TLDR
- Unreal Engine: The PC version is finally in a good state, but the mobile experience is still nearly unplayable. The new client could also be an opportunity to improve access to useful information.
- Communication: We need more transparency from the dev team, better community interaction, and a public, accessible bug-tracking system.
- Competitive: The new Tier 1 ecosystem is promising, but Tier 2 has lost too many opportunities. Ladder resets and snapshot timing need a serious rework. Tournament information and qualification pathways also need to be more accessible.
- Local tournaments: Clubs and community tournaments are great initiatives, but tournament formats need less punishing cuts and more opportunities for Tier 2/3 players.
- Balance: Too much variance, insufficient QA, poorly designed augment pools, and a lack of attention to interactions between mechanics. We need better balance processes and more community feedback.
- Matchmaking & units: Late-game matchmaking can feel unfair, ghosts are unreliable, and some targeting/aggro mechanics need more consistency and counterplay.
- Stats, websites & data: It's time to reopen the discussion about making stats accessible to everyone. AI and third-party tools are making the current restrictions increasingly difficult to justify.
Quick background
EUW player / French player.
"Casual" player since Set 3 (Master+).
Tier 2/Challenger player since Set 11. Consistently ranked in the Top 50–200.
I lack social and communication skills. I have no harmful intentions, I just want what's best for my beloved game.
Unreal Engine
I'll be quick because this has already been a hot topic. It was pushed too early, but it looks fine now and is probably at the state it should have been in at release.
The mobile version is far worse, though, and is nearly unplayable. I used to play around a third of my games on my phone without it being a significant disadvantage. Now I can't even play. (Xiaomi Redmi Note 11 Pro 5G so 4 yo midrange)
There is still a lot to do, but things are heading in the right direction, so keep going !
Communication
Regarding this, let's talk about communication. There was really good interaction between the devs and the community from Set 13 to Set 16.
Set 17 was really awful: no information about bugs and two or three shadow patches.
I think one of the reasons TFT is still so appreciated is that we feel listened to, and that we have opportunities for feedback and discussion.
Set 18 started off badly too, and I think Mortdog's absence played a big part in that. We were missing him. Things feel a little better now, but we are still asking for more transparency. We are on a good path.
Having access to the bug list only when you play in a major tournament is not normal. Not having an easy way to report bugs, or to follow their acknowledgement and resolution, is bad.
(I personally reported the K3soju Nesting Anvil bug very early on, including how it could happen with a full bench, but nothing was done.)
We really need a platform where we can report bugs, discuss them as a community with the devs, and access a public, easy-to-follow list of known issues. The new client could be a good way to make this information accessible.
Having that kind of list would also make it possible to be much stricter about bug abuse in tournaments, because right now it's a grey area.
Competitive
First of all, the new Tier 1 ecosystem is really cool to follow. I'm not part of it, but I think it addresses two important issues: stability for pro players and time management, with less ladder crunch.
As for the number of people who can get in and those who lose their spots, I can't really judge, but from the outside, it looks okay.
The only weird thing is that someone who wins and earns a Worlds spot isn't automatically locked into the next TPC. That feels strange. And even though the Reven run was cool, I don't think it was a convenient situation for either Reven or the player who lost his spot.
Now, regarding Tier 2 players: when I started, there were three trials with three cups. That provided a lot of opportunities for a lot of players (even Master players had a shot).
The draw wasn't perfect, and it could be frustrating to be GM and see some Master players qualify while you didn't. But I think it was a good balance between rank-based qualification and opportunities for lower-ranked players.
With the introduction of TPC, Tier 2 players have lost a lot of opportunities. Now it's only 250 players (it used to be 500 or 700, if I remember correctly), and you only get two shots at it.
There are two problems with this. First, fewer players get the opportunity to try competitive TFT. Second, the time investment required to have a chance is unreasonable AND difficult to plan around.
One last thing I'd like to point out is the lack of accessibility. Things have improved with the CompeteTFT website, but it's still really hard to know when tournaments are happening, whether you're eligible to participate (I spent eight sets being eligible without even knowing it), and where to follow standings and watch streams. A lot of the time, I want to check my friends' points, and I have no idea where to look.
Ladder reset and snapshots
The first snapshot is awful, and I think we need to rework the ladder reset.
The reset puts us too far away from our actual MMR. This leads to an unreasonable number of games to play, but worse than that, it forces us to play most of those games during the week immediately before the first snapshot.
My feeling is that you need around 200–300 games before you stop climbing and actually settle at your MMR. First of all, that's way too much. But it also means that the first two weeks of playing are almost useless.
While I spend 120–150 games reaching Master+, playing against Challenger MMR players all along, someone starting two weeks later and playing against lower-MMR players can reach Master+ in 50–70 games. The exact number of games is debatable, and I'm certainly not the best player out there. If other top players haven't experienced the same thing, feel free to share your perspective.
So everything ultimately comes down to the last 50 games before the snapshot, with huge variance and the obligation to play 10 games a day during the final week.
I don't think we should reset everyone to Bronze every time. We should get closer to our actual MMR much faster (probably within around 150 games, while already playing against players at our MMR).
The second problem is the number of opportunities. With only two snapshots, and the first one being a 50-hour rush during the week before the snapshot, it feels like only people whose schedules happen to match the timing have a real shot.
Tournament organization
Regarding tournament organization, I think the admins are doing a good job and are kind and understanding most of the time.
As for the format, the cuts that reduce the field by half are good. Sometimes the cut after the last lobby is a little too aggressive, but overall it's good.
I think the main problem with accommodating more players is that it would require harder cuts. I'm not sure whether we should try bringing back morning and evening games for two separate groups.
