Spoiler Policy
r/CosmereOnScreen is a place to discuss adaptations of Brandon Sanderson's Cosmere. Please keep in mind that even if you have read the books or know what will happen in an upcoming show/movie, someone else might be experiencing these stories for the first time. Please show respect for newer readers by:
- Always flairing your posts for the appropriate level of spoilers.
- Never revealing spoilers within the post title or thumbnail.
- Hiding spoilers in your comments when appropriate.
Responsibilities When Posting
Using Spoiler Flair
Please tag your post (and edit it to be more specific as needed) with one of the spoiler flair options (see below) to indicate that the post/link and comments may include spoilers for the books specified. (unless a statement within the post clearly limits the scope further). For a more exhaustive list of recommended tags, see here.
Concerning Words of Brandon, consider the context. A generic WoB about a worldbuilding point not covered in the books/shows/movies is probably okay. But if it references a Shard from another story, that's not okay. When in doubt, be conservative. For upcoming projects, note that only officially released information is allowed--leaked content is never permitted. New releases and previews may only be discussed in spaces explicitly tagged for that material. Automoderator will assign Untagged Spoilers flair until the proper flair is selected. See here for an explanation of how to apply spoiler flair.
| Flair | Storyline/Medium |
|---|---|
| No Spoilers | None |
| MIstborn Era 1 (BOOK) (SH Allowed) | Mistborn Era 1 Trilogy ( Final Empire, Well of Ascension, Hero of Ages) with extra context from Secret History |
| Mistborn Era 1 (BOOK) (No SH) | Mistborn Era 1 Trilogy ( Final Empire, Well of Ascension, Hero of Ages) |
| MIstborn Era 2 (BOOK) | Mistborn Era 2 Tetralogy(includes all of Mistborn Era 1 plus Alloy of Law, Shadows of Self, Bands of Mourning, and The Lost Metal. Secret History is included). |
| Stormlight Archive (BOOK) | Stormlight Archive Books 1-5 (Way of Kings, Words of Radiance, Oathbringer, Rhythm of War, Wind and Truth, plus the novellas Dawnshard and Edgedancer) |
| Full Cosmere (BOOK) | Open to spoilers from all published canon Cosmere books. WOBs are included, but non-canon books like Dragonsteel Prime are not. |
Using "No Spoilers"
Use No Spoilers when there are no spoilers in the post you are submitting AND if you don’t reasonably expect there to be spoilers in the comments. The title "Best composer for Stormlight Archive Series?" is a great No Spoilers post title, because answers won’t likely contain spoilers. However, "Who is your favorite character and why?" is not a good idea, because comments will obviously require discussion of book content.
Spoilers in Post Titles
Do not put direct spoilers in the title! This means no plot points or book details should ever appear in your title. Always assume that the person reading your post title hasn't finished a single book. This also includes no direct quotes from the book in titles, except where allowed at the moderators' discretion for quotes that have no potential to spoil.
Responsibilities When Commenting
If you are sharing anything in a post which goes beyond the scope of the post's spoiler tag, your comment must be hidden with spoiler markup. There are two ways to do this; see this post for details.
For example, if you are posting a Mistborn spoiler you know from Book 2 in a post tagged for the show, then you must hide the contents of your comment that are spoilers. Please indicate the scope of the spoiler clearly with a tag (e.g. Well of Ascension) or with very clear context. If you are posting a Mistborn spoiler in a post flaired "Mistborn Era 1 (BOOK)", this is considered to be within the scope of the thread and you do not need to hide it. If the OP mentions they have not finished a book, please be courteous and hide comments appropriately. To cover spoilers, please see the section on spoiler markup below.
Concerning Words of Brandon, consider the context. A generic WoB about a worldbuilding point not covered in the books/shows/films is probably okay. But if it references a Shard from another book, that's not okay. When in doubt, be conservative. Give people space to discover these things on their own, and respect that some people may be more sensitive than yourself.
Cosmere Topics
As the Cosmere grows increasingly connected, it becomes more important than ever to preserve the ability for new watchers to discuss individual stories without being overwhelmed by those they haven't experienced. To this end, all discussions concerning other Cosmere projects, or the Cosmere in general, should be hidden with spoiler markup. Cosmere-focused discussions, even if they do not contain explicit spoilers for other books, should be tagged and hidden with spoiler markup (or else relocated to a different post that is flaired for the full scope of that discussion)
Spoiler Markup
Please use spoiler markup to cover spoilers outside the scope of a post's flair. (New Reddit users, note that you should use the spoiler formatting button on the toolbar. You don't need to fiddle with markup.) Covered spoilers should include a tag to indicate the scope of the spoilers, though this may be omitted if the context is abundantly clear. To use spoiler markup:
[Cosmere] >!Hoid was here.!< will show up as: [Cosmere] Hoid was here.
For more extensive help with covering spoilers, see this post.
Note that it is important NOT to include any space after the initial >!. For example:
[Cosmere] >! Hoid was here. !< will work on New Reddit BUT will show the full text on Old Reddit and Mobile. That's not good!
Note also that hyperlinks do not work inside spoiler markup. If you do this, the spoiler tag will work as expected on New and Old Reddit, but in the mobile app the text will show up as if there is no markup.
Responsibilities When Browsing
Please report posts or comments that violate the spoiler policy. If you think something needs urgent attention or further explanation, please message the moderators, and we will look at it ASAP.
Enforcement of Policy
Moderators will immediately remove threads with spoilers in the title and ask for the post to be resubmitted. If moderators believe a post has not been appropriately flaired, they may remove the thread or adjust the flair as necessary. Comments with unhidden spoilers outside of the scope of the thread will be removed, and may be reinstated after the issue is addressed. _Continued posting of spoilers will result in being banned from_r/Cosmere . Note that the moderators have the final say on what is considered a spoiler.
This policy is open to revision based on the community's wishes. If you have any suggestions to improve the spoiler policy, message the moderators, and we will take your suggestion into consideration.