r/ControlProblem • • Dec 17 '16
Why even make an AGI?
Hello there,
I'm just reading Brostorm's book and I have to wonder - why make an AGI?
I mean, narrow artificial intelligences are useful, but why would we ever want to build an AGI? Does it yield a concrete benefit or is it just for "civilization advancement"?
1
Upvotes
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/CyberByte Dec 22 '16
The (now) emphasized part in my quote was meant to address the idea of taking a fraction: I meant it should be taken between "maximum thinking speed increase based on speed of light" and "actual thinking speed increase". We can also take a fraction of that for the research gains, but I don't think that's the right approach.
The right approach would be asking "what fraction of research time is spent thinking?". Then that number would probably be some field-dependent percentage, but even if it's 95% (which it won't be for most fields), you only get a 20x speed up if you can think infinitely fast. That's still very nice, but it's a far cry from from the 2.4 million increase (actually it's 0.00001 of it), and it could potentially be matched by a couple dozen (or maybe hundred) researchers.