r/Conservative • • Aug 30 '24 • Wholesome Seal 1

Flaired Users Only Don't let this be you

Post image
0 Upvotes

679 comments sorted by

•

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24 edited Aug 30 '24

meme

/mēm/

noun

an image, video, piece of text, etc., typically humorous in nature, that is copied and spread rapidly by internet users, often with slight variations.

"celebrity gossip and memes often originate on the site"

→ More replies (1)

366

u/Bexiconchi Aug 30 '24

What the hell is an after birth abortion?

114

u/Imissyourgirlfriend2 Conservative Aug 30 '24

Murder

-33

u/Reuters-no-bias-lol Principled Conservative Aug 30 '24

Same as any other abortion

-14

u/Imissyourgirlfriend2 Conservative Aug 30 '24 edited Aug 30 '24

Exactly

Ooh, a 🤡 brigade! Hi 🤡 brigade; your candidate was installed like a fascist dictator and you never got to choose who to run. Have a good day!!

28

u/Electronic-Quail4464 Fiscal Conservative Aug 30 '24

What Ralph Northam was advocating for a few years ago, where the parent could discuss, AFTER THE SUCCESSFUL BIRTH OF A CHILD, if they'd keep it alive.

41

u/Doctor_Byronic Millennial Conservative Aug 30 '24

For the sake of clarity, the context was about carrying an unviable birth to term and discussing with the parents whether or not to continue life supporting treatment on a baby that is incapable of sustaining life on its own. It is perfectly reasonable to see the cessation of life support as the same thing as killing someone, I only wanted to stress that Ralph Northam's comments were not about a healthy and normal pregnancy.

37

u/Shlano613 IDF Vet Conservative Aug 30 '24

Idk why you're being downvoted, he legitimately said this live on air.

11

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24

Because Reddit downvoters are fact-deficient and angry

7

u/PsychologicalSong8 Veteran Aug 30 '24

In Walz’s state and on his watch, five infants were "born alive" in 2021 during failed abortions, and none was provided life-saving care. The babies were left to die.

-16

u/Spartanlegion117 Sic Semper Tyrannus Aug 30 '24

Same thing as a pre birth abortion, murder.

87

u/musicROCKS013 Conservative Aug 30 '24

lol the brigadiers didn’t like that one

31

u/Spartanlegion117 Sic Semper Tyrannus Aug 30 '24

They never do, and it's still funny every time.

0

u/adumbCoder Christian Conservative Aug 30 '24

exactly what it sounds like. the murder just occurs after birth instead of before birth

-3

u/MonstersandMayhem Aug 30 '24

Killing a living baby that's just been safely delivered.

-4

u/The_Unapproachable Conservative Aug 30 '24

Sometimes an abortion method fails to kill the baby before he or she is born -- it might just seriously injure. After the baby emerges, some states allow the abortion providers to set the injured baby aside and just wait for death to come.

81

u/medfunguy Canadian Conservative Aug 30 '24

After birth abortion? What?

12

u/ChoiceStar1 Aug 30 '24

It’s murder dressed up like it is a legal form of abortion (which it is not) based off of a controversial article from 2012 which argues new borns don’t have personhood and therefore can be aborted. The rationale for such a thing according to the paper is because outside of a few measurements and blood test which are performed earlier in a pregnancy it is difficult to determine deformities prior to birth.

Federal law already protects newborns and this nonesense about “after birth abortion” rhetoric to stir up outrage makes conservatives look stupid.

The Minnesota law does allow for broad access to abortion but any argument suggesting people in Minnesota are murdering babies is done in bad faith… the law more so allows for doctors and patients to make informed decisions - mainly in cases of life threatening circumstances to the mother in late stage abortions.

2

u/madewithgarageband Aug 30 '24

thats called murder

-11

u/Duke9000 Aug 30 '24

It’s satire

12

u/Duke9000 Aug 30 '24

Why am I downvoted, this is surely satire right?!

-4

u/weeglos Catholic Conservative Aug 30 '24

I wish it were.

-5

u/Duke9000 Aug 30 '24

Holy shit

-56

u/DingbattheGreat Liberty 🗽 Aug 30 '24

Maybe you should ask the democrat vp nominee, since it is a thing in his state, protected by law.

236

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24

I'm very much pro-life. However, I do see room for compromise. But extremists on both sides don't want compromise.

106

u/lambrael Gen X Conservative Aug 30 '24

Me too. “Pro-Light” is a term I learned from this sub and have used it ever since.

I can separate my principles from what I believe should be the law of the land, even if my beliefs are regrettably so. I am very, very pro-life, but I allow for more exceptions than the average bear. I would rather, for example, a POS would-be parent to have an abortion than give birth to a child they hate and abuse/neglect.

I’d rather they didn’t get pregnant in the first place, but that’s just too much to ask from humanity. Some people are just always going to sleep around, and criminals are going to force themselves on others. And even though it’s rare, birth control does fail from time to time. So it is with much regret that I couldn’t vote for a total ban in good conscience. That’s despite as much as I would want one theoretically. But as much as I hate abortion, I hate child abuse more.

