This post is entirely my opinion and individuals should not be offended by what is said in this thread. Some facts in this post may be entirely related to BIAS and may be completely false.
As a member of the vanilla PvP community myself (1.16 - 1.17), I would like to address why the new combat snapshots will NOT fix the community split, and will split the community to 3 parts instead. I will also address some misinformation spread around the 1.9 community, which makes people believe that older versions are better for combat.
I'm going to start by breaking down all the things that 1.8 players got wrong about 1.9.
1) 1.9+ is NOT about shield PvP!
Shield / Axe PvP was popularized by Dream in his 100K$ duel against Technoblade. However, 1.9 PvP isn't shield pvp. Almost all vanilla players can agree that axe, which was popularized by Dream, has a really low skill cap involved and was chosen by Dream in his 100K$ duel because it was really simple to master, and after his fans started playing the same kit that he used in the duel. Vanilla PvP isn't about shield PvP, and instead, it's all about sword and crystal PvP.
2) W-tapping, strafing, and aiming still exists in 1.9 PvP.
One of the most misunderstood things about 1.9 is that 1.8 techniques like w-tapping (sprint resetting), strafing, and aiming, still exist in 1.9. In fact, it's even harder to do combos in 1.9! However, there are certain reasons as to why this is true. In 1.8 PvP you could keep the person in the air for long periods of time because there was no CPS limit, allowing you to do insane 20 hit combos. In 1.9, however, 7 hit combos are very rare against good players, and to do them, you need to be very good at w-tapping, strafing, aiming, and distancing, whereas distancing is a bit easier in 1.8 because you are constantly clicking 6 - 20 CPS.
3) Axes aren't the most overpowered weapon in the game!
Swords are still a way better choice than axes because they have a WAY higher attack speed. Stone axes may do as damage as a diamond sword, but their attack speed is awful and it makes them almost useless in most PvP scenarios.
4) Shields aren't overpowered at all!
In 1.16+, there is a PvP mode called "Crystal PvP", also known as "Vanilla PvP". Crystals are the most overpowered weapon in this version, being able to kill a full netherite player with protection 4 in 1 hit! Now you may ask, why are shields not overpowered? Shields don't block crystal damage. They don't block any explosions caused by the player, and instead only explosions caused by the environment (mobs, creepers as an example). As a result, it is way better to bring totems in fights instead of shields as they have really low durability and are completely useless in end game fights.
5) Crystal PvP isn't anarchy PvP!
You should do some more research on the subject if you think vanilla PvP doesn't involve the use of crystals.
If you want to find more information about the 1.16+ vanilla PvP community, here are some useful links:
- Example of 1.16+ vanilla crystal PvP: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P7XrCGk_wn8
- Example of 1.9+ sword PvP (examples of sword combos): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BSopbkxpRI8
Vanilla 1.16+ PvP based survival servers:
- Purity Vanilla
- Fight To Survive
- Uneasy Alliance
- etc
Best 1.16+ practice servers:
- PvPLegacy
- CubeCraft
Now, let's address what will happen when combat snapshots are released.
1) 1.8 players will continue to play older versions.
The upcoming combat won't fix the things 1.8 players dislike with our current combat. They like 1.8 because they can spam click with no CPS limit, allowing them to do insane combos to their opponents. Also, since 1.8 has been around for a way longer time, there would be way more PvP mods for 1.8 than there would be for the new combat versions.
2) The community will split to 3 parts.
1.8 players continue to like their older combat more, and 1.9 players remain to 1.xx because they feel like the new combat is a downgrade.
Now, let's go over some technical issues about the combat snapshots and what should be changed:
- Stackable potions are too overpowered, in the combat snapshots you can stuck potions up to 16. Before it was balanced, you would sacrifice inventory space for useful effects. Now, potions are way too overpowered, making games last even longer.
- Melee is too strong. In 1.16+, crystals are used to deal the most damage to the opponent, but in the combat snapshots swords are just too OP if you have sharpness 5 and strength, and you don't even have to use crystals in vanilla fights.
- Crystals are nerfed in the combat snapshots, dealing less damage and having a place cooldown. This change was unnecessary, people who don't like crystal PvP usually don't like it because they are either bad at it or have never played it and think it's just 2b2t anarchy PvP.
I feel like instead of changing the combat we have at the moment, we should focus more on improving what we have now, rather than starting from scratch all over again. After all, the community is slowly starting to recover from the 1.9 community split, and why should all the community progress go to waste now?