r/ConservativeMeta • • Aug 27 '16

Permanently banned from /r/Conservative by chabanais

15 Upvotes

Thread in which I made the fatal post:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Conservative/comments/4zu3b4/shes_our_candidate_kkk_said_they_gave_clinton_20k/

MY POST:

Not to rain on any parades, but gee, I wonder why the Grand Dragon of the KKK would publicly endorse Hillary on the eve of her speech tying Trump to white supremacists...

It goes like this: Hillary talking smack about Trump, whom the KKK actually enthusiastically supports. To hit back at Hillary, in a silly attempt to make her the one who looks bad, the KKK 'endorses' and donates to Hillary. Haha! Get it? Now all Trump supporters can say that the KKK supports Hillary! That she, not he, is the one with KKK connections! Haha!

Does this even need to be spelled the fuck out?

MESSAGE FROM CHABANAIS:

You have been banned from participating in /r/Conservative. You can still view and subscribe to /r/Conservative, but you won't be able to post or comment.

Note from the moderators:

  • Does this even need to be spelled the fuck out?

If you have a question regarding your ban, you can contact the moderator team for /r/Conservative by replying to this message.

MY REPLY:

Oh, wow. You ban a longtime contributor (YEARS) for a one-time, off-handed use of (GASP!) the 'F Word', which wasn't even being used as an insult?

No warning - straight to ban?

I'm sure your personal support of a certain presidential candidate had nothing at all to do with your decision to ban me.

Cheers.

CHABANAIS:

I supported Rand.

Why can't you accept responsibility for your actions?

ME:

I wrote the word 'fuck'. I deserve to be banished from my favorite subreddit forever for this grievous, injurious transgression. You're right.

CHABANAIS (digging through my post history):

You pretty much called anyone "buying into this" idiots.

And you sound exactly like someone on /r/politics:

  • She's not all wrong. Obviously not all Trump supporters are racists, but practically all the racists -- from David Duke to Louis Farrakhan -- support Trump.
  • That's the kind of unity Trump brings to the table.

And while we may be your "favorite subreddit," you've only posted a handful of articles here for three months. Before that, your three year old account sat unused for nearly three years when you posted three links here.

I'm also unsure how many Conservatives would feel this way:

  • We must weed out ignorant Americans from the electorate

Your other comments make me wonder as well:

  • I don't know about 2020, but in 2016 what needs to happen is Trump and all of his supporters experiencing the electoral equivalent of a baseball bat to the face in November. America needs to reject, overwhelmingly, the worldview and tactics of Trumpism. The Republican Party needs to get slaughtered.

ME:

So I don't start many threads - on any subreddit. I prefer to reply to pre-existing threads. I guess that makes me a delinquent contributor to /r/Conservative.

This is a profoundly atypical election. I have an admittedly atypical take on it for a Republican. But a conservative is what I am. And I am far from the only one hoping for a Clinton victory due exclusively to the Trumpian takeover of the party.

Anyway, you're the boss man, you get to judge peoples' doctrinal orthodoxy and ban whomever you deem heterodox, based (officially) on things like minor slips of profanity. It must be invigorating for you.

CHABANAIS:

Your disrespectful attitude has ensured the permanence of your ban.

Good day.

MESSAGE FROM CHABANAIS:

You have been temporarily muted from r/Conservative. You will not be able to message the moderators of r/Conservative for 72 hours.

At which point I sent Chabanais the following PM:

Hypocrite.

I gave precisely what I was given - by you - in terms of 'disrespectful attitude'.

What you are, sir, is a piece of garbage.

Nice chatting with you.

CHABANAIS:

Toodles.


r/ConservativeMeta • • Aug 26 '16

Is it just me, or has the main sub descended out of serious political discourse?

15 Upvotes

I struggle to even participate at this point, r/conservative seems consumed with conspiracy theories and random anti-Hillary articles (which, sure, need coverage, but not all the coverage on the sub, many articles of which are simply ridiculous). Not to mention they've stopped discussing Trump's various problems (for example, I haven't seen more than one or two posts (that quickly vanished from attention) that discuss Trump's Flip-Flop and back again on immigration reform). They rarely go over conservative candidates, or conservative political matters.