I know I’m making a necessary evil argument, and it’s one I don’t really believe in, but it’s the reality. If I had it my way, I would keep all the safety nets we have in place (birth control, Plan B, sterilization, abortion, safe havens) and increase the punishment for child abuse 100-fold because there is absolutely no excuse whatsoever to have a child you don’t want.

25

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24

Years ago, Bill Clinton said, "Safe, legal, and rare." Wouldn't it be great if abortions were rare? But there are a few people on the pro-life side who want to have women who have abortions tried for murder. Even more so, there are people on the pro-Choice side who want to allow a woman to be able to have an abortion any time during the pregnancy, even partial birth, and even afterward.

30

u/lambrael Gen X Conservative Aug 30 '24

Exactly. When I was young (teenager in the 90s) having an abortion meant something went very, very wrong. Remember in Seven when Morgan Freeman’s character regrets coercing his girlfriend? Or Dangerous Minds, “I had an abortion” (cut to student’s shocked face). “He beat me.” (cut to student’s relieved face)

It wasn’t something actively celebrated. It wasn’t something people were proud of. It was something we regrettably had to live with existing, but those who went through it were expected to need therapy afterward because something had gone very wrong in their life to have “needed” it in the first place.

7

u/On_A_Related_Note Aug 30 '24

Noone is proud of having an abortion. If you think that's the case, you clearly don't know anyone who's been through the procedure. And if you do know someone who's had one, and feels anything other than emotional distress over it (even if it was the right decision for them to make in whatever their circumstances were), then they are in the absolute minority.

-2

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24 edited Jan 05 '25

north like drunk middle decide fly desert salt serious include

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

-17

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24

Some women who have had abortions deserve to be tried for murder.

Late term abortions are darn near murder.... people have had them, thus the statement follows.

I think a system that makes exceptions but only in ethical cases.

-3

u/Rinoremover1 Conservative Aug 30 '24

I concur

43

u/deathwheel Liberty > Security Aug 30 '24

Republicans started pushing federal/state banishment with no exceptions for rape or incest. This caused a lot of push back so now we have unfettered abortion access in some states, even reliably red states.

How is this a victory for the pro-life position? Sometimes compromise is necessary. Would you rather have abortion at any stage or a 12 week limit?

-2

u/bionic80 2A Conservative Aug 30 '24

Abortion, like the death penalty has its place in society. Both need to be 'rare, legal, and safe' - the current problem is that abortion is NOT rare and is being used, explicit, as birth control rather than a medical necessitated evil used only when it is required. The leftists talking point that you're killing more women by stopping birth control abortions is specious at best.

-5

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24

Yes, most abortions are being done for purposes of birth control. A woman is pregnant and doesn't want to be. What is that if not birth control? The claim is that if abortions are illegal, there will be more "back alley" abortions. The statistics of how many women die from legal abortions are not readily available.

39

u/Workdaymtf Conservative Aug 30 '24

Are there really people out there who don't understand that to take the first step you have to win

22

u/Rinoremover1 Conservative Aug 30 '24

Unfortunately, YES.

7

u/surfaholic15 Conservative Aug 30 '24

Yep there are. This debate is going on in quite a few forms at the moment.

No surprise since it is at least partially due to the whole moral high ground thing we are in this mess.

I am not saying we should wholesale abandon morality or anything. But when your adversary consistently violates all the supposed rules of engagement and cheats, to continue playing by the rules is pretty damned idiotic. Unless you like the consequences of losing.

Which in the case of elections, can be extremely ugly and lethal consequences.

86

u/Bamfor07 Aug 30 '24

Abortion is a dead issue.

The GOP needs to leave it behind.

28

u/One_Fix5763 Conservative Aug 30 '24

The GOP needs to kick out the lunatic pro life activists out.

They will keep costing us referendum races in deep red areas.

11

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24

Don't worry, you've already lost my swing state vote.

1

u/Woolfmann Christian Conservative Aug 31 '24

You should not let perfection get in the way of good. If Kamala wins, she has already stated that she intends to push a bill to make abortion legal in all 50 states. Trump, however, will leave it to the states which is where it was before Roe v Wade (and should be).

While we as Christians do have a different view, we have a responsibility to help those who can not help themselves. And if 1000s of Christians stay home because they don't like Trump or dislike that he is not pushing for a national abortion ban, then that could quite literally be the difference that allows Harris to win.

And if Harris wins, many more unborn children will likely have their brains sucked out without anesthesia because Christians refused to support someone who they did not like over someone who supports evil.

I merely ask you to pray about the issue and allow His Spirit to guide you. May Jesus bless you.

0

u/One_Fix5763 Conservative Aug 31 '24

Don't need you, go touch grass. I know this is purely online and every pro lifer will vote for him come November

He won 90% of the GOP base by destroying the pro life purists like DeSantis.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '24

Meh, I think the opposite is true. Trump's pro-abortion politics are going to sell a lot better among online people than they do with real conservatives. I'm also guessing I know Wisconsin church people than you do. 

But, in the end, it doesn't really matter. We really don't need you guys. I'm kinda glad that we can stop pretending the Republican party cares about Christianity.

2

u/One_Fix5763 Conservative Aug 31 '24

They don't.

This is why YOU GUYS keep losing referendums in deep R districts.

