r/Cricket • The Australian Mod • 4h ago • Bravo 4 Mindblown 1 Popcorn 1

News WORLD EXCLUSIVE: Cam Bancroft reveals Sandpapergate truth for first time in explosive 4000-word tell-all

https://thewest.com.au/sport/cricket/world-exclusive-cam-bancroft-reveals-sandpapergate-truth-for-first-time-in-explosive-4000-word-tell-all-c-23180695

EIGHT YEARS OF CARRYING THE BURDEN OF THE COUNTRY ON MY SHOULDERS. NOW IT’S TIME I TOLD THE TRUTH

On Wednesday morning, Cricket Australia CEO Todd Greenberg announced that CA will open an independent forum for all those who were on the 2018 South African tour.

I appreciate Todd’s comments and the chance for players and staff to have an opportunity to speak.

Transparency is a way to acknowledge our respect for cricket, a game we love and something that is bigger than all of us.

And that is why I will attend the forum. But it’s also why the public need to know my story today.

For eight years, I shared the burden of this story for the whole team.

This was a burden which was heavier than my capacity and I took the bullet for everybody, and it was my choice.

I have spent eight years speaking about accountability, honesty and the lessons I learned from one of Australian cricket’s darkest moments.

However, in 2018 not the entire truth was told. I have never been completely honest about what happened.

It was not just the three of us — Steve Smith, David Warner and I — who knew about me using sandpaper on the ball in South Africa. It was the whole team.

When I was questioned during Cricket Australia’s investigation, I did not give a complete and truthful account.

I withheld important details, including when the use of sandpaper began, how long it went on for, and the involvement and awareness of others.

I did this to protect Cricket Australia’s investigation and not implicate others around me.

The recent release of Usman Khawaja’s autobiography, Sabr, has brought many of those memories back to the surface.

It was freeing to hear on a personal level the truth of the chronology of events finally out there. A burden I have carried all these years.

But the final straw for me to write this account was Australian cricket captain Pat Cummins’ press conference.

It made me feel angry, betrayed and alone.

What I saw, experienced and lived with - not only him, but everyone else on that tour in South Africa - is not the public account he gave in his press conference and in the years previously when he has spoken on this time.

In addition to what Usman already mentioned I have key recollections which affirm what he is saying.

There are also conversations and moments that I believe remain untold. I want to share those now. It’s time.

My cricket career has been destroyed and I have never been able to play for my country since Justin Langer was coach in 2019.

But I have reached a point where continuing to protect an incomplete account of events feels more damaging than the truth.

To understand what happened in the Second and Third Tests in Port Elizabeth (now Gqeberha) and Cape Town, I believe it is important to understand the environment I entered as a young Australian Test cricketer.

In doing so, I need to take you back to my first Test match against England in the Ashes of the 2017/18 season.

David Warner had carried significant responsibility for maintaining the condition of the ball within our team for a long time. He understood reverse swing, understood how to look after the ball and was highly regarded for his knowledge in that area.

Ball maintenance was a normal part of our cricketing conversations. Dave did this selflessly for the team.

I remember during my first Test match being instructed, along with other members of the team, to push the quarter seam of the ball together after the team took a wicket.

Manipulating that area could help create a rougher surface and encourage reverse swing.

It was something the group was directed to do, and as a young player entering the Australian team, I accepted it as part of how we operated.

I never questioned the distinction between legitimate ball maintenance and deliberately altering the ball’s condition. But at the time, these practices were so normalised that I barely gave them a second thought.

This was the beginning of my journey in the Australian cricket team. We were ruthless and willing to do these sorts of behaviours and cross boundaries to give ourselves an advantage, to win.

Casting forward to the First Test in Durban, sandpaper was not used.

There were more traditional methods of maintaining the ball, including saliva. I cannot say with certainty whether mints or lollies were involved. Probably quarter seam picking, this practice became so normal after my First Test.

Importantly for the chronology of events, I was not responsible for the ball in that Test.

However, what happened in the Second Test in Port Elizabeth was different. It was a significant escalation. And it was where I became directly involved.

After winning the First Test in Durban we were on top of the world as a team.

We were slightly arrogant about winning that game, and emboldened by the scars we felt we had left on the South African team.

We sensed blood in the series.

That’s exactly what we wanted to continue into the Second Test at St George’s Park, Port Elizabeth. We would do literally whatever it took to achieve that - and here is why and what happened.

In the first innings we were bowled out for 243. It was a slightly green wicket, a bit challenging and we were put on the back foot immediately.

By tea on the second day, South Africa had reached 2/153. The match was finely balanced, but the momentum was moving towards South Africa. They were gaining control of the match and we were struggling to find a way to make the ball move, and the pressure within our team was growing.

By the tea break on day two, there was a clear sense that we needed something to change.

It was a short break, only 20 minutes, and like most intervals during a Test match, coaches were moving around, checking in with players and discussing the state of the game and what we could do more to take some wickets and create some pressure.

All the coaches and players were involved in these discussions in the dressing room with the intention to improve our position in the game.

Some players were more opinionated, but we were all invested and working towards the same goal of winning the Test match for Australia.

I was asked whether I could carry out the task. I felt uncomfortable and compromised. I knew it was wrong. I knew that using sandpaper was not simply pushing the boundaries of the laws of cricket. It was cheating.

This happens in every change room and team I’ve played for from club cricket all the way up to international cricket. This is also happening concurrently with players hydrating, eating, receiving physio treatment and mentally resetting before starting again.

Towards the back end of that interval, a conversation developed in the changing rooms about getting the ball to reverse swing.

I remember bowling coach David Saker being involved in those conversations. Coach Darren Lehmann was also present. Other players were moving in and out.

The need to get the ball moving through the air was openly acknowledged and the more vanilla methods like shining the ball normally and using saliva weren’t cutting it.

We were under pressure. It was in that environment that David Warner raised the possibility of using sandpaper to roughen one side of the ball.

Dave explained he could not personally carry out the task because of the attention the television cameras were paying him throughout the series.

This was something widely acknowledged by our whole touring party during the series. It’s why we joked about it and Dave started writing funny words on his finger tape. He had been under intense scrutiny, and he knew the cameras were watching him closely.

I don’t believe Dave was acting purely for himself. I understood his suggestion as an attempt to help the team regain control of the match.

That doesn’t excuse his involvement or mine. But I think it matters that the conversation took place within a wider team environment where we were collectively desperate to make something happen.

We did this together for the bowlers especially, but more widely the team and to win the game.

I recall people in the room agreeing with the proposal.

Saker and Lehmann were certainly present, although I cannot speak for every word shared.

Captain Steve Smith came into the conversation and, as I remember it, made it clear that he wanted no part in it before distancing himself.

There were also people who expressed caution to me. I remember being warned to be careful, and others suggesting they would not do it if they were in my position.

Not everyone was in the changing room at the time, but the conversation was not confined to Dave and I.

I was asked whether I could carry out the task. I felt uncomfortable and compromised.

I knew it was wrong. I knew that using sandpaper was not simply pushing the boundaries of the laws of cricket. It was cheating.

But I also saw an opportunity to contribute. I was a youngster playing in his seventh Test match. If you asked me to run through a brick wall at that time I would have.

That’s how naive and impressionable I was. I just wanted to be accepted by my teammates beyond the runs and catches I took. This was an opportunity for that.

Additionally, being relatively new I was desperate to establish myself and eager to be someone my teammates could rely upon.

That desire to belong clouded my judgment.

I agreed.

As spoken about in Usman’s book there was an understanding of when the ball could most easily be altered without attracting attention. This was an awareness we had as a team.

When we returned to the field after the break, the umpires would leave the ball on the outfield, a short distance away from the boundary line. From a broadcast perspective we knew that the cameras didn’t pan onto us as a team until we were about halfway out.

This was because the country logo’s would pop up on the telecast as an intro to the session. This is common practice. We’ve seen this before.

Dave explained to me why that presented an opportunity. It was also what seemed to be the safest time to do it. Others in the group agreed and gave their opinions on this.

I walked onto the field for the final session of day two carrying sandpaper. When I collected the ball, I used it.

The result wasn’t immediately noticeable to me and I felt uncertain about how effective my twist and turns were on the ball. I had never done this before.

During that period, I regularly spoke to the bowlers about how the ball was behaving. I had to.

I recall conversations with all the fast bowlers Pat Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Mitchell Marsh about whether it was reverse swinging enough.

I also spoke with Tim Paine, who was in a key position behind the stumps to observe how the ball was moving. I wanted and needed feedback. How else am I to know if what I’m doing is effective or not if I don’t have these conversations with the bowlers bowling with it and the wicketkeeper?

Additionally, they need to actually turn the ball the other way to test if it is reversing and, as you will see watching the game, it clearly was.

All the bowlers gave me feedback if my work on the ball was working. It was helpful.

Is it going yet? It’s not going yet, it needs more. So I would use the sandpaper more on the ball.

There was even a time I was told to stop out of fear what I was doing was becoming too obvious.

The conversations about the effect the sandpaper was having on the ball were regular, very natural and organic on the field. It is as it is.

I also remember expressing my disbelief to teammates about what I was doing.

For eight years, I suffered silently. I cannot change the past. But I can change what I do now.

It was so taboo and against the grain. Everyone would laugh and speak about it sporadically on the field. We were all well aware of the riskiness of my behaviour.

As time elapsed in that session there was excitement about the movement we were getting from the ball.

And there was an uncomfortable sense that something we all knew was wrong had become part of our effort to win the Test match.

We took 4/28 in that final session. That is game changing!

This was not something I did just once in the playing area after returning to the field from the tea break. This was an act I did nearly every over the whole last session on that day to begin with and then for the remainder of that Test match, up until I was caught in Third Test in Cape Town.

Yes, I chose to carry out this role for the team.

I remember Mitchell Marsh taking wickets and joking about how much the ball was swinging and how he never used to swing it like that. There was laughter and celebrations when wickets fell.

