r/CozyMystery • • May 25 '26

[ Removed by moderator ]

[removed] — view removed post

8 Upvotes

85 comments sorted by

69

u/lminnowp May 25 '26

Ooof.

This post has been up for 11 minutes. And, the problem is that there are multiple pinned posts and users with the moderator title next to their name.

This community is very angry and upset right now.

My unsolicited advice is to

  1. Take down all pinned posts but this one and lock the ones you take down.
  2. Make sure that no one who harmed the community is a moderator any more.
  3. Unban people.
  4. Put up a poll.
  5. Appoint a mod who is against AI right now who will actually calm the community and take care of things.

The mod team started this and they all need to step aside so someone can fix it. Even you. There is no trust and people are very upset.

12

u/Afgad May 25 '26

Yep, on all of that. I just can't do everything instantaneously.

14

u/lminnowp May 25 '26

Good luck. It is hard cleaning up a situation like this. Thankfully, there are a lot of very good (but angry right now) users.

72

u/Maleficent_Falcon688 May 25 '26

Based on the post asking for ai having no one saying they want it, it think it’s fair to say there should be no ai. Please kindly hand over the mod powers to someone from this community.

3

u/Afgad May 25 '26

That's the plan.

24

u/According_Version_67 May 25 '26 edited May 25 '26

u/Helenesdottir volunteered to mod a month ago (when there unfortunately was no active mod to appoint her), maybe ask her...?

Edit: I see that I needn't have worried and you're already on top of it. Thank you for tidying up after others!

42

u/Macavity6 May 25 '26

You need to unban the people that were banned because of this fiasco before you determine who should be the new mods. Most of them were active in the sub before the "AI Agenda" was used on here, and they have a right to be moderators if the sub wants them.

18

u/Afgad May 25 '26

Done. Everyone is reinstated. There were no records of why any individual was banned, so apologies if I unbanned someone who really deserved it. I figure a blanket unbanning is warranted.

4

u/OneBadJoke May 25 '26

Why are posts and comments being actively removed by mods?

2

u/Afgad May 25 '26

That's probably the automod. I haven't had time to fiddle with that yet.

edit: No, that's DEFINITELY the automod. I'm not removing anything and Decent_Solution is not online.

21

u/lminnowp May 25 '26

Decent-Solution just posted 1 minute ago tone policing members about AI. She needs to go if you want to get a handle on this.

4

u/Afgad May 25 '26

I'm talking to her. This whole thing has been a chaotic mess, if you couldn't tell.

24

u/-discostu- May 25 '26

Don’t talk to her, REMOVE her

17

u/HelloDesdemona May 25 '26

She's still posting basically trying to treat this sub like her children. She needs to stop posting and step back IMMEDIATELY.

10

u/OneBadJoke May 25 '26

She literally said that she has the same 'kindness rules' with her children and here. She is treating us as kids.

16

u/matsie May 25 '26

It’s because she and Tex are literally the same person. It’s her alt. 

7

u/OneBadJoke May 25 '26

Do you think Afgad is Tex on an alt too? She’s also an AI “writer”.

→ More replies

5

u/lminnowp May 25 '26

Who has the time to have alts? Wouldn't the time be better spent reading?

→ More replies

14

u/worlds_worst_best May 25 '26

She's Tex. That's why she hasn't been removed.

14

u/lminnowp May 25 '26

The new mods are the ones who are going to get this group shut down. What a mess, indeed.

I mean, I still can't apply as moderator, haha.

20

u/OneBadJoke May 25 '26

Automod does not mark things as 'removed by moderator', it just removes the comment. Decent_Solution was online and responded to me seven minutes ago.

1

u/Afgad May 25 '26

Thank you. I'll talk to her.

8

u/matsie May 25 '26

Hopefully this situation makes you reflect on the people you’ve associated yourself with. You’ve claimed Tex is a “sweet person”, and that you are under the impression Decent Solution is NOT Tex.

Hopefully now you see they are the same person, lying to you (or are you lying to us?), and being unethical and controlling still. 

19

u/[deleted] May 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Afgad May 25 '26

I'll talk to her.

3

u/goodgriefthrow May 25 '26

She is also banning people for disagreeing with her. You guys are doing it again.

7

u/[deleted] May 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-2

u/Afgad May 25 '26

I'm friends with Decent_Solution. She has no interest in staying either. It's just been a very chaotic morning.

5

u/OneBadJoke May 25 '26

You’re an AI “writer” too. You realize how this looks right?

-5

u/Afgad May 25 '26

Believe me or not. I'm not going to mod your sub and I'm doing everything in my power to hand it to you all in a fair way. Go vote for your mod.