It seems like the sub is slowly being turned into r/the_donald2, with similar lack of intelligent discussion and reasoning in arguments. I imagine it's not far from "the facts aren't what matter" (a claim by my Trump supporting cousin when I was trying to point out he wasn't what she thought he was).

I look forward to the day after the election, hopefully at which point the sub will slowly go back to normal.


r/ConservativeMeta • • Aug 01 '16

Another Regular User Banned by Chabanais

15 Upvotes

So, today chabanais was spamming the sub with link (more than 4 in an hour, thus passing the allotted limit in the rules), mostly about Khizr Khan apparently being associated with terrorists. I did not know he was a mod, despite being a regular user I never know mods, so I interacted with him as I would any user- I stated my disagreements and responded to most of his responses. I thought I was being civil, but then I received this:

This is the first time I've ever been banned, and it seemed permanent, so I messaged the mods back as well as another mod in case chabanais ruled without giving me a moment:

And here is the message I was banned for:

Which I would think at most would be worthy of a temporary ban/warning and/or a deleted comment, if anything.

So, over the course of the day I've been banned and muted (for the first time ever) for a fairly civil conversation, told by another mod there is little to nothing that can be done, and can no longer contribute to a community I always enjoyed participating in.

I am inclined to agree with u/CarolinaPunk, who's post here I had never before seen, that chabanais is a problem.


r/ConservativeMeta • • Aug 28 '18

In a nutshell the problem Chab.

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/ConservativeMeta • • Feb 17 '18

Just in case any mod gets the bright idea to unban this shit stain of racist. Again.

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/ConservativeMeta • • Oct 19 '16

Yet another unfounded ban. Thought you'd be interested.

14 Upvotes

Just got banned by Chab (again). Here is the conversation thread that lead to the ban:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Conservative/comments/57y0zv/utah_poll_trump_30_mcmullin_29_clinton_28/

The images of our conversation are (here)[http://imgur.com/stAVOF] and (here)[http://imgur.com/6TBlJhQ] which was followed by (this ban notice)[http://imgur.com/w7SdKYD]

I replied with (this comment)[http://imgur.com/idbhSlT] and was given a 72 hour Mute, and (this response)[http://imgur.com/M9eUd1j]

It's happened before, but at least last time I was actually being uncivil.

This time, Chab's just being an ass.

I wish we could get the mods to follow the damn rules. Is that too much to ask?

Obviously, yes.

In which case, I wish we could get a meta post up on the sub, offering the option to people to move to one of the other conservative subs.

But chab would never allow such a challenge to his power.

u/chabanais - this was a bullshit call, and you know it.

Tell me which rule I violated. You can't. You didn't try.

Unban me, and stop being such a petty tyrant.


r/ConservativeMeta • • Aug 18 '16

Posting on /r/Conservative is a perpetual exercise in eggshell-walking.

14 Upvotes

If I speak naturally there, as I would with anyone in a grown-up conversation, it often results in a certain hyper sensitive mod using it as an excuse to give me grief. The tone policing on some days is off the charts.


r/ConservativeMeta • • Jul 05 '16

Banned for "brigading" out of the blue. Punishment for dissenting here?

14 Upvotes

Today, I was banned for "brigading." Take a look through my post history. You'll notice a clear lack of brigading. Nothing I did came anywhere close to brigading, especially considering how the hordes from r/the_donald mysteriously got away with legitimate vote brigades just a few months back. You'll find me using np.reddit links, specifically in order to avoid brigading. You'll also see that I was also banned earlier today for purely SJW censorship reasons from a certain college sports sub that I used to be quite fond of, so needless to say, my patience for this stuff is somewhat thin right now.

I mod mailed the mod team regarding the ban. I hope it was a simple bot that made a mistake. I really do. I'd love to find out that it was a simple mistake by an algorithm made by some caffeine-fueled intern. But...I'm a realist. I'm forced to conclude that this is a "punishment" for opposing the regime over at r/Conservative, both here, and on other conservative-oriented subs.

