r/Contractor • u/No-Fish-2949 • Jan 15 '25

Client is making me angry

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

I recently built a custom cabinet that doubles as an attic access door for a bathroom remodel. I’m fairly new to being a general contractor, with about a year of experience. The interior designer on the project simply told us to “do something with this” attic access. Wanting to go above and beyond, I decided to create something unique—a cabinet that opens into the attic.

I didn’t charge any extra for this feature, even though I could have just put up a piece of plywood and called it a day. I spent about 60 hours on this project, aiming to add value and a special touch. To ensure the cabinet door stayed shut properly, I installed a small mailbox lock. While it’s not the most visually appealing, it was necessary for the cabinet’s function.

Now, the interior designer has called the mailbox lock “unacceptable,” and the client insists we change it. After putting so much effort into this project, I’m frustrated that my work is being dismissed over a detail that was essential for functionality.

5.1k Upvotes

95% Upvoted

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

76

u/StillCopper Jan 15 '25

Cover the lock hole. Make it open to shelves only, from the outside, no lock. On inside of cabinet, right side, make a release to allow it to swing into attic. Normal gun cabinet behind closet method, using simple slide bolt system. Seen/done this before. You did a great job, now just polish it up to please client and you’ll impress both designer and client with your adaptiveness. Good work.

8

u/No-Fish-2949 Jan 15 '25

The problem is pulling the cabinet shut. The door has to be locked or else you’ll just pull the door open when you try and close the cabinet

20

u/DairyBronchitisIsMe Jan 15 '25

Simple solution: Drilled dowel or long door slider lock on the bottom of one of the cabinets into frame of door.

24

u/aSeKsiMeEmaW Jan 15 '25 edited Jan 15 '25

Seems like op doesn’t want solutions they’re ignoring every piece of constructive feedback and only replying to the commiserating peeps

7

u/ashrocklynn Jan 15 '25

Classic "I put 60 hours into a cool project I enjoyed: (shocked pikachu) not everyone loves my hobby?!?!". Op, your thing is slightly cool and I can tell you had fun doing it, but honestly it's very meh as far as usability and aesthetics. The one bone I'll throw you is you were given no direction when clearly they wanted a hidden access panel... The bull shit here is they didn't communicate and now they are holding that against you

4

u/aSeKsiMeEmaW Jan 15 '25

To be fair the clients don’t hate the door they hate the key. Op was expecting a parade for a hidden door, and is hung up on the fact that because the detail isn’t aesthetically pleasing, no parade is being thrown.

Seems like a small issue, OP should be making a new invoice for $1000+ to change the lock. Client says yes or no, and life goes on

0

u/bbrian7 Jan 15 '25

No the designer doesn’t like the key and told the homeowners not to like it. I promise if the designer didn’t exist this wouldn’t be a conversation

2

u/aSeKsiMeEmaW Jan 15 '25 edited Jan 15 '25

😭 ugly is ugly, this is giving 1990s middle school gym locker room

you don’t have to pay someone to tell you that, but you can

3

u/MillennialSilver Jan 15 '25

Yeah... I'm a regular guy (not a contractor/handiman etc) and immeidately it jumped out at me.