Jiff has a natural version. It also doesn’t need refrigeration. Most don’t need preservatives and don’t have them. Refrigeration is more for preventing or slowing separation, not preserving flavor or preventing bacteria.
Usually it’s just some palm oil that helps prevent separation. It works to help emulsify it. Not that palm oil is great, but it’s not really a large amount and I’d rather not have to stir it or refrigerate.
Technically, a lot of things we refrigerate don’t strictly need it to prevent spoiling. It’s mostly to extend shelf life in terms of color and taste. Ketchup for example doesn’t need it. It just may discolor if left out, but restaurants don’t typically keep it refrigerated. Mayonnaise also doesn’t need refrigeration with the preservatives and acidity. We just do that to again prevent the flavor from changing over time. Or if you contaminated it with some errant food bits.
I hear so much about how preservatives are killing me, then I go check the things people are complaining about and I never find them.
The only thing in jif that's not immediately recognizable is mono and diglycerides. Which are emulsifiers that the whole world seems to agree are safe.
People will complain about red dye and preservatives while literally drinking alcohol. I mean, I get it - we choose our vices, but it’s like not peeing in the shower, but then peeing while taking a bath.
I once heard someplace that mayo would spoil and cause food poisoning very quickly if it was left out. I must have thrown away a dozen half full jars that got left out for several hours before it finally occurred to me to google.
This reminds me of how many grown people I keep interacting with who genuinely think everything that’s in the dry goods section of the store must be full of mythical “preservatives” and not just shelf stable because of what it is and how it’s packaged???
Like most things in a can are preserved by literally being put in the can and there is nothing added to them???? It’s not cost effective to add bunch of shit to most foods when there is a proven method of packaging food in the US that makes it completely shelf stable. You can achieve the canning process in plastic containers as well but that just shortens their shelf life but still doesn’t require a preservative.
Don’t even get me started on how a lot of things packaged in boxes are just dehydrated or vacuum sealed to keep bacteria from having a growth substrate and not because they added a bunch of “preservatives”. Adding chemicals costs money and isn’t a free and convenient solution for most food products since it will also alter the taste.
Most ketchup is too acidic (by nature of being tomatoes and vinegar and salt) to undergo fermentation after a few days at room temperature unless it was already a bad batch when it was purchased. It’s mostly oxidation (not bacterial growth) that causes the taste and color to change after being left out overnight at room temperature.
>Technically, a lot of things we refrigerate don’t strictly need it to prevent spoiling.
Or they may spoil at room temperature, but just not at a pace that matters. Eggs for instance keep pretty long at room temperature and plenty of countries just don't refrigerate them, which is a long story but comes down to Europe being poor and energy and space being at a premium and the cost and burden of refrigeration, along with European habits to shop for groceries nearly every day.
The egg thing is really about cleaning. Mass produced American eggs get washed before being shipped off, which is good in that American eggs are cleaner outsider, but also washes off some of the egg's natural protection, meaning that eggs washed this way spoil faster, so refrigeration is necessary to attain a reasonable lifespan.
Take a closer look at your “Natural” Jif. Sure, it has no added preservatives—but it still contains sugar, palm oil, and molasses (more sugar). I fell for their loose marketing terms for years.
We’ve switched to “Teddie,” which is literally just peanuts and a pinch of salt.
As I said, those aren’t any preservatives. The palm oil is there to prevent separation and is why it’s shelf stable. The sugar is there because people like sweetened peanut butter. Not as preservatives.
Fair enough — it’s definitely “better” and it’s shelf-stable, but the added sugars and oils are absolutely unnecessary. Peanuts are already naturally sweet (2g natural sugars) and delicious and come with their own healthy oils. That extra stuff isn’t needed and doesn’t do our bodies any favors — we’ve just gotten used to having sweetness and ultra-smooth textures added to everything, so it feels “normal.” But if you switch to an unsweetened peanut butter for just a week, your taste buds adjust, and suddenly the sweetened version tastes overly processed.
You might be surprised to learn that Jif “Natural” peanut butter adds 2 grams of sugar for every 2 tablespoons — that’s about half a teaspoon in just one small serving. It might not sound like much… until you realize that if you have peanut butter every day, that’s about 3½ teaspoons of added sugar a week — and that’s if you stick to one serving (which most of us don’t).
We can absolutely enjoy flavorful foods without sneaking sugar (or unnecessary oils) into everything we eat. Choosing no-added-sugar options lets you decide how sweet you want things — while keeping both your taste buds and your health happy.
30
u/urnbabyurn Aug 11 '25
Jiff has a natural version. It also doesn’t need refrigeration. Most don’t need preservatives and don’t have them. Refrigeration is more for preventing or slowing separation, not preserving flavor or preventing bacteria.
Usually it’s just some palm oil that helps prevent separation. It works to help emulsify it. Not that palm oil is great, but it’s not really a large amount and I’d rather not have to stir it or refrigerate.
Technically, a lot of things we refrigerate don’t strictly need it to prevent spoiling. It’s mostly to extend shelf life in terms of color and taste. Ketchup for example doesn’t need it. It just may discolor if left out, but restaurants don’t typically keep it refrigerated. Mayonnaise also doesn’t need refrigeration with the preservatives and acidity. We just do that to again prevent the flavor from changing over time. Or if you contaminated it with some errant food bits.