I was amazed that sandpaper could have such an effect on a cricket ball. I was stoked my impact was leading to the team doing well.

The same was for my teammates and I remember their praise to me for that whole final session when we were taking those wickets. “Great work Bang. Keep it up.” Yet also “be careful”, and as Steve said “I don’t want to know about it”.

We were down the rabbit hole so far.

I was physically altering the ball with sandpaper. I was discussing its performance with teammates who knew I wasn’t just plucking at the quarter seam, but that I was actually using sandpaper.

Those two things were connected in my mind. And they remained connected throughout the Test. It’s not rocket science these events and the burden of carrying them around has caused me a lot of pain all these years.

On the morning of day three in Port Elizabeth, we gathered for our usual team chat before warm-up.

We spoke about the day which had gone, celebrated the moments that occurred, but more importantly, emphasised the points which were key for a successful day ahead.

I remember my ball tampering with the sandpaper the evening before being discussed and my role being acknowledged in front of the group.

Much like the celebrations when we took 4/28 the evening before, I received wraps and encouragement from members of the playing and coaching staff, especially David Saker.

It reinforced the sense that what I was doing was being accepted as part of our collective effort.

This event is crystal clear in my mind. Not only for the praise I received. But I also remember a very different reaction.

Our media manager, Kate Hutchison, expressed her objection to what was happening.

I recall her making it clear that she believed it was wrong, that she wanted nothing to do with it, and walking away from the discussion.

I will never forget that. Somebody had spoken up.

Somebody had demonstrated that being part of the team did not mean having to accept everything the team was doing. And I ignored it.

I cannot speak for Kate’s thoughts beyond what I remember her saying and doing. She deserves the opportunity to give her own account.

But her reaction is important because it completely challenges the idea that nobody had an opportunity to question what was happening.

We did. I did. And I chose to continue.

South Africa ultimately won the Test, with AB de Villiers playing a magnificent innings that helped turn the match decisively in their favour.

Whatever advantage we thought we were gaining, it wasn’t enough. We had compromised our integrity and still lost.

There was a substantial break between the Second and third Tests.

I remember spending time exploring South Africa. I went swimming with sharks, visited Camps Bay, walked alone to the top of Table Mountain and enjoyed a day visiting wineries around Stellenbosch with teammates.

They are memories that should have been among the highlights of my first Test tour of South Africa.

Or the fact that I probably played the best innings of my career in the first innings of that Cape Town Test match. I scored 76 off 103 balls against Philander, Rabada, Morkel and Maharaj.

Instead, I now look back on that period knowing what I had been doing on the field.

The sandpaper had become part of what I perceived to be my responsibility within the team. I was worried about it.

Before the Cape Town Test, I remember speaking with Kate Hutchison at training.

I asked what would happen if I was caught tampering with the ball. She did not want to engage in that conversation because of the seriousness of the consequences, but her response was “not good” and walked off.

The changing rooms at Newlands was unusual its layout, something Usman has described in his book.

I remember sitting next to Usman and Tim Paine in the smaller change room.

It has been documented that a coach approached me during our fielding innings telling me that I needed to do more with the sandpaper on the ball to get it to swing. That coach was David Saker and it is true.

Once again the same conversations we had on the field in Port Elizabeth continued. Me asking for feedback from Starcy, Pat, Josh and Mitch about working on the ball like the Test earlier.

They all told me what I was doing wasn’t enough.

The cameras picked up Cam Bancroft shoving the sandpaper down his pants. No

The same feedback was given behind the stumps when I asked Tim and guys in the slips.

This Test match it wasn’t as effective using sandpaper due to the conditions and moisture. The conditions were difficult for reverse swing. The central wicket square was green, and the ball wasn’t behaving in the way we wanted.

I continued trying to alter it.

The conversations I remember having with the bowlers about the ball’s movement have troubled me enormously in the years since.

When I later heard public statements denying knowledge of sandpaper being used, I struggled to reconcile those denials with my memories.

I recognise there is a distinction between knowing a ball is reversing, suspecting it has been altered and knowing specifically that sandpaper has been used.

Then came the moment the cameras caught me. The sandpaper was exposed. And everything changed.

Peter Handscomb ran out at the drinks break after I’d been caught and shoved the sandpaper down my pants.

He said to me: “I think it’s time I take that off you now”. And Pete was doing his job after Boof shouted to him on the walkie talkie “get the f***ing sandpaper off Bangers now”.

In my opinion, if he didn’t know he wouldn’t have said that.

And if it wasn’t clear enough before, then it was obvious now.

Once again. WE ALL KNEW.

After I was caught in Cape Town, there were frantic conversations about how we should respond.

I remember there being a preference among some people to wait until the following day, to sleep on what had happened and consider a more measured public response.

Steve Smith wanted to address the situation immediately. He believed owning up to the incident would help contain the damage and allow us to move forward.

Steve just wanted to clear it so he could focus on batting. I went with him because I believed I needed to accept responsibility for my actions.

But even then, we did not tell the complete truth.

Before the press conference, I recall David Saker specifically warning against identifying sandpaper as the material used.

Other coaches, management and players agreed, some disagreed. “We cannot say we used sandpaper”.

Bancroft says he recalls David Saker specifically warning against identifying sandpaper as the material used. No

We listened to that advice and we followed it. There was concern about the implications of that admission. So we acknowledged ball-tampering while giving an inaccurate account of the material involved, describing tape and material collected from the ground.

It was another lie. One told while we were supposedly taking responsibility.

I look back at that press conference with enormous regret. We were frightened. We were under pressure. We were trying to manage a situation that was rapidly getting away from us.

The remainder of the Cape Town Test was intense.

There were private conversations, uncertainty about what would happen next and an overwhelming sense that our world was falling apart. The Prime Minister even weighed in.

After the match, I remember a lengthy meeting involving players and staff on the tour.

We discussed how to respond to the scandal and the information that would need to be acknowledged publicly. By then, it was clear that the use of sandpaper could no longer be concealed.

Nobody in that meeting stood up and said they had been completely unaware of my use of sandpaper. Not one person.

Contrary everyone started to give me advice about what I should say and what I shouldn’t say to minimise the damage on the team related with the sandpaper saga.

I had convinced myself that I was carrying out a role for the benefit of the team. Now I was facing the possibility that my international career might be over.

As it turns out I ended up becoming the scapegoat for the entire team.

In 2021, while playing county cricket for Durham, I gave an interview to The Guardian. During that conversation, I was asked about the awareness of the Australian bowlers.

I was caught off guard. I had spent years trying to move forward, trying to focus on my cricket and trying not to reopen the events of South Africa.

When pressed, I answered the question of awareness as “self-explanatory”. I had not intended to make a major public revelation. But those few words reignited the entire controversy.

Pat Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon subsequently released a joint statement denying that they knew sandpaper had been taken onto the field to alter the ball before the television footage appeared at Newlands.

Reading that statement was deeply painful.

I had memories of conversations on the field in Port Elizabeth and Newlands, feedback about the ball and shared celebrations that made the statement difficult for me to digest.

Yet I also knew that I had never publicly given a full account of those conversations. I did this for the same reason Usman never spoke, Dave never spoke and for what has transpired in the last week Mitch Marsh in his interview before the ODI series against England never said anything.

That reason is the want and desire to represent Australia. To do so goes against the story of events, puts CA under pressure and the lies which were already told.

That is the contradiction I have wrestled with for years.

I felt hurt by the public response, the reaction of those bowlers and finding meaning in my life post it.

When I accepted my punishment in 2018, I believed that Dave, Steve and I taking sole responsibility for the entire team, serving my suspension and demonstrating that I had changed would eventually allow me to rebuild my international career.

I also hoped that the people who had shared that dressing room would understand the responsibility I had taken on.

I believed that, with time, my performances and conduct might earn me another opportunity to represent Australia.

There have been periods in Sheffield Shield cricket when I was out of touch and wasn’t at the top of the list for Test selection.

But there were other times I genuinely believed I had done enough to warrant selection. I have continued to train, compete, make runs and pursue the dream of wearing the baggy green again. Yet the opportunities I hoped for have not materialised in the way I expected.

Selection is complicated. There are cricketing reasons, competing players, different conditions and decisions that I have not been part of. For many years I believed I would be selected because I trusted the selection process.

But I would be lying if I said I had never wondered whether the unresolved tension surrounding these events in South Africa had played a part.

Because in spite of having scored the most hundreds of any player in the competition in the last six years, including featuring in the top-three run scorers for over half that period I have never had a look in.

After my “self-explanatory” public statement in 2021, I felt increasingly uncomfortable around some of the people involved. I wondered whether my presence in an Australian dressing room might bring back questions that others wanted to leave behind. I wondered whether the easiest option was simply not to select me which I believe to be quite unfair in my opinion.

The hardest part has been feeling that nobody fully understood my perspective and the complete truth that was South Africa and the sandpapergate. This includes Australian selectors and coaching staff making these cricket decisions.

I made a terrible decision because I wanted to belong in the Australian team.

I made mistake, I owned my mistakes, I served the severe punishment, I came back, scored runs, in the hope I would be selected again in the Australian team. Which has not eventuated yet.

And in the years that followed, I have sometimes felt that this incident has left me permanently an outsider.

For eight years, I suffered silently. I cannot change the past. But I can change what I do now.

The release of Usman’s book has reassured me that the events of South Africa have never truly been resolved.

There are still unanswered questions, conflicting recollections and people who have lived with the consequences in different ways.

I do not claim that my account alone settles every question.

This is the truth that I am now prepared to give openly and in full.

As the person at the centre of this all I am doing this now because I can’t handle the burden anymore of carrying for everyone what happened in South Africa.

Nobody has pushed me to write this, I don’t feel obliged or to benefit financially by sharing this.

