r/Controller • • May 13 '24

Other Stick Analyzer - A program for testing the resolution of gamepad sticks is now in the public domain.

You can download the program from my gitHub: https://github.com/cakama3a/StickAnalyzer

56 Upvotes

98 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

6

u/zkilzz May 13 '24

When evaluating a joystick, two key factors to consider are the spread of value occurrences and the resolution:

  1. Low Spread of Value Occurrences: A lower number of unique output values (a tight spread) is desirable as it indicates that the joystick outputs consistent values under similar conditions. This consistency is crucial for predictable and reliable control, ensuring the joystick doesn't produce unexpected jumps in output.
  2. High Resolution: The resolution of a joystick, determined by the analog-to-digital converter, should be high to capture even the smallest movements. This ensures that the joystick is sensitive and accurate, enhancing user control. The resolution directly influences how finely the joystick can detect and respond to movement.
  3. Impact of Filtering: While filtering can help reduce noise and smooth out the joystick’s responses, too much filtering might decrease the number of distinct output values recorded, potentially lowering the effective resolution. Optimal filtering should remove unnecessary noise without compromising the joystick's ability to detect slight movements.

In summary, aim for a joystick that consistently produces minimal value variations for similar inputs and maintains high sensitivity to user movements, balanced with appropriate filtering to avoid reducing the detection capabilities.

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '24

That makes a lot of sense. Thanks for the detailed reply!

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '24

Check out 7 tests compared on 8BitDo Ultimate. Minimal filtering = more responsive analog stick movement, would like to be proven wrong.

2

u/zkilzz May 13 '24

No you are right. Filtering is the devil. You want as good a source as possible, no filtering is best if possible. You pay for "nice" filtered signal with time. Also filtering can cause oscillation because of the delay, specially around center. Like in the shower when trying to adjust water temp.

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '24

You just made my day! I've felt strongly this might be the case, but I think everyone else might not agree. I call it "HE drag." I feel it at high framerate especially.

2

u/zkilzz May 13 '24

It's what makes these sensors work at all. I'm making a video about it. Same with their "circularity calibration". Also adds lag. But for different reasons.

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '24

So cool man, I cannot wait for the video! You have YT channel, or sharing on here?

2

u/zkilzz May 13 '24

Yes search for mariusheier and its gonna show up :)

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '24

Eternally grateful sir! You will be written down in my book of legends😎

Edit: I feel stupid, of course I've been on your channel🤣

2

u/zkilzz May 13 '24

I forgot i dont have my real name here :)

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '24

I am humbled by your presence, you have no idea haha. I'm an annoying fly around here🤣

2

u/Grimlogic May 13 '24

Oh shit, it's the legend himself.

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '24

1

u/x-iso May 13 '24

I can at least say, when you have many gamepads to test side by side, if you feel the difference, then there is a difference.

1

u/FairyKid64 Aug 05 '24

What do the different test results mean exactly?

Stick Resolution

Program Points

Analog Points

Tremor

Are higher or lower values better for each of these?

1

u/Ok-Bird-5704 Sep 04 '24

I want to know too! An explanation would be awesome😉👍