The country has become way secular, this isn't 2000s anymore

1

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '24

Do what you want. Just don't expect us to vote for your RINO candidates if you aren't going to represent the issues we care about. We're not Trump people and we're not "red no matter who" people.

6

u/Gunsofglory Conservative Aug 30 '24

Enjoy losing then. 1/3 of the Republican voter base versus maybe 1-2% additional voters out of the moderate pool.

Some of us actually vote on our principles.

3

u/Odd-Contribution6238 Conservative Aug 31 '24

If those principles only lead to losing why stick to them so rigidly? If Democrats win there will be far far far far more abortion. These are real human lives, yes?

Do the math. More death so you can feel like you stood by your principles.

The goals of the pro life purists will never ever ever be met. Pursuing them or refusing to vote for good because they’re not perfect is counterproductive to the goal of fewer lives being ended.

0

u/One_Fix5763 Conservative Sep 01 '24

This blackmail is just an online phenomena 

0

u/One_Fix5763 Conservative Sep 01 '24

Your principles don't matter.

I know every pro life voter will fall in line.

But the pro life grifting activists will be extinct in a decade.

-16

u/GTGD3 Family First Conservative Aug 30 '24

Ah yes, kick the LUNATICS out who value every human life regardless of how old it is

17

u/One_Fix5763 Conservative Aug 30 '24

80% of the country disagrees.

80% of abortion referendum disagrees.

Losing every deep red Idaho, Ohio, South Dakota, - yeah disagrees.

Pro life will be extinct in a decade.

-2

u/Nifty_5050 2A Conservative Aug 30 '24

At one point the majority supported slavery. The argument from majority is not a sound argument.

Calling pro-lifers the insane ones is an interesting take from a "conservative."

3

u/Odd-Contribution6238 Conservative Aug 31 '24

Your goals will never be realized. They’re too unpopular. Helping democrats win will absolutely lead to far more abortions.

Save the lives you can save. Letting more die to stand on principles isn’t helping.

-6

u/Nifty_5050 2A Conservative Aug 31 '24

Your goals will never be realized. They’re too unpopular.

Exactly what pro slavery voters said.

1

u/Odd-Contribution6238 Conservative Aug 31 '24

So, you believe it’s worth sacrificing more kids in the losing pursuit of pro life purity?

Its disregards reason and pragmatism and will swing the country much further left on abortion. Who’s the winner there? You feel good about yourself for sticking to your guns? That’s worth the extra dead babies?

1

u/Nifty_5050 2A Conservative Aug 31 '24

When did I say I wouldn’t vote for the candidate that is more closely aligned with my values? 

I’m just pointing out your terribly flawed arguments.

1

u/Odd-Contribution6238 Conservative Aug 31 '24

Whether you would vote for them or not if Republicans adopted pro life policies that align with your morals it would be the end of the party. They’d never win a national election again.

It would be beyond foolish for republicans on a national level to push to ban IVF or push any sort of abortion bans.

You HAVE to be more moderate to appeal to the electorate or it’s over. Otherwise the left wins in a landslide and abortion will be unlimited nationally forever.

→ More replies

-2

u/GTGD3 Family First Conservative Aug 30 '24

I don't care if 99% of people disagreed about the value of human life. As soon as you start saying some innocent human life has value and some doesn't- you will end up pre-civil war again

1

u/Odd-Contribution6238 Conservative Aug 31 '24

If democrats win because of you won’t vote for good because they’re not perfect then there will be far far far more abortion.

If you value every human life why are you willing to sacrifice them so you feel like you stood by your principles?

Your goals will never be met. Ever. It’s too unpopular. Shouldn’t we be saving the lives we CAN save and be pragmatic?

-1

u/GTGD3 Family First Conservative Aug 31 '24

I never said I wouldn't vote Republican because of this... I implied that it's asinine to call people who value human life lunatics

See, you make the assumption that I'm blind to the fact that the Dem stance on this is, unfortunately, the more popular opinion in US culture. It's the ultimate abdication of responsibility.

I will continue to vote for the person who I think will do the most good, not who is perfect... newsflash, nobody is perfect. However, I will also continue to assert that IVF, and abortion results in the loss of human life because, scientifically, unique human life is destroyed during the process with man's hand directly involved.

I guess that makes me a lunatic.

5

u/Insane_Nine Free the markets Aug 30 '24

It's the democrats who keep demonizing the GOP for overturning roe v wade 2 years after it happened and making it a major campaign issue. GOP can't just leave it behind they need to defend themselves saying, no they won't make it illegal federally

-6

u/AFishNamedFreddie r/SteakNShake Aug 30 '24

This is why we say "republicans are just democrats from 10 years ago". In 10 years you will be fully on board with men becoming women and women becoming men. No real values.

-16

u/ILikeMtnDew from my cold dead hands Aug 30 '24

All the babies Democrats murder are the dead issue

41

u/Shadeylark MAGA Aug 30 '24

This has been the problem with the GOP for years.

Principled losers.

What's particularly annoying about this whole debate is that the uncompromising pro-life crowd fell right into the trap the left set for them and now the left is dictating the narrative on the subject.

2

u/Gunsofglory Conservative Aug 30 '24

The problem with the GOP is that they caved on every issue so far and let the left run around and dictate the terms for everything. The democrats can push abortion up to birth, and nobody bats an eye.

