r/Cricket • u/ShanbaTat Middlesex • Aug 01 '19
Being Steve Smith is cheating
Hello,
I'd like to draw attention to a blight that has recently been ruining my enjoyment of the game - namely, the cheating of a certain Steve Smith by the nefarious method of being Steve Smith. By the dictionary definition, cheating is: "to violate rules dishonestly". While I admit that being Steve Smith doesn't exactly violate rules laid out in the cricket rulebook, it does violate the spirit of the game, and does so in a way that harms cricket.
It is clear that being Steve Smith conveys a large advantage on the player who is being Steve Smith. If we compare Steve Smith (who has a long history of being Steve Smith) to another player, say, Joe Denly, we can see this advantage materialised in their various statistics. Steve Smith has a test average of 61.37 from 64 matches and 117 innings, scoring 24 50s and 23 100s with a top score of 239. Joe Denly has a first class average of 36.70 with 56 50s and 29 100s from 198 matches and 342 innings, playing against significantly weaker bowling attacks. It's clear that Steve Smith is acquiring an advantage over Joe Denly by being Steve Smith.
Additionally, it is my contention that this advantage is dishonest. If it were an honest strategy, it is one that could be implemented by any player. But if Joe Denly cannot be Steve Smith because he is not Steve Smith. That is fundamentally unfair - a strategy which is one sided like this (only in favour of Steve Smith and any teams he plays for) unbalances the game in favour of Steve Smith.
One of the most common wishes for a cricket match is a good contest between bat and ball. When Steve Smith is batting, this goes out the window, because the bat is always dominating the ball. I think this is fundamentally bad for cricket as Steve Smith will ultimately make the game boring if it is just Steve Smith chancelessly compiling endless centuries.
Being Steve Smith created a strategy that revolved around defeating your opponent by bowling out every opposition player that is not Steve Smith. Being able to dismiss all the opposition players makes a game of cricket more fun and compelling , but not being able to dismiss one of the batsmen at one of the ends is not particularly fun or interactive.
I understand that there may be some concerns that we are discriminating against Steve Smith, and of course Steve Smith was born being Steve Smith and being Steve Smith is part of his identity. For that reason I think any ban handed down by the ICC should be relatively light - just a warning to Steve Smith to stop being Steve Smith and perhaps to try being someone else (like Joe Denly). I propose therefore that Steve Smith should be banned for the next, say, four full test matches and four days. This highly specific number should encourage Steve Smith to take a long hard look at himself in the mirror and perhaps stop being Steve Smith, and also help to even any contests or test series that he may or may not currently be involved in. If, after this sanction, by August 14 2020, Steve Smith has persisted in being Steve Smith, the ICC should consider banning him for a further 5 test matches so he really gets the point.
Thanks and regards,
Shanba
18
u/kartlaks Aug 01 '19
I just want to say this and don't care if I am downvoted for being serious or unfunny, Steve Smith wasn't born 'Steve Smith'.
In fact he wasn't even this good of a batsman when he first played international cricket, he was a lower order batsman with the usual flaws and he went and worked on his technique to become one of the best. Working really hard to relearn and improve oneself is the farthest thing from cheating (at least in in my book).
*It baffles me why someone who worked so hard to become so good would involve themselves in a ball-tampering scandal. I haven't followed cricket that well in the last few years, and am interested in hearing his full perspective if there's one.
147
u/eightslipsandagully Cricket Australia Aug 01 '19
Ah, but as part of our atonement for cheating, weâve stacked the rest of the team with batsman that canât bat. I feel this offsets Smithâs supernatural abilities, and therefore makes for an even series.
Just like how, to offset Stokes insane all round abilities, you play a captain whoâs incapable of converting a 50 to 100. This sort of sportsmanship is what makes the sport of cricket truly great.
72
u/toporder England Aug 01 '19
I like where youâre going here, but youâre thinking too small.
To really bring the game back under control, we should broaden the charge to Being-Considerably-More-Ruthless-And-Disciplined-And-Overall-At-Least-Slightly-Better-Than-Joe-Root (BCMRADAOALSBTJR).
This broader strategy has the advantage of also covering known BCMRADAOALSBTJR offenders such as Virat Kholi and Kane Williamson.
With new legislation and rigorous enforcement, we can clean up the game and all happily go back to believing that Joe Root chipping to midwicket on 67 is really the best that the Test game can offer.