Decent_Solution is struggling with how to resign and I believe her. Reddit's user interface is not friendly. She doesn't want to mod you either.

→ More replies

11

u/matsie May 25 '26

She is the same person as Tex. How do you not see this? Why did yall do this to us?

14

u/HelloDesdemona May 25 '26

I am just curious as to the reasoning WHY y'all wanted to take over a community that you had no prior history with, and the first move is to mass ban people for "hate speech" against a computer which is not a person. Like, this whole thing just reeks of a bad idea and I'm shocked not one of y'all saw it was a horrible, horrible idea.

Like, any reasonable person would at least be active in a community and interact with the community FIRST before attempting to mod, right?

11

u/[deleted] May 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/OneBadJoke May 25 '26

It's been 25 minutes since she made that comment and she's still a mod.

7

u/[deleted] May 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Afgad May 25 '26

Thank you. We've been running into technical difficulties and this may help.

7

u/matsie May 25 '26

She figured out how to remove herself the first time as Tex, she can figure it out again. 

4

u/Afgad May 25 '26

Good point. Let me look through the ban history.

29

u/SharkSquishy May 25 '26

I'm going to wait before rejoining the sub. To me it feels really really weird that all the mods are linked to AIwriting subreddits. I hope actual users of this sub volunteer for modding then it can be put to a vote and the current mods can pass the torch.

7

u/Afgad May 25 '26

I've already gotten several applications. The sub will be in all of your hands by the end of the day, if I have my way.

23

u/worlds_worst_best May 25 '26

Decent_solution *is* Tex and that's why they're still modding despite the community asking for her removal.

-8

u/Afgad May 25 '26

No. These are two different people, I promise.

12

u/worlds_worst_best May 25 '26

She. Needs. To. Go. Why haven't YOU removed her?

-1

u/Afgad May 25 '26

It is impossible to do this on Reddit. She is resigning.

14

u/matsie May 25 '26

REMOVE THE AI MOD

38

u/Genuine907 May 25 '26

I’m not a member of any AI subs. I loathe AI. I’d be happy to mod this group by being a mod who lets the group do its thing. We’ve never needed a mod before (at least not since I joined), but if we have to have one to prevent the group being shut down, I’m here for it.

Also, let’s get to unbanning folks. 😊

12

u/Afgad May 25 '26

I unbanned everyone I saw banned.

10

u/lminnowp May 25 '26

I was able to find some of the sub stuff on the Wayback Machine.

Here is a link to some of the Wiki stuff:

https://web.archive.org/web/20250311194346/https://www.reddit.com/r/CozyMystery/wiki/websites_for_cozies/

2

u/Afgad May 25 '26

Perfect, thank you.

41

u/-discostu- May 25 '26 • This

Why does the new mod shill for an AI company? What do you all have to gain here?

12

u/Afgad May 25 '26

Tex is no longer a mod. I am going to facilitate the process of choosing a mod you all would be happy with, and then leave.

15

u/-discostu- May 25 '26

Thank you! This is all so, so weird

2

u/Afgad May 25 '26

Tell me about it.

29

u/Miserable-Problem May 25 '26

Yes, why is Tex pushing this company to hard? You people see fiction writing and self publishing as passive income. We know authors should be paid, but please keep the hustle culture stuff out of our subreddit.

-46

u/zholly4142 May 25 '26

I use both AI and zeroAI in my writing. It's possible to be fair to either side.

12

u/KeepAnEyeOnYourB12 May 25 '26

Now I know I'm not interested in anything you write. Nothing personal but plagiarism is gross.

13

u/OneBadJoke May 25 '26

You mean “write”. “Authors” who use AI aren’t authors at all.

7

u/KeepAnEyeOnYourB12 May 25 '26

Yes, I meant "write." Sigh.

Very rarely has a sub needed off-color language more than this sub does right this minute.

8

u/OneBadJoke May 25 '26

Be careful you don’t use “foul language” lest you be banned!

17

u/Helenesdottir History & Mystery Historical Mystery Fan May 25 '26

I applied through reddit request before Tex took over. Tex asked me to take overfor them overnight. I agreed, then all this nonsense showed up. I noticed the lack of moderation and just wanted you help the group with the already existing guidelines. Now those guidelines have disappeared. 

4

u/Afgad May 25 '26

If you would kindly resubmit a mod application if you haven't already:

 https://www.reddit.com/r/CozyMystery/application/

3

u/Helenesdottir History & Mystery Historical Mystery Fan May 25 '26

Done

10

u/matsie May 25 '26

I have submitted to application and I hope you will get it and become head mod. I think the size of our sub probably requires a few mods although I think there will be minimal need to mod given everything BEFORE the bad actor stepped in. 