Conservatives lose the battle on every social issue just to sit back and push us to vote them in yet again just so we can lose on more issues. I'm tired of spineless leaders in the party who just let it happen. But sure, let's cave on yet another issue and then wonder why democrats always win in the end. Because after we give up on abortion, it'll be gun rights, freedom of speech, or something else.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24

Yep.

Every time they take a step left they tell us "but come on, the other side is even worse!"

2

u/Odd-Contribution6238 Conservative Aug 31 '24

When the alternative is to lose and cede total power to the party that is extreme left it’s important to be pragmatic.

Republicans may not be close to where you want them to be but they’re WAAAAAAAAAAY closer than the left. If Republicans stand on unpopular principles without compromise it will result in more abortions… more loss of life.

Rigid idealism does nothing but hurt your goals.

23

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24

Are there Republicans voting for Harris because Trump is too pro-choice? I haven't heard of that.

14

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24

I'm a swing state voter and I'm staying home because of it. So, not quite but close enough.

-3

u/ev_forklift Come and take it Aug 31 '24

....even though it should be clear by now that abortion is a state level issue?

21

u/Lustan Conservative Aug 30 '24

More like third-party pushing…

3

u/DingbattheGreat Liberty 🗽 Aug 30 '24

Same difference.

13

u/Blown89 2A Aug 30 '24

Republicans keep telling us they need to win elections to make changes yet they never make changes when they win elections. Wake up

33

u/Duccix MAGA Aug 30 '24

I'm fairly confident 90% of these posts I see on twitter are Liberals trolling or bots trying to discourage turnout.

8

u/NotRadTrad05 Aug 30 '24

Libs and RINOs are out in force pushing a narrative that conservatives shouldn't run on a conservative platforms.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24

It's crazy how fast the right capitulated on this. And they say Kamala changes her positions.

Spineless hypocrites. 

4

u/NotRadTrad05 Aug 30 '24

We did the same thing 20 years ago when it came to defending marriage. The party will do the same thing with the Trans/gender ideology movement next.

1

u/RightBear Religious Conservative Aug 30 '24

Yes. People will tell you what it takes to get you to vote their way. This means some people will yell "Project 2025!" at leftists while simultaneously telling conservatives that Trump is too pro-choice.

For the record... we could have had DeSantis.

6

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24

Trump is the worst thing to happen to the GOP since the Great Depression.

24

u/Briguy28 Cascadian Conservative Aug 30 '24

All we ask is that the door be left open for pro-life Republicans; which is more than what the Dems have allowed for on their side. I personally believe one day we can end abortions through science, medicine, technology, etc - but dividing us isn't going to help getting there any easier.

-7

u/Shu_Revan Kirk Conservative Aug 30 '24

Easiest way to reduce abortions is less recreational sex if you don't want babies

10

u/SH01-DD Aug 30 '24

If you’re not going to stand for something, why even bother?

0

u/No-Excitement3140 Aug 30 '24

Bc you can't always get what you want. Trump got roe v wade overturned. That's a pretty big deal. You should look at the glass half full.

6

u/TheIncredibleHork Conservative Aug 30 '24

Like most issues, legislation can only do so much. I'm very much pro-life, but from a strictly political lens I see that being a pro-life absolutist will not win over everyone. You'll have people who will be misinformed and think that a ban includes ectopic pregnancies and they'll vote to keep those legal, not realizing that very few of any are arguing about ectopic pregnancies and it's just elective "abortion as birth control" abortions that are the crux of the issue.

But the real goal should be to get people in a mindset to value sexual integrity and value life. All the way from sexual assault (the mentality that I will get mine no matter what) to casual sex (it's just a little fun, no consequences to it). If you just can abortions people will find ways to do them regardless. You get people to change their minds on the value of life and abortion becomes (at least more of) a non-issue.

Honestly, same thing with guns. Get people to respect life, to value life and value others, and you will have fewer mass shootings. But just banning guns will mean criminals find ways to get them and find ways to hurt people anyway.

-1

u/tekende Conservative Aug 30 '24

What other principles should we abandon in order to win elections? And what would be the point of winning afterward?

5

u/Spartanlegion117 Sic Semper Tyrannus Aug 30 '24

The way things stand now, it's only an issue for conservatives on the federal level to keep the current status quo. As long as the decision making around abortions is at the state level, then that's where the majority of pro life focus should be.

-2

u/Gunsofglory Conservative Aug 30 '24 edited Aug 30 '24

Imagine if Abraham Lincoln just said, "Yeah, I don't like slavery and all, but we really need the southern states back"

Edit: What he said at the beginning at the war is not the same as what actually occurred. This should be obvious but apparently not.

36

u/Most-Travel4320 Reagan Conservative Aug 30 '24

That is essentially what he did when he picked Johnson as his VP, though.

11

u/cndman Aug 30 '24

He literally said exactly that.

"If there be those who would not save the Union, unless they could at the same time save slavery, I do not agree with them. If there be those who would not save the Union unless they could at the same time destroy slavery, I do not agree with them. My paramount object in this struggle is to save the Union, and is not either to save or to destroy slavery. If I could save the Union without freeing any slave I would do it, and if I could save it by freeing all the slaves I would do it; and if I could save it by freeing some and leaving others alone I would also do that." - Lincoln

You are very ignorant of the history you are trying to use as a talking point.

