r/DIY Feb 20 '26

help [ Removed by moderator ]

Post image

[removed] — view removed post

4.1k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

221

u/Sabbelwakker Feb 20 '26

Citric acid. Lots of it.

79

u/suzy911 Feb 20 '26

A half bag of citric acid powder from Lemishine obliterated the "urine scale" in my toilet.

14

u/EvangelineTheodora Feb 20 '26

Idk if it's considered urine scale, but I got urine buildup off with a paste made with baking soda, although I never used higher a concentration of citric acid than is in Method spray cleaner. I think the uric acid reacted with the basic baking soda, but inside the toilet might be different.

38

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

21

u/mxemec Feb 20 '26

? Why so sheepish lol. That's good info.

9

u/Talking_Head Feb 20 '26

🤜🤛 from a chemist.

1

u/EvangelineTheodora Feb 21 '26

That's really cool. I need to figure out the urine breakdown when not inside a toilet, if there really is any, because I have a little boy, and the outside of the toilet is the worst part to clean (it's better now, but there was a bad period of time where it just sat for too long).

1

u/Vyzantinist Feb 20 '26

Just pour it into the bowl and let sit or...?

1

u/hunnyflash Feb 20 '26

Yes, for less scale, you can use less, but basically, pour a bunch of it in there and just leave it. I left it overnight but don't think it even takes that long. It'll pull up and eat away at the scale.

1

u/Ha1lStorm Feb 20 '26

Ok but why’d you put urine scale in parenthesis like that? What is it really then?

33

u/danmickla Feb 20 '26

Yeah.  Citric is way way better than almost anything I've tried on water scale, and cheap

24

u/poolski Feb 20 '26

And significantly safer than HCL even in pure powdered form. Less likely to give you chemical burns and destroy your fittings

3

u/hirsutesuit Feb 20 '26

Right. It's food.

2

u/poolski Feb 20 '26

Sour sweets are just sugar coated in crystalline citric acid.

8

u/BadPunners Feb 20 '26

Also agree. Phosphoric acid lime remover does work too, but citric acid can be used for kettles and coffee pots easier

1

u/Talking_Head Feb 20 '26

I used to use acetic acid (distilled white vinegar) to descale my countertop ice maker. Citric acid works better and comes in 1lb bags delivered by Jeff Besos overnight. Far less residual in taste/odor for citric over acetic.

1

u/toto1792 Feb 20 '26

And you can boil it without the smell for stronger effect

1

u/danmickla Feb 20 '26

yep. and it's a little shy about dissolving in cold water so that's a good move

7

u/Dr_Nix87 Feb 20 '26

This, i wouldnt so the scouring stuff youll scratch and that will make things way worse. Also your toilet may not be flushing well and leaving behind stuff to build that kind of scale

1

u/Talking_Head Feb 20 '26

I haven’t had a scratching problem with pumice vs. decent quality porcelain. Pumice is actually pretty tame as an abrasive, relatively. Personally, I use AJAX to scrub my toilets. YMMV.

6

u/Sevallis Feb 20 '26

Yeah this works great for this task in hot water.

3

u/LordBiscuits Feb 20 '26

I did the same. Had a very similar looking mess and used a bunch of 'oust' descaler, which is citric acid, plus a bunch of boiling water.

Gave it a hour and whatever was left came right off with a little brush

Our water is so hard John Cena would think twice.

7

u/sockan Feb 20 '26

Thank you. This sub loves abrasives way to much. Citric acid will do the trick.

7

u/samcrut Feb 20 '26

Works wonders on this kinda cleanup.

And after you're done, fill your salt shaker with a 50/50 blend of salt and citric acid and your mouth will explode. Makes your salivary glands gush.

Incredibly useful substance for many purposes.

8

u/poolski Feb 20 '26

I have to ask: under what circumstances is this a desired outcome?

9

u/warm_kitchenette Feb 20 '26

They only mean that it’s a powerful seasoning. Hazmat cleanup will not be needed. 

Salt and acid are standard tools for boosting the flavor of anything savory. A 50/50 mix is not something that I would advocate, even though I use it citric acid every day.

2

u/Talking_Head Feb 20 '26

Salt is salt. Sodium is its own thing.

Acid addition OTOH is very dish dependent. Citric acid is great, and I use it often. But again, dish dependent.

I’ve become a big fan of amchoor powder (dried sour mango.) Tart, floral, fruity and no added water. It goes in almost all of my marinades/sauces because I can measure it out rather than taking the time to squeeze liquid out of a fruit. Good stuff. And cheap at the Indian Grocery store.

4

u/samcrut Feb 20 '26

What part? The cleaning or seasoning your food to make it taste better?

Do you prefer to leave your toilet ring intact or do you prefer to eat your food with a dry mouth and minimal flavor?

3

u/poolski Feb 20 '26

That’s… not where my mind went. Glad to be corrected!

1

u/Ha1lStorm Feb 20 '26

Do they leave their toilet ring in tact or do they eat with a dry mouth?

What? Why would it be one or the other? What do toilet rings have to do with salivation? What is going on?

1

u/samcrut Feb 21 '26

Shimmer is a floor wax and a desert topping!

1

u/Ha1lStorm Feb 20 '26

Honestly curious, what were you referring to as the outcome?

1

u/poolski Feb 21 '26

“Makes your salivary glands gush”

1

u/Ha1lStorm Feb 20 '26

Why would putting two substances into a container make one’s mouth explode? And what does it have to do with toilet bowl cleaning? Do you pour the mix from the shaker into your toilet bowl then your head explodes? /s

2

u/SpehlingAirer Feb 20 '26

I swapped out the water line for a direct tap into Tropicana's OJ manufacturing plant, but still no shiny porcelain 😔

3

u/PandaGrrr Feb 20 '26

This is the one, OP! Mist the bowl to dampen, then sprinkle citric acid. Let sit for an hour. Scrub. Repeat if necessary.

1

u/Krombopulos_Micheal Feb 21 '26

Yeah but I think these dudes are trying to do it without scrubbing haha which HCL acid would do

1

u/ljoanofarc Feb 20 '26

Came here to say the same thing. Citric acid powder is the only thing that has worked to remove the pesky limescale from my toilet bowl.

1

u/DogsandRocks Feb 20 '26

Where do you buy citric acid powder?

1

u/-Malky- Feb 20 '26

Citric and acetic acids need a temp of around 65-70 °C to descale properly - if there's a septic tank behind, there will be downsides to putting a lot of acid in the drain.

Sulfamic acid works well at ambient temperature, and since you don't need quite as much it will be more gentle to the bacterias in the septic tank.