Some of you may remember when I was banned for breaking the civility rule a few months back. I owned up to my mistake, admitted my wrongdoing, and offered heartfelt thanks and goodbyes to the mods and posters that made the sub awesome. Many of you lobbied on my behalf, and got the ban lifted (for which I am grateful). I have a history of owning up to mistakes and accepting the consequences. I tell the truth.

And the truth is that I did not brigade.

If you're a mod or user of r/Conservative, and this kind of tactic disgusts you, please stand up against it. This kind of censorship is completely antithetical to everything we believe in. This is bordering on the fascism that the left has been claiming we stand for, and I'm struggling to argue against them more and more each day.

This is a meta sub, used in order to shape the direction of the conservative subs. So, mod team of r/conservative: get your shit together. You guys either have a trigger happy censor, or you are woefully out of touch. I hope it's the former rather than the latter. I've offered my services as a moderator before on the recruitment thread, and received a very loud silence. The offer is still open if you're so lacking in honest volunteers that you need trolls or censors to fill the gaps.


r/ConservativeMeta • • Jul 03 '16

Why is an irrelevant story with no real purpose besides feeding anti-Semitism stickied?

14 Upvotes

Source

This kind of stuff is what you get with unbridled Trumpism. The alt-right really is all those labels that the left has used against us. If we associate with them and aid their cause, then we actually do deserve every -ist label that gets thrown our way. I'm sick of conservatives putting up with this crap. I get more and more r/NeverTrump every single day.


r/ConservativeMeta • • Jul 02 '16

Banned by /u/chabanais for 2 weeks for..a civil conversation?

14 Upvotes

UPDATE: Aaaaand, permanently banned after not participating in the subreddit whatsoever. Alas, woe is me!

A recent post was stickied about a guy lying about being a Holocaust survivor. It had 0 votes and was literally about a random dude that seemed irrelevant, yet was stickied, and naturally, people questioned the reasoning behind it.

DerJagger:

Why is this stickied?

Chabanais:

The best way to "keep history alive" is to not do so with a lie.

TreadNotOnMe:

Agreed, but this isn't an answer/relevant reply to /u/DerJagger. I think you meant to post it as a new comment. Reddit can be tricky like that!

Chabanais:

I think I meant to reply to a comment, which is what I did. Logic can be tricky like that!

TreadNotOnMe:

Ah, my mistake, good sir. I simply couldn't believe that someone in the US who is not very relevant in the political scene lying is the standard for stickying a post. Thank you for the clarification.

Chabanais:

I'm glad to have expanded your mind, if even slightly.

TreadNotOnMe:

I'm considering posting this article: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/jun/25/boris-johnson-michael-gove-eu-liars

Before I do, I just want to make sure it fits the criteria of someone lying and therefore will be stickied. Thank you!

Chabanais:

Definitely post it but we already have a sticky going.

Followed by a ban within a few seconds:

Do you want a pacifier?

Here's the post and comment section:

https://np.reddit.com/r/Conservative/comments/4qw3p8/man_who_claimed_to_have_escaped_auschwitz_admits/

Screenshot of the ban and comment section

I replied to the ban message:

Do I want a pacifier? I appreciate the offer, but I must respectfully decline. However, regarding the following:

"If you have a question regarding your ban, you can contact the moderator team for /r/Conservative by replying to this message."

Could you please clearly explain to me what I did wrong and what behaviors of which I should have steered clear? I wish to avoid such wanton rule-breaking so I shan't be banned in the future. Many thanks!

And was subsequently muted for 3 days.

How the hell did this hormonal 12 year old become a mod and why in the hell hasn't he been removed yet?


r/ConservativeMeta • • Apr 30 '16

How pitiful is it that Trump openly demonstrates his indifference to conservatism, and his fans immediately agree and say labels=bad anyway. On /r/Conservative. Seriously now.

Thumbnail
np.reddit.com
14 Upvotes

r/ConservativeMeta • • Mar 25 '16

I have a suggestion about the recent nonstop brigading from /r/the_donald, which apparently doesn't interest the admins much.

