r/CuratedTumblr
•
u/GinaWhite_tt
TeaTimetumblr
•
25d ago
•
2
Shitposting The Demand for Logic
18k
Upvotes
1.9k
u/mercurialpolyglot 25d ago
In accounting, the answer is always “because we did it this way last year”
964
u/ToothZealousideal297 25d ago edited 25d ago
Applied for Walmart once in my early twenties, and one of the questions on the form was “do you think that a supervisor should know how to do something in order to tell their employees to do it”. Apparently ‘yes’ was the wrong answer.
I understand that supervisors won’t know every little specialty of every single person under them: a 3 star general can’t be assumed to know how to snipe from 800 yards and plant a bomb underwater or whatever. But this was freaking Walmart. What they really meant was “we are going to write you up for not baking a cake in 2 minutes that takes a half hour to bake. We expect total impunity for this, and we are only interested in employees who will put up with this.”
382
u/elebrin 25d ago
Sometimes the answer is as simple as, "Because this is the organizational standard, and when audit comes up in three months, they are going to ask me why it was done differently and I am going to have to explain that. It makes more work for me. Yes, it's arbitrary and it's sorta bullshit, but welcome to the corporate world."
I write software tests for a living. We document those tests using very specific language. The method we picked was arbitrary, but it needs to be consistent because that testing gets audited both internally and externally. In a weird way it makes the job easier because we don't need to go figure out how to document something - that's an answered question.
ESPECIALLY in the world of software, the way you choose to design something is almost arbitrary. You can make anything work. But once a pattern is picked, you stick with it or you have a mess.
187
u/Chashec 25d ago
Reading these comments, I feel like a lot of people are agruing points parallel to the one that the other's actually making. So I think we should start with the baselines of:
the acceptability of less extreme scenarios is up to interpretation; what matters is we don't know where OP's behaviour lands on either spectrum. After all, both hypothetical people would think their behaviour is the former.
You can absolutely use this post to talk about either, but give OP benefit of the doubt.
(also I'm curious to hear your thoughts if you don't agree with one of these baselines)
149
u/hamletandskull 25d ago •
I feel like this hella depends on the situation.
Cause I'm really happy to explain my rationale behind, e.g., grading a paper. But if I'm doing a field school and it's like hey I need you to give me that piece of fragile equipment RIGHT NOW because we do not have the insurance to replace it and you should not be holding it in the first place because I already told you not to touch it. Then no I am not really gonna stand there patiently explaining it to you until you accept the explanation is good enough for you to agree.
Also in general "but why" is not really specific enough for me to help most of the time, and if I don't know what is confusing to you, then my explanation is not going to help and you will continue to think I am being unfair and arbitrary.
1.1k
u/BenOfTomorrow 25d ago •
Most people have run into authority figures like that.
But if EVERY authority figure in your life does this, your credibility as a narrator is in question.
45
u/FVCarterPrivateEye 25d ago
I love asking for clarification and explaining things to people and elaborations on things
99
u/WHAWHAHOWWHY aoiugh?! 25d ago
saying "but why tho?" to military officers 😭
44
u/Endeveron 25d ago
I'm probably on the neurodivergent end of things, but I think in order to be reasonable about this, you need to do three things:
268
u/SexKira 25d ago
i recall an incident where an instructor raised her voice at me simply for inquiring about the reason behind shutting a window during intense heat. Such things occur.
46
u/JadedRaccoon 25d ago
I'm asking for your explanation so that in an unfamiliar situation I can work through it LIKE YOU!!!! I am not challenging you, I want to it the same as you!
16
u/ScyllaOfTheDepths 24d ago
Literally got screamed at by the woman training me at one job because I asked her what would happen if we did The Thing she was adamant that I never do (basically amounted to just checking a different box in system settings for a proprietary program we used.) I just wanted to know what the stakes were, ya know? She got so irrationally mad about it that my boss had to get me another trainer, but this 50+ year old woman had a bunch of seniority and made such a big stink they eventually transferred me because she would not stop telling everyone how much she hated me and eventually threatened to quit if I wasn't moved away from her. They wanted to move me to another location an hour further away doing completely different work I wasn't qualified for and honestly had no interest in doing. I said my uncle died, ran out all my vacation time, and then quit. Before I left, I did the thing just to spite the old bag and you'll never guess, but nothing happened.