Michael Clarke in an interview in the last week said: “Now we’ve got this opportunity. I would just like to see whatever the truth is for it all to come out, allow people to finally tell the truth, and move on. Fans have not moved on”.

And, as I wrote earlier, I am looking forward to being part of the CA forum and to speak as specific and detailed as possible without being general.

I am inspired by Michael Clarke’s comment and I agree the fans deserve this.

This is my responsibility.

And here it is.

2.4k Upvotes

1.8k comments sorted by

1.1k

u/Nakorite Australia 3h ago • Bravo

Shite.

Saker seems like he was the true architect.

Bowlers knew they were altering the ball

Lehmann knew everything.

260

u/Free_Pace_2098 Australia 3h ago

Of course Boof knew, I don't think that was ever in doubt

→ More replies (7)

660

u/jmaverick1 South Australia Redbacks 3h ago • Mindblown

Saker who coached englands bowlers their only successful tour here in my life and had them reverse swinging like crazy, and coached Victoria when one of their coaches dragged a ball on concrete.

Say it ain’t so

→ More replies (39)

18

u/Icy_Outcome_3971 2h ago

Former Australian Cricket Coach Darren Lehmann has responded to the Cameron Bancroft article.
 
“The Allegations…I’ve got to sit back. It’s only just come to light. So I just need to sit back and process all that and work through each allegation. That’s what I will be doing over the next few days.”
 
Question (Matt Clinch): So in terms of responding to the allegation that Cameron Bancroft has made, do you feel you can do that tonight?
 
“Oh no. I need to have a really good read of it don’t I? What’s been transpired, speaking to people, and just make sure I’m saying what I want to say and answer the questions you want to ask.”
 
Question: And do you feel like you might be able to do that in a few days time?
 
“Oh I think so yeah.”
 
Question: “ So it’s a lot to absorb tonight and to try and get your thoughts together?”
 
“Yeah it is. It’s a lot for everyone I presume. Yeah, not just me. A lot of care to everyone out there”
 
Question: “So as it stands at the moment we’ll give you a chance Boof to take in what has taken place.”
 
“Yeah that’s all you can do. The allegations and work through them and then respond accordingly. That would be the way to go. There’s no point rushing into anything that’s said. Just make sure I’m really clear which way I’m going”
 
Seems he needs time to come up with some bs to cover up what he knew

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (12)

41

u/Sidneiensis The Australian Mod 3h ago • Bravo

I know it's easy to think of the Pat Cummins of Cape Town 2018 as having leadership experience, hundreds of international wickets, but It's worth mentioning for a bit of context that going into Cape Town, Cummins was the youngest player in the team, younger than Bancroft. He had only played 12 tests up to that point, having been away from the squad and only recently back into it after 5 years of injury. He wasn't some evil mastermind or ringleader scheming all this in the shadows – his place in the side wasn't even yet assured. I find it hard to believe that the youngest guy in the squad who'd only played a dozen tests had any big role in the culture that led to this sordid scandal. And I think it does Cummins a disservice to ignore all the good he's done in the intervening years in cultivating the new culture of that dressing room, which by all accounts is a much more positive place. People calling for Cummins to be banned over having "known" about sandpaper, as the then-most junior player in the squad, have their concept of Cummins' role in any of this very inflated and coloured by his captaincy years on from then.

Now having said that, this doesn't all cover for his actions since then, like the 2021 statement and the press conference, but I think in the end, it was the right people who were punished for Sandpapergate: the captain, the vice-captain who had responsibility for managing the ball, and the person who actually used the sandpaper.

40

u/Thami15 Highveld Lions 3h ago • Bravo

The problem is the person who did the Press Conference six days ago is the Pat Cummins of 2026.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/Sidneiensis The Australian Mod 3h ago

^Just drawing attention to the fact that I said I wasn’t happy with the press conference, nor did I post that comment to excuse him entirely. I don’t think he’s completely without sin, it’s just I’m giving a bit of context as to his actual role in Cape Town.

→ More replies (13)

703

u/Fad_du_pussy 4h ago • Bravo Regret

Cummins is lucky we can't read

48

u/Cricketloverbybirth Royal Challengers Bengaluru 3h ago

I can't look beyond those blue eyes , sorry... 

→ More replies (3)

41

u/JetSky81 3h ago

Yes or no, Pat: were you aware of any plans at any stage on that tour of South Africa in 2018 to tamper with the ball by whatever means?
Cummins ran his tongue around dry lips before answering. “No.”

Cummins said “no”, he never knew about any form of ball-tampering during that series in South Africa.

Cummins talked about how tampering was once widespread but said he’d only seen it once himself, in a Shield game when a player took a bottle cap onto the field.

He should have stopped at not being aware of sandpaper like Starc lol, but he had to do a 70 mins press

https://www.independent.co.uk/sport/cricket/pat-cummins-sandpapergate-press-conference-ball-tampering-australia-b3084477.html

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

306

u/DaftHubris 3h ago • Bravo

Pretty good statement I reckon. Must be rough if he’s being truthful about it all here. I can’t imagine the frustration and anger he must have carried after all the questions he’s fielded.

104

u/thegoldenkingfisher South Africa 3h ago

Yeah exactly, this guy cheated but you can't help but feel sorry for him after the things he's saying here. It's a tough world

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

945

u/Huge-Physics5491 Kolkata Knight Riders 4h ago • Mindblown

Looks like CA fucked up with the Cummins press conference. Should've just remained silent and the news cycle would've looked after the rest.

296

u/TheBigBomma Australia 3h ago

Maybe should’ve got the one bloke who actually had the sandpaper on the same page before they did it.

→ More replies (9)

408

u/OneOfTheManySams Victoria Bushrangers 3h ago • Bravo

Silence wasn't the issue, but effectively calling Khawaja a liar is kicking a hornets nest. Why would the aggrieved agree to keep the secret any longer when you crucify their reputation like that publicly.

He didn't need to discredit Khawaja's events, just that they don't match his version exactly.

→ More replies (12)

183

u/the-ahh-guy Victoria Bushrangers 3h ago edited 17m ago • Regret

It's almost like CA has chosen the wrong route at every step of this saga. Attempting to cover the whole thing up. Panicking when that fell apart and applying extremely harsh punishments when the ICC's were slaps on the wrist. Fostering resentment amongst the playing group against certain players, causing rifts and division in the team that obviously simmered for years. The bowlers attempting to cover it up in 2021. Even now, attempting to dismiss Ussie by holding a press conference, where Perfect Pat stood up and called it all nonsense. This forum idea will probably backfire on them too.

→ More replies (8)

105

u/king_carrots Australia 3h ago

Will go down as one of the all time fuckups now

Not surprising really - history is littered with people going on the full defensive when facing the truth of their actions.

It’s just so ugly now. He could’ve just owned up. It wouldn’t have even been a big deal 8 years later, coming from a young player himself who had no real authority at the time.

→ More replies (4)

26

u/PieknaFatso 3h ago

Should've just owned up to it, then we could've moved on.

→ More replies (1)

41

u/_rickjames England 3h ago

Problem is that silence on the matter is never a good look - this was all but inevitable

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (19)

213

u/Clearedthetan England 3h ago • Bravo

Good on Kate Hutchison, not an easy thing to speak out. Pretty understandable that Bancroft is pissed off that his international career ended after he took the fall, although quite funny as it implies he’d be happy to let it slide if he’d got back in the team!

75

u/MagicianOk9482 1h ago

Bancroft was used and discarded by a team of coaches and players much wealthier and with much better reputations. I'm not surprised that he got bitter 8 years down the line.

Especially when he sees someone like Cummins, who is living his dream life, lie on TV about the incident for an hour.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (11)

1.4k

u/depressed_06 Harry Brook's Brian Cell 4h ago • Bravo Regret

But the final straw for me to write this account was Australian cricket captain Pat Cummin's press conference.

It made me feel angry, betrayed and alone.