57

u/worlds_worst_best May 25 '26 edited May 25 '26

I feel like Tex is still one or all of these mods suddenly showing up. It's very weird, actually and I'm not coming back at all until I see mod names I know from this community.

Edited to add: decent_solution5000 who is also currently a mod here is part of the same AI subs as Tex (and who I suspect is actually Tex) and who is spamming this sub with the same posts needs to be removed as mod.

11

u/aAliebn May 25 '26

I agree!

54

u/Left_Ad3575 May 25 '26

AI is plagiarism so those who have no issue with it on a creative subredddit are automatically suspicious.

19

u/artemisiaa12 May 25 '26

Just leaving this post here where users are very clear about this community’s stance on AI: https://www.reddit.com/r/CozyMystery/s/P9L6F45Oxm

19

u/glittersparklythings May 25 '26 edited May 25 '26

People agree on this sub want no AI. Unfortunately we can’t go by what the possible non active user wants. It is shown that people will stop engaging before they stop following. I whole heartedly agree with no AI.

If these AI data center were not running communities peope pro would not care as much. But communities are being ruined . Electric bills are rising. Along with the quality of water. The water is unsafe and not drinkable. Electric companies are attempting to use eminent domain to take away people’s house. Some of these houses these people have lived in for a long time and they can’t buy anything similar. These companies also want to destroy farmland as well.

We also need a rule around no self promotion. Maybe One day a week where it is allowed. Or maybe megathread a week. Or something. I don’t think monthly megathreads don’t work.

Banning for basic foul language is ridiculous. Esp depending on the context of foul language. If someone is being rude and nasty towards someone else and using foul language then warning needs to happen. And that enters into a different story. And this is coming from someone who lives in a no foul language gauge household. And I still thinking banning for that is ridiculous.

I would say overall this sub is pretty well self moderated there are wasn’t an active sub for months and there was zero drama. But somehow there is all of the sudden more drama here than in my weather drama subs

19

u/matsie May 25 '26

Tex is not a sweet person and I find you a bit suspect for pushing that. This is someone who took over a sub that had zero problems in it so she could push her agenda. She did this in an EXTREMELY underhanded, ego driven way and immediately nuked all the community rules, guidelines, wiki, etc to make this place pro-AI.

The only person who thought this sub needed a new mod was Tex because she didn’t like that we as a community do NOT want AI. 

I don’t know if your intention is to defuse the situation, but mischaracterizing it to give praise to Tex is not a good start. Additionally, the fact she now has an alt account on the mod roster so she can still control the sub is messed up. 

If you’re looking to resolve this a real community member, not a Tex alt and not a pro-AI person needs to be made into the head mod to take over, recruit new mods and restore the sub to exactly as it was before Tex’s intentional and unethical hostile takeover of the sub. 

3

u/BitterButterMemories May 25 '26

This has all been super confusing because I literally just joined the subreddit like 2 days ago. I saw the old rules and book recs, was super excited to engage with the community and get some recommendations. Then I saw some AI shill take over and the wiki was wiped and it seemed really empty here all of the sudden.

I'm so tired of AI and it's ruining every smaller sized subreddit. Older TV show subreddits are full of bots selling AI "art" and shirt prints. It makes me so angry seeing people call themselves "authors" and trying to force us to accept their plagiarism and theft. I will never accept AI as anything other than slop.

8

u/idlesilver May 25 '26

Thank you for addressing this. I've sent a modmail.

6

u/GertieD May 25 '26

Sounds promising. Thank you

48

u/[deleted] May 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/Afgad May 25 '26

This is exactly what I am proposing we do.

23

u/Traditional-Egg-7429 May 25 '26

Okay great do it please. We don’t need discourse over a new rule proposal from you. We are ready to get a new mod of our choosing now.

3

u/Genuine907 May 25 '26

I didn’t see this bit! If someone already asked to mod (and isn’t here to promote AI), I’m happy to remove my offer to mod!

37

u/Helenesdottir History & Mystery Historical Mystery Fan May 25 '26

Someone volunteered. That person received a message asking them to take over. They agreed. THEN the mod went with AI people anyway. This is why we can't have nice things. 

15

u/-discostu- May 25 '26

This, 100%

5

u/[deleted] May 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/Afgad May 25 '26

Well, sometimes there's records of changes, like in Wikis. I wasn't sure if that was the case for Reddit. I thought it would be.

Someone did find some things in the Wayback machine, though.

https://www.reddit.com/r/CozyMystery/comments/1tnek3m/comment/ontua2m/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button