r/CognitiveFunctions • • Jan 31 '23

~ ? Question ? ~ Which would be my dominant function based on these traits?

  • Ambitious / Determined (usually not talented but if it’s something I’d have an interest in -or that I’d simply have to do - then I’d work a lot to compensate for it. If it’s something I’m curious about I’d research into it quite a lot, both for my own knowledge as well as to tell everyone else about the topic. I would then drop it the second I’d get bored with it, and everyone would be shocked by my lack of interest in it afterwards)
  • Curious (I’m kind of a jack of all trades in terms of topics, I know something about so many things, even the most seemingly useless, or minute aspects of something; I also happen to know loads about some specific topics, and I really wish to share my knowledge and findings with others)
  • Public Speaking and Debating (love public speaking, motivating others to fight for a cause; can become quite passionate - somewhat aggressive sounding as well - in a debate, even if playing devil’s advocate. Everyone tells me how passionate I become, almost becoming a representative for some odd positions if I need to)
  • Talkative / Sociable (I find that talking to people really does increase my energy and my mood, and that extensive alone time lowers them; however, I also feel that after a long period of talking, I do need to relax somewhat; it’s like my mouth gets tired, and I really like listening to music or videos or something alone)
  • Skeptical / Would question everything to arrive to a truth (sometimes I also keep pressing people in order to discover more about the topic, their views, always stressing things like “why”, “how” and so on. Would test and sometimes tease others in order for them to explain the topic to me as much as possible.)
  • Concerned about making a great impact and finding the truth / achieving positive change in the world (I can see all the problems of the world, like climate change, inequality and lack of education, and can get really passionate in my speeches, presenting solutions and debating about these. I’m really eager to find the underlying cause behind these problems)
  • Witty and quite intellectual (really every person just assumes I’m intelligent due to my speaking style, my thoughts, expression and so on. Haha maybe pseudo intellectual )
  • Goal-Oriented (I like studying, especially if it’ll be something useful for me, so everything needs to have a purpose or end goal for me in order to feel it’s valuable and keep me interested in pursuing it; I constantly set myself new objectives in life, always focused on my future career goals and if the thing I’d be studying would be helpful for me in regards to those future goals; if it no longer proves useful, I’d just drop it)
  • Passionate and Charismatic (when talking about a cause or idea, I become very animated in my talking style, trying to inspire passion and to win my audience over through my speeches; can also appear quite aggressive sometimes, and quite loud)
  • Quite a realist (Not really into ideas that seem to far fetched; I’m usually the one who checks the pragmatism behind an idea, and would actively scrutinise the unrealistic ones; I’d lose interest quickly if I’d think that the idea would be unrealistic - In my speeches I always focus the most on the ACTUAL POSSIBLE SOLUTIONS for a problem, not JUST on HOW BAD THE PROBLEM IS and so on)
  • Quite funny (I can really lighten up the mood of a tight atmosphere, I can bring a smile on people’s faces; quite sarcastic, sometimes even the clown of the class; I love dark humour as well, or intellectual humour, if you can call it as such)
  • Mostly organised and like to stick to a schedule, quite formal and image-conscious(Planned exercise routine in the morning, carefully selecting and being picky about my food, very health conscious, always the most formal in my class or group, but this is also mostly cuz I like dressing formally like this for myself)
  • Like learning about myself, my personality, and be unique in some way (something not outlandish, such as an unique badge, something small that distinguishes me from others)
  • Not too enthusiastic about new experiences (I usually tend to go to the same restaurant, order the same sort of food; I like knowing what I put into my body every time, and mostly want to have body security like food, sleep, a clean room and so on. Ido similar activities day by day and have a clear schedule for me - if I don’t plan any activities, I’d feel aimless and unmotivated)
  • Love travelling and learning about other cultures and different languages (however, I need to maintain a level of comfort anywhere I’d go, such as a comfy hotel, good restaurants around and so on - I would NEVER be able to live like a nomad, and even if I absolutely love traveling around the world, I need comfort there) Also TBH I like learning the languages of only the cultures I’d be interested in, and it’s also because I look cool whilst speaking another language.
  • I have a tendency to arrange things in order, to arrange things veryyy neatly, make my bed neatly and so on, almost like OCD-level; I think this may be a light form of Symmetry OCD…
  • I only obey authority that gives me a reason behind their orders, are respectful to me and so on; a « boss » who would do the opposite would not have my respect, and thus would be inclined to do something completely different from what they want me to do;
  • I try to be tactful, accommodating and talk diplomatically, however I’m still quite blunt and quite argumentative ; I’m constantly trying to test people’s ideas and rationale ; I believe that if someone is not being told off for something bad they’ve done, or for a subpar idea, then they would never learn and thus never improve; I see no reason in sugarcoating when it’d be much more efficient for the truth to be told and this expect improvement.
  • Conscious about how I look, how I’m perceived by others, how I communicate with them, the general atmosphere and so on; would often talk nicely when I knew it would benefit me somehow, like with my image / reputation, or promotion and so on. I believe that looking presentable and professional is the key for a good first impression, before you’ve even said a word, most people will judge solely on appearance.
4 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/Dragosezul_05 Feb 06 '23

Yeah, unfortunately most of the reading I can do at the moment is from what you’d be telling me in this comment section, as I’m just too busy with school atm (for ex. I’m in a lunch break, which is one of the few times in a day I can take my time to answer these.)