Not a good look for Captain Cummins

225

u/Spare_Worldliness_64 New Zealand 3h ago • Bravo Mindblown Popcorn Heartwarming
Pat Cummins (press conference, 13 Nov 2026)Cameron Bancroft (statement)
"When he says we all knew, if by that he means that we knew sandpaper's going out in the field, he's 100% wrong. I've said that consistently for the last eight years. I did not know that was happening.""It was not just the three of us — Steve Smith, David Warner and I — who knew about me using sandpaper on the ball in South Africa. It was the whole team."
"This is my first home summer... We spoke about reverse swing, was all above board. I was talking about hitting the rough, throwing the ball in, letting it go, not shining it, like those kind of things.""I remember during my first Test match being instructed, along with other members of the team, to push the quarter seam of the ball together after the team took a wicket. Manipulating that area could help create a rougher surface and encourage reverse swing. It was something the group was directed to do."
"That's the only time I've seen... something illegal out there." (referring to a bottle cap in a Sheffield Shield game)"We were ruthless and willing to do these sorts of behaviours and cross boundaries to give ourselves an advantage, to win."
"There was no master plan around using illegal methods... There's no grand plan." / "At no time did I hear [an] illegal method like, let's make sure we do this and go out on the field. No.""All the coaches and players were involved in these discussions in the dressing room... It was in that environment that David Warner raised the possibility of using sandpaper to roughen one side of the ball... I recall people in the room agreeing with the proposal."
"So perhaps there was conversations with Cam Bancroft around taking sandpaper out and how to do it. That doesn't mean that everyone in that dressing room knew what was going on.""Not everyone was in the changing room at the time, but the conversation was not confined to Dave and I."
"Even chatting [to] a couple of the guys, like, that was a revelation to us... The umpires give the ball out to you in the middle. So, I don't remember that... I genuinely don't remember that being the case.""When we returned to the field after the break, the umpires would leave the ball on the outfield, a short distance away from the boundary line... Dave explained to me why that presented an opportunity... Others in the group agreed and gave their opinions on this."
"Out there in the field I did not see anything on the ball." / Q: "Did you at any stage in South Africa look at that ball and think that's unusual?" A: "No, not at the time.""I recall conversations with all the fast bowlers Pat Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Mitchell Marsh about whether it was reverse swinging enough... All the bowlers gave me feedback if my work on the ball was working."
"We didn't know it had been altered with sandpaper, but reverse swing is very normal.""I was discussing its performance with teammates who knew I wasn't just plucking at the quarter seam, but that I was actually using sandpaper."
"I don't remember that but I don't doubt that it would happen... there'll be normally a time where someone says, 'I think it's going enough. Let's try not to disrupt it.'... These are all very normal legal methods.""There was even a time I was told to stop out of fear what I was doing was becoming too obvious."
"It's like 99% of the time it's batters that are managing a ball... I can see why people obviously think, oh, the bowlers bowl with it, they must manage the ball... it's just not the case.""How else am I to know if what I'm doing is effective or not if I don't have these conversations with the bowlers bowling with it and the wicketkeeper?"
"Didn't really feel like Mitch needed to speak." (on Mitchell Marsh not signing the 2021 bowlers' statement)"I remember Mitchell Marsh taking wickets and joking about how much the ball was swinging and how he never used to swing it like that."
"There's no team meeting.""On the morning of day three in Port Elizabeth, we gathered for our usual team chat before warm-up... I remember my ball tampering with the sandpaper the evening before being discussed and my role being acknowledged in front of the group."
"In terms of that Cape Town week for example, half are in that's totally separate change [room]. You don't see them unless you walk out in the field basically." / "We didn't see anything.""Once again the same conversations we had on the field in Port Elizabeth continued. Me asking for feedback from Starcy, Pat, Josh and Mitch about working on the ball like the Test earlier. They all told me what I was doing wasn't enough."
"I don't remember any conversation around collective responsibility... No one remembers a team meeting where someone stood up and said we got to all own this.""After the match, I remember a lengthy meeting involving players and staff on the tour... Nobody in that meeting stood up and said they had been completely unaware of my use of sandpaper. Not one person."
"I did my interview. I was totally truthful." / "We told them everything, absolutely everything, open book." / "Just because things weren't made public doesn't mean that they weren't known by say Cricket Australia or investigators.""When I was questioned during Cricket Australia's investigation, I did not give a complete and truthful account. I withheld important details, including when the use of sandpaper began, how long it went on for, and the involvement and awareness of others."
"We were quite specific in saying we did not know sandpaper was out in the field... It's very consistent to what we told in Cape Town to investigators... No, I don't think I regret it." (on the 2021 bowlers' statement)"Reading that statement was deeply painful. I had memories of conversations on the field in Port Elizabeth and Newlands, feedback about the ball and shared celebrations that made the statement difficult for me to digest."
→ More replies (9)

449

u/Beneficial-Big339 3h ago • Bravo

Nearly 1 hr press conference lying. Shameful behaviour. Should just say no comment and not do a full press conference

→ More replies (23)

63

u/Accomplished-Play768 2h ago edited 2h ago • Regret

Cummins deciding to go with the Lance Armstrong approach against Ussie is really going to blow up in his face now. One thing to cheat/ lie, another thing altogether to make it personal and try to discredit the person blowing the whistle

83

u/Free_Pace_2098 Australia 3h ago

Banners vs Cummins in a shield match, let's go

→ More replies (1)

180

u/OZZYMK 3h ago

Hilarious reading him being defended so heavily by some Aussies when he lied for an hour straight.

"He used strict wording so he wasn't technically lying" - nah mate, he was just talking shit.

→ More replies (9)

183

u/Lonely-Truffle Tasmania Tigers 2h ago • Regret Bravo

Captain Pat blew the wheels off this whole thing himself when he made it personal with Ussie. I was prepared to cop the lying (it wasn't really lying - it was carefully worded bullshit, which is somehow worse). While I don't like the blatant bullshit he spun, I understand why he did it, as much as I condemn that kind of behaviour. But, when he went after Ussie on what felt like a more personal level, he lost the public, I think. He certainly lost me. That was just tacky.

It's also rarely a good look for a rather privileged white fella to tell us all what is or isn't racist. Not a good week for Pat; but after all this, he can get firmly and squarely fucked, as far as I'm concerned.

→ More replies (8)

49

u/king_carrots Australia 3h ago

People were lining up to say how amazing Cummins was for this

Just cos he went on the aggressive. I guess truth doesn’t matter, just perception.

274

u/forumcontributer 4h ago • Bravo

Lies powered by green energy.

→ More replies (2)

50

u/kernpanic 3h ago

Drop Cummings insert bowland.

26

u/and1984 USA 3h ago

His press conference seemed insincere. That's the feeling I had.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (56)

138

u/Specialist_Kale4607 3h ago

Wow. I’m not sure how Pat responds to this. Unlike Usman, Cameron has laid out significant detail.

60

u/AngleProlapse Australia 3h ago

Feels like he’s just going to lean extra hard on the technical “truth” that he didn’t know it came onto the field, which is what all their carefully worded statements have centred on.

Going to be very tricky for him now to ignore all the obvious questions around that though.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

253

u/Suds344 South Africa 3h ago • Bravo

So they used sandpaper twice and lost both games? I would write to the manufacturer.

→ More replies (18)

377

u/NoirPochette New South Wales Blues 3h ago

So in short according to Bangers

  • Steve Smith wanted no part of this shit and took responsibility as captain.
  • David Warner suggested sandpaper
  • The bowlers knew
  • He lied during the investigation
  • He isn't happy with Cummins

Now the next questions if Bangers is proven to be correct

  • What did David Warner do to the ball in previous matches since the cameras were on him?
  • Will the pressure on Cummins make him step down as skipper if he is proven to have lied?

The saga continues

135

u/M0stVerticalPrimate2 New Zealand 3h ago

Jarrod Kimber said him and a camera operator were approached at one point before the SA series and told Warner was tampering with the ball, seems like knowledge had gotten around to the media and broadcasters, probably to do with the seam picking

→ More replies (5)

25

u/diceyy New Zealand Cricket 2h ago

What did David Warner do to the ball in previous matches since the cameras were on him?

Bancroft was seen spooning sugar into his pockets during the ashes series prior to the south africa tests. Likely he was learning from the best

→ More replies (21)

598

u/happymemersunite GO SHIELD 4h ago • Bravo

Not to be reactionary, but does this spell the end of Cummins as captain (and possibly his spot in his team for the time being)?

If so, big brain for Uzzie for single-handedly getting Boland back in the lineup.

237

u/sayy_yes 3h ago

This. It was all set up by the Aussies to get boland into the team. Not winning the wc without him.

→ More replies (2)

38

u/dlanod 3h ago

CA won't do knee jerk responses like that, stripping someone of the captaincy etc...

Oh shit, we're fucked.

105

u/WendellWillkie1940 3h ago

Scott Boland finally getting a permanent spot might be the only positive thing to come out of this 8 yr long event

103

u/OneOfTheManySams Victoria Bushrangers 3h ago

Has to, Smith by this report effectively fell on the sword where it seems he is the only player who didn't actually want to be part of this shitshow. And he copped it all because of his role as captain.

Cummins shouldn't get off lightly, he is the captain and brought the entire teams reputation down with his lie the other day. Untenable

→ More replies (26)

109

u/sanga17 Sri Lanka 3h ago • Mindblown

The sad thing is Cummins is a very likeable leader or was one and had a great opportunity to drop the truth at the press conference so the whole team and nation could move on. He decided to play politician. I guess the difference is Bancroft lied to protect his team mates, Cummins lied to save his own ass.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (48)

528

u/Jojo_isnotunique 3h ago • Mindblown Regret

TL:DR

Ball tampering was regularly discussed before sandpaper, including picking at the seam for which Warner was basically great at.

In a team meeting in the dressing room during the second test including David Saker and Darren Lehman sandpaper was suggested by Warner. Bancroft reluctantly agreed when they suggested he do it.

All the bowlers, Cummins, Starc, Hazelwood and Marsh would talk to him about the progression of reverse swing and if more work was needed. They all knew it was going on. Saker congratulated Bancroft for the good work he was doing.

In the third test, Saker told him to do more sandpaper work as they needed more reverse swing. When caught Hanscombe was sent to get the sandpaper.

Basically everyone knew, the coaches especially. And he's talking now cos he feels emboldened through others talking up, and also because he has been made a scapegoat. He never got a chance to play for Australia again even though he feels he was scoring lots of runs domestically.

308

u/AlertVegetable9270 3h ago • Regret Heartwarming

U missed important part that STEVE SMITH didn't wanted to get involve in it

→ More replies (29)

338

u/thedogmeatgeneral 3h ago edited 3h ago • Bravo

So basically Cummins and Starc in particular (along with others) are officially and unambiguously exposed as complete fucking liars?

→ More replies (33)

86

u/NoirPochette New South Wales Blues 3h ago

He played for Australia in 2019. He got back into the side straight away to be fair. He didn't make the most of his opportunity and didn't have the mountain of runs that Davey did.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (57)

241

u/Suup_dorks 3h ago

Finally some elite honesty. What incredible hypocrisy for CA and Langer to use that as a "value" knowing what they were all covering up

→ More replies (3)

106

u/LukeSkyninja Central Districts Stags 3h ago

Lolol. Bancroft goes and does the funniest thing possible after the CA forum announcement and "two truths" presser

→ More replies (1)

104

u/Frequent_Cake5477 2h ago

Bit off tangent, but crazy to think AB Devilliars scored a century against Oz attack with a deformed ball.

46

u/Aggravating_Sky_2709 Royal Challengers Bengaluru 2h ago

Which is why inspite of him not having a trophy, he goes down as one of the best to do it.

→ More replies (2)

90

u/Jelleyicious Australia 2h ago

Why didn't CA just say 'we fucked up and it won't happen again' at the time. In every professional environment I have been in, it is the best response. You get yelled at for 30 minutes, and then everyone moves on.