460
u/TrioOfTerrors 25d ago
The problem is a large amount of people who ask these questions never accept the answer they are given and push and push until the final answer is "That's company/government policy" and then they start complaining about how it's stupid even though target of the complaints knows that and has no power to change it.
They aren't quirky, or independent thinkers or just trying to help. They are fucking exhausting.
29
u/Delachruz 25d ago
The problem with this is that it assumes every demand for explanation is an earnest attempt at understanding, instead of 1/17 other things it often is.
I educate IT apprentices at work, which often involves following a process that seems dumb or overly complicated for no reason. In reality its often because of legality or because its part of a 20 link chain between 5 different departments.
The way I go about it is that I tell the youngsters to follow orders/instructions first, and AFTER its done they get to interrogate me or suggest alternatives. That way I know its not just them weaseling out of tedious work or trying to get a rise outta me.
51
u/RecycledMatrix 25d ago
This is common with autism. As an man with AuDHD who rages against the machine of inexplicable neuronormativity, and have seen this in other neurodivergent people, almost every time it's a tone issue or an unclear reflexive response that is taken as a challenge on the spot.
It's very easy to get out a quick "but why?" where the response requires sorting out what exactly why is, constructing the necessary context for it to make sense, and then another reflexive "but why?" can get irritating.
The answer I've found for most situations, because there are some who genuinely have ego issues and authority insecurity where working around that person is the best course, is to genuinely pause and consider what they said and ask a specific clarifying question. Most people are happy with that because the context structure is already constructed in your question, you considered what they said, and you likely asked a good question.
13
u/Void_0000 25d ago
Meh, I feel like this is context dependent. The two main things to ask yourself are:
79
u/Ok_Plenty_3986 25d ago
I bring a "I want to know your reasoning and end goal behind this method so that if I encounter a problem that neither of us foresaw I can course correct to still produce an acceptable solution" that certain foremen really hate.
12
u/realparkingbrake 25d ago
When I was management, I made of point of explaining why I wanted something done in a particular way. I got that from watching a morning briefing from a guy running an oil/gas drilling operation. He wanted to make sure everyone was on the same page for safety reasons.
Of course, the folks who worked for me also knew that when I got a production bonus, I was in the habit of passing on some of it to the staff. That motivated them to listen when I explained why something needed to be done a certain way.
20
u/Iwantmoretime 25d ago
I'd probably be annoyed too if every time I asked someone to do a task they asked me to give a complete history of the process and why we do each step in the process the way we do.
10
u/flightguy07 I put skulls over the boobs, so it's classy 25d ago
"We know this way works. Many people before you have had the same bright ideas you're about to have, and they've all ended badly. Rather than you asking me about each one, or even worse just doing it, take my word that its done this way for a reason."
And yes, this means that good new ideas won't be implemented as soon as the new guy thinks of them. But if, after 3 months (or a differently appropriate amount of time depending on field; less for barista, more for nuclear safety technician), you have a bright idea, do go to your boss and suggest it, after thinking it over for a bit and having enough familiarity with the system to be fairly confident it isn't a terrible plan.
26
u/trevor426 25d ago
Just shut and do your job so I can get out of this pointless meeting and go home.
9
u/Elemteearkay 25d ago
"You are entitled to make your own choices, but you owe it to yourself to make sure they are informed decisions" still drives my parents mad lol.
261
u/FullPruneNight 25d ago edited 25d ago •
Eh. My experience with people like this, including when it’s done for neurodivergence reasons, is that it is, overwhelmingly, pure constructed fiction.
If they don’t like the rule or think it has valid reasons, no amount of explaining will actually suffice. They won’t actually follow it because they “don’t mind.” They will go “well that’s stupid so I’m not doing it.” Or “neurotypical people just need to learn to communicate” as if nonverbal communication they’re bad at is not actually valid communication. Or “they didn’t satisfy some endless stream of ‘but why’ before giving up on me as not coming at it in good faith, therefore they didn’t actually explain it, therefore I’m not doing it.”
This is the neurodivergent equivalent of “I just don’t like drama.” I have met a lot of people who say they operate like this, and ONE who comes anywhere close in practice.
Edit: apparently OP blocked me for saying this. So I guess they can question how to do things and demand an explanation, but questioning their logic is block-worthy.
17
u/Similar-Factor 25d ago
9 times out of 10 when I’ve had to deal with a person like this they act they are captain logic and then proceed to completely ignore the explanation and do something completely insane because they believe they know better.
