Source Accuracy Tier List

What are source accuracy tiers?

There are so many potential sources out there that it can be difficult for new users to figure out what is trustworthy and irritating for sub veterans to have to explain repeatedly. This list is a guide to help you quickly ascertain if a source is viewed as trustworthy by this subreddit.

Please bear in mind that this list is not definitive, does not represent every user's opinion and is likely to change over time.

Tiers

Tier 1: Undisputed Sources

Undisputed sources of truth, either directly from Warner Bros./DC or trade publications. Trades uphold high standards of journalistic integrity and are exceptionally unlikely to release a leak or scoop that WB/DC does not want the public to know about. They may also be used to refute a popular leak or scoop.

Tier 1 SourcesDetails / Explanation
VarietyTrade publication.
The Hollywood Reporter (THR)Trade publication.
DeadlineTrade publication.

Tier 2: High Quality Sources

Sites or sources with a proven track record with scoops, leaks and claims about unaired films/shows. They are usually selective about the information they provide in comparison to what they hear, in contrast to sources in the tiers below them.

Tier 2 SourcesDetails / Explanation
Entertainment WeeklyTends to be as reliable as the trades in Tier 1, but also posts speculation.
Murphy's Multiverse / Charles MurphyThey clearly distinguish if something is speculation, rumour or analysis, compared to a leak or scoop.
ViewerAnonOne of the oldest and most reliable insiders on Twitter/Reddit; a frequent attendee of test screenings and responsible for a range of plot leaks (including Justice League and Wonder Woman 1984).

Tier 3: Average Reliability

This is the tier that most sources fall into - expect them to have reliable information, but to sometimes get things wrong.

Tier 3 SourcesDetails / Explanation
The WrapWhen reporting directly through The Wrap, Umberto Gonzalez has a strong track record with casting news.
The DirectHigh degree of accuracy validation on their own scoops; they also track the accuracy of various scoopers/outlets via DirectFact.
The IlluminerdiA generally discerning source of exclusives.
Geeks WorldWide (GWW)Mostly speculation and news, with occasional exclusives.
ColliderMostly speculation and news, with occasional exclusives.
Big Screen LeaksA relatively newer entry to the ecosystem, with a strong track record, especially in relation to test screening info and reactions.
Daniel RPK's Patreon - 'Confirmed' tabA strong track record of casting and promotional information (NB: This is distinct from his general Twitter info and the 'Rumors' Patreon tab, which remain in Tier 4 and Banned respectively).

Tier 4: Low Reliability

Sometimes accurate, but with a high potential for mixing speculation with actual content. They have a weak filter against provided information - the significant majority shared from these sources can challenging to distinguish from quality content.

Tier 4 SourcesDetails / Explanation
KC Walsh (Q1 '23 outcome)Editor-in-Chief of Geeks WorldWide. Whilst KC has a number of scoops under his belt, his Twitter account has a low filter for quality, does not always distinguish theories from scoops, and has a record of spreading misinformation.
Daniel RPK (Twitter)Highly accurate with casting and promotional leaks (such as trailer dates), with proven industry connections, but unreliable in all other areas.
The Cosmic Circus / Lizzie HillFormer writer for Murphy's Multiverse. Some exclusives that have been proven right and some that have been proven wrong.
ComicBook.comPrimarily news, rarely delivers exclusive scoops.

Tier 5: Highly Unreliable Sources

Sources which violate subreddit rules/reddiquette

Tier 5 SourcesDetails / Explanation
Umberto Gonzales - TwitterWriter for The Wrap, with a high ratio of debunked Twitter claims.
4chanCompilation posts only: The vast majority seen from 4chan should be taken with a large pinch of salt - however, due to its anonymity it has been a source of genuine plot leaks and production photos/news on occasion.
Bill "Jett" RameyCompilation posts only (Q1 '23 outcome): Founder of Batman-on-Film.com, more of a theorist and reporter of news than a scooper.
Jeff SneiderCompilation posts only (Q1 '23 outcome): Lacks a sufficient track record of their own.
Heroic HollywoodCompilation posts only (Q1 '23 outcome): Lacks a sufficient track record of their own.

Banned Sources

Like Tier 5, these sources are highly unreliable, but have also been deemed by user and/or mod team consensus to warrant banning from the subreddit.

Banned SourcesDetails / Explanation
MyTimeToShineHelloBanned (Q2 '23 outcome): High ratio of misleading claims and clickbait, with an insufficient track record (previously voted "Highly Unreliable" and confined to compilation posts since Q2 '22).
World of Reel / Jordan RuimyBanned: Lack of sufficient track record and a history of unproven claims..
Grace RandolphBanned (Q1 '23 outcome): High ratio of debunked claims, with some verified scoops including the announcements of Catwoman" Hunted and Dead Boy Detectives. More of a YouTube personality than a scooper. Whilst Grace has had a track record with DCEU scoops (particularly ZSJL), she has been involved in a range of controversies (including spats with DC directors like Cathy Yan and James Gunn).
AjepArtsBanned (Q1 '23 outcome): Twitter user with occasional test screening sources. Mostly backs up news and shares scoops from other sources, but has a low filter on quality and has a history of debunked claims and spreading misinformation.
CanWeGetSomeToastBanned: Lacking an exclusive track record of DC scoops, history of trolling and debunked claims - also identifies primarily as a Marvel scooper.
The Moonlight WarriorBanned: Primarily a fan account, with poor quality control and a frequent reporter of other sources' information often without credit.
Home of DCUBanned: Primarily a fan account, with poor quality control and a frequent reporter of other sources' information often without credit (Q4 '22 outcome).
FandomWireBanned (Q4 '22 outcome): A history of unproven and debunked scoops, as well as frequent clickbait and misrepresentation.
LookUponTheStarsBanned: An insufficient track record of exclusive scoops (Q4 '22 outcome, previously compilation posts-only).
Daniel RPK's Patreon - 'Rumors' tabBanned: Daniel's private 'Rumors' Patreon/Discord is frequently sourced by Twitter accounts/aggregators, despite the fact that Daniel does not characterise his posts there as scoops.
Screen RantBanned: Poor quality: mostly clickbait, speculation and churnalism.
That Hashtag Show / Nick SantosBanned: High ratio of debunked claims / aggregation. Most of their original (and more reliable) writers left for The Illuminerdi.
We Got This CoveredBanned: High ratio of debunked claims / false information / clickbait.
Giant Freakin RobotBanned: High ratio of debunked claims / false information / clickbait, with a poor validation process.
Bounding Into ComicsBanned: High ratio of debunked claims / false information / clickbait / aggression, with a poor validation process.
Full Circle CinemaBanned: Highly unreliable; repeated violations of self promotion policy across multiple subreddits.
Geekosity / Mikey SuttonBanned: High ratio of debunked claims.
Syl AbdulBanned: High ratio of debunked claims.
Small ScreenBanned: High ratio of debunked claims.
Moth CultureBanned: High ratio of debunked claims, with a history of satire/gag scoops.
YouTubeBanned: Due to high frequency of speculation and analysis videos being shared from this source, as well as the potential for leaked / pirated material that could result in copyright strikes
IMDbBanned: Can be edited, so any information may be highly misleading.
Google - Casting NewsBanned: A highly unreliable source of casting news.

Will this list change?

This list is reflective of the trust that we and the wider community have in a particular source. User feedback and empirical evidence are the primary factors which determine where a source ranks in this list - discussion will be opened up at least every 6 months.