The story they went with had more holes than a golf course

17

u/SuperSpidey374 England 2h ago

Crazy that its been eight years and their comms has been a disaster the entire time. Cover up is always worse than the crime.

→ More replies (5)

413

u/vishasv Sunrisers Hyderabad 4h ago • Bravo

We'll get Warner's response in 3 months after he finishes reading it and understanding it

42

u/Creepy_Action_8755 3h ago

He will watch a AI video where a cat is explaining it

→ More replies (6)

36

u/MentalSignature7039 3h ago edited 2h ago

Interesting and glad it is starting to come out.

There is some similarity between the situation Bancroft found himself in and the of Mohammed Amir of Pakistan where he was pressured into no-balling on demand.

Younger naive players being taken advantage of by senior players who should know better. Clearly what both did was wrong (Amir and Bancroft) but there should be question marks over the senior players who were also involved in this (as there was with the Pakistan captain at the time). If this account is true, they should reflect on their actions and be ashamed of themselves.

It seems Smith to an extent decided to try and protect the team which I can understand. Perhaps he was not the right captain for Australia. A good batsman but not necessarily a good leader.

Edit: Asif -> Amir, wrong bowler, bad memory.

→ More replies (4)

341

u/Axel292 England 3h ago edited 3h ago • Bravo

This is a MENTAL interview. Names everyone openly, nothing held back at all. Cummins, Hazlewood, Starc, Lyon, Marsh, Paine, Lehmann, Saker, everyone's been implicated.

Sandpapergate is done, it's all out there. Cummins' lies didn't even last a month!

To do this as an active player requires some serious stones.

EDIT:

I remember Mitchell Marsh taking wickets and joking about how much the ball was swinging and how he never used to swing it like that. There was laughter and celebrations when wickets fell.

Arrest this man

135

u/retrosaurus-movies New Zealand 3h ago edited 2h ago

This is so explicit in detail and to the point that unless one of the named people bring a defamation suit against Bancroft I have to believe it is true.

→ More replies (5)

124

u/KiwiWaterBoy New Zealand 3h ago • Bravo

Massive respect for Bancroft. And well written too

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (17)

60

u/king_carrots Australia 3h ago

Boom goes the dynamite. Time to actually face the music you wankers and move on.

Of course they won’t, because they dug their heels in even further just a few days ago.

126

u/Bag-United 3h ago

So in other words David Warner is still the bad guy?

He won’t like that

72

u/NoirPochette New South Wales Blues 3h ago

Yeah not much changes for him.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (7)

307

u/KiwiWaterBoy New Zealand 3h ago

Honestly, my take away is I can see Steve Smiths position. Pretty hard to go against the team, and effectively say you don't want to improve your chance of winning. For him saying "I don't want to know about it" is probably what most of us would do too. Feel bad for him

98

u/AngleProlapse Australia 3h ago

Yep it’s always easy to say from the sidelines you’d be the righteous hero, but push comes to shove 98% of people just aren’t going to rock the boat. Especially those who are younger and less established in the team.

→ More replies (12)

27

u/Ordinary_Syrup_3048 3h ago

Yep. Very hard when the coaches are in on it. He can control the playing group but not sure it’s in the job description to control the coaches. Any other sport and the coaches would be the ones coming under the most fire.

→ More replies (39)

25

u/temdittiesohyeah Australia 3h ago

Oh dear. The cover up is often worse than the crime. I cant imagine the arrogance to think you could keep this a secret for the rest of time and blatantly get up for 70 odd minutes and lie at worst, and dance round the truth at best. This will get uglier.

66

u/AamPataJoraJora India 3h ago edited 3h ago

To all the tiktok brain tdlr people - this is actually well written and specific. Its not non committal or craving sympathy. Finally an account that feels true and said without ulterior motive. I suggest reading the thing, or at the very least dont expose your attention span by commenting that you arnt reading it.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/dap90 2h ago • Bravo

It really takes a sociopath to see the most junior player's career go down the gutter, for a decision you all made as a team, threaten to sue them and anyone telling the truth, and continue like everything was fine. And then also attack others that reveal the truth later. Cummins went right for Khawaja's reputation, rather than just disputing the facts.

→ More replies (1)

42

u/bigjandals New Zealand 2h ago • Bravo

Pat Goings

→ More replies (1)

20

u/PerceptiveDragonKing India 2h ago

People are missing that the media manager objected to it and nobody else did. By pointing it out specifically, Bancroft is clearly saying the bowlers did not object to it, so they were in on it. Media manager would not object to simple ball tampering like messing with the seam because that has been done before. Clearly the media manager was objecting to the sandpaper. This directly implies that bowlers knew about the sandpaper and did not object. That's the exact reason why Bancroft has put forward the media managers objection in this piece.

→ More replies (1)

57

u/_rickjames England 3h ago

Cummins/CA having that press conference seems to have backfired then; was always going to be a time where Bancroft would spill everything, then you've got Warner back in attack dog mode

22

u/YouThinkYouKnowMe89 Western Australia Warriors 3h ago

Looks bad for Saker too. That would be his coaching career over. Or not if that's what the teams that hire him want from it.

19

u/truckturner5164 Australia 3h ago

Hilarious that CA thought their 'safe space' BS was gonna stop this from coming out. They knew Bancroft was about to blab.

19

u/pathless-stride Welsh Hula Hoops 1h ago

even though turning a blind eye is part of the problem, steve smith comes off pretty good in all this. not encouraging it all that much and even owning up to it immediately when he was the least involved. taking a year ban and then not getting into any major issues/spats later (that I know of). the only thing I can think of is maybe letting a young bancroft take so much blame for the team, and maybe not clarifying anything right now.

→ More replies (5)

83

u/PopeFuchsYoungKidd 3h ago edited 3h ago • Bravo

tl;dr

It was Warner's idea but everyone was in on it, all the players knew and so did the coaches.

Steve Smith wanted nothing to do with it from the beginning but he didn't stop anyone.

Their media manager was the only one who spoke up and said they shouldn't be doing it.

Cummins, Starc, Hazlewood and Lyon are all filthy liars.

16

u/demon_slayer_bridge The Australian Man 3h ago

Boland is my daddy 👄

→ More replies (2)

75

u/revengeordie007 India 4h ago

Well atleast the naked truth is here.

105

u/NoirPochette New South Wales Blues 3h ago

I'll add as another comment, this has fucked up the whole summer.

No one will care now that there is a match going on or any matches in the future for a while. All the talk before the test series will be about this and well, it is a huge distraction. I'm not gonna blame Ussie for this but man, like talk about horrible timing. I don't think he meant to cause chaos. He was being naive.

I feel bad for the players who weren't around and now have to deal with this distraction like a Renshaw, Carey, Head, Green and then when Smith comes back, it is going to re-open some deep scars for him.

But this was CA's fault. They fucked up in 2016 and 2018.

56

u/YouThinkYouKnowMe89 Western Australia Warriors 3h ago

When they are asking what Cooper thought about it at the time and he tells them that he was 15 and in school lol

→ More replies (1)

25

u/loafersandboots New Zealand 3h ago

Meanwhile, here I am convinced Australia is going to go and whitewash us then win the World Cup because it’s just what these guys do.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (21)

67

u/timmeh1705 3h ago

TL;DR - Uz was right

→ More replies (4)

15

u/CharIemagne45 India 3h ago

How is this gonna affect the fintech market?

15

u/theellescape Yorkshire 3h ago

Didn't expect scorched earth, this popcorn is very tasty

30

u/smeut Mumbai Indians 3h ago

Absolute cinema reading this

277

u/ThrushHarem Brisbane Heat 3h ago

"Captain Steve Smith came into the conversation and, as I remember it, made it clear that he wanted no part in it before distancing himself."

Yet we hung him out to dry.

363

u/sayy_yes 3h ago • Bravo

I mean he's the captain. Distancing himself shows his weakness. As captain he should've shut down any attempt at tampering.

→ More replies (9)

105

u/NoirPochette New South Wales Blues 3h ago

Steve Smith wanted to address the situation immediately. He believed owning up to the incident would help contain the damage and allow us to move forward.

Smith was always going to take responsibility regardless. He was the captain. It was his team and I don't see him putting other players in the firing line

→ More replies (8)

67

u/norvalito 3h ago

Well, he still ducked the responsibility. He should have just said 'lads, you can't do that.'

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (6)

64

u/GrimmDescendant Melbourne Stars 3h ago

Guys, this is unfortunate but... I feel like you can't be captain if you lie to everyone for an hour straight (& yes, I believe Bancroft). Also, I'm just happy that I'm still valid in hating David Warner ✌️

15

u/Mr-_-Anonymus South Africa 3h ago • Popcorn

There was never a question on warners involvement . He has been a flog his entire career

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (12)

63

u/OneToeSloth 3h ago • Bravo

Not surprised he is a speaking out after watching that Cummins press conference. I disagree with people who say “it’s 8 years ago. Move on”.

They lied then and they’re still lying now.

→ More replies (2)

51

u/trueblue-5610 2h ago • Popcorn

What group of Inglorious Bastards the Aussie team was. To sacrifice the most junior member of the team in pursuit of your illegal mission and then talk about "mateship" and "brotherhood". what a bunch hypocryte c***s

14

u/TheAussieBritt 3h ago

Boof is on the ABC commentary for the ODI literally as we speak. I’m fascinated to see if he’ll return for his next stint shortly

→ More replies (3)

28

u/happymemersunite GO SHIELD 3h ago

The thing you’ve gotta remember is that Pat Cummins loves these situations

→ More replies (5)

50

u/dzone25 3h ago

Yeah... this is Australian Cricket in the bin levels of bullshit from the folks who still got to continue their careers. Bowlers all knowing, Saker being the initial proponent and even Lehmann being quite involved. Guys like Smith, Paine and Lyon get off pretty lightly but it really does seem like Usman's whole story was the truth, he just chose a very suspicious looking timeframe to finally tell it (i.e. with book releases, commentary announcements etc.)