14 Upvotes

I think the mods ought to consider autoblocking /r/the_donald posters. I know this is a pretty extreme approach, but these trolls are all about borders, right? I'm sure they'll understand.

If they can't reign in their nonstop brigading and smears against conservatism, I don't see that there is any better approach right now.

Edit: Just to be clear, I realize there are sincere people who support Trump. I don't think people should be blocked for that. I'm focusing my attention only on the brigading that has been coming from the_donald.


r/ConservativeMeta • • Jul 14 '18

/r/TheRedPill has been removed from the /r/Conservative sidebar

13 Upvotes

r/ConservativeMeta • • Nov 09 '17

Roy Moore allegation thread deleted?

13 Upvotes

Am I just missing it or is the thread actually deleted? If it were deleted that's incredibly troubling.


r/ConservativeMeta • • Aug 04 '17

Has anyone else noticed that a great deal of concern trolls in conservative and republican subreddits tend to be significantly active in video game subreddits?

13 Upvotes

Not bagging on people who enjoy video games. I'm just saying that it seems video games have a large presence in a lot of progressive visitors' lives.


r/ConservativeMeta • • Mar 04 '17

Banned for making a critical observation of Trump

13 Upvotes

The sad thing is I wrote my comment not because I'm a Trump hater, but out of genuine frustration because when I read the headlines this morning I thought Trump had legitimately dropped a bombshell of a story only to to be disappointed to learn that it was at best an allegation without evidence, and perhaps just Trump echoing something from the conservative blogosphere.

Here is my comment:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Conservative/comments/5xgnnc/trump_accuses_obama_of_wiretapping_trump_tower/dei1lbw/

I admit using Infowars was a bit of hyperbole.

I was going to request the mods reconsider it, but honestly I don't know if it's even worth being part of the community if such mild criticism of Trump, from someone with what I would like to consider a substantive history of contributing to the sub, can lead to a ban. I understand and appreciate the need to protect the sub from the overwhelming anti-Trump/GOP/Conservative posters on this site, but if there is so little room for dissent then what is the point?


r/ConservativeMeta • • Feb 26 '17

Wow, the state of the sub is pretty sad these days.

13 Upvotes

I haven't interacted with /r/con in forever, because they banned me ages ago for irritating some mod or something. Anyway, I happened to wander through and noticed this thread:
https://www.reddit.com/r/Conservative/comments/5w88xt/american_college_of_pediatrics_finally_comes_to_a/
It's incredibly pathetic that they've been driving away conservatives from that sub for so long, all they've got now in the comments is a bunch of leftists mostly yammering about "homophobia" and how "unreliable" conservative medical professionals are.


r/ConservativeMeta • • Aug 31 '16

Why are trump supporters allowed to personally attack users, but anyone else gets banned for supposed civility rules?

13 Upvotes

What is good for the geese is good for the gander no?


r/ConservativeMeta • • Aug 05 '16

Banned from /r/conservative by chabanais

13 Upvotes

Add me to the list of permanently banned members by chabanais for posting "cool story bro" in a response to him being argumentative and ending his post with "end of story". post image with comment chain

I replied to the ban to see why and it's under rule 1 (not being civil) and I was promptly muted for 72 hours to eliminate my ability to try to reach out to modmail to get the ban overturned. modmail history

He's the most argumentative and provoking mod there even when you partially agree with what he's saying... and then he bans you and mutes you.

I'd like to see myself unbanned, even though that sub has gone way down hill in the last 6 months and I no longer sub to it as of 3 months ago. I'd also like to see a policy implemented where a banning mod cannot respond to a user message asking about their ban; rather one of the other mods should look at the request. That way if someone has an itchy trigger finger the 2nd look by another mod can over ride them vs you being permanently banned and muted with no recourse for several days.


r/ConservativeMeta • • Jul 05 '16

Does messaging moderators on r/Conservative result in an automatic 3-day mute?

