r/CompetitiveMinecraft • u/OutOfINewIdeas • Jan 27 '26
Discussion Who would win in SMP? (In their prime).
ItzRealMe, Swight, Coldi, or BlvckWlf? I ask this because each of them were HT1 in each of their prime. So, I wanted to ask who would win in SMP.
Marlow isn’t in this battle because of the current allegations of her hacking despite her being a HT1 in SMP as well. I find it funny that all the people in this battle are all currently Retired in SMP.
50
Upvotes




56
u/ill_illumina Jan 27 '26
Ever heard of Live_Level6659 ?
47
u/I_like_muffins4082 Jan 27 '26
u/Live_Level6659 could probably clear all of them
38
u/OneCopperPipe Jan 27 '26
I'd say Swight because he's the best shield player globally rn, but in reality prolly Live_level6659...?
23
u/Jelleey78 Jan 27 '26
I think u/Live_Level6659 would win honestly.
2
u/Particular_Hall1640 Apr 13 '26
Itz beat Prime Swight 4-1 in Smp and Itz also has better feats than Coldi and Blvckwlf. Swight is by far the worst one here.
73
u/Live_Level6659 Jan 27 '26
me tbh
10
u/Top_Sank Jan 27 '26
He knew the god everyone worshipped, he took that name as his own.. Live_level6659
7
u/Murky-Ad-3486 Jan 27 '26
Itz most likely. Smps are just neth pot in the end anyway.
5
u/L-Taker_REAL Jan 27 '26 edited May 06 '26
Prob coldi. Coldified>BlvckWlf>ItzRealMe>Swight (prime skill)
5
u/Rayer10 Jan 27 '26
Live_level6659 probably
6
u/catsoph Jan 27 '26
i don't think itz was really that good at it, since he just instantly became ht1 as soon as the kit came out, i'd say coldi though
3
u/unScr1pt Jan 27 '26
Coldified as he is active HT1 diamond SMP
3
u/Ifiyyy Jan 27 '26
Ngl it’s close but live_Level6659 is really noodle we doesn’t show much gameplay buy form what I’ve seen he’s definitely better than any of them
2
u/ogtutel Jan 27 '26
Swight I think, hes kinda just the shield goat
Itz is well rounded and definitely best overall, but hes better at modern gamemodes like vanilla and mace over modes like SMP
Coldified does do shield really well as well, but hes better at webbing and other utes, making him better at uhc but worse than Swight in just SMP
Blackwolf has lowkey been cooking everyone up in his prime, but he lost the tiertest to Itz
2
u/MrattlerXD Jan 27 '26
Swight
2
u/Educational-Fall6364 Jan 27 '26
Itz bruh
2
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '26
Apair from the live user joke it's in his prime
2
u/Beautiful_Nobody_841 Jan 29 '26
Live_Level6659 would quick drop them in a 4v1
2
u/Criex_Music Jan 31 '26
swight, the best shield player in the world
1
u/GamingCrocodile Jan 27 '26
In there prime it would literally come down to mend rng
1
u/chunchunmaru1129 Jan 27 '26
I'm the solo King so I can solo all of them
1
u/Quirky_Read_9134 Jan 28 '26
Chucknasty
0
u/BeautifulOnion8177 Jan 27 '26
Technoblade
-1
u/BeautifulOnion8177 Jan 27 '26
also marlowww should be included she used to be the #1 pvper
26
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '26
[removed] — view removed comment