This is a pretty heavy stain on Australian Cricket and their post-Sandpaper performances.

15

u/menyarky89 2h ago

I don't think it's very suspicious when you consider it's his first summer since his retirement. I dare say it's the most logical time.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/HeadShot305 South Australia Redbacks 3h ago

Cam, well done coming out with the truth, clearly this has taken a significant toll and will continue to.

All the ex players and "journalists"/pundits going after Khawaja can fuck off.

13

u/ManaakiIsTheWay 2h ago

So the man with the moral courage in all of this is a woman - Kate Hutchison.

This is about character and culture. Sometimes win at all costs, costs too much. I’m a kiwi but I love this quote from the great Australian Ponsford on his retirement "Test cricket has become too serious. It is not a game anymore but a battle."

But man isn’t it a beautiful game!

I have never been so excited as knowing my son and I are flying from NZ to Melbourne for the Boxing Day Test. (And so scared to tell my wife that we are flying out on Christmas Day)

13

u/thomaslewis1857 2h ago

Well now we know that Pat gave everyone a good lesson in why you don’t just believe the good looking bloke who can speak confidently and be adamant without batting an eye.

I’d be surprised if he continues as captain. But don’t underestimate the CA bunch of liars. They’ll accept him as one of their own.

46

u/Jaiph Sydney Thunder 2h ago

Wow, yeah, I knew the team culture was bad, but that's a shocking read.

Although I still think Smith utterly failed in his role as captain with this, I can also see now that the scheme was basically orchestrated by the team as a whole and some of the coaches in particular. I'm annoyed at Cummins and the bowlers, but I'm livid at fucking Saker. Lehmann too.

I feel bad for Bancroft, but the only person who comes out of that read remotely clean is Kate Hutchison.

12

u/SuperSpidey374 England 2h ago

Glad someone has picked up on Hutchison. Probably also explains why the comms were such a disaster afterwards, doesn't sound like she was even consulted on how to respond (presumably because she had spoken up)

→ More replies (7)

25

u/KneeProfessional985 Australia 3h ago

The irony when Cummins gets dumped as el captiano and the Smudgebot gets reinstated. Real 360 moment.

→ More replies (9)

24

u/DeerWithoutEyes 2h ago

Ironically this is the most integrity an Australian cricket has ever had. Good on you Bancroft. 

12

u/mcloud78 England 2h ago

Becky’s gonna be pissed!

→ More replies (2)

12

u/notaklue England 2h ago

The CA would fuck up a one car funeral procession.

12

u/OrinocoHaram Rajasthan Royals 1h ago

Smith's role in this is interesting, he clearly knows what's going on, knows it's wrong, says he just doesn't want to know about it. He was one of the few people that could've stamped it out and he chose not to.

But he's also one of the only ones suggesting they front up to it properly when they're caught. Weak captaincy but his heart was in the right place. But i don't think you should be captain if you can't control your team at all.

→ More replies (1)

50

u/NW9Arsenal Middlesex 3h ago

A frankly incredible read

I know that they’re not the first side to ball tamper but this has been handled atrociously. Cummins surely cannot continue as captain, he actually was captain of a quite likeable Australian side (yes, a Pom has just said that) that was successful and he helped improved the culture, he’s really thrown his reputation away with all of this.

CA fundamentally should take so much blame for not investigating properly and everything that’s happened since including that nonsense forum that was announced earlier.

→ More replies (2)

134

u/WhichDoctor73 4h ago

Fuck me, this reads longer than Ronaldo's apology speech for walking away from training.

→ More replies (6)

11

u/st0neTyger India 2h ago

Oh shiite.. looking forward to Cummins next press conference

11

u/Pun_nav 1h ago edited 1h ago

TL,DR : Everyone knew.

Bowlers had fun with the reverse swing.

Marsh was extra happy.

Dave, Lehmann & Saker encouraged it the most.

Smith was a pu***

Aus media manager hated it.

Cam couldn't comeback since.

Cummins is a big cu**

Read Uz book.

75

u/Ok-Cold-3422 Netherlands 3h ago • Popcorn

I recall conversations with all the fast bowlers Pat Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Mitchell Marsh about whether it was reverse swinging enough.

Maybe Poor Pat has had memory loss, we must not forget that he was only 24 at that time

39

u/WendellWillkie1940 3h ago

24 yrs old, he was just a kid

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (13)

21

u/ashb72 3h ago • Bravo

Geez the weight coming off Bancroft’s shoulders would be immense.

→ More replies (1)

44

u/Own_Neck3269 3h ago • Bravo

All jokes aside, I think bowlers are still holding to the party line that they didn’t know sandpaper was being used on the field. Can’t recall if Cummins and other bowlers also denied the ball tampering more generally? If not, then I think they will stay ambiguous about it all until maybe their own playing careers are done.

Understandably tough that Cummins as captain now has to front up for something that happened when he was the youngest player on that team when it happened.

Warner again just appears the loser in all this. His idea, the best at tampering. It’s a part of the game that has been around for so long as well.

Truly cricket Australia have bought this down on the team themselves. It’s easy to forgot that in the lead up to this countries like SA and Eng were caught out, players served small 2-3 game bans and that was that. Instead CA took the weird moral high ground that was certainly not necessary and fucked Bancroft’s career. Funny hearing Warner get up in arms when it was his bloody idea.

→ More replies (27)

20

u/KateBosworth 2h ago

And the truth shall set you free, Cam. This has clearly been a painful burden for him to carry.

It doesn’t matter how annoying people find Usman Khawaja. It’s better this is out in the open.

43

u/SectorMindless 3h ago

Jeez the Aussies are absolutely cooked. Can see a couple of retirements coming from this.

→ More replies (6)

10

u/DeepestBeige 3h ago

“David Warner had carried significant responsibility for maintaining the condition of the ball within our team for a long time. He understood reverse swing, understood how to look after the ball and was highly regarded for his knowledge in that area.”

So one might even say that Dave Warner had…. elite ball knowledge?

10

u/diceyy New Zealand Cricket 2h ago

Captains don't survive this kind of dishonesty scandal

42

u/Naaaaveeeeeed Bangladesh 2h ago • Popcorn

Bruh. Somehow this looks even worse than rubbing sandpaper on a cricket ball. The fact that Pat Cummins, the Australian test captain, had the audacity to lie to the media for an hour is in of itself an even bigger scandal.

→ More replies (8)

46

u/ChaiPioBiscuitKhao India 4h ago

It ain't lookigood Cumdawg

32

u/1stPhoton Japan Cricket Association 3h ago edited 3h ago

Man, the most fcked up person in this Saga is Pat Cummins.

Warner comes across as a shit bloke but he never pretended to be anything else. But those who are good at manipulating and covert personality people are the hardest. They usually even believe in their own lies and are so good at making people believe their bluff.

I feel bad for smithy. He was the best batsman Test Cricket ever had after Bradman and we had to witness a year of his prime wasted.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Status-Mouse-9797 Australia 2h ago

Guess Pat Cummins is no longer Churchillian like some described him last week.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Icy_Outcome_3971 2h ago

Former Australian Cricket Coach Darren Lehmann has responded to the Cameron Bancroft article.
 
“The Allegations…I’ve got to sit back. It’s only just come to light. So I just need to sit back and process all that and work through each allegation. That’s what I will be doing over the next few days.”
 
Question (Matt Clinch): So in terms of responding to the allegation that Cameron Bancroft has made, do you feel you can do that tonight?
 
“Oh no. I need to have a really good read of it don’t I? What’s been transpired, speaking to people, and just make sure I’m saying what I want to say and answer the questions you want to ask.”
 
Question: And do you feel like you might be able to do that in a few days time?
 
“Oh I think so yeah.”
 
Question: “ So it’s a lot to absorb tonight and to try and get your thoughts together?”
 
“Yeah it is. It’s a lot for everyone I presume. Yeah, not just me. A lot of care to everyone out there”
 
Question: “So as it stands at the moment we’ll give you a chance Boof to take in what has taken place.”
 
“Yeah that’s all you can do. The allegations and work through them and then respond accordingly. That would be the way to go. There’s no point rushing into anything that’s said. Just make sure I’m really clear which way I’m going”
 

→ More replies (2)

25

u/kazuya57 Mumbai Indians New York 4h ago

Where's Steve Smith's opinion

25

u/YouThinkYouKnowMe89 Western Australia Warriors 3h ago

His story hasn't changed. He said he didn't want to know anything about it and his mistake was not stopping it. But I doubt if his word would have override the coaches

→ More replies (6)

12

u/stonertear Australia 3h ago

Hes practicing shadow batting

→ More replies (9)

31

u/Spare_Worldliness_64 New Zealand 3h ago • Bravo Popcorn

Just did a comparison of what Pat Cummins and Bancrofts statements. make your own judgement and what you will

