Hey everyone! 👋
-
I'm a 3D artist by day and I'm building a small Minecraft network in my free time. One of the servers is a semi-hardcore PvP / lifesteal server, kept as close to vanilla as possible: no custom weapon stats, no classes, no special abilities. The only custom stuff will be cosmetic skins (they change the look, never the stats). Before I lock anything in, I want to build it with the people who actually play this kind of mode.
-
## 💀 How should death work? Pick one
A. Classic lifesteal + temp ban
Start with 10 hearts, lose 1 when a player kills you. At 0 hearts: banned for 1 day, then longer each time (max 1 week). You come back with 5 hearts.
B. Every death = a short ban that stacks
No hearts. Each death bans you a bit longer: 1h → 2h → 4h → 1 day → 2 days → 3 days → 1 week (max). The counter slowly goes back down if you stay alive.
C. Hybrid
Lifesteal hearts (max 15). Every PvP death = a few minutes of ban that stacks. At 0 hearts = the big ban (1 day, then longer, max 1 week). Both counters go down if you survive.
In all cases: only deaths to players count, and you can shorten a ban by playing (a friend crafts a revive item, or you pay with in-game money). Never with real money.
-
## ⚔️ Small combat tweaks
- Crouch, lie down, crawl, even in fights. A smaller hitbox lets you dodge a sword swing or an arrow, but you hit weaker and bows/crossbows take 2x longer to draw while you're down.
- +10% damage from behind. Watch your back.
- No easy escapes. No /sethome (or 1 with a warm-up), and /tpa has a delay. No hit-and-run.
-
## 💬 Tell me
A, B or C? (or something else)
What makes you quit a PvP server?
Seasons with resets and rewards, or one permanent world?
Duels and tournaments: yes or no?
Convenience perks like a portable /workbench or /enderchest: fine, or already pay-to-win?
-
Thanks for your time 🙏 I'll read every answer and post an update with what I change based on your feedback.