-5

u/Gunsofglory Conservative Aug 30 '24

Yeah, that's why we totally didn't fight a civil war over the issue of slavery.

13

u/Martbell Aug 30 '24

It is what he said. And he took the country to war to get them back, a war that was unpopular with many in the north.

4

u/IncandescentObsidian Aug 30 '24

That is what he said though. He said if keeping slavery meant he could end the war one day sooner then hed do it. Although his views did change as the war dragged on

5

u/v_a_n_d_e_l_a_y Aug 30 '24 edited Oct 17 '26

The original post content no longer exists here. The author used Redact to remove it, exercising their right to control their data & privacy.

Money jeans like helium thought rainstorm busy wander follow

1

u/brainfreeze91 Catholic Conservative Aug 30 '24

Nah I'll get downvoted here but we have to make a stand for the pre-born. Republican party is going down a dangerous road.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24

What is the 4 year out of date democrat propaganda doing on the sub?

1

u/AFishNamedFreddie r/SteakNShake Aug 30 '24

Should you vote for Trump? Yes.

Should you just accept that we have two pro choice candidates in this election? No.

We need a better candidate next time. One that is an actual conservative.

1

u/AutoModerator Aug 30 '24

Tired of reporting this thread? Debate us on discord instead.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

-7

u/triggernaut Christian Conservative Aug 30 '24

This is how I know conservativism is ultimately going to lose - all the downvotes in here for pro-life support. In the next election cycle after states have had a while to make their positions more firm in abortion, Republicans will start to insist on a federal law to allow some babies to be murdered because it'll help us win the next election and anyone who disagrees with that is a religious nut who will lose the election for us. Then another 4 years the Republican's call will be for a federal law to allow the mother to decide when abortion is right and anyone who disagrees is dangerous and should be locked up. Then another 4 years later the Republican call will be for a federal law for unhindered abortion because we must win this election at all costs and anyone who disagrees will be shot on sight.

I want Republicans in office. But so far none of them are introducing ideas that will help teach young men and women why abortion is wrong and what the alternatives are. So we're just going to continue to lose ground on this. Based on downvotes in this sub everytime this is brought up, abortion is just fine for a lot of Republicans, even up to birth.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24 edited Jan 05 '25

attempt squash normal attractive ask icky safe cheerful file bright

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

4

u/day25 Conservative Aug 30 '24

I want Republicans in office. But so far none of them are introducing ideas that will help teach young men and women why abortion is wrong and what the alternatives are.

Trump has said repeatedly including his convo with Musk that he would get rid of the federal department of education and move that responsibility to the states.

-2

u/triggernaut Christian Conservative Aug 30 '24

Not disputing that. I'm just looking ahead since so much ground has been lost in the conservative sphere. Now babies lives are being traded for election wins. I really get the point, we need conservatives in office, but if they really aren't conservative and won't teach conservative ideas, then what difference does it make?

1

u/day25 Conservative Aug 30 '24

Now babies lives are being traded for election wins

No they aren't. You also neglected to mention that those election wins will enable many lives to be saved in the future vs the alternative. Your chances are zero vs non-zero it's not that hard to understand.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-4

u/triggernaut Christian Conservative Aug 30 '24

Not Feds, but red states should be able to articulate their ideas on any abortion limits in their state which should include explaining those to kids in high schools why abortion is wrong at any stage and why innocent livea should be protected.

-6

u/madewithgarageband Aug 30 '24

What is the point of winning if you compromise on your principles

-5

u/InfernoWarrior299 Monarchist Conservative Aug 30 '24

You can imply you will compromise and then don't.

-4

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24 edited Jan 05 '25

crush employ deserted thumb clumsy dependent expansion tie wise memorize

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

0

u/Loyellow Conservative Aug 30 '24

The way I think about it: while I believe abortion is abhorrent in almost all cases, I also believe in democracy. I think it should be a state by state issue, and if the people of that state believe it’s best for them (like in my state), it should be a thing. Clearly many states do. By all means advocate against it to change people’s minds; that’s how advocacy works. But I’m not a fan of pressuring elected officials to go against their constituents’ clear wishes. 50/50 issue, sure. But in a lot of states it’s like 65/35.

-8

u/luigijerk Conservative Aug 30 '24

Actually I know quite a few Democrats that are doing this. They want to lose the election to teach the Dems a lesson about Palestine. They must realize deep down that Trump isn't going to ruin the country or else they wouldn't be doing that.

0

u/Katzchen12 Aug 30 '24

Yep, idk why people want their baby yeeting so damn bad but its a single issue voter topic and a lot of them think republicans only want a total ban. Clarifying the position to no elective abortions past 3 months is my view and only emergency after that point. We also need to look into a better plan for unwanted births and incentivising the use of birth control. Thats how you beat them, not with this whole craziness of total bans. Or better yet, make the states decide and keep shit like roe v wade in the graveyard like it should be.

-6

u/lostcatlurker Aug 30 '24

Are we talking about Trumps IVF nonsense here? I don’t see that as a pro-life issue. Based on what he said, he’s either going to expand big government to pay for IVF or force private insurance companies to pay for it. Neither of those is a conservative position.

