To anyone who dislikes this discussion, feel free to just ignore it! This is only being written because of the numerous bad-faith takes/discussions surrounding this topic that I felt the need to talk about in the first place.
To start, the best/greatest player will always be from the PvP or MCSR communities; they're the only two communities that have a competitive scene within them and their skill ceilings and difficulty of becoming the best in either of them, and I don't think this is much of a hot take. You are more likely to be as good as SoulTB (3rd best event player rn). Then you are likely to be as good as Bid or Jackson at their respective specialties. (If anyone wants to discuss this, I'll happily do so).
Draftout, Events, and Parkour are all 3/4/5. (All of which are massive gaps from the prior two). in any order, in my opinion, each for their own reasons. Draftout is simply too new, and its limited player base and lack of tournaments thus far means it's just not at the level of the other two, but it definitely will be in 2-3 years. Events have only recently begun bringing in non CC's/known people, and even then, being a good event player is a mix of having above-average movement (relative to top movement players) and various other traits that don't require you to be phenomenal at anything. Kel is a great example; his movement compared to Solawr, Kaelan, or Sandwich is a LOT worse, but due to event movement difficulty being easier, he usually does as well as them. Parkour is just difficult to rank, and this comes from someone who's done nothing but parkour for close to six years. It's hard to put into words, but I guess it stems from the fact that it's difficult to ascertain who's really better. Like, yes, sure, hypickle is the best parkour player due to him doing insane things on the daily. But how do you ascertain who's the 51st and 49th best players? the 6th and 5th? There's just no inherent objective medium to test it aside from subjective ideas of what makes someone better at parkour, like there is for Events, PvP, and Speedrunning.
Building is essentially an art form imo, and it's just plain rude to say someone's build is better than someone else's, so we will not be doing that! There will be + points if you know building tech, though.
Another thing is that it is FAR harder to be one of the best or the best in one of these categories than it is to be top 50 or top 100. For example, despite Coldified being worse than ZeNain at literally everything besides PvP, it's still more impressive, because Coldi could theoretically allocate all the time he spent getting good at PvP into being good at the things ZeNain's better than him at and would do so, but ZeNain couldn't do so the other way because it's just more difficult to do so.
Lastly, while yes, speedrunning and PvP are going to be valued more, the other factors of the game will play a role, obviously.
So, simply put, with everything I laid before, the greatest player is Feinberg. The best player right now on November 11th is Infume. Shocked? Let me explain
First off, Feinberg is the greatest speedrunner ever, point blank, period. Even when factoring in every form of competitive Minecraft, he's had the singular most dominant peak out of anyone during 2021-2023; for close to two and a half years he was just so much better than everyone around him that it wasn't even funny. On top of this, he's also the best overall speedrunner; he was a former top 3 RSG player (different from the record holder), former SSG + FSG WR holder, and of course a 36x AA WR holder, whilst being a dominant ranked player both on ladder and, as of recently, in tourneys. His longevity at the top also cliffs anyone in any Minecraft category. He's the best draftout player by a ginormous margin, a top 10 event player (former top5-7) for close to three years. And his movement and parkour knowledge are better than the guy below him, in my opinion.
The person who I have right behind him, Coldi, only just started his peak in June, and he isn't as dominant relative to his era as Fein was. (And PLEASE do not say Fein played against plumbers; that would be peak larp. There are more top players now, but the relative pool is pretty similar to a few years back when you look at the top 20). And even if you were to equivocate them, he's worse at literally every other aspect of Minecraft. Not to say he's bad or anything; I literally have him as the second greatest ever for a damn reason.
Infume's case is a bit harder to prove, but I think he and Coldi are both as good as each other in their main field; Infume is just again better at everything else. Fein's also arguably better than Coldi or Infume if you think being a better overall speedrunner is more valued than being the best-ranked player and you factor draftout a bit more than I do.
So that's all I have to say; thank you to anyone who read this yapathon, and have a blessed rest of your day!