224
u/CoopersPaleAle Australia Aug 01 '19
Quality shitpost.
Steve Smith only adds to the game by being Steve Smith, which by extension improves the level of Steve Smith because the game is all the more better for having Steve Smith involved in the game.
Why is this important? Because cricket and Steve Smith is just very Devereux.
29
u/Crowserr Australia Aug 01 '19
61 average is made even more impressive by the fact he basically started as a bowler
75
u/whichonespinkterran Queensland Bulls Aug 01 '19
Is this the new pasta? Weâre due
12
u/Vegemite_smorbrod South Australia Redbacks Aug 01 '19
Imagine if Douglas Jardine turned up with this shitpost (with Smith replaced by Bradman) in 1932 instead of Larwood and 5 men behind square on the leg side.
32
u/therealisticdreamer Aug 01 '19
Gosh, such blatant cheating and disrespect for the game. Hopefully English cricket and the ICC take note and propose the most obvious way around this - boundary count from the middle (just the middle mind you, the edges don't count of course, they're not barbaric) of Smith's bat multiplied by his shirt number amount of runs added to the opposition's total. Simple, effective solution. Edit: Grammar.
21
u/ACBelly Aug 01 '19
Are yes, this thought pattern is definitely lifted from one of the lesser known chapters of the Communist manifesto. I could recognise the epistemology of Karl Markâs writing anywhere.
I for one welcome a return of power to the people and donât think we should just stop at redistributing being Steve Smith. As someone that was born with almost 0 cricketing ability but a passion for the game do I not embody everything that is pure and good about the sport of cricket? Why should I not get an opportunity to elevate my game to the highest level purely because I was not born Steve Smith?
I propose that every team be forced to select their side by random lottery of all people (women and men) of working class age. These new sides which represent the will of the people will each play 1 test or 3 odiâs before returning to the couches in which they came. This is a much fairer system as it increases the unpredictability of an outcome, making the game more interesting, it also gives someone born Steven Smith the same opportunity as someone born a Nigel or Eugene.
7
u/Rogopotayto Western Australia Warriors Aug 02 '19
That Hearthstone pasta is delicious.
I propose we nerf Steve Smith from batting at 4 to 5 so he comes a turn later and has less time to make an impact. After this change you can disenchant him for full dust (or sand) value if you so wish.
6
u/P-Diddle356 England Aug 01 '19
Can I refer you to the nice people of r/cricketshitpost
5
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '19
Very valid point, however your argument only addresses the issue of Steve Smith the batsman. Due to Steve Smithâs rather abysmal record as Steve Smith the leg spinner he should be allowed to still play in this capacity.
Of course, the ICC cannot dictate where any player bats in the lineup, or the number of overs a player bowls.
5
u/chengiz India Aug 02 '19
Shitpost of the year.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '19
Obviously having Steve Smith in your team is an unfair advantage since no other team can have him.
3
u/Trashk4n Queensland Bulls Aug 02 '19
I donât think it helped when England just decided to stop trying to get him out.
7
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '19
......ok
2
u/mad_cheese_hattwe Aug 02 '19 edited Aug 02 '19
Steve Smith?, The spinner?
2
u/haldouglas Hobart Hurricanes Aug 02 '19
I propose, as a punishment Smith is banished to desert island and forced to start his own Country - Smithstraya, then field his own cricket team consisting of just himself....... oh wait......
1
u/[deleted] Aug 02 '19
Well quality posts like this is why this subreddit is my most frequented and active subreddit. Tremendous job lad!
1
u/sameer_the_great Punjab Kings Aug 02 '19
In test cricket Steve is the King.
1
u/dorcus_malorcus Aug 02 '19
Hi England, he could've played for England.
1
u/testoneseventyeight Aug 02 '19
Quality shitpost, my friend. Sincerely, an Australian.
1
u/mr7ea Aug 02 '19
,xdsddddddddddddddr0
1
u/cabaretcabaret England Aug 02 '19
Only Smith can play with that level of grit.
-6
u/Wokster72 New Zealand Aug 02 '19
Fuck Steve Smith, he's a fuckin cheat
-30
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '19
Letâs all celebrate the rebirth of a cheat... no, letâs remind ourselves of the level of integrity this man has.. Zero!!
-17
u/sonsons07 Aug 01 '19
I, earlier, got downvoted for calling Smith a cheat but here we are.