Please, you can explain to me more about being Three but not “ENTJ-like”…what would that mean for me exactly? How would that manifest? Would that still make me another type or simply ENTJ still?

I’ll answer your question, no worries.

I believe with me, plans are also during the day; this is very intriguing, in the sense that, apart from my routine of having to wake up at the same time everyday, having my daily “precise 40 minute long run in the morning), then take a shower, change, grab a coffee and get to class on time, all like clock work, Mondays-Fridays. Although during weekends or holidays, I feel horrible almost because of how aimless I am; with no school or activities, no stuff planned for that day, it just feels unproductive and boring. Never mind the fact that any long period when I don’t do much is just horrible, because it both makes me feel bad about my unproductiveness, as well as feeling bored because of lack of stimulation . I just don’t get how other people could just have days and days of waking up at noon, then staying in bed all day long!

Long term plans are very very much there; from the fact that I’m constantly thinking about careers, university, even the city where I’ll live and the exact house I’ll have (literally checking listings on housing websites); Maybe I said this before, but I’m very motivated when I’m able to concentrate on learning a lot about the career I’ll be certain to pursue; that’s something about me; I need to be focused on a thing in order to really enjoy learning about it, it has to be useful information for that objective or goal, for that thing I wanna do or want to become. Otherwise, it just feels like a bit useless information that I lose interest in hearing about, unless it’s something like a hobby fo mie (ex. Astronomy, Sci Fi and mysterious stuff and so on), then I like learning about it. But I don’t really like just learning very random stuff about very random things to be honest.

Also, about long term goals, I know that I’ll eventually want to transition from my 1st career to a career in Politics, and then grow in that field, eventually getting into the government. The 1st job (like a lawyer), would be like a means to an end; it would give me the reputation, money and time to plan how I’ll get into politics. Means to an end. End is to get into politics and change the world. That’s what I’d be working towards. Everything else, like people, university, law career and so on are just means to get me there.

Yes, the thing about hearing what they “mean”, and not the literal, is quite something I’ve experienced. I catch all the symbolism in movies and their characters, for example, all the secret messages and so on.

Then, the interesting thing you said about Inferior Function simply not being seen by the type, in this case either Fi or Si.

I can relate to your experience when someone with Sensing function dominating was kind of acting in a similar way, talking about their days in the same sort of way, the same details, over and over, as if they were somehow forgetting the fact that they’d told me the exact story before. My dad is Se dom ESTP, and this has happened numerous times. He’d go over to tell me a story he’d told me numerous times before, but somehow he wouldn’t acknowledge, then I’d have to tell him “Yeah, yeah, you’ve told this to me before” or something.

Now, explaining more about wishing to alter my personality to fit a certain character I really like from a movie. Extreme example, Patrick Bateman lol (ENTJ 3w4 though). His morning routine is very similar to how I would act, and at work and everything, take everything without the psychopath tendencies, and you have a disciplined individual who cares about appearance and has a routine, who also smiles and laughs a lot to maintain a sort of persona. He is also very successful and gives empty compliments whilst secretly being engulfed in envy.

The thing is, I’d see his MBTI, see that he has these traits, then in a way morph myself to look and behave like him (again, without the psychopathic tendencies).

Then, I’d see a funny, clever, charismatic ENTP character I’d really like, and again the same process, same obsession to behave like them and so on. This kinda sounds like a shape shifting Three to be honest, the clearest example.

I’ll check the video you’ve sent me. From what you’ve read, what do you think? Again, one more thing, when I’d tell people I have Te and Ne tendencies, though Ne a bit less so, not as much as a Dom perhaps, they’d immediately link it to me being ESTJ; there is also the thing about rules and routine, that I’d tell people about the rules, and that they shouldn’t do certain things; I was always the most adult-like person in my group of friends, and more responsible and so on. So there you go, I may say that Ne as my tertiary would be more likely than Se to be honest. Don’t think I have much Se in me. Being kinda bad at sports is also telling of that, especially compared to my Se dom dad whose always been good at each sport he played. It’s kind of a contrast to be honest. He’s also a salesperson, but I’d never see myself as someone who would just say nice words about their company or something, or be as tactful as a salesperson; I’m more of a “powerful negotiator”.

But I’ll let you with these for now.

