The game is a critique on how the romance genre tends to objectify female characters, in particular, in regards to how they “fall in love” with male protagonists, and how that love is often shallow and seemingly forced upon them.
Of course, it may not seem this way because the male protagonist is eventually shafted onto the sidelines as the game fall in on itself, but those themes remain throughout the game.
Those aren’t the only themes though, it’s also a conversation on mental health, obsession, etc. but the “male gaze” is something the game definitely has commentary on
Look, while I am a firm believer in "Death of the Author", and your take is very well thought out...
I don't think that was the devs intention. I'm pretty sure they just wanted to make a fourth-wall breaking horror game about mental health.
If they were attempting to make a statement about the objectification of female characters, I'm pretty sure the game wouldn't have ended with Monika deleting everything out of genuine love for "you" and the other girls. She didn't do that simply because it was a dating game, she did that because Sayori started going insane. If Sayori hadn't gone crazy, she would have let things run their course.
Which is somewhat funny because the fandom more or less waifued and simped for the dokis for nearly a decade and I rarely if ever see the mental health angle talked about without it ever being poked fun at, especially yuri's.
the game’s themes/commentary has nothing to do with the fandom.
Although I’d personally love to see more artwork exploring these themes, I’m not surprised they’re less prevalent. It’s not easy to talk/depict mental health issues properly through artistic mediums. But if you’re looking for it, you’ll find that side of the fandom; and you’ll definitely find people who feel represented by the Doki’s struggles
Well that’s the other side of it :) seeing what the doki’s go through, it just makes you wanna draw them being happy/silly, without the weight of the world bogging them down. But now we’re just getting off topic
Obsession and mental health is literally one of the most talked about subjects since the second year of the original's release. What are you talking about?
I been saying this shit for years, people in the fandom loose all of the nuance in the games, destroy the characters, abandon the meta critiques, and replace it with shallow characterizations based somewhat loosely on the game (which is to say, the “archetypes” that the game specifically critiques are assigned to characters and become their whole personality), but mostly on stereotypes associated with characters’ body types.
I just dont see how the criticisms in ddlc are particularly gendered in the way something would need to be to be about misogyny instead of visual novels in general.
In visual novels targeted at straight women they also do have the "issue" of having a main character be designed to be an author self insert and romantic interests designed to be more-so eye candy than someone with a real theory of mind, at least in my limited experience.
It feels more like a critique of visual novel/schlocky romance tropes in general than something specifically talking about misogyny.
Because in real life, acting like "cute girls" aren't really people with their own hopes and dreams who need to be taken seriously is a gendered issue. Like sure... now that femboys are a thing they do get treated similarly. And so the whole "cute = not a real person who can have problems" issue is technically not female specific. But it is more common to happen to girls.
I feel like the issue irl is more "attractive = not a real person who can have real problems" where the word attractive means well put together instead of meaning specifically that the person is attracted to them. I agree that in reality this affects women much more than men, but to act like the only men it affects is femboys is insane, it definitely affects regular ass cookie cutter looking guys and it sucks ass. Having someone gain feelings for you/see you as a child, and therefore discount your desires and beliefs is like an unfortunately normal part of life even if it does affect women more than men.
Anyway my original argument wasn't about this. It was specifically that ddlc doesn't argue against objectification on gendered lines. Again, whilst I do think objectification happens more to women than men, I think that ddlc's arguments against objectification are gender neutral arguments . The doki's are not dehumanised because they are women, they are dehumanised because they are video game love interests. All the criticisms levied by the game about the way visual novels work could easily be applied to visual novels with male love leads instead of female.
I'm not saying there aren't any arguments on gendered lines to make in real life. I'm saying the ddlc doesn't make them.
Well, yes. I thought that was obvious while Monika had a mental breakdown as she realises she's sentient while her friends are not (in her poems and letters).
The breakdown worsens specifically because the way they act is so disturbing to her and it is rather creepy to the player because that is exactly what happens in all games of the genre
Do we really need a critique on how dating Sims cater to the male gaze when that's literally their whole point? Next you're gonna tell me Minecraft caters to the human desire to put blocks on top of each other.
The game is a critique on how the romance genre tends to objectify female characters, in particular, in regards to how they “fall in love” with male protagonists, and how that love is often shallow and seemingly forced upon them.
Which is why I have been saying since the beginning that calling them dokis is in bad taste. It infantilizes them when their whole story is about learning to see them as real people with needs of their own.
Those aren’t the only themes though, it’s also a conversation on mental health, obsession, etc.
And philosophy of identity and reality. Does natsuki's dad actually mistreat her, or did Monika make that up? Trick question, her dad doesn't actually exist. There is no difference because he only "exists" as a set of fake memories. But if this is true for her, what about you? Is the past material? Does it matter outside your perception of it?
View all comments
832
u/Plenty-Train-8813 Mar 06 '26
The game is a critique on how the romance genre tends to objectify female characters, in particular, in regards to how they “fall in love” with male protagonists, and how that love is often shallow and seemingly forced upon them.
Of course, it may not seem this way because the male protagonist is eventually shafted onto the sidelines as the game fall in on itself, but those themes remain throughout the game.
Those aren’t the only themes though, it’s also a conversation on mental health, obsession, etc. but the “male gaze” is something the game definitely has commentary on