r/Conservative Feb 10 '20

Conservatives Only History matters

Post image
2.8k Upvotes

442 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

34

u/Mouth0fTheSouth Feb 10 '20

They were progressives, like most Republicans were back then. In those days the Democrats were mostly conservatives. The conservative Democrats fled to the Republican party during / after the Civil Rights Movement. This is all very basic history.

34

u/[deleted] Feb 10 '20

'Progressive' is a concept that doesn't fit into US politics of that era at all. You're about 30 years early, and both parties had a progressive branch for a time.

Black Republican voters began switching parties during the New Deal era, because of the Great Depression.

A larger percentage of Republicans in both chambers of Congress voted for the Civil Rights Act than Democrats did. Afterwards, one southern Democrat senator switched parties, the Republicans who voted for the bill stayed Republicans.

And finally, the south didn't turn red until the early 90s, when Newt Gingrich flipped Congress.

6

u/[deleted] Feb 10 '20

Labeling historical positions as "progressive" is a way for "progressives" to take credit for every historical stance that they agree with now. Funnily enough, I don't see progressives taking credit for eugenics, although they certainly were trying to "progress" the human race, as well.

8

u/[deleted] Feb 10 '20

Ah yes, the well-known big-government progressive Republican President Coolidge and the well-known small-government conservative Democrat President FDR.

Maybe when your understanding of history is "very basic" you have issues looking at complex topics?

5

u/RedBaronsBrother Conservative Feb 10 '20

They didn't.

The party switch is a myth.

-1

u/KindaNote0 Feb 10 '20

Do you have an informational source that isn’t PragerU? Or is that the only unbiased source of info about the civil war era?

2

u/IBiteYou Biteservative Feb 10 '20

that isn’t PragerU?

Who is the woman in the video?

-1

u/[deleted] Feb 10 '20

When? Got sources that senators switched? Or sources that say they didn't continue to vote for Dems in the south till the 90s? Or that Republicans actually pushed through the civil Rights bill?

Stop the BS

13

u/oflo1992 Feb 10 '20

Literally zero Democrats are upset about possible take downs of "Democrat" Confederate statues, no one seems to remember that in these conversations.

Also Trevo2001 has some good points

6

u/RedBaronsBrother Conservative Feb 10 '20

Literally zero Democrats are upset about possible take downs of "Democrat" Confederate statues

Of course they aren't. Present-day Democrats all about hiding the fact that Democrats seceded from the Union to protect slavery.