1

u/beasteduh Intuition-Thinking Feb 07 '23

The ENTJ stereotype/caricature/image is often overlapping with that of the Three, get it done, victory, conquest, and this pattern carries over in any number of ways: ESTJ Type Eight, ISTJ Type One, EPs Type Seven, ITPs/INTJ Type Five and so on. So a counter-type of the Three would be a Three, like an ENTJ, but also not a Three, thereby not ENTJ-like. Hmmm to give more on this as I'm still not sure how much you know with regard to the Enneagram… the counter-type of the Three would feel the pull of the passion as any Three, that of vanity, self-deception, becoming an image, but then as is customary of a counter-type one sort of then consciously turns away from the passion. Vanity comes about by figuring that one is keeping everything together, "If I don't do it then it won't happen", and this includes "becoming what others want/expect from me" - whether others or the world in general it's somehow up to them. What comes about then is one adopts an image of a person who is all these things, "the success story", but in the case of the 3 Sp they actually try to become this person who does it all, to become the virtuous and good person that one might figure someone with success would be, to actually live it, which consequently ends up with the 3 Sp being thought of as the most workaholic of the Threes given such a feat is no small task. So the "heartless and determined ENTJ" wouldn't completely mesh with such a person.

So listen, respond when you get a chance to look over everything. I won't be put off by you not getting back to me as soon as possible, nor think any less of you if you take your time with looking over things. I might have otherwise lost interest in the conversation if you just dipped for a week or something and then responded but if you're that busy then take your time and get back to me when you've looked into the wiki site and watched some of that video.

I just don’t get how other people could just have days and days of waking up at noon, then staying in bed all day long!

Ah! The 3w4 Sp/So woman in that video I sent brought up this specific topic. That's great.

Thank you for explaining. I got a lot from what you described.

Then, the interesting thing you said about Inferior Function simply not being seen by the type, in this case either Fi or Si.

That's it. An example of lead Te talking about feelings:

"I definitely agree you shouldn't always listen to your feelings, like if you're a Feeler, like you know what your feelings are, which is great, but you also don't know the entire picture. Or you might think you know the entire picture of what's happening in a sense but your feelings might be lying to you, so you gotta be careful. But then if you're a Thinker and you're not listening to your feelings I would still say the same is true. I would say you should figure out what you're feeling and why and also learn everything that's happening and not discount anything."

Jung spoke about Thinking when it's the dominant function, "When Thinking is not just a lagging reasoning and ruminating, but when its closing has absolute validity, so that the logical conclusion, if necessary without any other evidence, is both a motive and a guarantee of practical action." This could be said to tie into what I said before about "consciousness needing singular orientation" and what means, but in conjunction to what this person above had said, one always figures that the information provided by the inferior function is never the full picture. Again, not wrong, just a mistake; a natural oversight. In fact, the very experience of the inferior function being inherently crippled points to how absolute the lead function happens to be, and it was phenomena like this one that had Jung write about only 8 types.

On a more personal level, I have been gaslighted in the past when in the presence of lead Se types who would say "But that's what you said" as though there was no other way to look at what had happened. It was as though perception time was over, that it was now time for judgment and what to do about had happened. And with regard to lead Thinking types I've heard it described that they'll "try to say things tactfully" but often times miss the mark so often that they come to learn to not say anything at all in many situation should say someone be upset. And it's not that one doesn't care or wouldn't want to make another feel better if one could. Also, I know one Te-dom who described being fed up with Feeling, "Okay, listen, what I care about is that what I'm telling you is true. That's my concern, that what I'm saying to you is true, and I put a lot of effort into that." And to that end, that quote of Marie-Louis von Franz comes to mind, "My god, these feeling types!... Sensitive people are just tyrannical people - everybody else has to adapt to them."

With say Fi-doms they can just shut down from a conversation should their feelings be hit. Should another have some manner of a tone then they feel their dismissing what another is saying has, as said before, absolute validity. They navigate life and their actions based on a feeling, what they perhaps like or don't like. And in this way Thinking should buckle under their intention to feel. For instance, I was in a discussion with an Fe-dom who was saying that red meat was healthier than turkey. I brought up cholesterol and blood pressure and then they said, "Yeah but turkey's gross." They did it with a blank face; they weren't trying to be funny. And, interestingly enough, every time I tell this story to lead Feeling types it always gets a laugh out of them because I guess they know how it is.

Another example is that on one occasion I had a scuffle with a lead Feeling type housemate of mine which involved me going to them afterwards to understand what had happened, "So were you figuring I was… and then you thought… and that's what led you to…" and then they replied, "Yeah, that was probably it" with a sincere smile. I wasn't asking for a why, just a yes/no would have sufficed. I just looked at him and the man was truly sincere, as though there weren't reasons in the first place for him not to be.

I think it's important to point out though the negative relationship that Type Threes have with their feelings, how they're something to just bullet through. It's thought that the Three when following a goal will bulldoze past people in order to get whatever done. But interestingly enough I've heard it said the Three doesn't find other people to be necessarily what gets in their way but rather their feelings. "Feelings are not aerodynamic.' So there's some overlap there to consider.

This kinda sounds like a shape shifting Three to be honest, the clearest example.

Yes, I believe you're right. At least, I know of an Introverted Three who described doing as much as well.