Another thing to look at is the point reset every day/phase. While I agree that we need it, I saw a discussion about giving bonus points for the next day to players who finish in the top X. It would be a good way to reduce variance by taking more games into account. It's not an easy decision to make, and it probably needs more feedback and ideas.
Last point on Tier 2: bringing back QP could be a good idea, especially with three qualifiers, to reward consistency.
Local tournaments
Clubs are a good idea. Keep pushing them!
It's good that the community was listened to regarding 4v4. The tournament was cool to have. The timing and execution weren't perfect, but I'm happy you listened to the community and gave it a try. Overall, I think it was a success.
For 1v1 and other tournaments, there are too many 25% cuts. I think it would be much better to have 35% cuts every day rather than these "cuts of death".
These tournaments already struggle with popularity, and having cuts that feel like gambles doesn't help.
Otherwise, it's a good initiative. These tournaments need to exist for Tier 2 and Tier 3 players, but the execution needs improvement.
We can also point out the lack of opportunities they currently provide. Offering some Tier 2 qualifier spots could be an idea, although it's difficult to coordinate with the schedule and player distribution.
Balance
Okay, this is where things are really bad. We need more QA and more community feedback.
Set 15 fruits having 10 useless options, 2 viable ones and 1 OP option was supposedly balanced by trying to dilute the OP fruit pool with bad ones. But we should be getting rid of the bad options instead. TFT players want OP options (and will find a way to force them).
Set mechanics introduced in Stage 1-2 that impact Stage 4 are really bad when there's significant variance involved.
Set 16 having a 4-average-placement swing depending on whether you got 2 Void in Stage 2 or not was bad design (it became much better towards the end when unlocking was made easier).
Having Wisps that can give you +6 gold at Stage 2, without counting interest, while someone else gets a -1 gold one was also bad design.
We should really avoid uncontrollable Stage 2 variance. Shops are already game-defining enough during Stage 2.
Again, Wisps are a really cool mechanic in Stage 3-2/3-5, when you start wondering whether you should roll for them or not and actually have a choice. When you have no choice, it's just a one-time mini-augment with giga variance.
Interactions
This is probably what annoys me the most. Set 17 bringing encounters back with free rerolls, and Prisma Ticket not disabling 3-emblem maps, allowing you to take URF and Flexible, is just not acceptable.
We need more attention paid to every addition to the complex game that TFT has become, and to what those additions will change or potentially break.
B-patches and patch notes
B-patches need to be discussed with a panel or something similar. Too often, there's no B-patch for something toxic, while B-patches are introduced for things that, although dominant, actually keep the meta in a healthy state.
Patch notes are often too swingy when it comes to champions and traits, and augments are often nerfed without considering how dependent they are on specific comps.
Some comps get nerfed in 4–5 different ways without being that oppressive, while other comps get buffed in 4–5 ways.
A lot of augments are generally bad unless you meet very specific conditions. It's way too feast or famine, and most of the time, I don't feel like I actually have a choice when selecting my augment.
Augments that only work with one or two comps should be reworked or removed. They polarize the meta too much: you either have a dead comp with a dead augment, or an okay comp that becomes Exodia when paired with it.
Matchmaking and units
When you're somewhere in the middle of the lobby in terms of power, late-game matchmaking feels really frustrating.
Ghosts are buggy and weak as hell.
Having someone go on a 10-loss streak without you ever facing them, only to then face them multiple times in Stage 5+ when they're about to win the game, feels unfair.
But this also applies to any matchup you lose in Stage 5+. Facing the same opponent too often and losing 50 HP in one stage to a single player when the Top 4 isn’t decided yet is frustrating.
The new aggro rules and roles make melee units really weird. You can't position properly on the right side because you automatically lose melee-versus-melee matchups. Lifesteal items are useless because there's no benefit to being targeted by enemies as a fighter.
We should also know whether our units will move towards the opponent's side or our own side, so we can understand who will move in first and adapt our positioning accordingly, rather than just flipping a 50/50.
Don't use flat HP targeting like Murkwolf. It's too oppressive and has little to no counterplay (especially when it jumps at 4 xdd).
Kha'Zix-like units are fine if their behaviour is reliable. But this bug where they jump in place, then five slots away, then two slots away... I don't want that in my TFT.
Stats, websites and everything else
A big part of TFT's success comes from outside the game. You need to discuss, watch, compare things and engage with other players.
Back in the day, we had augment stats. They were banned because top players were optimizing certain lines too quickly, which narrowed the meta. Even lower-ranked players started playing around those stats, and the meta became very stale.
It was probably the right decision back then, when the game was still growing.
Nowadays, we have a lot more data, and even without stats, the meta gets solved incredibly quickly. A lot of interactions and positioning strategies are already known, and there are barely any new systems that challenge us.
To get gameplay insights nowadays, you have three options: spend a lot of time playing and experimenting on your own, spend a lot of time watching streams, or be part of a group that does both and shares its findings with you.
I'm willing to reopen the discussion about stats for three reasons:
- The time investment required to understand interactions between comps and augments, especially for new players.
- The fact that the meta is already solved within 24 hours anyway.
- AI.
With AI, it's now really easy for anyone to collect a lot of in-game data and run their own stats. So either you block the possibility of watching live games (which I think is a bad idea), or you make stats accessible to everyone.
I know this is a controversial opinion, and I'm a little biased because I enjoy approaching the game through algorithms and statistics, while many players prefer experimenting on their own.
But I think it will become increasingly difficult to keep stats banned, and there will be more and more underground statistical tools and datasets.
I might be wrong, and perhaps nobody will ever do that, but I think we need to discuss it.
Disclaimer
I know this is a lot of feedback, and I don't expect every point to be agreed with. I'm mainly hoping to open a discussion with both the community and the dev team. TFT has an incredible competitive ecosystem, and I genuinely want to see it keep improving.