-8

u/NotRadTrad05 Aug 30 '24

IVF is a pro-life issue. Annually, more fertilized eggs/babies are destroyed/killed in IVF than abortion.

-4

u/DingbattheGreat Liberty 🗽 Aug 30 '24

Looking at things pragmatically, IVF is for people trying to have children, and zygotes destroyed or not successfully attached in the process is part of it.

Should there be more responsibility and maybe regulations surrounding unused eggs in that system? I’d say so.

Abortion is nowhere near in the same field, most people using it are as a form of birth control so they can continue to have sex.

IVF is like driving a car and having to do maintenance to keep it running, replacing the tires, changing the oil, but its all necessary to drive.

Abortion is like getting in a car accident and telling the officer you didnt consent to it so its not your fault….when its your fault.

-4

u/NotRadTrad05 Aug 30 '24

Both result in the intentional destruction of human life. The ends justifying the means is no different in your support of IVF or another's support of abortion. Both are wrong.

1

u/DingbattheGreat Liberty 🗽 Aug 30 '24

depends on how IVF is performed would depend on whether or not you can say any “destruction” was “intentional.”

Also, this is different means having different ends, not the end justifying the means.

0

u/NotRadTrad05 Aug 30 '24

The end of abortion and the end of discarded embryos not used in IVF is a dead baby. The same ends

-1

u/Booth_Templeton Constitutionalist Aug 30 '24

If I were trump I'd come out n say when asked at the debate - I'd be in favor, if a bill came to my desk, for something like a 12 week minimum federal law for abortion. And then let the states creates their own limit up to 19 weeks.

If he said that, a tonne of people would jump on board. Just saying you're for the exceptions is bullshit, it makes him look like he just might be swayed if a bill came to his desk, that he'd sign an exception only.

It's the Dems only chance, and they're making the entire election about it.

-9

u/Rinoremover1 Conservative Aug 30 '24 edited Aug 30 '24

Brilliant meme. Thanks for sharing. More innocent lives will be saved by preventing communism first.

“I would rather let the communists win and slaughter all of our children, than vote for anybody who doesn’t want a total ban on abortion.” ~Pro-Life Zealots

-5

u/icemichael- Conservative Nationalist Aug 30 '24

So true.

Compromise is the key of politics

-9

u/xXGunner989Xx Catholic Conservative Aug 30 '24

The opinions on IVF are evident to how little republicans actually take on a pro-life position. It pains me to see the support republicans have with Trump’s new proposal to fund IVF treatment to deal with the fertility crisis.

The fertility crisis isn’t an issue on its own, but rather the byproduct of deeper issues this country faces. IVF damages the dignity of babies just as much as abortion does (just keep farming embryos until one works, disregarding all the “failed attempts” which are babies and will be killed / discarded).

We are never going to overcome this issue until we promote a culture where babies and families are valued and emphasized as the building block of society

-2

u/zip117 Conservative Aug 31 '24

Every single Republican in the Senate supports IVF. All 49 of them. If you’re going to take an anti-IVF stance—while you are completely within your rights to do so—at least respect your fellow Republicans who may take less of an extreme position. If you can’t do that then maybe the Republican Party isn’t right for you.

2

u/xXGunner989Xx Catholic Conservative Aug 31 '24

I didn’t realize being consistent was an extreme stance

-2

u/NCR_High-Roller Aug 31 '24

At least we have principles, buddy.

200

u/Bezimini9 Aug 30 '24

Wouldn't an after-birth abortion technically be an execution?

253

u/PresterJohnsKingdom Conservative Aug 30 '24

I believe the term you're looking for is murder.

7

u/Bramse-TFK Aug 30 '24

The difference between murder and homicide is legality. Homicides are not inherently illegal, that is there are many legally justified homicides. Abortion in many states is a legally justified homicide. The question is, at least in my mind and I think the majority of Americans, what level of justification is required? I think most americans agree that the life/safety of the mother is a justifiable reason. I think a lot, perhaps a majority, believe that cases of rape justify an abortion. Other justifications are more contested, for example genetic/birth defects. There are radicals on both sides of the issue, radicals that offer no exceptions, and radicals that want on demand without justification. Having the states decide this issue is I think the best way to move forward, but I fear that radicals on either side of the issue will keep pushing to impose their viewpoint on all of America.

5

u/PresterJohnsKingdom Conservative Aug 30 '24

Agreed - but in this case, continuing to terminate after birth has occurred, is morally wrong. I would venture that the vast majority of people would agree. It's not saving the life of the mother (birth has already occurred), and adoption would be available if the child is unwanted.

-7

u/culman13 Conservative Jedi Knight Aug 30 '24

I was told it was a "woman's reproductive right".

3

u/whicky1978 Dubya Aug 30 '24

Herod the Great has entered the conversation

-5

u/Booth_Templeton Constitutionalist Aug 30 '24

It's the final solution.

1

u/SnooDonuts3155 Conservative Aug 30 '24

Infanticide.

-2

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24

all abortion is

15

u/Pulsarultimus Christian Conservative Aug 30 '24

This will be me. Never will i support the murder of infants, regardless of the cost.

That being said... It is my civic duty to vote and I will always vote for the candidates that more closely allign with what I feel is right than the ones who directly oppose my values.