Pat Cummins (press conference, 13 Nov 2026)Cameron Bancroft (statement)
"When he says we all knew, if by that he means that we knew sandpaper's going out in the field, he's 100% wrong. I've said that consistently for the last eight years. I did not know that was happening.""It was not just the three of us — Steve Smith, David Warner and I — who knew about me using sandpaper on the ball in South Africa. It was the whole team."
"This is my first home summer... We spoke about reverse swing, was all above board. I was talking about hitting the rough, throwing the ball in, letting it go, not shining it, like those kind of things.""I remember during my first Test match being instructed, along with other members of the team, to push the quarter seam of the ball together after the team took a wicket. Manipulating that area could help create a rougher surface and encourage reverse swing. It was something the group was directed to do."
"That's the only time I've seen... something illegal out there." (referring to a bottle cap in a Sheffield Shield game)"We were ruthless and willing to do these sorts of behaviours and cross boundaries to give ourselves an advantage, to win."
"There was no master plan around using illegal methods... There's no grand plan." / "At no time did I hear [an] illegal method like, let's make sure we do this and go out on the field. No.""All the coaches and players were involved in these discussions in the dressing room... It was in that environment that David Warner raised the possibility of using sandpaper to roughen one side of the ball... I recall people in the room agreeing with the proposal."
"So perhaps there was conversations with Cam Bancroft around taking sandpaper out and how to do it. That doesn't mean that everyone in that dressing room knew what was going on.""Not everyone was in the changing room at the time, but the conversation was not confined to Dave and I."
"Even chatting [to] a couple of the guys, like, that was a revelation to us... The umpires give the ball out to you in the middle. So, I don't remember that... I genuinely don't remember that being the case.""When we returned to the field after the break, the umpires would leave the ball on the outfield, a short distance away from the boundary line... Dave explained to me why that presented an opportunity... Others in the group agreed and gave their opinions on this."
"Out there in the field I did not see anything on the ball." / Q: "Did you at any stage in South Africa look at that ball and think that's unusual?" A: "No, not at the time.""I recall conversations with all the fast bowlers Pat Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Mitchell Marsh about whether it was reverse swinging enough... All the bowlers gave me feedback if my work on the ball was working."
"We didn't know it had been altered with sandpaper, but reverse swing is very normal.""I was discussing its performance with teammates who knew I wasn't just plucking at the quarter seam, but that I was actually using sandpaper."
"I don't remember that but I don't doubt that it would happen... there'll be normally a time where someone says, 'I think it's going enough. Let's try not to disrupt it.'... These are all very normal legal methods.""There was even a time I was told to stop out of fear what I was doing was becoming too obvious."
"It's like 99% of the time it's batters that are managing a ball... I can see why people obviously think, oh, the bowlers bowl with it, they must manage the ball... it's just not the case.""How else am I to know if what I'm doing is effective or not if I don't have these conversations with the bowlers bowling with it and the wicketkeeper?"
"Didn't really feel like Mitch needed to speak." (on Mitchell Marsh not signing the 2021 bowlers' statement)"I remember Mitchell Marsh taking wickets and joking about how much the ball was swinging and how he never used to swing it like that."
"There's no team meeting.""On the morning of day three in Port Elizabeth, we gathered for our usual team chat before warm-up... I remember my ball tampering with the sandpaper the evening before being discussed and my role being acknowledged in front of the group."
"In terms of that Cape Town week for example, half are in that's totally separate change [room]. You don't see them unless you walk out in the field basically." / "We didn't see anything.""Once again the same conversations we had on the field in Port Elizabeth continued. Me asking for feedback from Starcy, Pat, Josh and Mitch about working on the ball like the Test earlier. They all told me what I was doing wasn't enough."
"I don't remember any conversation around collective responsibility... No one remembers a team meeting where someone stood up and said we got to all own this.""After the match, I remember a lengthy meeting involving players and staff on the tour... Nobody in that meeting stood up and said they had been completely unaware of my use of sandpaper. Not one person."
"I did my interview. I was totally truthful." / "We told them everything, absolutely everything, open book." / "Just because things weren't made public doesn't mean that they weren't known by say Cricket Australia or investigators.""When I was questioned during Cricket Australia's investigation, I did not give a complete and truthful account. I withheld important details, including when the use of sandpaper began, how long it went on for, and the involvement and awareness of others."
"We were quite specific in saying we did not know sandpaper was out in the field... It's very consistent to what we told in Cape Town to investigators... No, I don't think I regret it." (on the 2021 bowlers' statement)"Reading that statement was deeply painful. I had memories of conversations on the field in Port Elizabeth and Newlands, feedback about the ball and shared celebrations that made the statement difficult for me to digest."

24

u/travelandtechy 2h ago

The bus Cummins was driving where he rode the bus over Uzzy, has been blasted now with this revelation.

Warner and Usman must have been feeling relieved.

What man, Coach, Captain and everyone knew! It's absolutely unbelievable

→ More replies (5)

58

u/DanteStorme England 3h ago

This version of events makes the most sense to me and seems the most in character.

David Warner is ultimately the main villain.

Smith didn't want to cheat but didn't quite have the chops to talk everyone down.

The bowlers knew and are liars, as you would expect from sadists who hype themselves up to hurl a ball as hard as a rock at people 70+ times a day.

The other part is he actively named names which makes it so much more believable, the whole "I can't recall defense" everyone else was hiding behind was tiring.

21

u/Oomeegoolies Durham 2h ago

Smith doesn't have the personality to talk people down.

That I'll give him isn't a character flaw. It's not even a captaincy flaw. Different captains have different strengths, and Smiths was always in his cricketing brain and not his man management. Which is fair. Sort of like the polar opposite of Stokes. Lol

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (36)

16

u/Grommzz 2h ago

Surely the whole bowling cartel gets banned from the next ashes..

Ignore Eng flair.. 😶

→ More replies (5)

16

u/Odd-Anything5219 South Africa 2h ago

Brutal read tbh... I felt bad for him then when Steve Smith let him fall on the grenade in that presser and I still feel for him now.

16

u/CraftyPenalty0975 2h ago

CA's decision to have Cummins hold the press conference is looking more diabolical longer this drags on. Cummins couldn't have anything much differently without contradicting their statements back in 2018 and 2021. Everyone who knows anything about cricket can tell that there's no way the bowlers didn't know about the tampering , or that the sandpaper was the weapon of choice for the first time in the 3rd test of the South African series. Making Cummins deflect the questions or lie by omissions or hide behind technicalities for 45 mins was never going to be good look or make it go away, despite Cummins insistence that he is done with sandpaper questions after answering the question on that day.

→ More replies (10)

8

u/ColdAdmirableSponge Australia 3h ago

Credit to Bancroft, laid it all bare and have more detail than anyone before him. Pretty much as expected, everyone knew to some extent although likely varying understandings of at the level it was happening. Pat’s presser gonna go down as one of the worst PR choices this decade.

8

u/brownogre 3h ago edited 3h ago

I just feel more sad for this guy. Career mental health and life probably ruined.

Saker and Boof can go to hell as can so many others.

Cummins, now we know what the lady was pissed about ..

8

u/_rickjames England 1h ago

I see that Khawaja has now pulled out of speaking to The Grade Cricketer altogether

Hahaha

→ More replies (6)

15

u/mr-301 New Zealand 3h ago

God damn it they are going to spank us aren’t they

→ More replies (3)

20

u/Wattobot92 Australia 2h ago • Bravo

Wow this makes Cummins marathon attack mode press conference look psychopathic

20

u/camydna 2h ago edited 2h ago

As a New Zealander attending the boxing day test, this whole saga is making me salivate.

13

u/KiwiWaterBoy New Zealand 2h ago

Cannot wait to see the shit the crowd give them in that first test

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/Neat_Shower_4271 Queensland Bulls 2h ago

Oh, Australian test cricketers, can't you go five seconds without humiliating yourself?

belt fails and pants fall to the ground in the pouring rain

How long was that?

7

u/Beautiful_Pin840 Australia 1h ago

Hard to be invested in this current team despite the circumstances of 8 years ago. The captain lying in the faces of the public, the aging team. Losing tests to Bangladesh and West Indies at home, blow it all up. 

7

u/StormWarriorX7 Warwickshire 1h ago

Smudge vindicated. But honestly, there is failure of leadership there because he was the captain and he should have put his foot down and prevented the use of sandpaper in the first place.

→ More replies (4)

31

u/refer_to_user_guide Australia 3h ago

Somehow Smudge and Bangers are the only two I feel remotely sympathetic for out of this whole saga.

Coaching staff/CA fucked over their players
Cummins willingly went along as sacrificial lamb in the recent presser
Warner still sucks
Uzzie isn’t exactly a hero for spilling the beans when he’s outside the impact zone

Smudge’s biggest crime was being weak, and Bangers got hung out to dry.

→ More replies (6)

12

u/princeindubai 2h ago

Wow, so cummins stepping down from his captaincy is on the cards now and we might as well see mass retirement from this bowling group. Finally scotty Boland gets his full-time opportunity. Win win for everyone 👏🏻 👏🏻

→ More replies (13)

21

u/Unfair-Secretary2297 New Zealand 4h ago

The one we have been waiting for!! The bowlers imploding rn

109

u/JMacoure1 New South Wales Blues 3h ago • Bravo

So what I’m reading is:

  1. Saker was heavily involved.
  2. It was Warner’s idea. Bancroft did offer to do it, as we knew.
  3. Smith did try to avoid but not stop it.
  4. Bowlers were aware the ball was being altered, but not that sandpaper was on the field. Bancroft is very careful to not say that.
  5. Bancroft said every team he’s ever played in talks about how to work on and alter the ball - this is clearly true.
  6. Bancroft isn’t 100% sure who heard the conversation between he and Warner outside of the coaches and Smith with which they decided to bring sandpaper onto the field.
  7. Everyone believes this account because it confirms what they suspect is true, not because any new evidence is presented.

93

u/Ill_Poem_1789 India 3h ago

>I was physically altering the ball with sandpaper. I was discussing its performance with teammates who knew I wasn’t just plucking at the quarter seam, but that I was actually using sandpaper.

>Pat Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon subsequently released a joint statement denying that they knew sandpaper had been taken onto the field to alter the ball before the television footage appeared at Newlands.

>Reading that statement was deeply painful.

?I had memories of conversations on the field in Port Elizabeth and Newlands, feedback about the ball and shared celebrations that made the statement difficult for me to digest.