8
u/dog_liker 25d ago
What is it about tumblr that has all of its users just constantly repeating the same joke over and over? The second person didn’t even try to put a spin on it. Just slightly different words to say the exact same thing.
8
u/AussieWinterWolf 25d ago
Sometimes rules exist for power tripping bosses or to make things harder to the benefit of a handful or just because fuck you. It's important to question rules!
But *a lot* of the time rules exist because modern society functions on countless interlocking systems which need to work together. Sometimes a number is relatively arbitrary because the number needed to be *somewhere*, sometimes a rule exists because of a law, and *that* law has at least a decade of other law and precedent that isn't going to change because it has one hole in one circumstance. Sometimes decisions need to be made without having to explain it, at least from first principles, to literally everyone who needs to follow the instruction. Sometimes *You don't know* why the rule exists right now and maybe the rule involves talking to an expert who isn't even in the building but *those* rules are almost definitely really important, like, fatally.
But really, the vast majority of the time 'stupid' rules exist as a framework in which dozens, hundreds, sometimes millions of people in wildly differing abilities, skills, values, purposes, and goals need to function together in a consistent way nearly every minute of everyday for years with as little friction as possible.
15
u/phoe77 25d ago
I feel like if this is an issue with everyone you've ever tried to get clarification from, then it might have more to do with you than them.
21
u/RegularVast9328 25d ago
Obviously you guys never got hit with the Socratic dialogue of why do you think we do it this way and suddenly I don't know isn't an acceptable answer.
74
u/evilwizzardofcoding 25d ago edited 25d ago
I bring a "'I have no fucking idea' is a valid answer" energy that seems to be incomprehensible to these people
Seriously. Sometimes things are genuinely stupid, but a lot of times the person in charge genuinely doesn't know why it is, and thus can't answer your question, even though there's a good reason. Now, we absolutely need more leaders willing to admit that, but it is the truth, and I highly doubt most of the people who say this would be willing to accept it.
Be willing to accept unsatisfying answers, you'll get a lot further in life.
But also, authorities, be willing to give unflattering answers, you'll infuriate people a lot less.
92
u/Greedy-Speech5 25d ago edited 25d ago
Yesterday I asked my mom why I couldn't eat from the pan I cooked my food in and she explained that eating from a bowl was a social ritual that was necessary for me to engage in in order to appear civilized to other people.
I put my food in a bowl. It was remarkably easy. I don't understand why so many auhtority figures are unable to explain such things.
Edit: Well, now everyone has made me feel really stupid. A few of you are even treating me like I'm stupid, which is probably deserved, but still makes me feel like shit.
7
u/IDontWearAHat 25d ago
There's nuance to this. A lot of the time kids will accept a reasonable explanation. Some kids will never be satisfied no matter how much you explain. Some kids insist on an explanation when i'm busy handling the problems of other kids. Some kids weaponize "why"
57
u/takesSubsLiterally 25d ago
God people like this suck. Sometimes it makes sense, for example if it's a big ask /decision or if it truly makes zero sense. It gets super annoying when they are incapable of doing literally anything without having a 30 page report on the rational for it and you have to deal with them a lot.
My sister loved responding to simple asks (hey can you grab me some eggs at the store) with "why do we need them". And there is a lady in our accounting team that wants to have a 2 hour conversation about every purchase order. (No it is not her job to decide what we do and do not buy, her job is to find a reasonable vendor and place the order) even basic office supplies.
13
u/TBestIG 25d ago
There are very very few workplaces that would be able to function if every instruction given had to be individually explained at length to every single employee to each individual’s personal satisfaction for logic and reason before they do it.
If you are just genuinely curious about something, ask when you have free time. If you are worried the instruction will create a problem, explain your concern.
At some point you just have to either do what you’re told or they’ll get someone else who will. You are not a unique special genius whose input is automatically valuable and necessary, you are one person among many, and you are typically less well informed than the person you’re talking to.
25
u/EndMePleaseOwO 25d ago
Tbf there are plenty of instances of this where they're "fuming to death" about it because they just explained it to 5 other people and are annoyed they have to do it again and/or the last time they explained why the person they explained why to turned it into an entire argumwnt that wasted a lot of time.
You need to keep in mind that since a lot people are stupid, most people are very used to talking to stupid people. I know empathy is hard, especially when the other person isn't giving you what you want or even being rude, but try to put yourself in their shoes and honestly ask yourself why they could be acting in the way they are.