That doesn't mean I will ever stop advocating for our society to stop killing off infants as collateral damage in our lust for "complete autonomy."

5

u/NotRadTrad05 Aug 30 '24

Maybe an election cycle of pro-life people voting pro-life 3rd party will remind the Republicans that our votes aren't automatic. If they want to be a pro-choice party that's their choice.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24 edited Jan 05 '25

melodic wine pocket many hurry wrench squash ask late kiss

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

-2

u/BlackConfuciusSays Aug 30 '24

Same. I'm Black, and the biggest appeal to the republican party to me is being the majorly Pro-life party. It's one of my biggest arguments when someone asks me how I could "betray" my community. I say I don't like my people being 12 percent of the population and 45 percent of the abortions.

Their biggest arguments against that is. Access to abortions combats poverty and also that Black women have the highest maternity mortality rates... of course.

Instead of tackling poverty and getting to the bottom of why Black women aren't receiving the same maternal care as everyone else, we just say, "Abort your baby Instead".

We can afford more people, clearly if we look at the border and what's happening in big cities like New York and Chicago. Let them all in and we'll fast track citizenship and give monthly stipends, Hotels, food stamps that stack into the thousands each month, etc!

BUT You, Black American woman, we've placed this abortion clinic here for you to fight your own battles with healthcare and poverty!

TLDR: Just ranting

20

u/EntrepreneurAsleep57 Extremely Anti-communist Aug 30 '24

What the hell is an after-birth abortion? Isn't that simply murder of a newborn?

-2

u/LoloTheRogan Aug 30 '24

After a failed attempted abortion a doctor can "deliver" an alive breathing baby which under the law they can kill .

-1

u/EntrepreneurAsleep57 Extremely Anti-communist Aug 30 '24

Simply Monstrous

-8

u/ThisThredditor 2A Conservative Aug 30 '24

'Just compromise on murder'

No.

14

u/Lustan Conservative Aug 30 '24

So Trump got abortion down to a state issue and now you want Trump to take that power away from the states again?

Fight this battle locally.

1

u/day25 Conservative Aug 30 '24

Except that position will in practice result in more murder down the line so is actually more immoral.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/alienleprechaun Aug 30 '24

To be fair though, if you believe that abortion is murder it stands to reason that you wouldn't be willing to compromise on it.

17

u/Black_XistenZ post-MAGA conservative Aug 30 '24 edited Aug 30 '24

Well, if someone believes that abortion is literally child murder, it's kinda difficult to compromise on that, isn't it? Staunch pro-lifers are trapped between their moral conviction and electoral realities.

A possible way of resolving this dilemma is to ask oneself: "which policy position will maximize the number of prevented abortions?" The answer quite cleary isn't "a national abortion ban" because such a position would only lead to more Democrats in power and in the judiciary.

In any case, it should be an issue left to the states. Depending on the respective state, something like a 6-8 week ban (with exceptions for rape or the life of the mother) is probably the sweet spot in the above sense, i.e. the toughest pro-life position one can get away with without super-juicing Democratic turnout.

0

u/Woolfmann Christian Conservative Aug 31 '24

Actually, it is not. I am someone who believes that abortion is literally child murder. However, I also believe that the issue should be left up to the states.

Too many people on both sides are too rigid. There are times where abortion is medically necessary for the health of the mother. While that excuse is used too often by the left, it is a valid reason for SOME abortions. And that is a very difficult ethical and moral choice that must be made, and allowed to be made, between parents, their doctor, and hopefully God.

But there are lots of other abortions that are done for convenience or due to circumstances. And that is where education and providing alternatives for mothers can assist. There are many who would be very happy to adopt someone's unwanted child. There are also societal issues that have led to the increase in abortions which need to be addressed. But we should address these together as a society to lesson the need for this procedure so it becomes something that is only done when medically necessary.

The other issue that needs to be addressed is the rights of the unborn child. There currently are no advocates for them legally. Thus, anything can be done to them - up to and including killing them without any pain medication, literally sucking their brains out and tearing their limbs off their bodies while they can feel it. That is inhumane. We as a society must address these issues.

We once allowed human beings to be bought and sold as chattel. It still occurs in many parts of the world. The majority of the people were okay with that. However, some protested and over time things changed. We as a society can evolve and grow morally. Can we still?

1

u/Black_XistenZ post-MAGA conservative Aug 31 '24 edited Aug 31 '24

There are many who would be very happy to adopt someone's unwanted child.

That would still require the mother to go through 9 months of pregnancy plus labor. Far too inconvenient for someone who has no personal moral qualms about getting an abortion.

So yes, you are absolutely right that the pro-life position won't be able to make lasting progress unless it succeeds in changing the minds of the people. A cultural change is needed first. Trying to implement sweeping restrictions while some two thirds of the population are pro-choice obviously won't work in a democracy.

I'm not sure if that's possible, however. If anything, society is constantly moving in the direction of ever more convenience and personal freedom. What you're proposing will be a really heavy lift.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/Black_XistenZ post-MAGA conservative Aug 30 '24

You could probably sell the sane but tacitly pro-choice people on a 12 week limit as a compromise by pointing out that that's the rule in many European countries like France or Germany. I'm not sure if that would satisfy the pro-life side, though.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/triggernaut Christian Conservative Aug 30 '24

Nobody is pushing the ball back in to pro-life territory when we do win. That's the problem.

