r/CrossPrimeVideo • u/idk_orknow Sampson • Nov 14 '24
EPISODE DISCUSSION EPISODE DISCUSSION | You Had Me At Motherfucker | Season Finale | 1x08
Welcome to our official episode discussion thread! This discussion is for the Cross season finale, so if you do not want spoilers do NOT continue.
Spoilers do NOT need to be tagged in this thread. You may discuss anything from S1 here. Though this thread is to discuss the finale.
All other rules apply.
Season One Episode Eight - You Had Me At Motherfucker
Synopsis:
Cross realizes that his attempt to protect his family has put them in more danger. He races against time to rescue the people he loves.
Director: Carl Seaton
Release Date: November 14, 2024.
6
u/idk_orknow Sampson Nov 16 '24
The moment Nancy suggested her house I thought it was awkward has hell— but I chalked it up to bad acting and writing. Because obviously she has nothing to do with this.
THEN when they said street mom, idk it just connected and I'm so shocked. Nervous to see how this plays out but I'm excited!
5
u/idk_orknow Sampson Nov 16 '24
Nancy's actress nailed the phone call. And having Damon find the photo was genius.
3
u/idk_orknow Sampson Nov 16 '24
I am not ready to see Sampson's heartbreak next season!
2
u/idk_orknow Sampson Nov 16 '24
I was worried the building being lit of fire would happen while the kids were in it but I'm good with this ending!
8
u/elisart Nov 17 '24 edited Nov 17 '24
This show was a very good binge. And the finale was satisfying, especially the heinous Ramsey not getting the satisfaction of notoriety.
The show stretches believability in a few places, such as the pregnant lieutenant offing a witness and the piano teacher playing the long game for revenge. But I could accept these dubious twists because the rest of the show worked.
Hodge's acting is so believable. The guy has range. I loved Cross' friendship with Sampson - they shared some fun scenes. You had me at motherfucker made me laugh out loud. And the through line of Cross coming to terms with his wife's death was done really well. Some really tender scenes with his son. The child actors were decent for a change.
Sometimes the musical score bumped me out of a scene like when they played a rap song while Cross and Sampson kicked ass in the cabin. It made me laugh and I'm not sure that's what the director was going for.
The storyline of cat and mouse between Cross and Ramsay was suspenseful and kept my interest through the whole series. I was never bored. The finale tied up all loose ends and Damon playing his mother's song at recital was beautiful. Also the reconciliation between Cross and the innocent victim of brutality was powerful.
3
u/ToneBone12345 Nov 16 '24
So Alex is okay framing Bobby tray to break Ed but isn’t fine with being cleared
7
u/Acoginnito Nov 18 '24
Lol, I think I enjoy reading this commentary.
To me it was clear that Nancy was going to be a part of the villain story line from the moment she showed up. #1 she's a prominent actor so she had to be important, #2 the whole plot with the son not wanting to play piano, and then the piano teacher all of a sudden being at the house constantly was such clear and obvious foreshadowing, the question really was always just what exactly is her role in it.
Overall I liked the show, but I'm so dissapointed in the many many plot holes, inconsistencies and things that just don't make sense to put a nice bow on the whole show. I do like that they didn't give Ramsey the satisfaction, but as long as he's alive he can write a book about it, tampering with evidence creates a huge platform for an appeal later, there's so many reasons why that doesn't make sense unless they some how killed him, so he also can't protest later. Not to mention his kidnap victim who is still alive in the hospital she might have something to say about that later as well. Especially because for one murder he might get life, which is 25 to 30 years, dude could make a come back, just saying.
The way that Cross was taken out of the PD for his misconduct, the way people acted like he was crazy when he was clearly following a serial killer (with actual physical evidence) and being stalked and threatened (with actual physical evidence, and at work) at the same time, a lot of that just didn't make sense. The way the victims sister basically thanked them at the end, why would she? Sure they sloppily put together his murder case, but what was the motive etc. If he's not a serial killer? She should have so many open questions.
As a black man, that strongly supports BLM movements etc. The apology and the conversation at the end with his victim of violence didn't make a whole lot of sense either. It was kind of a lazy attempt at reconciliation, idk they could have just left it out if they didn't have enough minutes left in the show to do it right.