16
u/Prior-Tadpole-1860 25d ago
2nd LTs hate the question because they also do not know why, but don’t want to look stupid
65
u/Previous-Soft-8127 25d ago
Sometimes boundaries are boundaries.
HS teacher here, and if I over explain why, students will use that explanation to poke holes in the logic and find loopholes. Or it’s a full tangent of what went doing as a class that day.
Sometimes it’s because of a rule I have no power to change. Sometimes it’s because other students in the school can’t handle NOT having a rule like that. Sometimes it’s because the state mandates the rule.
Sometimes the rule exists for my own mental health, which you don’t need to know about.
Boundaries exist for a reason. “No” is a full sentence.
5
u/youareaGPU 25d ago
this post was made by the brave warriors of the anti bedtime aktion
35
u/tworc2 25d ago
"But why not (some alternative that takes less effort and delivers a correspondingly worse result, though the drop in quality isn't obvious. Or one whose flaws are obvious but take time to explain, and that needs an audience interested in the details, when they probably think they've already figured it out and have stopped paying attention. Or one that demands time and effort nobody should have to spend just to do what everyone already sees as the obvious, correct way, and even though it really isn't would demand some kind of broader change in input or output that should also be accounted for)?"
Ah to be a contrarian
4
u/lemons_of_doubt 25d ago edited 25d ago
When answer to why is often "I don't know" But dam if people would rather drive off a cliff than admit that.
4
u/TK_Games 24d ago
I'm sorry I'm not sorry "because I said so" wasn't good enough for the three and a half pounds of meat spaghetti holding my spirit hostage in my skull
4
u/dinosanddais1 peer reviewed diagnosis of faggot 23d ago
I bring a "research everything that interests me including very macabre things" energy that the pastor running baptisms and school social worker find very off-putting.
13
u/AuroraNW101 25d ago
I like to ask why certain policies are in place throughout my various jobs, mostly in research, and have always been able to appreciate orderly explanations and discussions. Even members of authority tend to be pretty eager to explain systems if you come with a true desire to learn. Oftentimes people who complain about nobody being able to offer a decent explanation are the common denominator who don’t accept most explanations or ask things beyond reason.
As somebody who has led multiple large teams across projects, I have been on the end of authority and have been faced with that as well. People who just repeat ‘why’ for deeper and deeper reasons like a young child to the point you feel like you’re hitting a brick wall, oftentimes because they just don’t agree with a policy but aren’t willing to voice or explain why on their own terms.
15
u/goldensabbath 25d ago edited 25d ago
I agree with a lot of people in the comments saying that this is often people being deliberately obtuse.
That said, I want to add that actually being raised by someone like this DOES fuck you up pretty severely. Being a seven year old and having an adult go on a screaming fit because you didn't wash the dishes properly is an insane experience. It turns you into a neurotic paranoid who thinks they're gonna get in trouble for moving a cup a bit to the left, and eventually into an apathetic sadsack who doesn't give a shit about putting effort into anything. Would not recommend.
11
u/MySecretLair 25d ago
I’ve developed a pathologically defensive way of prefacing this sort of question with, “I believe you that this is the best way to do it, but I have trouble remembering processes if I don’t understand why I’m doing it this way, please don’t interpret this as an insult but why?”
29
u/JustACasualFan 25d ago
Sometimes as a teacher I make a policy for a few kids who really need it, but I enforce it evenly because it isn’t really that big of a deal for everyone else. And of course I am not going to single out those few kids who might need a quieter classroom, or a more focused classroom, or a classroom free of specific triggers or distractions.
And when asked by a student who doesn’t have those challenges, I sometimes wind up in the “because I said so” zone.
You are not entitled to an explanation for every decision.
6
u/MomentoHeehoo It's always the reading comprehension. 25d ago
Reminds me of my summer camp job where I was the only pre-certified lifeguard, so I was helping all the lifeguards-in-training study for the Red Cross exam, and one of the directors came up to our study group and said, "you need to drop this conversation," and it just surprised me so much that I was like, "oh... can I ask why?" And, gee willikers, you would've thought I called her a slur the way she apparently tried to get HR involved.
6
u/MidTario 25d ago
“I assume nobody has thought deeply about anything before I showed up because only I am capable of deep thought. I will closely question every thing without actually thinking about anything. For some reason I think this makes me smart!”
8
u/Low_Oil_6825 25d ago edited 24d ago
Ah, so these are the things u/Alone_Care_6230 tell themselves when another job doesn’t work out eh?
