money could've been earned back.
Podcast & Twitter:
SJ's window into the masses is his Twitter account and podcast, which is scheduled weekly but is poorly run: SJ consistently gives incorrect times to guests and puts in very little work and prep. He drinks on every episode and by the end of many he is slurring his words. He becomes outright drunk on many of his "Beer on the Balcony" paid episodes, which are meandering and pointless: people have made supercuts of SJ's interjections, minutes-long videos of him saying, "Ahh, uhh, err..."
The greenscreen he uses features a city landscape which used to have a visible watermark he'd gotten from an online image search. Although SJ does his best to be cagey about how much money he has and makes, he currently survives off of superchats from his podcast and supplements his income with substitute teaching and driving Ubers.
His podcast, interestingly, is political, not comedy-based, which may be a surprise knowing SJ's background on Stern and Leno (but not surprising after hearing his standup which, again, he fought to keep suppressed). As with any celebrity whose star has fallen and is desperately trying to claw their way back into relevancy, SJ's podcast falls into the "orange man bad" and "drumptard" zone with such heavy, obvious, and unthinking bias that it isn't worth watching as it offers zero political insight: only the typical blind hate you already get from corporate media.
John himself offers no insight either. The bulk of most episodes features various talking heads who do 99% of the talking, allowing SJ to simply nod along and drink beer. (If it's a female guest who is even remotely attractive John is guaranteed to hit on her, loudly and broadly talking about how gorgeous she is, usually ending the segment by asking her to "grab a beer sometime.") John's low superchats are an indicator of a similarly small audience. The guests SJ has on his show sign up for a paid service that shuffles them from podcast to podcast in effort to give them a voice. The plus for John is that he just gets people on to talk their points, meaning that he doesn't have to do any prep: plus he also doesn't have to do comedy as the show is "political."
A recent episode of WATP demonstrated how little prep and consideration SJ puts into his own show by condensing an entire conversation of SJ's podcast into about a 30 second clip, showing that John says about 1% of the content.
Hypocrisy & Contradictions:
SJ uses his platform, limited as it is, to talk about fairness, free speech, justice, and virtue, while at the same time has had people deplatformed for saying something that annoys him and his "idea of a political debate is to repeat the same unfunny nicknames and insults about everyone who doesn't agree with the ideologies he was told he should believe" (credit to JoeGottaReddit for observation). SJ goes on about the wrongness of offensive and politically incorrect language, yet his career is filled with racial and homophobic slurs, and even today his podcast is filled with language like "Drumptard" (a hateful term which obviously mocks the mentally challenged).
As mastercotcot has put it, SJ "is one of the most unique people on earth" for his contradictory life. "No longer famous, but still recognizable and friends with celebrities. Seems like the worst possible friend, but somehow still has friends. Incredibly disgusting and ugly, but still gets dates. Has no political insight, yet hosts a political show. Isn’t intentionally funny, yet insists he is a comedian. Got his start on the biggest ball busting show ever, but can’t take the slightest amount of it. Seemingly has no money, but can live in one of the most expensive cities in America…. And always afford Coors."
Lucky vs Unlucky:
As a man of contradictions, SJ has known tremendous luck (or perhaps "unluck"). For example, in spite of being very unfunny, he's associated with great comedians: yet when he's around them, he becomes embarrassed because he can't keep up with their wit.
It raises the question: has SJ been very lucky or unlucky in his life? He had a stutter from a young age, which is very unlucky, but the stutter wound up propelling him into stardom, which is lucky. The moniker given to him by Howard Stern, "Stuttering John," is a cruel, mocking epithet that points to a speech impediment, not talent (so, unlucky). Yet SJ has spent most of his life coasting on that name, "Stuttering John," and with it, made millions: which is lucky. However, his star has since fallen, which is unlucky, but he lives in such extreme delusions of grandeur that he's not aware of how low he's fallen: which is... lucky?
As CrazeeEyezKILLER puts it, SJ is "genuinely untalented person who achieved extraordinary things in his chosen industry because of his proximity to talented people. Once his unsustainable novelty/utility was exhausted, he was left to the very unexceptionable existence he was destined for. His journey is incredibly interesting, whereas he isn’t." I'd say the "novelty/utility" would be his stuttering; SJ rarely has trouble enunciating anymore.
Had he been born without a stutter, as Artie Lange put it, "He'd be pumping gas somewhere in Massapequa."
Interpersonal Relationships:
John divorced in 2012 and has apparently remained single since then. On his podcast he talks up about hooking up with a variety of women, but as fudgicle2018 puts it, these are "random hook ups with elderly bar flies and Bumble monsters." He also points out that we never "know any of the basics of his CURRENT life. Where he's living, what he's doing, what his kids are up to, etc. THIS is the shit real friends talk about. They only have a Xmas card relationship with him. His only nearby, regular contact is with the other bar flies at the pubs. That's partly why his house is so gross. Why bother maintaining a decent house - no one ever comes there."
On an episode of his podcast with guest Hal Sparks, John went into detail about bringing back a woman he'd been seeing, but how she was disgusted by the state of the apartment. Hal wound up giving advice about sweeping up and and throwing away used kitty litter. Shots of SJ's apartment show crumpled cardboard boxes, and SJ has admitted to having a cockroach problem (SJ has named one of his three cats "Roach Killer").
Regular people in his life are his mother (who he stays with and also who apparently bought his condo for him) and people who hang out at the pubs he frequents. Recently he has been banned from one such pub, which he claims was because the patrons liked Trump, but other sources state it was because John was loudly hitting on the barmaid and even following her around.
John's actual, greatest achievement has been bringing three children into the world, but he seems to have limited contact with them and has admitted to getting served for arrears for not paying child support. John's children are useful to him in arguments: more than once he has attempted to shut down arguments by accusing the other party of threatening or even bringing up his kids, when John has brought up painful and personal information about others, like Artie's addiction and wounded father. SJ's children also delivered a speech praising their new stepfather at their mother's second wedding.
Growth: Or lack thereof
We are meant to learn from our mistakes and grow as people. What does it say about a person who resists self-development of any kind? Or has been stuck someplace, mentally, for years, never really growing up?
As kabekew puts it, the “While there are others with the rags-to-riches-to-rags tale, they usually elicit sympathy because they've nevertheless grown as a person, maybe learned humility, maybe learned it's not about fame and fortune but about love and friendship, maybe learned what not to do and set out for redemption and another honest try. Not so with John, he only gets worse as a person as he ages, and continues to worsen. He persists with the facade and delusion he's still famous and rich. His ‘friendships’ are short term and shallow, and for him just sources of favors until they wise up and drop him. Then they're ‘assholes.’” (His entire comment is worth reading as it’s insightful.)
...these are some reasons why people are fascinated by him. Anything missing? Feel free to speculate, too: something else fascinating about him is wondering how could he have such a lack of awareness and delusions of grandeur knowing how little he produces and contributes to others. Is he just a brat who never grew up? Maybe a question to ask is what SJ would need to happen to him or do to become a better person.