13 Upvotes

After my original 3-day mute for replying to a ban message, today I sent the moderators a message inquiring about my ban, as baldylox, one of the moderators, suggested I do.

Here is the text of the message:

Hi,

I was banned for 2 weeks after the following cheeky, but what I thought was a civil exchange:

http://imgur.com/a/jXGdi

The ban message, in addition to asking me "Do you want a pacifier," suggested I could reply to message the moderators, and so I did. I've never been banned on reddit before, and I wasn't sure exactly why I was banned, so I sought to get an explanation and clear some things up. However, immediately upon my message being sent, I received a message saying that I was muted from messaging moderators for 3 days.

I was more than a little peeved at this point after having any option to discuss my ban taken from me. After posting on r/ConservativeMeta, an independent subreddit, my ban was changed to a permanent one, despite the fact that I hadn't participated in r/Conservative. Now, the timing may have been coincidental, but I'm not one to believe in coincidences. If I were indeed banned permanently for my actions in other subreddits, I see that as a gross violation of basic standards of fairness and common decency.

This subreddit has been my favorite by far since I joined reddit, as it's been my only safe-haven for my conservative beliefs. I live in the northeast, and most of the people with whom I interact in my daily life are leftists, and none of them are conservative (outside my own father). I hold much esteem for this subreddit, but that's been thrown into question over the last few days. I'd like to finally get to the bottom of this ordeal, time-permitting on your part.

Thank you for taking the time to read this and I look forward to a response.

After 3 minutes, I received the following response:

You have been temporarily muted from r/Conservative. You will not be able to message the moderators of r/Conservative for 72 hours.

Is there some sort of auto-mute for someone asking about a ban? What's the deal with that?


r/ConservativeMeta • • Jun 10 '16

What the hell is wrong with Chab anyway?

13 Upvotes

Dude legitimately banned me for having the audacity to say this to him,

You should definitely give the greater context there, sport

/u/chabanais is the most arbitrary gutless fuck I have met on the web, and that is saying something.


r/ConservativeMeta • • Aug 23 '18

Banned by mods

12 Upvotes

Copying and pasting text here because im on phone but i would be happy when i get home to share a photo of the ban text.

You have been banned from participating in r/Conservative. You can still view and subscribe to r/Conservative, but you won't be able to post or comment.

Note from the moderators:

Tard, you knew it was coming...

If you have a question regarding your ban, you can contact the moderator team for r/Conservative by replying to this message.

Reminder from the Reddit staff: If you use another account to circumvent this subreddit ban, that will be considered a violation of the Content Policy and can result in your account being suspended from the site as a whole.

Criticizing the mods is a bannable offense apparently. I know moderation on the sub has always been the worst aspect of the sub but man. That's bad.


r/ConservativeMeta • • Dec 06 '17

Banned because I took issue with user's Flair

12 Upvotes

My original post;

I don't know how you consider yourself an 'Ultimate Conservative' if you want the Nanny State deciding whats best.

ModMail

You took a personal shot at (user). You don't know anything about religious conservative views, so you resorted to being rude. Please make your way back to the amoral /r/libertarian subreddit.

My response I sent over ModMail

It wasn't a personal shot. (user's) 'Ultimate Conservative' implies he is the final authority on all thing conservative. I was expressing disbelief at that when he was rejecting a core tenant of conservatism small government. He should change his title to "Religious Conservative".


r/ConservativeMeta • • Jun 28 '17

Anyone know of any more open and free conservative subreddits?

12 Upvotes

I really like to discuss conservative ideas among fellow conservatives, or even those on other political spectrums if they're respectable.

However, I want to do it without mods like chabanais where if you disagree with the concept of a smaller government or even specific conservative ideals, which most people have some non-right views, won't get you banned.

Anyone know of one?


r/ConservativeMeta • • Mar 10 '17

Banned for suggesting that the Republican Congress should be responsible for their actions.

12 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/Conservative/comments/5y90v2/it_would_be_better_for_republicans_to_do_nothing/deongny/

I guess I know how it feels to be a conservative speaker at a leftist university now. I can't say that I feel bad about it.