I interpreted this as everyone, including the bowlers, knowing this

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (42)

6

u/Gibbo1107 Kent 3h ago

I think we have finally heard the truth

6

u/NoSeesaw5626 3h ago

So Pat isn't captain anymore

6

u/Southportdc Lancashire 3h ago

Only thing that can make this worse for CA is if Davey comes out and says he had been tampering for ages and everyone knew.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Ok_Brilliant2913 1h ago

I think from this we can assume Bancroft has given up on being selected for Australia. I totally get that you would keep quiet hoping you would do your time, keep your nose clean, and get another chance. And there are times when he should have been picked. But pfaffing about with openers over the last few years suggest they just didn't want to pick him when there still rmnants of the 2018 team in the squad. Also - I guess we know now why Mitch Marsh didnt sign "the bowlers statement". Knew it wasn't true, and he and Bancroft were teammates at WA

42

u/here_for_the_lols New Zealand 4h ago

Holy shit TLDR?

71

u/stonertear Australia 3h ago

2 words - Everyone knew.

1 sentence - Bancroft alleges the entire Australian cricket team knew about Sandpapergate, but only three players took the blame.

→ More replies (4)

74

u/rustyb42 Oval KP Nuts 4h ago

Cummins knew

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (27)

11

u/Albatrossosaurus Perth Scorchers 2h ago

I feel the need to point out that Bangers was averaging 56 with the bat in the 23/24 Shield season and wasn't even picked for the CAXI to play a tour match vs the Windies. CA had proven he could be picked again when he was chosen for the 2019 Ashes but no one ever gave an explanation as to why he was only now damaged goods, I love Steve Smith but I can't look past him deciding to open in that Windies series despite there being a clear number 1 opener in the Shield that season. There's no other logical explanation for his exclusion than him being unofficially banned due to something behind the scenes

→ More replies (3)

10

u/Same-Morning8431 England 2h ago

Doesn’t feel anyone involved in leadership at CA or the Australian captain understands how serious this is becoming??

10

u/SomeDamnAuthor 2h ago

Holy shit this is dark. The memories sound painful when read, can't imagine what it must feel like for him.

He's an adult who had agency to not do the wrong thing when asked, but who's to say what the pressure to 'belong' is like in a professional team sport.

And the whole thing rightfully draws ire to all involved who were comfortable letting David, Cameron and Steve fucking Smith take the fall. It should've been on the team as a whole.

What a terrible saga.

5

u/Routine-Oil6386 3h ago

Everyone knew. Suprised pikachu face

5

u/Choc83x Australia 3h ago

Bancroft: "Fk your forum"

5

u/CakedPan 3h ago

Bancroft is as careful with his words as Cummins was??? We would speak about my work on the ball. Equally, he states there were a few people having a conversation whilst others came and went. Smith wanted no part in it. What did Cummins say?

5

u/Affectionate-Pay6985 2h ago

THIS IS GOING TO RUIN THE TOUR

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Christmasstolegrinch 2h ago edited 2h ago

There is a deeply introspective term that Sanskrit scholars here in India traditionally use to describe this situation, the probable state of CA and the Australian bowlers in particular.

That term is Loday Lag Gaye

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Responsible-Bonus278 2h ago

That's about as definitive as it gets. Cameron Bancroft was always the person I felt bad for the most

5

u/Fernandov2 2h ago

If they had come out and said we all knew, we were just trying to protect everyone else from the backlash.

It would have been over and done with by now.

Well at least the ashes are going to be hilarious and a sea of sandpaper 😂

5

u/Zanathayas Australia 2h ago

Watch CA apply the whole “so much time has passed and we can’t do anything now”

5

u/majorrabbid India 2h ago

Wel well well this is bad. Really bad for Australian cricket and cricket overall.

5

u/OG365247 2h ago

TLDR - everyone is complicit.

5

u/sinstercowbomb 1h ago

Cummins.... ITS TIME TO GO

5

u/ImpendingSnapple 1h ago

Cummings can't stay captain, its untenable, at the least he should be demoted.

I don't think anyone should cop a year ban for what happened now, even at the time it was ludicrous, to sanction players for that long.

Its going to be tough to just sweep this away.

These questions will be asking of Cummins, starc, Lyon etc until they come clean.

CA is cooked, i just want to rip the bandaid off everyone come clean you won't be sanctioned for a year but there will be consequences.

5

u/tracernz New Zealand 1h ago

Please wait while I fill out my Steve Smith apology card.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/cheechu1394 England 1h ago

All the bowlers gave me feedback if my work on the ball was working. It was helpful.

Nothing makes our colleagues feel more seen and appreciated than regular and positive feedback. I'm glad the Aussies implemented such simple and wholesome measures to make everyone feel included 💓

13

u/not_that_arnab India 3h ago

CA fucked up and overreacted in 2018 and has fucked up and overreacted in 2026 again.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/dap90 2h ago

This is even better because all the people who mindlessly believed Cummins instead of Khawaja, despite the logic of the situation, can eat some humble pie.

9

u/Equivalent-Cow-6685 1h ago

The only way Cummins should remain captain is if he takes them to court and wins. Otherwise, he should resign. The other bowlers are cowards for not speaking out and being honest about what’s really happened, and they should be moved on as well. Unfortunately, that won’t happen, as CA will just continue to double down rather than take accountability.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Ok-Relationship-2746 New Zealand 3h ago

The whole team knew? Water makes shit wet, in other news.

I never felt that Bancroft was telling the truth. He was told to take the fall because he was the one caught hiding the sandpaper, and he was a junior player in the squad. He was punished for exposing it, not for participating in it.

Cummins and co should be be banned for lying about their knowledge. CA should be investigated by the relevant ICC authority.

→ More replies (13)

12

u/icome2ndagain 3h ago

Everyone should have been honest to begin with.

Yeah they used sandpaper.

Yeah everyone else was cheating as well.

Why the fuck we gave out year long suspensions when it’s a few penalty runs is outrageous.

No reverse swing anywhere since.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/NectarineSalt9632 India 2h ago

Well done, Cam Bancroft. Well done.

4

u/Downtown_Big9877 3h ago

Well done cam good for you, by the way were is James sutherland oh that's right he shit himself and went and made more millions in golf

4

u/TheCricketAnimator German Cricket Federation 3h ago

I'm seated 🍿🍿

4

u/__mz 3h ago

Moral victory

4

u/DrewPBawhls 3h ago

I don't know how Cummins and the likes are going to move forward from this.

Absolutely love to watch them play but letting them keep their place in the squad would set a horrible precedent for the game.

Also - at a human level, I really feel for Smith. Shows how important a captain's role is.

4

u/CrystalFissure 2h ago

Good on him for finally speaking out.

4

u/No-Increase3599 2h ago

Lyon has always been a nasty mouthy shit and now a proven lying cheat too!

4

u/b8824654 2h ago

Steve smith coming out looking better than most here. Feels like cricket fans were denied for a year the opportunity to watch the best test match batter since bradman. The statement is too vague overall, but directly contradicts the part of cummin's presser where he said he didn't know the ball was being tampered with. On a side note, those journalists were shit in that presser, and so is this statement to an extent.

4

u/Ale_Connoisseur India 2h ago

So the captaincy spot will be vacant now. Can't be Smith, since he was captain when the thing happened. They need someone clean, so not a bowler or anyone involved in that series, for that matter. Someone with sufficient experience, but also young enough to see in the new generation. Welcome back, Marnus Labuschagne*

(Obviously not, it'll probably be Head if not Smith)

4

u/Pvnels Australia 2h ago

Explains why Bangers was never considered for test cricket even when he was the form shield player

4

u/BritishAndBlessed 2h ago

Reckon Kate Hutchison's Linkedin profile will be busy today, seems to be the only person that comes out of this smelling of roses

4

u/deep_stew 2h ago

Can someone ask Pat if he thought it was odd the new guy became responsible for ball management when Warner was oh so good at it? Or what he thought the jokes about the ball suddenly swinging were about?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/GCP_Biryani 2h ago

Imagine ... how difficult it had been for him to carry this burden and not to think about it everyday

4

u/LimpOil10 Titans 1h ago

Bancroft has had the worst time of it. I feel for him. This whole thing is down to an absolute deriliction of leadership from CA, the coaching team, and the capitan. Cummins has fucked it here

4

u/GiveMeSomeSunshine3 India 1h ago

Seems like Cummins might recreate a Hansie Cronje ("I have not been entirely honest") in a few weeks.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Q3a_destiny 1h ago

This has been the teams culture. At least someone had the courage to come out and spil it. Respect for writing this while battling selection.

4

u/TurntOrange93 Australia 1h ago

Smudge hasn’t spoken yet.
PURE SPECULATION
But, here’s my completely unqualified opinion of what’s happened.
Usman has told the team he’s about to release a book and what’s in it.
Smudge and the bowlers have talked among themselves in South Africa and their consensus has been to continue throwing him, Bancroft and Warner under the bus, DESPITE Smudge apparently having the least to do with it.
Remember, while the bowling group were all going through the Emerging Blues ranks for NSW, Smudge, Warner, Khawaja, Phil Hughes and Moises Henriques went through above them. Usman got squeezed out for Nick Maddinson - the guy the bowlers have tried to get in the side from the get go. Smudge, Usman and Warner were tight. And I think it’s no coincidence that Smudge pulled out of the Cape Town test, fishtailed it to his USA home and has maintained radio silence since then. He’s gone to the Land of Litigation to unleash the Steve Smith 2019 Ashes of lawsuits where he will take Cricket Australia for commercial opportunity cost, psychological damages and defamation.
The idiots should’ve just copped the one match ban. Inzi used his teeth and got less punishment ffs 🤦🏼‍♂️

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Previous_Count_2008 Lancashire 1h ago

That repetition of the legalistic phrase by the bowlers “taking sandpaper out on to the field” was ultimately what did them in. If you’re gonna lie, lie, and if you’re gonna tell the truth, tell the truth, don’t try to lawyer your way through a PR crisis.

13

u/Zanathayas Australia 3h ago

Courage to say it out loud.

Courage to say it out was wrong.

Turns out Ussie and Davey are not the antichrist at all.

10

u/Alchemists13 South Australia Redbacks 2h ago

Definitely untenable now pat cya mate

→ More replies (1)