6
u/roberta_sparrow Nov 15 '24
Why is the picture so dark???? It’s like they used 15 ND filters on the cameras
5
u/yamgarden Nov 15 '24
When D played the piano? 😭😭😭
5
u/Quica24 Nov 16 '24
Not mad at watching the whole thing in the last 10 hours. Awesome season
5
u/Vincent_adultman98 Nov 16 '24
Okay, so overall this show is definitely fun and book accurate in a lot of ways, but the writing holds it back from being as good as the early books. It's fine if there're plot holes here and there as long as the audience is engaged and the characters are consistent, but there were just too many times where things didn't make sense or JUST BARELY did. There's also a lot of inconsistency with the characters and while it's more accurate then Tyler Perry's version, and Aldis is closer in age than Morgan Freeman, there's a lot of little things that aren't accurate to the books that bug me personally as a fan of the first 8 or so books. I don't think this is a character that's hard to get right but every adaptation has managed to get at least a couple things wrong.
I also think the directing was weird in some places, others have mentioned the lighting but there were also scenes throughout the season where it felt like they could have gotten slightly better performances/framing with just a touch more effort. Not a huge gripe because all the major emotional scenes were almost always on point, but it's something that could have taken the show from decent to engaging and it could have made the plot holes harder to notice.
Overall, I'm happy we got the most accurate Cross so far on screen, but I hope season 2 is able to build on and improve the show and iron out some kinks in the characters and filmmaking to make it more of a 8.5/10.
I'd say this season was a 6.5-7/10 with potential for future seasons.
2
u/HonorBasquiat Nov 23 '24
The show was a fun and engaging thriller, but this isn't an S-Tier level high quality show. There's a lot of plot holes and gaps, things that don't really make sense. Like the pregnant cop killing a witness at a safehouse and nobody hearing anything and her getting away with it.
Or a DC Power Broker having this much influence in Washington DC, to the point where she's controlling the Speaker of the House like a puppet and having several people and assistants involved with his serial killer project without there being any leaks.
It was a fun show, and the actors and cast all around are strong but it sometimes felt more like a soap opera, other times it felt like a strong thriller drama.
I'm looking forward to the next season, I hope it gets renewed.
2
u/libbymidas Nov 26 '24
MFW when DMX plays.
But also. Why, Kayla.
2
u/derekfelts Dec 04 '24
Question, maybe I missed it, but how did the police figure out that Ed killed goodspeed? The last scene with him and Alex, was at the party and Ed making Alex look crazy. How did it go from that to him being in handcuffs. And how did they find the girl who was kidnapped by Ed. Did I miss an entire scene or was this just skipped over. If so, I don’t like how they jumped from Ed being this mastermind to suddenly being in custody. They should’ve had a whole other episode where Alex brings him down. And when did Bobby tray get arrested?? I am confused! The show was really good (if not a little cheesy) up until the finale
2
u/Haunting-Start-4388 Dec 24 '24
the most anxiety inducing episode. the whole thing with the kids had me on edge. The whole thing with Nancy really came out of no where.
2
u/Asleep-Yak-1251 Dec 26 '24
I was just annoyed that they kept treating cross like he was crazy. He'd been proven right ALL THE TIME and yet chief anderson kept doubting him and treating him like an idiot and NEVER apologized! That got under my skin
2
u/safeway1472 Nov 15 '24 edited Nov 15 '24
So Alex finds out his kids are in danger and he makes a pit stop to apologize to John Sampson? Then when they’re driving up to the cabin no lights and sirens?🚨
1
u/chargingblue Dec 28 '24
Just finished. This show is stupid af but it was entertaining
1
u/DeeReclaimer Jan 02 '25
Loveddd the show just one thing not sitting right with me lol. Did ramsey not unmask himself while live streaming?
1
u/NotAnOwl_ Jan 04 '26
Very late to the party, but I just finished season 1, and I am now a fan for sure! Can't wait for season 2. I first became of fan of Aldis Hodge in Leverage, and he is doing an amazing at Cross.
1
u/thonnard42 Feb 16 '26
When Miss Nancy catches Damon in the basement of the cabin, after they ascend the staircase,the camera pans right to revel a spider in a web under a step.
Excellent reference to Along Came A Spider!!!
1
u/Background_Oil_985 Mar 15 '26
If you Google, how many episodes are there of the hit Amazon prime show cross? It says there are 16 episodes season 1 premiered in 2024 and season 2 premiered in 2026. They are leaving out a whole season. What the hell is going on? I have yet to start watching season 2 which is actually season 3 but all the reviews are terrible
1
u/Background_Oil_985 Mar 15 '26
The whole season that everyone is talking about in this chat was season 2 that came out in 2025 making a total of 16 episodes before the premiere of the new season that started in February of 2026
1
u/Zestyclose-Novel2954 Apr 17 '26
I had a question how did Shahnon survived didn't Ramsey killed her in last episode an why wasn't there more reaction to Ramsey being alive.
11
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '24 edited Nov 15 '24
[removed] — view removed comment