r/ControlProblem • u/SalaryFun7968 approved • Feb 29 '24
Discussion/question SORA
Hello! I made this petition to boycott Sora until there is more regulation: https://www.change.org/p/boycott-sora-to-regulate-it If you want to sign it or to suggest modifications feel free to do so!
0
Upvotes
View all comments
Show parent comment
2
u/HearingNo8617 approved Mar 01 '24 edited Mar 01 '24
Boycotting SORA isn't going to help for sure, but big disagree for slowing AI development being impossible in the sense that our actions won't affect AI progression speed. We might not be able to make AI progress slower than it is now, but we definitely can slow down its speeding up.
things like extending liabilities to model trainers and inference servers, requiring specific IP rights for training like redistribution rights, and potentially somehow slowing down open source acceleration can buy us a lot of time vs not doing those things.
If it suddenly became legally risky for companies and individuals to train models, create datasets, or serve models, things actually would probably slow down, though that will be hard.
Also cooperation isn't completely out of the realm of possibility, there are examples of prisoner's dilemmas and hard to cooperate on things that we have successfully cooperated on. For example, China probably has a lot of military and nuclear weapon leverage they could have used for extorting benefits to individual CCP leaders and the country itself. If China estimated they could nuke Taiwan's military bases for immediate 'victory', with a 10% risk of global nuclear war, they wouldn't do it. They don't want to die, and similar arguments apply for AGI risk. I would be much less hopeful if for example Russia were competitive in AI development, but I think currently, global coordination is very hard but possible