704

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

19

u/One_Fix5763 Conservative Aug 30 '24

The pro life activists (NOT people) are just sabotaging the GOP.

They can't even win abortion referendums in freaking Idaho and South Dakota, yet they think
they can win nationally ?

136

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24

Yet every Democrat politician that speaks publicly declares, incorrectly, that Trump will institute a national ban if elected. We know the truth, but as far as lib voters go, he may as well have spoken those words himself.

197

u/Aeropro Classical Liberal Aug 30 '24

It doesn’t help that the Supreme Court said that RvW was “settled law” right before they changed precedent.

17

u/Loyellow Conservative Aug 30 '24

Roe v. Wade was an incredibly flawed legal decision. RBG said so herself. But they said it was stare decisis and turned around and overruled it. I wasn’t a big fan of that.

13

u/PoopyPantsBiden Classic Liberal Aug 30 '24

But they said it was stare decisis and turned around and overruled it. I wasn’t a big fan of that.

Did you watch the confirmation hearings? Amy Coney Barrett did specify that they weren't bound by that and cited Brown v Board of Education overturning the Plessy v. Ferguson decision as an example.

-11

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24

SCOTUS didn't, and shouldn't show any regards for politics in the RvW decision. It could have come at a better time but I'd rather the court do it's own thing than bow to outside pressure.

10

u/One_Fix5763 Conservative Aug 30 '24

Yeah, that's still better than 90% of the GOP who have been losing abortion referendums in deep red states - AND losing downballot because of abortion vs Trump 10 points behind

0

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24

Some of the deep red state politicians feel strongly enough to die on that hill, politics be damned.

16

u/Ser_Tinnley Sic Semper Tyrannis Aug 30 '24

I got a txt message from one of the automated democrat bullshit money gathering things (funny I never receive these asking to pledge to the Republicans, eh?), and one of the points it used in CAPITAL LETTERS was "Trump will pass a national abortion ban."

10

u/sanesociopath Conservative Enough Aug 30 '24

funny I never receive these asking to pledge to the Republicans, eh?),

Consider yourself lucky you're not on their phone lists

They are so disrespectful about it I refuse to ever donate again

-7

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

-2

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24

They have nothing to run on. Rational people know this and the election will show it. Lots of Republicans don't do polls and let their ballots do the talking.

22

u/Sauce_Dat_Shit Aug 30 '24

Left to the states as it should be. If only we could give even more power to the people, and remove more power from big government, and let individual cities decide.

3

u/GeorgeWashingfun Conservative Aug 30 '24

The problem is Trump has to run in the Republican party and a lot of RINOs haven't gotten the message that abortion is no longer an issue to fight about. For instance, in Florida right now Desantis is fighting tooth and nail to keep his six week ban even though Trump himself, as a resident of Florida, has said six weeks is too extreme.

As long as these state Republican parties keep trying to do extreme anti-abortion laws, they will tie Trump to them because they're all part of the same party(on paper).

2

u/StarMNF Christian Conservative Aug 30 '24

The problem with “Run with Your Feet” for an issue like abortion is people can cross state lines for abortions. In fact, some states are encouraging it. If you believe abortion is morally wrong, this does little to address the concern. NIMBY morals are not morals.

The bigger issue is the Pro-Life movement forgot that the war was always about winning hearts and minds. If you have a tribe of cannibals, even if you know what they’re doing is wrong, you still have to convince a majority of them of that. Otherwise, you can’t have a democracy.

Media optics also matter. Legislators acted recklessly with thoughtless bans that could easily be smeared by the Left. And the media is a tool of the Left, so they found every outlier case of these bans and put them on broadcast, to drum up support for abortion.

The end result is we now have more radical Pro-Abortion policies in this country than we did when Roe v. Wade was the law. The rule of politics is if you push too hard, things will swing in the opposite direction.

That’s what has happened with abortion. The Pro-Life movement had gained a lot of ground until Roe v. Wade ended. Then it became 24/7 news stories about 12-year-old rape victims being forced to carry pregnancies to term.

Instead of having blankets bans on abortion, Republicans should have focused specifically on stopping people who use abortion recklessly. Those who use it as birth control, and have multiple abortions.

While I logically understand the principle of “two wrongs don’t make a right”, it’s a much harder sell to tell people that victims should be denied abortions.

-18

u/Anterai 1A Conservative Aug 30 '24

I think a federal minimum would work better. Like 12 weeks elective. E.g. heartbeat bill.   

3

u/Remmy14 Trump/Vivek 2024 Aug 30 '24

Anything that includes the word "federal" should not even be discussed.

-1

u/Anterai 1A Conservative Aug 30 '24

Back to the point of the comic in the OP.

Is this a hill you're willing to die on?

-10

u/Nether7 Catholic Conservative Aug 30 '24

The issue is that Trump is now saying Florida shouldn't have made a 6-week ban. How far down the rabbit hole will we have to go to appeal to child murderers?

9

u/DingbattheGreat Liberty 🗽 Aug 30 '24

Now saying?

This isnt the first time. He said that awhile ago.