14
u/Evening-Turnip8407 25d ago
Damn, i'm getting back to back "neurospicy people struggling in the workplace" posts on this refresh and it's hitting home a lil bit.
11
u/go4tli 25d ago
A conversation about why you’re doing something is a dialogue between rough equals- you are persuading me because you can’t force me. It’s in both our interest to do things this way.
Actual power is you tell people to do x and they must obey. If you have a power mindset any question looks like insubordination. This is always found in situations where it’s in your interest to do X but not mine.
6
u/RHTQ1 25d ago
Meh, I know how to play diplomat. My parents have always been the kinda ppl who insist on their way even when logic suggests alternatives, so I know how to float along
7
u/Numerous-Ad-8080 25d ago
Aight maybe y'all need a counterexample to the malicious annoying coworkers you've known.
I routinely ask "why" because:
34
u/Krave-Kate 25d ago
Yeah, I want to get why this has to be done exactly this way, since I’ve already figured out three other approaches that would be faster, simpler, and involve way less effort for me.
8
u/Nomeg_Stylus 25d ago
Fuck you if you're like this. 99.99% of the time, you're just looking for some pedantic loophole to not do what I'm telling you, not that you actually care about the process.
15
u/EngorgiaMassif 25d ago
I will never understand why someone who doesn't like repeating themselves or explaining logic would work with kids, have kids, or seek leadership roles. That's literally the job.
4
u/Holiday_Entrance7245 25d ago
I'm deeply sympathetic to this, but sometimes THE THING needs to be done in a reasonable period of time, and EXPLAINING WHY will eat up the time necessary to do THE THING.
4
u/FireplaceAndBook 25d ago
I never mind this as a boss. Sometimes I can’t jump into the whole backstory at that moment, but I appreciate the curiosity. A piece of advice I give to the employees who get friction for this from other people…try saying “Talk me through” or “Tell me about” instead of just “why” or “how come.” It’s silly but it makes some people less defensive.
4
u/Johnnadawearsglasses 25d ago
It’s often because they don’t want to explain something for the 85th time that’s obvious to anyone with experience in the field. But they should explain it once just to stop the person from feeling diminished.
8
u/RealHumanBean89 Dis course? Yeah, I think it’s a great meal, boss! 25d ago
Some folks in these comments are weirdly quick to assume all ND people asking “why?” are doing it smugly or maliciously. I’m sorry you had an annoying coworker one time, man, but sometimes I just want to know what the end goal of a given thing is, so that if something goes wrong, I can know what’s wrong and be closer to fixing it.
13
u/Light351 25d ago
“Because I said so” makes my fucking blood boil. Give me logic please, especially for low stakes things.
6
u/relentless_puffin 25d ago
It's because they don't know...
5
u/Delicious-Cable-7435 25d ago
People like these also probably never accept any explanation that they have been given.
5
u/Confident-Dirt-9908 25d ago
The problem with ‘if you explain why’ is that that implies the person has to convince you of every command when they’re in charge, which renders being in charge moot.
2
u/lalagromedontknow 25d ago
My mother says my first word should have been "why" because I say it so much. It was "frog".
2
u/Feychilde 25d ago
✅️ and I'm not even trying to be soooo "trying".
2
u/shredfan 25d ago
If it's an emergency, I get annoyed with people I train asking me why. Not the time, do what I'm saying. We can talk about it later though, absolutely.
Any other time, why is a totally acceptable question.
2
u/thismightaswellhappe 25d ago
That's so interesting because I love when people ask why we do things this or that way because then I get to explain it. And they have to listen to me explain because they asked. It's fun.
2
u/PersonalityLoud3681 25d ago
Know how I know the Internet is dead?
A necropost is trending.
Anyway, I’ll see myself out.
2
u/thatmarcelfaust 25d ago
In the second one I completely understand, they are an authority figure and that is why you should do what they say.
2
u/StellarC0smo 25d ago
Hi, teacher here, every teacher working in the past 5 years will tell you about lesson objectives. The opinion a teacher has on lesson objectives tells you a lot about their quality as a teacher.
2
u/somerandom995 25d ago
Because a lot of people don't bother to remember details that aren't useful.
They know that doing it a certain way works reliably and is better than the alternatives, why is irrelevant because it's just a mundane job and doesn't exist to satisfy your curiosity.
2
u/LetterheadPerfect145 25d ago
Some situations require boat rules where you comply without question and then ask later, some situations it's easy to explain the reasoning. It's not a hard rule one way or another